RR No. 18-2006 allowed qualified taxpayers to pay IVAP amounts for 2005 and prior years to obtain last priority in BIR audit, subject to strict exclusions.

Taxpayers with possible underpaid income tax, VAT, percentage tax, withholding tax, excise tax, documentary stamp tax, preferential-rate tax, or one-time transaction taxes for taxable year 2005 and prior years were given a limited opportunity to pay a prescribed IVAP amount and obtain last priority in BIR audit. RR No. 18-2006 mattered because a valid availment could suspend audit action and lead to cancellation or withdrawal of Letters of Authority, Audit Notices, Letter Notices, Taxpayer Verification Notices, and Mission Orders for the covered taxable year or period and tax type. The deadline for availment was November 29, 2006, subject to extension by the Commissioner on meritorious grounds.

What RR No. 18-2006 Changed

RR No. 18-2006 prescribed the policies, procedures, and guidelines for the Improved Voluntary Assessment Program, or IVAP, for taxable year 2005 and prior years under certain conditions. The program allowed qualified taxpayers to voluntarily pay an additional amount based on the prescribed IVAP formula in exchange for the privilege of last priority in audit and investigation.

The program covered all internal revenue taxes for taxable years ending December 31, 2005, fiscal years ending on any day not later than June 30, 2006, and prior years. It also covered one-time transactions, including estate tax, donor’s tax, capital gains tax, final withholding tax, expanded withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax on the transfer, sale, exchange, or disposition of assets. Taxpayers enjoying preferential tax treatment, such as those under PEZA or SBMA regimes, were also covered.

The most important practical change was that IVAP availment was allowed on a per taxable year or period and per tax-type basis. This means that a taxpayer could seek IVAP coverage for one tax type or period without necessarily covering every other possible tax exposure. For businesses searching for BIR IVAP 2005, voluntary assessment program Philippines, no audit program BIR, or BIR last priority in audit, this regulation established the applicable conditions, exclusions, payment computations, installment rules, and deadline.

Who Could Avail of IVAP

Any natural or juridical person, including estates and trusts, liable for the covered internal revenue taxes could avail of IVAP if the taxpayer erroneously paid internal revenue tax liabilities or failed to file tax returns or pay taxes due to inadvertence or otherwise. The coverage was broad and included taxpayers with possible exposure to income tax, VAT, percentage tax, excise tax, documentary stamp tax, withholding taxes, preferential-rate taxes, accrued penalties, and taxes on one-time transactions.

However, RR No. 18-2006 imposed specific exclusions. A taxpayer could not avail of IVAP for tax types and periods already covered by a Preliminary Assessment Notice or Final Assessment Notice issued on or before the effectivity of the regulations. Taxpayers under investigation due to verified information filed by a Tax Informer under Section 282 of the NIRC, if duly processed and recorded in the BIR Official Registry Book on or before effectivity, were also excluded.

The program also excluded tax fraud cases filed and pending in the Department of Justice or in the courts; cases handled by the BIR under the Run After Tax Evader or RATE Program; and cases where Letter Notices were issued and the discrepancy in sales exceeded 30% of sales of the base year or the discrepancy in purchases exceeded 30% of purchases of the base year. Taxpayers with unpaid tax liabilities admitted and reflected in their books, records, financial statements, or tax returns for the covered period were excluded for the relevant tax type unless they first paid the admitted liability, such as DST payable, withholding tax payable, or unpaid second installment income tax.

Audit Benefit: Last Priority in BIR Audit

A taxpayer with valid IVAP availment was not to be audited, except upon prior authorization and approval of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. That exception applied when there was strong evidence or finding of understatement in the payment of the taxpayer’s correct tax liability by more than 30%, supported by a written report stating in detail the facts and law on which the finding was based.

If a taxpayer who availed of IVAP was nevertheless subjected to audit under the allowed circumstances, the IVAP payment would be allowed as a tax credit against the deficiency tax due. Audit was also automatically suspended upon filing of the IVAP application and payment of the IVAP amount. Where the audit case was prescribing within six months from the date of application and payment, the investigating office had to evaluate the availment within five days from receipt of payment to determine whether the taxpayer qualified.

For taxpayers with a Certificate of Qualification, Letters of Authority, Audit Notices, Letter Notices, Taxpayer Verification Notices, and Mission Orders were to be cancelled and withdrawn. This audit suspension and cancellation applied only to the taxable year or period and tax type covered by the IVAP availment.

