RR No. 11-2014 imposes 1% CWT rules for REIT income payments and locally produced raw sugar or molasses, with release authorization requirements.
Businesses dealing with Real Estate Investment Trusts, locally produced raw sugar, molasses, agricultural products, and top withholding agents must update their withholding tax treatment by January 1, 2015. RR No. 11-2014 creates a separate 1% creditable withholding tax category for income payments to REITs and a separate 1% creditable withholding tax regime for locally produced raw sugar and molasses, while clarifying how agricultural products are treated under existing withholding tax rules.
What RR No. 11-2014 Changed
RR No. 11-2014 further amends Section 2.57.2 of RR No. 2-98, as amended, particularly the provisions on creditable withholding tax for income payments made by top private corporations, income payments to agricultural suppliers, income payments made by top individual taxpayers, income payments to Real Estate Investment Trusts, and income payments involving locally produced raw sugar and molasses.
The most important change is the creation of separate withholding tax classifications for REITs and locally produced raw sugar. Instead of leaving these transactions to be analyzed under broader supplier or agricultural product categories, the regulation expressly provides a specific creditable withholding tax treatment for each. This matters because withholding agents, sugar mills, sugar refineries, traders, direct buyers, and companies paying REITs must apply the correct rate, use the correct basis, and secure the required authorization before releasing locally produced raw sugar or molasses.
For income payments to Real Estate Investment Trusts, RR No. 11-2014 provides a 1% creditable withholding tax on income payments made to corporate taxpayers duly registered with the Large Taxpayers Regular Audit Division 3, now Regular LT Audit Division 3, of the Bureau of Internal Revenue as REITs for purposes of availing the incentive provisions of Republic Act No. 9856, otherwise known as the Real Estate Investment Trust Act of 2009, as implemented by RR No. 13-2011.
For locally produced raw sugar and molasses, RR No. 11-2014 provides a separate 1% creditable withholding tax treatment. Proprietors or operators of sugar mills or refineries on their mill share, and direct buyers of Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates from sugar planters, must withhold and remit the tax to the BIR based on the applicable base price of P1,000.00 per 50-kilogram bag for locally produced raw sugar and P4,000.00 per metric ton for molasses, subject to adjustment by the Commissioner after consultation with the Sugar Regulatory Administration.
Who Is Affected by RR No. 11-2014
RR No. 11-2014 affects several groups of taxpayers and withholding agents. First, corporations making income payments to REITs must determine whether the payee is a corporate taxpayer duly registered with the relevant BIR Large Taxpayers office as a REIT under Republic Act No. 9856 and RR No. 13-2011. If so, the income payment is subject to 1% creditable withholding tax under the newly created REIT subsection.
Second, the regulation directly affects the Philippine sugar industry. Sugar mills, sugar refineries, sugar planters, traders, industry users, and direct buyers of Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates must comply with the withholding and authorization requirements for locally produced raw sugar and molasses. The regulation recognizes the peculiar operations of sugar industry players regulated by the Sugar Regulatory Administration and creates a separate subsection for these transactions.
Third, top twenty thousand private corporations remain affected when making income payments to local or resident suppliers of goods and services other than those already covered by other withholding tax rates. RR No. 11-2014 clarifies that, for this purpose, agricultural products in their original state include only corn, coconut, copra, palay, rice, cassava, coffee, fruit, vegetable, marine food product, poultry, and livestock.
Fourth, top five thousand individual taxpayers engaged in trade or business in the Philippines remain affected when making income payments to local or resident suppliers of goods and services, again subject to the clarification that agricultural products in their original state include only corn, coconut, copra, palay, rice, cassava, coffee, fruit, vegetable, marine food product, poultry, and livestock.
Fifth, hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, food processors, canneries, supermarkets, livestock dealers, poultry dealers, fish and marine product dealers, hardwares, factories, furniture shops, and other establishments that make income payments to agricultural suppliers must review the P300,000.00 cumulative threshold within the same taxable year. Income payments made to agricultural suppliers in excess of the cumulative amount of P300,000.00 within the same taxable year are subject to 1% creditable withholding tax.
