The CTA ruled that Globe Telecom could redeem its seized shipment as no fraud was attributable, clarifying importer rights under CMTA and CAO rules for misdeclaration cases.

Importers now have a clear precedent for redeeming seized shipments when no fraud is attributable, ensuring compliance with customs regulations while protecting their rights to recover goods. Businesses involved in international trade must carefully document their transactions and maintain records showing lack of participation in any misdeclaration to secure redemption of shipments.

Background

The case arose when the Commissioner of Customs filed a petition challenging Globe Telecom Inc.’s ability to contest the seizure of a shipment. The dispute involved alleged misdeclaration in shipping documents that prompted the Bureau of Customs to initiate forfeiture proceedings. The taxpayer argued that it was not involved in preparing the shipping documents and sought relief from seizure by demonstrating good faith and absence of fraud (CTA EB No. 2782, June 2025).

CTA En Banc Resolution

The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc denied the Commissioner’s Motion for Reconsideration, affirming prior decisions that Globe Telecom effectively countered prima facie evidence of fraud. Testimonies from witnesses, including Mr. Jianfeng Ding, confirmed that Globe Telecom had no direct involvement in document preparation and that discrepancies were due to negligence by the supplier, Alcatel Shanghai Bell (ASB). The Court emphasized that redemption of seized goods is permissible under Section 1124 of the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act (CMTA) when no fraud is attributable to the importer.

Key Legal Principles

The Court reaffirmed that misdeclaration involves false or inaccurate declarations affecting duties and taxes. Under CAO No. 001-20, a discrepancy exceeding 30% of the assessed duties may constitute prima facie evidence of fraud, warranting seizure. However, the CMTA and related administrative orders allow settlement by redemption if the importer or consignee is not complicit. Evidence showing lack of participation in misdeclaration or preparation of shipping documents is crucial for invoking this right.

Additionally, settlement by redemption requires payment equivalent to 100% of the Total Landed Cost, and it is only barred when fraud or prohibited importation is established. The Court highlighted that importers may present contrary evidence to rebut allegations and redeem their shipments even when initial discrepancies exist, provided no fraud is committed.

Practical Takeaways

Importers must maintain robust documentation to prove non-participation in any misdeclaration. Regular communication records with suppliers and verification of shipping documents are essential. The ruling clarifies that businesses are not automatically liable for errors by suppliers if they can demonstrate lack of involvement in documentation preparation.

Customs compliance programs should incorporate verification of supplier documents and proactive review of shipment declarations. When facing seizure, businesses can seek redemption by showing absence of fraud, ensuring continuity of operations without financial loss from forfeiture.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Our tax litigation team provides strategic guidance for importers facing seizure or forfeiture issues. We assist in documenting transactions, preparing evidence to counter prima facie fraud, and negotiating redemption settlements. Learn more about protecting your shipments and ensuring customs compliance at

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *