RR No. 5-2007 sets BIR tax, registration, reporting, and penalty rules for PDEx fixed-income securities borrowing and lending transactions.
Participants in the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program must register the Master Securities Lending Agreement and their Participation Agreements with the BIR before entering into securities borrowing and lending transactions if they want the intended tax-free treatment for the lending, borrowing, collateral delivery, and collateral return. Without strict compliance, the same transaction may be treated as a deposit substitute or as a sale and purchase of securities, triggering the applicable taxes, surcharges, interest, and reporting penalties under the Tax Code.
What RR No. 5-2007 Changed
RR No. 5-2007 prescribed the specific tax treatment, conditions, registration rules, and reporting requirements for Securities Borrowing and Lending transactions, also called Securities Lending Transactions, under the Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program of the Philippine Dealing & Exchange Corp., or PDEx. The regulation is limited to borrowing and lending of fixed-income securities under the PDEx program. Securities lending transactions administered by exchanges other than PDEx, even if duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission, are excluded and are to be covered by separate regulations.
The core tax rule is that qualified borrowing and lending of securities under the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program is not subject to documentary stamp tax under Section 175 of the Tax Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 9243. The delivery and return of collateral in respect of the qualified transaction are likewise not subject to documentary stamp tax, capital gains tax, income tax, and other taxes, if otherwise applicable. This favorable treatment applies only if the parties execute a valid Master Securities Lending Agreement, register and secure approval from the BIR, comply with SEC rules, transact under the PDEx-administered program, and comply with the regulation and implementing issuances.
Who Is Affected by RR No. 5-2007
The regulation primarily affects PDEx trading participants, institutional lenders, lending agents, borrowers of fixed-income securities, and entities involved in securities settlement, short positions, market-making activities, collateral management, and fixed-income trading operations. It is especially relevant to banks, securities dealers, financial institutions, investment houses, custodians, and other entities participating in the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program.
The regulation identifies the principal parties to a covered transaction. The Borrower must be a duly admitted PDEx Trading Participant qualified under the Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program. The Lender is an institution qualified by PDEx that lends securities from its own asset pool or from client assets through a lending agent. A foreign lender must deal through a Lending Agent. The Lending Agent must be accredited by the BSP or the SEC and qualified by PDEx. The Philippine Depository and Trust Corporation, or PDTC, acts as both Lending Pool System Operator and Collateral Management System Operator under the program.
Covered Securities and Eligible Collateral
RR No. 5-2007 covers only fixed-income debt securities acceptable for lending under the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program. For Philippine peso-denominated fixed-income instruments, these include securities issued by the Republic of the Philippines Bureau of the Treasury, securities issued by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, securities issued by municipal or local government units of the Philippines and listed in PDEx, and private corporate debt securities listed in PDEx. For U.S. dollar-denominated instruments, the regulation covers Republic of the Philippines debt securities and private corporate debt securities listed in PDEx.
The collateral that may be delivered into the Collateral Management System is also limited. The regulation recognizes Philippine peso-denominated fixed-income instruments, U.S. dollar-denominated fixed-income instruments, Philippine peso-denominated equity instruments listed as components of the Philippine Stock Exchange Composite Index, and cash. Because the regulation ties tax treatment to the PDEx program, securities not listed in or traded through PDEx generally do not fall within the scope of the regulation.
Key Conditions for Tax-Free Treatment
The tax treatment is conditional. Before any borrowing of covered debt securities, the parties must have entered into a Master Securities Lending Agreement through execution of their respective Participation Agreements. The MSLA must preserve the lender’s economic position by giving the lender the right to receive all income and benefits accruing on the lent or borrowed securities during the borrowing period. The borrower must pass through coupon payments, interest income, and other benefits to the lender as Manufactured Income or Substitute Payment.
The MSLA must also preserve the borrower’s rights over the collateral. Although title over collateral may be transferred, the borrower continues to retain the rights accruing to the collateral, including interest income or cash stock dividends, which the lender must pass on to the borrower. The transaction must not be structured as a regular buy-and-sell transaction. The borrower merely provides collateral to secure the obligation to return equivalent securities.
