RR No. 1-2019 sets 10% and 15% creditable withholding tax rates on MERALCO refunds, meter deposit refund interest, and certain debt instruments.
Withholding agents paying covered MERALCO refunds, interest on refunded meter deposits, or interest income from certain debt instruments must apply the revised creditable withholding tax rates beginning January 1, 2019. The key compliance point is immediate rate correction: the withholding rate under the amended rules must not be less than 1% and must not exceed 15% of the income payment, with specific 10% and 15% rates prescribed for the affected income payments.
What RR No. 1-2019 Changed
RR No. 1-2019 further amended Section 2.57.2 of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as previously amended by RR No. 11-2018, to implement changes under Republic Act No. 10963, or the TRAIN Law, on creditable withholding tax for certain income payments. The regulation focuses on particular income payments involving MERALCO refunds, interest on meter deposit refunds by electric distribution utilities, and interest income from certain debt instruments.
The most important general rule carried into the amendment is that, beginning January 1, 2019, the rate of withholding under Section 57 of the Tax Code shall not be less than 1% and not more than 15% of the income payment. For businesses and accounting teams, this matters because the regulation identifies specific income streams where the applicable creditable withholding tax rate is fixed at either 10% or 15%.
MERALCO Refunds Subject to 15% Creditable Withholding Tax
RR No. 1-2019 provides that MERALCO refunds arising from Supreme Court Case G.R. No. 141314 dated April 9, 2003, to customers under Phase IV as approved by the Energy Regulatory Board or Energy Regulatory Commission, are subject to creditable withholding tax on the gross amount of refund given by MERALCO to customers.
The prescribed rate for this MERALCO refund is 15% on the gross amount of the refund. This is a highly specific rule and should be separately identified in withholding tax mapping, especially for companies receiving or processing MERALCO refund amounts covered by the Supreme Court case and the approved Phase IV refund mechanism.
Interest on MERALCO Meter Deposit Refunds
RR No. 1-2019 also addresses interest income on the refund of meter deposits determined, computed, and paid in accordance with the Rules to Govern Refund of Meter Deposits to Residential and Non-Residential Customers, as approved under ERC Resolution No. 8, Series of 2008, dated June 4, 2008. This rule implements Article 8 of the Magna Carta for Residential Electricity Customers and ERC Resolution No. 2005-10 RM, otherwise known as the Distribution Services and Open Access Rules or DSOAR, dated January 18, 2006, exempting electricity consumers from the payment of meter deposit.
For MERALCO, the creditable withholding tax applies to the gross amount of interest paid directly to customers or applied against the customer’s billings. Residential and General Service customers whose monthly electricity consumption exceeds 200 kWh, as classified by MERALCO, are subject to 10% creditable withholding tax. Non-residential customers are subject to 15% creditable withholding tax.
Interest on Meter Deposit Refunds by Other Electric Distribution Utilities
The same framework applies to other electric Distribution Utilities, or DUs, paying interest income on meter deposit refunds through direct payment or application against customer billings. The covered refunds must be in accordance with the rules embodied in ERC Resolution No. 8, Series of 2008, dated June 4, 2008, governing the refund of meter deposits, as approved and adopted by the ERC in compliance with Article 8 of the Magna Carta for Residential Electricity Customers and Article 3.4.2 of DSOAR.
For other electric DUs, Residential and General Service customers whose monthly electricity consumption exceeds 200 kWh, as classified by the concerned DU, are subject to 10% creditable withholding tax on the gross amount of interest paid directly or applied against billings. Non-residential customers are subject to 15% creditable withholding tax.
Interest Income from Certain Debt Instruments
RR No. 1-2019 further provides a 15% creditable withholding tax rate on interest income derived from any other debt instruments not within the coverage of deposit substitutes and Revenue Regulations No. 14-2012, unless otherwise provided by law or regulations.
This amendment is important for corporate accountants, treasury teams, lenders, borrowers, and payors of interest income because it confirms the 15% creditable withholding tax rate for interest income from debt instruments outside the deposit substitute rules and outside RR No. 14-2012. Companies should review whether their instruments fall under deposit substitutes, RR No. 14-2012, another special rule, or this residual category.
Who Is Most Affected
The taxpayers most directly affected are MERALCO, other electric distribution utilities, customers receiving covered refunds or interest credits, non-residential electricity customers, corporate customers with large electricity accounts, and withholding agents responsible for processing these payments. Businesses receiving interest credits against electric bills should not assume that a billing credit is tax-free or outside withholding simply because no cash was physically released.
The regulation is also relevant to finance departments handling interest payments on private debt instruments, intercompany loans, notes, or other instruments that may not qualify as deposit substitutes. CFOs, controllers, and tax managers should check whether interest payments have been classified under the correct withholding tax bucket.
Effective Date and Compliance Deadline
The regulation is effective beginning January 1, 2019. From that date, covered withholding agents must apply the prescribed rates to the applicable income payments. For MERALCO refund payments, the rate is 15%. For interest on meter deposit refunds paid or credited to Residential and General Service customers exceeding 200 kWh monthly consumption, the rate is 10%. For interest on meter deposit refunds paid or credited to non-residential customers, the rate is 15%. For interest income from covered debt instruments outside deposit substitutes and RR No. 14-2012, the rate is 15%.
Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance
RR No. 1-2019 does not create a special penalty provision for these amendments. However, the practical compliance risk is under-withholding or failure to withhold the correct creditable withholding tax on covered income payments beginning January 1, 2019. Accounting teams should treat the prescribed rates as part of their regular withholding tax compliance controls, voucher review, billing credit review, and tax return preparation process.
Because the regulation expressly revokes inconsistent rules and regulations or parts thereof, taxpayers should not rely on prior inconsistent withholding classifications for the covered income payments. The safer approach is to update withholding matrices, ERP tax codes, accounts payable review protocols, and supporting documentation for any payments or billing applications falling under RR No. 1-2019.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Withholding Agents
First, identify whether the company receives or processes MERALCO refunds, meter deposit refund interest, or billing credits from MERALCO or another electric distribution utility. Second, classify the customer account as Residential and General Service exceeding 200 kWh monthly consumption or Non-Residential, because the rate changes depending on that classification. Third, ensure the tax base is the gross amount of interest paid directly to the customer or applied against the customer’s billings.
Fourth, review debt instruments generating interest income and determine whether they are within deposit substitutes, RR No. 14-2012, another special rule, or the residual category subject to 15% creditable withholding tax under RR No. 1-2019. Fifth, update internal withholding tax tables so that bookkeepers, accounts payable personnel, treasury officers, and tax compliance teams consistently apply the 10% or 15% rate as required.
Common search issues for this regulation include RR No. 1-2019 withholding tax, MERALCO refund withholding tax 15%, meter deposit refund interest tax Philippines, 200 kWh electricity customer withholding tax, non-residential customer meter deposit withholding, and creditable withholding tax on debt instruments.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, finance teams, utilities, withholding agents, and corporate taxpayers on BIR compliance, withholding tax classification, tax risk reviews, and documentation of payment structures. For companies dealing with MERALCO refunds, electric utility billing credits, interest income, or debt instruments, the issue is not merely knowing the rate; it is building a defensible process that applies the correct tax treatment every time.
For assistance in reviewing withholding tax exposure, updating tax compliance procedures, or assessing the treatment of refunds, billing credits, and interest payments under RR No. 1-2019, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.