Key Withholding Tax Rates and Thresholds
The key rate introduced and clarified by RR No. 11-2014 is 1% creditable withholding tax. This 1% rate applies to income payments to REITs duly registered with the BIR Large Taxpayers office for purposes of Republic Act No. 9856 and RR No. 13-2011. Businesses making payments to REITs should confirm the REIT registration status of the payee before applying the rate.
The same 1% rate applies to income payments on locally produced raw sugar and molasses. The withholding tax is computed based on the applicable base price of P1,000.00 per 50-kilogram bag for locally produced raw sugar and P4,000.00 per metric ton for molasses. These base prices are expressly subject to adjustment when deemed necessary by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue after consultation with the Administrator of the Sugar Regulatory Administration.
For agricultural suppliers, the regulation maintains the rule that income payments to agricultural suppliers are subject to 1% creditable withholding tax when the payments exceed the cumulative amount of P300,000.00 within the same taxable year. The term agricultural suppliers covers suppliers and sellers of agricultural, forest, and marine food and non-food products, livestock, and poultry of a kind generally used as, or yielding or producing foods for human consumption, including breeding stock and genetic materials.
The regulation also clarifies that meat, fruit, fish, vegetable, and other agricultural and marine food products remain covered even if they have undergone simple preparation or preservation processes for the market, such as freezing, drying, salting, smoking, or stripping. The rule also includes products using advanced packaging methods such as shrink wrapping in plastics, vacuum packing, tetra-pack, and similar packaging methods.
Special Rules for Locally Produced Raw Sugar and Molasses
RR No. 11-2014 gives special attention to locally produced raw sugar and molasses. For sugar mills and refineries, mill share is treated as equivalent to a sale of locally produced raw sugar. This means that proprietors or operators of sugar mills or refineries must withhold and remit the creditable withholding tax on their mill share.
Direct buyers of Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates from sugar planters must also withhold and remit the 1% creditable withholding tax. A Quedan is a warehouse receipt issued by a sugar mill or refinery to the owner, attesting that the volume and class of sugar is kept at the sugar mill or refinery, with a commitment that it will be delivered to the holder upon demand. A Molasses Storage Certificate is a warehouse receipt issued by a sugar mill or refinery attesting that the volume of molasses is stored at the mill’s facilities and will be delivered to the holder upon demand.
The regulation defines buyers of Quedan or Molasses Storage Certificates as traders or industry users duly accredited by the Sugar Regulatory Administration who bid for or purchase the Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates from sugar planters. It also defines a trader as a domestic company or person authorized and licensed by the Sugar Regulatory Administration to engage in the business of trading sugar, molasses, or muscovado.
Authorization Required Before Release of Raw Sugar or Molasses
A critical compliance requirement under RR No. 11-2014 is the Authorization Allowing the Release of Locally Produced Raw Sugar or Molasses. The Regional Director, through the recommendation of the Revenue District Officer having jurisdiction over the physical location of the sugar mills or refineries, must issue the authorization to proprietors or operators for the transfer or withdrawal of their mill share, or to buyers of Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates on locally produced raw sugar or molasses.
The authorization is required for release for further processing into refined sugar, consumption, or other purposes. Before the authorization may be issued, copies of proof of payment of the creditable withholding tax must be submitted and attached to the written request. These proof documents include the duly validated Monthly Remittance Return of Creditable Income Taxes Withheld (Expanded), BIR Form No. 1601-E, and the Bank Payment/Deposit Slip or Revenue Official Receipt, BIR Form No. 2524.
This requirement is operationally significant. Sugar mills, refineries, traders, and direct buyers cannot treat withholding as a mere year-end tax reporting item. The withholding tax payment documents are tied to the physical release or withdrawal of locally produced raw sugar or molasses. Businesses in the sugar supply chain should therefore align their accounting, treasury, logistics, and regulatory documentation before attempting any transfer or withdrawal.
Effect of Income Tax Exemption Claims
RR No. 11-2014 expressly states that even if proof of exemption from income tax is presented, such as a BIR ruling or special law, the concerned proprietor or operator of the sugar mill or refinery, or any buyer of Quedan or Molasses Storage Certificate, is still required to withhold and remit the creditable withholding tax.