The borrowing period agreed by the parties must not exceed one year from the date of execution of the SLT Confirmation Notice. On or before the end of that period, the borrower must return the equivalent of the borrowed securities, and the lender must return the collateral.
Permitted Purposes for Borrowing Securities
RR No. 5-2007 limits covered SBL or SLT transactions to specified purposes. Securities may be borrowed to settle a sale of Philippine securities effected in the Philippines and avoid failed settlement. They may also be borrowed to settle a future sale, including where the borrowing is made in anticipation of a short sale. Securities may be borrowed to replace securities previously obtained under another SBL or SLT agreement, provided the initial borrowing itself qualifies under the regulation.
The regulation also allows on-lending of borrowed securities to another borrower who has entered into another SBL or SLT agreement, provided the subsequent borrower uses the securities for a permitted specified purpose. Other purposes similar or analogous to the enumerated purposes, or consistent with the objectives of the SBL or SLT program, may be allowed if determined by the BIR upon favorable recommendation of PDEx.
BIR Registration Requirements and Deadlines
The registration rules are central to RR No. 5-2007. PDEx must provide the BIR with three certified true copies of the MSLA, a specimen Participation Agreement, and registration of the MSLA initially before operation of the Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program and for every amendment thereafter.
Each Borrower and Lender must provide the BIR with a duly executed Participation Agreement bearing the conformity of the Exchange, pay the prescribed registration fee of Php 5,000.00 for every Participation Agreement on a per-capacity basis, and submit other documents and information that the BIR may require. A participant acting as Borrower must register and pay the fee for that capacity. If the same party also wants to participate as Lender, a separate Participation Agreement and separate compliance with registration requirements are required.
The Participation Agreement must be registered with the Law Division of the BIR National Office, or such other office as the Commissioner may direct. Payment of the registration fee must be made with the General Services Division at the BIR National Office. Registration of a duly accomplished Participation Agreement must be made within two weeks if executed in the Philippines and within one month if executed outside the Philippines before an SBL or SLT can be effected.
The BIR is required to return the Borrower’s and Lender’s copy of the Participation Agreement, endorsed with a registration number and stamped to acknowledge payment of the registration fee, with approval or denial within ten working days from receipt. The Participation Agreement does not bind PDEx until the participant submits the BIR-registered Participation Agreement to PDEx in the required form.
Tax Treatment of Manufactured Income and Collateral Income
Manufactured Income, also called Substitute Payment or Pass-through Payment, includes interest income or coupon payments from the lent or borrowed securities, as well as interest income accrued and received by the Borrower from its sale of the lent or borrowed securities, which must be passed on to the Lender during the life of the SBL or SLT.
The Lender’s receipt of Manufactured Income from the Borrower is subject only to the applicable taxes on the interest income, coupon payment, or other benefits paid by the issuer and accruing during the borrowing period, as prescribed by law. However, the Borrower’s payment of Manufactured Income to the Lender, whether derived from the sale of the lent or borrowed securities or from a coupon payment by the issuer, is not treated as a tax-deductible expense. Separately, the Borrower’s receipt of interest income accruing on the collateral is subject to withholding tax under Section 57 of the Tax Code.
When the Transaction Becomes a Deposit Substitute or Sale
A non-compliant SBL or SLT may lose the intended tax treatment. The transaction is deemed a deposit substitute if the borrowed securities are used for purposes other than those allowed, if the borrower or lender fails to comply with the essential features of a valid MSLA, if the Participation Agreements are not registered with the BIR, or if the transaction involves regular banking unit transactions subject to the appropriate taxes under the Tax Code. In that case, the transaction is subject to the applicable taxes on deposit substitutes under Sections 24(B)(1), 25(A)(2), 25(B), 27(D)(1), 28(A)(7)(a), and 28(B)(1) of the Tax Code, plus other applicable taxes.
