RR No. 6-2018 restores rules allowing expense deductions despite withholding tax errors if tax, interest, surcharges, and penalties are paid during BIR audit.
Businesses that failed to withhold, underwithheld, or discovered withholding tax errors now have a restored route to preserve deductions: RR No. 6-2018 revokes RR No. 12-2013 and reinstates the Section 2.58.5 rules under RR No. 14-2002, as amended by RR No. 17-2003. For corporations, SMEs, withholding agents, accountants, and CFOs, the practical consequence is significant: an otherwise deductible expense may still be allowed if the required withholding tax, interest, and applicable surcharges are paid at the time of BIR audit, investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
What RR No. 6-2018 Changed
RR No. 6-2018 revokes Revenue Regulations No. 12-2013, which previously dealt with the requirements for deductibility of certain expenses. By revoking RR No. 12-2013, the regulation reinstates Section 2.58.5 of RR No. 14-2002, as amended by RR No. 17-2003.
The central rule restored by RR No. 6-2018 is that an income payment which is otherwise deductible under the National Internal Revenue Code may be allowed as a deduction from the payor’s gross income only if it is shown that the income tax required to be withheld has been paid to the Bureau of Internal Revenue in accordance with Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code.
This matters because many tax assessments do not involve only the direct deficiency withholding tax. They also affect the deductibility of the underlying expense. For example, payments to suppliers, contractors, service providers, professionals, lessors, or other payees may be questioned if the withholding tax was not properly remitted. RR No. 6-2018 clarifies that the deduction is not automatically lost in every case, provided the remedial payments required under the reinstated rule are made.
Who Is Affected by RR No. 6-2018
RR No. 6-2018 is addressed to all withholding agents, internal revenue officers, employees, and others concerned. In practical business terms, the most affected parties are corporations, sole proprietorships, partnerships, SMEs, large taxpayers, corporate accountants, finance departments, and tax compliance teams that make income payments subject to withholding tax.
The regulation is especially relevant to taxpayers facing BIR audit, Letter of Authority examinations, withholding tax reconciliation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration. Businesses that previously failed to withhold expanded withholding tax, compensation withholding tax, final withholding tax, or other applicable withholding taxes should review whether their expense deductions may still be defended under the restored Section 2.58.5 framework.
Common search issues covered by RR No. 6-2018 include deductibility of expenses without withholding tax, BIR audit withholding tax deficiency, underwithholding tax deduction Philippines, RR 6-2018 requirements for deductibility, and failure to withhold tax expense deduction.
Key Rule on Deductibility of Expenses
The default rule is direct: an income payment that is otherwise deductible under the Tax Code shall be allowed as a deduction from the payor’s gross income only if the income tax required to be withheld has been paid to the BIR in accordance with Sections 57 and 58 of the Tax Code.
This means that the business expense must still be deductible under ordinary tax rules. RR No. 6-2018 does not create a new deduction. It addresses the withholding tax condition attached to the allowance of an otherwise deductible expense. The expense must still satisfy the regular requirements under the Tax Code, including that it is properly substantiated and legally deductible.
For CFOs and accountants, the operational point is that withholding tax compliance remains tied to income tax deductibility. A payment booked as expense may become vulnerable during assessment if the required withholding tax was not remitted. The restored rule allows the taxpayer to protect the deduction by complying with the payment conditions specified in the regulation.
When a Deduction May Still Be Allowed Despite No Withholding
RR No. 6-2018 reinstates three specific situations where a deduction may still be allowed even if no withholding tax was made.
First, the deduction may be allowed where the payee reported the income and paid the tax due thereon, and the withholding agent pays the tax, including interest incident to the failure to withhold the tax and surcharges, if applicable, at the time of audit, investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
Second, the deduction may be allowed where the recipient or payee failed to report the income on its due date, but the withholding agent or taxpayer pays the tax, including interest incident to the failure to withhold the tax and surcharges, if applicable, at the time of audit, investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
Third, the deduction may be allowed where the withholding agent erroneously underwithheld the tax but pays the difference between the correct amount and the amount actually withheld, including interest incident to the error and surcharges, if applicable, at the time of audit, investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
These rules are highly practical. They recognize that withholding tax errors can occur in business operations, but they also require actual payment of the basic withholding tax deficiency, interest, and applicable surcharges. The regulation does not excuse non-compliance; it provides a pathway to preserve deductibility when the withholding agent cures the deficiency during the relevant BIR proceedings.
Special Rule for Return of Capital Items
RR No. 6-2018 also reinstates a specific rule for items of deduction representing return of capital. These include purchases of raw materials forming part of finished products and purchases of goods for resale.
For these return of capital items, the deduction shall be allowed upon the withholding agent’s payment of the basic withholding tax and penalties incident to non-withholding or underwithholding. This is important for trading, retail, manufacturing, distribution, food, logistics, and inventory-heavy businesses where purchases of goods or raw materials are central to the cost structure.
In a BIR audit, this distinction can matter because the disallowance of inventory-related purchases or cost of goods can dramatically affect taxable income. RR No. 6-2018 confirms that, for these items, payment of the basic withholding tax and penalties incident to non-withholding or underwithholding is the remedial requirement stated in the regulation.
Effective Date and Compliance Deadline
RR No. 6-2018 provides that it shall take effect after fifteen days following publication in any newspaper of general circulation. The regulation was approved on January 5, 2018.
Because the effective date depends on publication, businesses applying RR No. 6-2018 to historical assessments should confirm the applicable publication date when dealing with a specific taxable period or assessment. For current compliance purposes, however, the key operating rule is clear: withholding taxes required under the Tax Code must be withheld and remitted, and any failure or underwithholding should be corrected promptly, especially when a BIR audit, investigation, reinvestigation, or reconsideration is pending.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RR No. 6-2018 specifically refers to payment of the tax, interest incident to the failure to withhold or underwithholding, and surcharges, if applicable. It also refers to penalties incident to non-withholding or underwithholding for items of deduction representing return of capital, such as raw materials forming part of finished products or goods for resale.
The practical risk is twofold. First, the withholding agent may be assessed for the unpaid or deficient withholding tax, together with interest and applicable surcharges. Second, the underlying expense deduction may be challenged if the withholding tax requirement is not satisfied. This combination can significantly increase a company’s tax exposure because the same transaction may trigger both a withholding tax deficiency and an income tax consequence through disallowance of deductions.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
Businesses should immediately review expense accounts that are typically subject to withholding tax, including payments for services, rentals, professional fees, contractors, commissions, supplier arrangements, and other income payments covered by withholding rules. The review should identify payments where no withholding was made, where the wrong withholding rate was applied, or where withholding tax was not remitted on time.
Finance teams should also reconcile withholding tax returns, certificates of tax withheld, general ledger entries, accounts payable records, supplier master files, and BIR audit schedules. If a deficiency is found, the company should quantify the basic withholding tax, interest, and any applicable surcharge or penalty before entering audit discussions or filing a reinvestigation or reconsideration position.
For inventory-heavy taxpayers, accountants should separately identify purchases of raw materials forming part of finished products and purchases of goods for resale. RR No. 6-2018 expressly recognizes these return of capital items and states that they shall be allowed as deductions upon payment by the withholding agent of the basic withholding tax and penalties incident to non-withholding or underwithholding.
Companies under BIR audit should avoid treating withholding tax findings as isolated issues. Every withholding tax issue should be reviewed alongside the potential disallowance of the related expense. Conversely, where the BIR proposes to disallow expenses solely because of withholding tax non-compliance, taxpayers should evaluate whether the reinstated Section 2.58.5 rules allow the deduction to be preserved through payment of the required tax, interest, surcharges, and penalties, as applicable.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 6-2018 is a critical regulation for businesses facing BIR audit, withholding tax deficiency findings, and possible disallowance of expense deductions. The difference between losing a deduction and preserving it may depend on timely payment, correct classification of the transaction, proper documentation, and a legally grounded response during audit, reinvestigation, or reconsideration.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, finance teams, and business owners in BIR audit defense, withholding tax compliance, deductibility reviews, tax assessment responses, and settlement strategy. For legal assistance on RR No. 6-2018, withholding tax deficiencies, or BIR disallowance of expenses, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.