RR No. 9-2006 amended BIR No Audit Program rules, clarifying qualification tests, VAT and percentage tax ratios, disqualifications, deadlines, and appeal rights.
Business taxpayers seeking exemption from BIR audit under the No Audit Program must meet stricter and more detailed qualification rules, including a minimum 20% increase in income tax payment, required tax-to-sales ratios, VAT or percentage tax ratio tests, and specific filing deadlines. For taxpayers with calendar year 2005 or fiscal years ending January, February, or March 2006, the NAP Participation Form and required attachments had to be filed on or before July 31, 2006. Taxpayers who failed to qualify for the 2004 NAP may still avail under the amended rules, but only if no Final Assessment Notice has yet been issued for taxable year 2004 and the required filings and additional payments are completed by the same July 31, 2006 deadline.
What RR No. 9-2006 Changed
RR No. 9-2006 further amended RR No. 6-2005, as amended, implementing Executive Order No. 399, as amended by Executive Order No. 422, otherwise known as the No Audit Program or NAP. The key change is that the BIR clarified who may qualify, how the required tax increases and ratios are computed, what taxes are counted as cash payments, which taxpayers are disqualified, and how applications are reviewed.
The regulation defines a taxpayer, for purposes of the NAP, as any person, whether individual or corporation, earning business income. This is important because the program is not limited to corporations. Individuals earning business income may also be covered, subject to compliance with the same qualification requirements.
The most important compliance requirement remains the income tax payment test. A taxpayerâs income tax payment for the current taxable year must exceed the income tax payment for the base year by at least 20%. In addition, the ratio of income tax payment to gross sales or receipts for the current taxable year must be at least equal to that of the base year. These two requirements are central to any NAP availment analysis.
Who Is Affected by RR No. 9-2006
RR No. 9-2006 affects business taxpayers who want exemption from audit or investigation under the No Audit Program. This includes corporations, individual business owners, taxpayers earning mixed income from business and employment, taxpayers paying Minimum Corporate Income Tax or MCIT, taxpayers enjoying preferential tax rates, VAT-registered taxpayers, percentage tax taxpayers, and taxpayers with VAT zero-rated or VAT-exempt transactions.
For CFOs, accountants, and tax managers, the regulation is especially relevant when reviewing whether a taxpayerâs annual income tax return, VAT returns, percentage tax returns, and supporting withholding tax certificates are sufficient to support a NAP application. The BIR made clear that only taxes actually paid in cash, as shown in the relevant tax returns, are considered for purposes of determining current-year tax payments.
Creditable withholding taxes for the taxable year, if properly supported by BIR Form No. 2307 or BIR Form No. 2316, are treated as cash payment. However, Tax Credit Certificates, Tax Debit Memos, and tax credits carried over from prior years are treated as non-cash items and excluded in determining tax payments for the current taxable year.
Key Qualification Rules Under the Amended No Audit Program
To qualify for the NAP, the taxpayer must satisfy all prescribed tests. First, the income tax payment for the current taxable year must exceed the income tax payment for the base year by at least 20%. Second, the ratio of income tax payment to gross sales or receipts for the current taxable year must be at least equal to the same ratio for the base year.
For taxpayers earning mixed income, meaning business income and employment income, the computation of the 20% increase and the tax-to-sales ratio must be based on the taxpayerâs total tax paid and total income from both business and employment. However, any increase or decrease in compensation, and the corresponding effect on the tax due for the current taxable year, must be excluded when computing compliance with the required increase in income tax payment and the ratio of tax payment to gross sales or receipts.
Taxpayers paying MCIT are not automatically excluded. They may still avail of the NAP, provided the required increase in income tax payment and the tax payment to gross sales or receipts ratio are based on the MCIT payment in the base year and the MCIT due in the current year. However, excess MCIT may not be credited against the succeeding yearâs tax due, even if the normal income tax later becomes higher than the MCIT. The Deferred Charges-MCIT for the current year must also be closed to the retained earnings account.
Taxpayers enjoying preferential tax rates may also avail of the program if they comply with the required 20% increase and ratio tests. For these taxpayers, the required increase in income tax payment and the income tax payment to gross sales or receipts ratio are based on tax due computed using the preferential tax rate for the base year and the current year. The same rule applies even if the taxpayer is no longer entitled to the preferential tax rate in the current year.
VAT, Percentage Tax, and Business Tax Ratio Requirements
RR No. 9-2006 also requires a business tax ratio test. The ratio of net VAT or business tax actually paid to gross sales or receipts for the current taxable year must be at least equal to that of the base year. However, the regulation sets floor levels. For taxpayers subject to percentage tax, the ratio must in no case be less than 3%. For taxpayers subject to VAT, the ratio must in no case be less than 30% of the value-added tax rate provided by law for any given period, or the applicable industry benchmark as may be determined from time to time by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
VAT zero-rated transactions and VAT-exempt transactions not subject to percentage tax are not considered in determining compliance with the VAT or percentage tax ratio. However, gross sales or receipts from those transactions are still included for purposes of meeting the income tax payment increase and income tax payment to gross sales or receipts ratio requirements.