How the IVAP Amount Was Computed

RR No. 18-2006 required taxpayers to file the IVAP application, pay the required IVAP amount to the appropriate BIR collection agent, and submit the application form, proof of payment, and required attachments to the Revenue District Office with jurisdiction over the taxpayer’s registered address. Payment could be made through an Accredited Agent Bank, or through the Revenue Collection Officer or Deputized Municipal Treasurer where there was no Accredited Agent Bank.

For income tax, including payment under MCIT, if returns were filed in both the covered year and base year, the total tax due for the covered year had to be at least 30% higher than the tax due of the base year. If no return was filed in the covered year, or if no return was filed or there was zero tax due in the base year, the required condition was at least a 30% increase of the declared tax due in the covered year. The minimum IVAP payment was P25,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with P10 million in assets or less; P100,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with more than P10 million in assets; P50,000 for estates or trusts; P50,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with P10 million in assets or less; P100,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with more than P10 million in assets; and P20 million for Large Taxpayers and taxpayers with cases handled by the National Investigation Division.

For VAT, the net VAT due for the covered year had to be 30% higher than that of the base year where returns existed for both years. Where the covered year return was not filed, or where the base year return was not filed or reflected zero net VAT due, the net VAT due had to be at least 3% of gross sales or gross receipts for the covered year. The minimum IVAP payment for VAT was P50,000 or 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with P10 million in assets or less; P100,000 or 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with more than P10 million in assets; P100,000 for estates or trusts; P100,000 or 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with P10 million in assets or less; P200,000 or 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with more than P10 million in assets; and P20 million for Large Taxpayers and taxpayers with cases handled by the National Investigation Division.

For percentage tax, the general 30% increase requirement applied. The minimum payment was P50,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with P10 million in assets or less; P100,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for individuals with more than P10 million in assets; P100,000 for estates or trusts; P100,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with P10 million in assets or less; P200,000 or one-half of 1% of sales, whichever was higher, for corporations with more than P10 million in assets; and P20 million for Large Taxpayers and taxpayers with National Investigation Division cases.

For excise tax, the general 30% increase requirement applied. The minimum IVAP payment was P50,000 for individuals with P10 million in assets or less, P100,000 for individuals with more than P10 million in assets, P50,000 for estates or trusts, P50,000 for corporations with P10 million in assets or less, P100,000 for corporations with more than P10 million in assets, and P20 million for Large Taxpayers and National Investigation Division cases.

For documentary stamp tax on business, withholding tax on compensation, expanded withholding tax, final withholding of income tax, withholding of business tax, and preferential-rate taxpayers, the regulation generally applied the same 30% increase standard, with minimum payments generally ranging from P25,000 to P100,000 for individuals, estates, trusts, and corporations, and P20 million for Large Taxpayers and National Investigation Division cases, depending on the specific tax type. For improperly accumulated earnings tax, the minimum was P100,000 for corporations and P10 million for Large Taxpayers and National Investigation Division cases.

For taxes on one-time transactions, including estate tax, donor’s tax, capital gains tax, expanded withholding tax, and documentary stamp tax on sale or disposition of real property, personal property, or shares of stock, the required payment was 130% of the unpaid tax due for covered transactions where returns were filed, or 130% of the declared unpaid tax due where returns were not filed. For accrued penalties, the required IVAP amount was 30% of the basic tax paid.

Important Payment and Credit Rules

IVAP payments could not include tax debit memos, creditable withholding tax, MCIT carry-over, or income tax carry-over from a prior period. The IVAP payment could not be used as a tax credit in the year of payment or in subsequent returns, and it could not be claimed as a deduction for internal revenue tax purposes.

However, if an audit was still conducted on the covered year under circumstances allowed by RR No. 18-2006 or by law, the IVAP payment would be credited against the deficiency tax after audit. The regulation also clarified that IVAP availment was not an admission by the taxpayer that it had erroneously paid tax or failed to file returns and pay the required tax.

Installment Payment Rules and Deadline

Where the IVAP amount exceeded P5 million, the taxpayer could elect to pay in three equal installments, provided all installment payments were made on or before November 29, 2006 unless extended by the Commissioner. If any installment was not paid on or before the fixed date, the entire unpaid amount became due and payable; otherwise, the IVAP application would be denied and the payment invalidated as an IVAP payment.

