A refund and tax credit fight ended on strict CTA deadlines after a late petition for relief and counsel neglect failed to reopen the judgment.
Taxpayers and government litigants in refund and tax credit disputes must treat Court of Tax Appeals deadlines as strict, concurrent, and unforgiving: a party that misses the period for relief from judgment may lose the ability to reopen the case, even if it later blames counselâs absence, mistake, or internal case-handling lapses.
Background of the Refund Dispute
The controversy arose from a refund or issuance of tax credit case involving a taxpayer and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. After an earlier decision in the taxpayerâs favor became final and executory, the Commissioner attempted to obtain relief from judgment and later pursued a special civil action before the Court En Banc. The En Banc had already dismissed the Commissionerâs petition for certiorari in its January 16, 2025 Decision, and the matter before the Court was the Commissionerâs motion for reconsideration of that dismissal (CTA EB No. 2833).
The Commissioner argued that the petition for relief from judgment had been timely filed because the Commissioner allegedly learned of the entry of judgment only upon receipt of the Entry of Judgment on January 30, 2023. Counting sixty days from that date, the Commissioner claimed that the filing made on March 31, 2023 fell within the period allowed under Rule 38 of the Revised Rules of Court. The Commissioner also relied on the alleged failure of one counsel to timely file a motion for reconsideration, asserting that the counselâs work absences justified the requested relief.
The Motion for Reconsideration Was Denied
The Court En Banc denied the Commissionerâs motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. It found that the motion merely repeated arguments already addressed in the January 16, 2025 Decision and did not present any new ground sufficient to disturb the dismissal of the Commissionerâs petition.
The decisive issue was not whether the Commissioner eventually learned of the entry of judgment, but whether both periods under Rule 38, Section 3 were satisfied. The Court emphasized that a petition for relief from judgment must be filed within sixty days from knowledge of the judgment, order, or proceeding to be set aside, and not more than six months from entry of the judgment, order, or proceeding. Both periods must concur. They are not extendible and are not interrupted.
Why the Petition for Relief Was Filed Out of Time
The Commissioner counted the six-month period from January 30, 2023, the date when the Entry of Judgment was allegedly received. The Court rejected this approach. Under Rule 14, Section 6 of the 2005 Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, the date when the judgment or final resolution becomes executory is deemed the date of its entry.
Based on the records, the Division decision dated October 26, 2021 became final and executory on August 19, 2022. That date was therefore deemed the date of entry of judgment. Counting six months from August 19, 2022, the Commissioner had only until February 15, 2023 to satisfy the six-month requirement under Rule 38. Because the petition for relief from judgment was filed only on March 31, 2023, it was beyond the six-month period. The Court therefore sustained the finding that the petition for relief had been filed out of time.
Counselâs Neglect Was Not Excusable Negligence
The Court also rejected the argument that counselâs alleged failure to file a timely motion for reconsideration justified relief. The Commissioner argued that one lawyer had stopped working around May 2022 and had already been reporting irregularly even before then. The Court was not persuaded that this amounted to excusable negligence under Rule 38.
The Court noted that the case was not being handled by only one lawyer. The records showed that other lawyers were also counsel in the case. If the client or office was aware of the lawyerâs frequent absences before May 2022, the proper course would have been to have the other counsel monitor and assume responsibility for the case. The Court applied the principle that clients are generally bound by the mistakes of counsel, including the counsel of record, especially where there were other lawyers who could have acted to protect the clientâs remedies.
Key Legal Principle for Tax Refund and Tax Credit Cases
The ruling is important for taxpayers and the government alike because refund litigation can turn not only on substantive tax entitlement, but also on procedural discipline. A winning refund or tax credit decision can become difficult, if not impossible, to reopen once it becomes final and executory. Conversely, a losing party cannot rely on a late petition for relief by simply arguing that it learned of the entry of judgment later, if the six-month period from the deemed date of entry has already expired.
The decision also reinforces a practical rule for litigation teams: the date of receipt of an Entry of Judgment is not necessarily the starting point for all post-judgment remedies. In CTA proceedings, the date when the judgment becomes final and executory may be deemed the date of entry. This matters because the six-month period under Rule 38 is counted from entry, and failure to meet that outer limit is fatal.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers, CFOs, and Corporate Counsel
For taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds, income tax refunds, excess creditable withholding tax refunds, or tax credit certificates, this ruling highlights the importance of tracking every procedural date from promulgation to finality. A favorable decision should not be treated as secure until counsel confirms whether any appeal, motion for reconsideration, or extraordinary remedy remains available to the other side.
For taxpayers defending a favorable refund ruling, the case is a reminder that finality can be a powerful shield. If the opposing party files a petition for relief from judgment, the taxpayer should examine both Rule 38 periods: the sixty-day period from knowledge and the six-month period from entry. It is not enough for the opposing party to satisfy only one of them.
For companies managing external counsel, the ruling is also a warning that internal monitoring systems matter. Courts may not excuse missed deadlines merely because a particular lawyer was absent, unavailable, or negligent, especially where a law office or multiple counsel of record were involved. Businesses with significant tax disputes should maintain a parallel internal litigation calendar and require periodic status reports on CTA deadlines.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, business owners, and corporate finance teams in handling tax assessments, refund claims, tax credit disputes, customs controversies, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can help evaluate procedural deadlines, preserve remedies, prepare petitions and pleadings, and defend favorable refund or tax credit rulings against belated challenges.
If your company is involved in a tax refund, tax credit, assessment, or customs dispute before the Court of Tax Appeals, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our Makati-based tax litigation team.