Taxpayers with purely VAT zero-rated transactions or VAT-exempt transactions not subject to percentage tax are not required to comply with the business tax ratio requirement. They are deemed qualified for that exemption if they comply with the income tax requirements and present photocopies of the required documents included in the NAP Participation Form, April 2006 version, for validation of their business tax types.
Deadlines for Filing the NAP Participation Form
The general deadline under RR No. 9-2006 is that the taxpayer must file a duly accomplished NAP Participation Form, together with the required attachments, not later than 30 days from the statutory deadline for filing the Annual Income Tax Return for the year subject of the participation.
If the taxpayerâs statutory deadline for filing the Annual Income Tax Return occurred earlier than the effectivity of RR No. 9-2006, the application must be filed within 30 days from the effectivity of the regulations.
For taxpayers whose taxable year ended December 31, 2005, and for fiscal years ending in January, February, or March 2006, the NAP Participation Form and required attachments had to be filed on or before July 31, 2006.
The July 31, 2006 deadline also applies to taxpayers who failed to avail and qualify for the 2004 NAP but want to avail under RR No. 9-2006. They may still participate if no Final Assessment Notice pursuant to a Letter of Authority, Tax Verification Notice, or Letter Notice has yet been issued for taxable year 2004. Any additional payments must be made using BIR Form 0605-101, and the NAP Participation Form must be filed not later than July 31, 2006.
Taxpayers Disqualified from the No Audit Program
RR No. 9-2006 expressly disqualifies taxpayers reporting a net loss or having a Net Operating Loss Carry-over without MCIT due. This includes taxpayers who have net income but have no tax payable because they deducted personal and additional exemptions.
This disqualification is significant for businesses reviewing whether NOLCO, exemptions, or the absence of tax payable may prevent NAP availment. A taxpayer cannot rely merely on filing a return or having gross receipts. The regulation requires actual compliance with the tax payment and ratio requirements, and it excludes taxpayers with the specified loss or no-tax-payable situations.
Review, Deficiency Payments, and Appeal Rights
NAP applications and required attachments are reviewed by a NAP Review Committee. For regional cases, the committee is headed by the Assistant Regional Director, with the Revenue District Officer where the taxpayer is registered, the Chief of the Assessment Division, and the Chief of the Legal Division as members. For large taxpayers, the committee is headed by the HREA for regular or excise cases, with the Chief of LTAID I, LTAID II, or the LTDO where the taxpayer is registered, the Chief of LTCED, and the Head of the Review Team as members.
The NAP Review Committee recommends the issuance of either a Certificate of Exemption from Audit or Investigation or a Notice of Disqualification. For regional office cases, the certificate or notice is signed by the Regional Director. For large taxpayersâ cases, it is signed by the Assistant Commissioner for the Large Taxpayers Service.
If the NAP Review Committee finds any unpaid amount after review, the taxpayer must pay it within 30 days from receipt of written notification from the RDO or the Chief of the concerned Large Taxpayers Office. Failure to pay within that 30-day period invalidates the taxpayerâs availment.
Taxpayers who receive a Notice of Disqualification may appeal to the NAP Committee at the National Office Level within 30 days from receipt of the notice. This appeal period is a critical deadline for taxpayers who believe that the disqualification is incorrect or that the BIRâs computation should be reviewed.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Accountants
Taxpayers reviewing RR No. 9-2006 should begin by identifying the base year and current taxable year applicable to their NAP participation. They should compute whether income tax payment increased by at least 20% and whether the income tax payment to gross sales or receipts ratio is at least equal to the base year ratio.
VAT-registered taxpayers and percentage tax taxpayers must separately compute the net VAT or business tax actually paid to gross sales or receipts ratio. Percentage tax taxpayers must check the 3% minimum. VAT taxpayers must check whether the ratio is at least 30% of the VAT rate provided by law for the relevant period or the applicable industry benchmark determined by the Commissioner.
Taxpayers should also separate cash and non-cash tax payments. BIR Forms 2307 and 2316 may support creditable withholding taxes treated as cash payments. However, Tax Credit Certificates, Tax Debit Memos, and prior-year tax credit carryovers should be excluded from the current-year tax payment computation.
Businesses with MCIT, preferential rates, mixed income, VAT zero-rated sales, VAT-exempt transactions, or NOLCO positions should not assume automatic qualification. RR No. 9-2006 contains special computation rules for these cases, and the wrong treatment may result in disqualification or invalidation of the NAP availment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 9-2006 remains a useful reminder that BIR audit-exemption programs are highly technical. The difference between a valid NAP availment and a disqualified application may depend on proper treatment of MCIT, withholding tax certificates, VAT-exempt sales, zero-rated transactions, NOLCO, or preferential tax rates.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and tax practitioners in reviewing BIR compliance positions, preparing audit responses, evaluating exposure from tax assessments, and structuring practical tax compliance strategies. For assistance with BIR audit issues, tax assessments, voluntary compliance programs, or Philippine tax advisory work, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.