This is one of the most important risk points for taxpayers. A party claiming income tax exemption should not automatically assume that no creditable withholding tax must be withheld on locally produced raw sugar or molasses. The regulation makes withholding mandatory notwithstanding the presentation of proof of exemption from income tax. Withholding agents who rely only on an exemption document without remitting the 1% creditable withholding tax may face BIR exposure and operational delays in securing release authorization.
Effective Date and Repeal of Prior Inconsistent Rules
RR No. 11-2014 takes effect on January 1, 2015, following publication in a newspaper of general circulation. From that date, affected taxpayers and withholding agents must apply the amended rules under Section 2.57.2 of RR No. 2-98, as amended.
The regulation also modifies, amends, revokes, or repeals all existing rules and regulations, or parts thereof, that are inconsistent with its provisions. Importantly, it lifts the suspension of the implementation of withholding tax on income payments made to suppliers of agricultural products under Section 2.57.2(S) of RR No. 2-98, as amended, as prescribed under RR No. 3-2004, insofar as locally produced raw sugar is concerned.
Practical Compliance Steps for Businesses
Businesses should immediately map all payments that may fall under RR No. 11-2014. Companies paying REITs should confirm whether the payee is properly registered as a REIT with the relevant BIR Large Taxpayers office and apply the 1% creditable withholding tax where applicable. Accounting teams should update vendor master files, withholding tax codes, and payment processing workflows to reflect the separate REIT category.
Businesses in the sugar industry should identify whether they are acting as a sugar mill, sugar refinery, sugar planter, trader, industry user, or direct buyer of Quedans or Molasses Storage Certificates. They should compute the 1% creditable withholding tax using the base price of P1,000.00 per 50-kilogram bag of locally produced raw sugar and P4,000.00 per metric ton of molasses, unless the Commissioner has adjusted the applicable base price after consultation with the Sugar Regulatory Administration.
Before any release or withdrawal of locally produced raw sugar or molasses, taxpayers should prepare the written request for authorization and attach proof of payment, including the validated BIR Form No. 1601-E and BIR Form No. 2524 or the applicable bank payment or deposit document. Businesses should not wait until the intended release date before preparing these documents because the authorization requirement may affect deliveries, production schedules, refining, consumption, and downstream supply commitments.
Companies dealing with agricultural suppliers should monitor the P300,000.00 cumulative payment threshold within the same taxable year. Once the threshold is exceeded, the 1% creditable withholding tax rule applies to income payments to agricultural suppliers. Businesses should also classify agricultural and marine food products carefully, including products that have been frozen, dried, salted, smoked, stripped, shrink-wrapped, vacuum-packed, tetra-packed, or similarly packaged.
Penalties and Compliance Risk
RR No. 11-2014 does not set out a separate penalty table. However, failure to withhold and remit creditable withholding tax exposes withholding agents to the consequences provided under the National Internal Revenue Code and related BIR regulations. In practical terms, non-compliance may result in deficiency withholding tax assessments, penalties, interest, and disallowance or audit exposure, depending on the facts of the transaction and the taxpayer’s records.
For locally produced raw sugar and molasses, the more immediate business risk is operational. The release or withdrawal authorization requires proof of payment of the creditable withholding tax. Without proper withholding and remittance documentation, taxpayers may encounter delays in securing authorization for transfer or withdrawal of mill share, raw sugar, or molasses.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 11-2014 is not merely a technical amendment. It affects payment processing, withholding tax coding, supplier classification, REIT transactions, sugar industry documentation, and the release of locally produced raw sugar and molasses. For businesses, the practical question is not only whether the 1% rate applies, but whether the company has the records, forms, and internal controls to prove timely withholding and remittance.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, accounting teams, in-house counsel, REIT counterparties, agribusinesses, and regulated businesses in reviewing BIR compliance obligations, withholding tax exposure, supplier documentation, and tax audit readiness. For assistance with RR No. 11-2014, creditable withholding tax compliance, REIT transactions, agricultural supplier payments, or sugar industry tax documentation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.