A taxpayer could request in writing an extension for installment payment on the ground of financial incapacity. The request had to be approved by the concerned Regional Director or Officer-in-Charge of the Large Taxpayers Service. To support the request, the taxpayer had to submit a list of banks where it maintained deposits or accounts, execute a waiver of secrecy of bank deposits authorizing the BIR to inquire into bank accounts, submit a written undertaking to pay the IVAP installments within a period not exceeding six months from the date of filing the IVAP application, and put up a bond corresponding to installment payments if the tax case was prescribing within six months from the filing of the IVAP application.

Processing, Certificate of Qualification, and Disqualification

The IVAP application form, validated IVAP payment form, and other required documents received by the RDO or Large Taxpayers Service served as proof of availment. The availment was still subject to review and evaluation by the concerned Regional Office or Large Taxpayers Service. If the availment was correct, the Regional Director or Officer-in-Charge of the Large Taxpayers Service would issue a Certificate of Qualification.

If the review revealed deficiencies or defects, the reviewing BIR office would require the taxpayer to comply, correct, or rectify the deficiencies. The Certificate of Qualification would be issued only upon completion of all requirements and satisfaction of all conditions. IVAP availments were to be reviewed within 30 days from the date of application and payment, after which a Certificate of Qualification or Notice of Disqualification would be issued. A taxpayer receiving a Notice of Disqualification could appeal to the Assessment Service through the Assessment Programs Division, subject to approval by the Commissioner after review by the Deputy Commissioner for Operations Group.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RR No. 18-2006 did not create a new schedule of penalties for failure to avail of IVAP. The practical risk was that invalid or incomplete availment would not produce the intended audit protection. Taxpayers excluded from the program, taxpayers that failed to meet the payment conditions, and taxpayers that failed to complete installment payments could lose the benefit of last priority in audit.

Where an IVAP availment was invalid, the taxpayer’s payment could be applied against deficiency taxes for the same taxable year on a per tax-type basis. Invalid availments included, among others, the excluded cases identified in Section 1 of the regulation, such as PAN or FAN-covered periods, tax informer cases, pending tax fraud cases, RATE cases, admitted unpaid liabilities not first paid, and certain Letter Notice cases with more than 30% sales or purchase discrepancies.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Finance Teams

For taxpayers evaluating IVAP under RR No. 18-2006, the first step was to identify the specific taxable year or period and tax type to be covered. Since availment was per tax type and per taxable year or period, accountants and CFOs needed to match the IVAP application to the exact exposure, such as 2005 income tax, VAT, expanded withholding tax, documentary stamp tax, or capital gains tax on a one-time transaction.

Second, the taxpayer needed to determine whether any exclusion applied. The existence of a PAN, FAN, tax informer case, pending fraud case, RATE case, admitted unpaid liability, or qualifying Letter Notice discrepancy could block availment for the relevant period and tax type. Third, the finance team had to compute the IVAP amount using the applicable 30% increase test, minimum absolute payment, 3% of gross sales or receipts test for certain VAT cases, 130% rule for one-time transactions, or 30% of basic tax paid for accrued penalties.

Fourth, the taxpayer had to prepare payment through the appropriate collection channel and submit the application, proof of payment, and required attachments to the proper RDO or Large Taxpayers Service. Fifth, if the IVAP amount exceeded P5 million and installment payment was needed, the taxpayer had to comply with the three-installment rule and ensure full payment by November 29, 2006 unless an extension was approved. For financial incapacity extension requests, the taxpayer had to be ready to disclose bank accounts, execute a bank secrecy waiver, provide a written undertaking, and, in some cases, post a bond.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RR No. 18-2006 shows how BIR voluntary assessment programs can provide meaningful audit protection only when the taxpayer meets the technical coverage, exclusion, computation, payment, and documentation requirements. A small error in tax-type selection, base-year computation, minimum payment, or eligibility review can result in disqualification and loss of the intended audit benefit.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and tax practitioners in reviewing BIR issuances, assessing tax exposure, preparing voluntary compliance strategies, responding to BIR audits, and managing deficiency tax disputes. For guidance on BIR compliance, tax assessments, voluntary disclosure programs, and audit defense in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *