Old local business tax assessments may be void if fraud is raised too late and not proven by clear and convincing evidence under the Local Government Code.
Local governments seeking to collect old local business taxes must clearly state, at the assessment stage, why they are relying on an extended prescriptive period. A taxpayer cannot be forced to defend against a fraud theory raised only during trial, and a stale local tax assessment may be cancelled when the taxing authority fails to prove fraud by clear and convincing evidence.
Background of the Local Business Tax Dispute
The dispute involved a local business tax assessment issued by a city government against a tollway operator for taxable years 2005 to 2014. The assessment was issued on November 11, 2019, and the local taxing authority sought to collect alleged deficiencies despite the passage of several years from the periods involved.
In the earlier decision, the Court of Tax Appeals affirmed the cancellation of the local business tax assessment. The court held that the assessment was already barred by prescription under Section 194 of the Local Government Code, which generally requires local taxes to be assessed and collected within five years from the date they became due. The local taxing authority then filed a motion for reconsideration, asking the court to reverse that ruling (CTA AC No. 296).
Why the Local Government Invoked the Ten-Year Period
Section 194 of the Local Government Code recognizes a longer ten-year period in cases involving fraud or intent to evade payment. The local taxing authority attempted to rely on this exception by arguing that the taxpayer had verbally proposed to treat allegedly erroneous tax payments as a donation. According to the taxing authority, this proposal supposedly showed deliberate circumvention of tax obligations.
The court was not persuaded. It held that fraud cannot simply be inferred from a taxpayer proposal to treat certain payments as a donation. Standing alone, the proposal did not show an intent to evade taxes. The taxpayer had, in fact, paid the assessed amounts despite maintaining that it was not liable, and then used the proper legal remedy to protest the assessment.
Fraud Must Be Proven by Clear and Convincing Evidence
The ruling is important for taxpayers facing old local business tax assessments because it reinforces that fraud is never presumed. While fraud may be inferred from circumstances and need not always be proven by direct evidence, the burden remains on the party alleging fraud. The court emphasized that the required level of proof is clear and convincing evidence, a standard higher than preponderance of evidence though lower than proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Here, the local taxing authority failed to present evidence meeting that standard. The court characterized the fraud theory as a mere imputation. Without clear and convincing proof of fraudulent conduct, the local taxing authority could not extend the assessment period from five years to ten years.
Due Process Requires the Assessment to State the Basis for the Extended Period
The court also ruled that the assessment suffered from a due process defect. The taxpayer argued that the local taxing authority did not make a finding of fraud in the assessment itself and raised fraud only for the first time during testimony in court. The court agreed that this violated the taxpayer’s right to due process.
A tax assessment must inform the taxpayer of the basis of the assessment with enough clarity to allow an intelligent and timely protest. Where a taxing authority invokes the extraordinary ten-year prescriptive period, it must communicate that position clearly in the assessment notice. It must also state the bases for alleging falsity or fraud. A taxpayer should not be left guessing whether the ordinary five-year rule or the extraordinary ten-year rule is being applied.
The court relied on Supreme Court guidance holding that the law on prescription should be liberally construed in favor of the taxpayer. Prescription rules exist to protect taxpayers from unreasonable examination, investigation, and assessment. When the government seeks the benefit of an exceptional period, it must observe the taxpayer’s fundamental right to due process.
Assessment Void Even Assuming Prescription Had Not Set In
The court made a critical point: even assuming that the assessment had not prescribed, it would still be void because of the due process violation. Tax assessments issued in violation of due process rights are void, and no right to collect can arise from them.
This means the defect was not merely technical. The failure to disclose the fraud basis at the assessment stage prejudiced the taxpayer’s ability to defend itself. A taxing authority cannot cure that defect by later asserting fraud during trial or in litigation filings.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Local Governments
For taxpayers, the ruling confirms that old local business tax assessments should be reviewed carefully for prescription. If the assessment covers periods beyond five years, the taxpayer should examine whether the local government clearly invoked fraud or falsity in the assessment notice and whether the factual basis for that allegation was adequately stated.
Taxpayers should also distinguish between payment, protest, compromise discussions, and admissions of fraud. A taxpayer’s attempt to resolve a tax dispute, or its proposal on how to characterize payments, should not automatically be treated as evidence of fraudulent intent. The ruling recognizes that a taxpayer may pay under protest or pursue legal remedies without conceding liability.
For local governments, the ruling is a warning that the extraordinary ten-year period cannot be used casually. Fraud must be specifically pleaded in the assessment, supported by clear factual bases, and proven by clear and convincing evidence. Raising fraud for the first time in court is too late and may render the assessment void for denial of due process.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, businesses, property owners, importers, and corporate officers in tax and customs disputes before administrative agencies, local treasurers, trial courts, and the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can evaluate whether an assessment is barred by prescription, whether the assessment notice complies with due process, and whether the government has properly established the factual and legal basis for collection.
If your company is facing a local business tax assessment, a disputed city treasurer collection action, or a tax case before the Court of Tax Appeals, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.