The transaction may also be deemed a sale and purchase of the borrowed securities, and of the collateral as well, if there is no return of the lent securities or collateral at the end of the borrowing period, if there is an actual sale of debt securities subject of the SBL or SLT such as a short sale, if the borrower or lender fails to comply with the essential features of a valid MSLA, or if the parties are not registered with the BIR as securities lender or borrower through their Participation Agreements. In such case, the transaction is subject to the applicable taxes on the sale and purchase of securities under Sections 24(C), 25(B), 27(A), and 28(B) of the Tax Code, plus other applicable taxes.
Record-Keeping and Reporting Requirements
Borrowers and Lenders that enter into SBL or SLT transactions must keep SBL or SLT ledgers and other books of account in the form prescribed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. They must enter the required particulars of SBL or SLT transactions and Securities Returns into the ledger, provide the BIR with reports of SBL or SLT transactions together with Confirmation Notices and Securities Returns, and prepare and keep an SBL or SLT Report for each specific transaction.
The ledgers may be kept in written or electronic form, provided the relevant information can be supplied in legible hard copy. PDTC must prepare a bi-annual summary report of outstanding SBL or SLT transactions and Securities Returns every six months and file it with the Law Division of the BIR National Office within one month after the end of the covered period. PDTC must also prepare a report of all liquidated SBL or SLT transactions as of December 31 of each year and file it with the Law Division within one month after that date.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RR No. 5-2007 imposes the penalties applicable to unpaid taxes, unfiled tax returns, and failure to comply with reporting and record-keeping obligations. A 25 percent surcharge applies for failure to file a return and pay the tax due on the prescribed date, filing with the wrong internal revenue officer unless otherwise authorized, failure to pay deficiency tax within the prescribed time, or failure to pay the full or part of the tax due on time.
A 50 percent surcharge applies in case of willful neglect to file the return or pay the tax due within the prescribed period, or if a false or fraudulent return is willfully made. Interest is imposed at 20 percent per annum, or such higher rate as may be prescribed, from the date prescribed for payment until full payment. Deficiency interest and delinquency interest may also apply under the regulation.
For failure to file an information return, statement, or list, or to keep any record or supply required information on the prescribed date, the penalty is Php 1,000.00 for each failure, unless reasonable cause and absence of willful neglect are shown. The aggregate penalty for all such failures during a calendar year must not exceed Php 25,000.00.
Practical Steps for PDEx Participants and Financial Institutions
Institutions participating in the PDEx Fixed-Income Securities Lending Program should first confirm that the securities involved are covered fixed-income securities and that the proposed collateral falls within the eligible collateral categories. They should review the MSLA to ensure that it contains all essential features required by RR No. 5-2007, including the lender’s entitlement to income on the lent securities, the borrower’s entitlement to income on collateral, the collateral valuation mechanism, a borrowing period not exceeding one year, the return obligations, and the permitted purpose for borrowing.
Borrowers and Lenders should also register the appropriate Participation Agreement with the BIR before the first covered transaction. The Php 5,000.00 registration fee applies for every Participation Agreement on a per-capacity basis, and registration must be made within two weeks for agreements executed in the Philippines or one month for agreements executed outside the Philippines before any SBL or SLT is effected. Participants should also calendar the annual payment of registration fees and the filing timelines for PDTC reports.
From a tax risk perspective, the most important control is documentation. The parties should retain the BIR-registered Participation Agreement, Confirmation Notices, Securities Return records, transaction ledgers, SBL or SLT reports, and proof that the borrowed securities were used only for specified purposes. If the transaction is recharacterized as a deposit substitute or sale, the tax consequences may be materially different from the intended treatment.
ASG Law Can Assist with BIR Compliance for Securities Lending Transactions
RR No. 5-2007 is highly technical, but its business consequence is straightforward: favorable tax treatment is available only for properly structured, properly registered, and properly documented PDEx fixed-income securities lending transactions. Financial institutions, securities market participants, and corporate treasury teams should not treat registration and record-keeping as clerical matters because non-compliance can change the entire tax character of the transaction.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients with Philippine tax compliance, BIR registrations, securities transaction documentation, withholding tax issues, tax risk reviews, and regulatory structuring for financial and capital markets transactions. For assistance with RR No. 5-2007, PDEx securities borrowing and lending tax treatment, BIR registration of Participation Agreements, or tax review of fixed-income securities transactions, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.