RR No. 6-2005 set the BIR No Audit Program rules, requiring higher tax payments, ratio tests, timely application, and waiver of refund claims.
Business taxpayers that wanted protection from BIR audit for taxable years 2004 to 2008 had to increase actual tax payments, preserve tax-to-sales ratios, and file a formal application within the prescribed deadline under RR No. 6-2005. The regulation implemented the No Audit Program, or NAP, under Executive Order No. 399, giving qualified taxpayers exemption from audit and investigation for the taxable year covered, but only if they satisfied strict income tax and business tax benchmarks.
What RR No. 6-2005 Changed
RR No. 6-2005 established the implementing rules for the BIR No Audit Program. The program was designed to encourage taxpayers to voluntarily declare and pay higher taxes by granting qualified taxpayers an exemption from audit and investigation for the taxable year in which they qualified.
The No Audit Program applied to taxable years 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2008. For business owners, CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax practitioners, the central rule was practical and measurable: pay more income tax, maintain the required tax-to-sales ratios, satisfy the VAT or business tax ratio requirement, and timely apply for the program. Failure to participate and qualify at the required time could permanently bar the taxpayer from joining the program in later years.
The benefit was significant. A taxpayer who qualified under the regulation would be exempted from audit or investigation of his tax for the relevant taxable year. However, the exemption did not cover Overseas Communication Tax and all forms of withholding taxes. In other words, the NAP was not a blanket immunity from every BIR inquiry. Withholding tax compliance remained outside the protection of the program.
Who Was Affected by the No Audit Program
RR No. 6-2005 applied to any taxpayer registered with the BIR who earned purely business income and who had actually filed and paid income taxes and business taxes for taxable year 2003. The regulation covered both individual and corporate taxpayers, provided they were earning purely business income.
The program was therefore most relevant to business owners, corporations, SMEs, proprietors, and professionals or enterprises earning business income, provided they had a 2003 tax payment history against which the required growth and ratios could be measured. Taxpayers that started business after the effectivity of the regulation could apply only in the taxable year following the taxable year when they commenced operations and registered with the BIR.
The regulation also imposed a continuing participation rule. If a taxpayer failed to participate and qualify for taxable year 2004, the taxpayer could no longer participate in the NAP for any later year. If a taxpayer did participate and qualify for one taxable year but failed to qualify in a later taxable year, the taxpayer would be disqualified from further participation for the remainder of the program.
Key Qualification Requirements Under RR No. 6-2005
To qualify under the No Audit Program, a taxpayer had to satisfy all of the criteria set out in RR No. 6-2005. First, the income tax payment for the current taxable year had to exceed the income tax payment for the base year by at least 20%. For taxable year 2004, the base year was taxable year 2003.
Second, the income tax payment for the last quarter of the current taxable year had to exceed the income tax payment for the last quarter of the base year by at least 25%. This prevented taxpayers from merely increasing annual payments while failing to show growth in the final quarter comparison.
Third, the income tax payment for the first quarter of the taxable year immediately following the current taxable year had to exceed the income tax payment for the first quarter of the current taxable year by at least 25%. This made the program forward-looking. A taxpayer seeking NAP protection for a current taxable year also had to show increased first-quarter tax payment performance in the following year.
Fourth, the ratio of income tax payment to gross sales or receipts for the current taxable year had to be at least equal to the same ratio for the base year. This prevented a taxpayer from qualifying merely because sales increased while the tax-payment ratio declined.
Fifth, the ratio of income tax payment to gross sales or receipts for the first quarter of the taxable year immediately following the current taxable year had to be at least equal to the ratio for the first quarter of the current taxable year.
Sixth, the ratio of net value-added tax or business tax actually paid to gross sales or receipts for the current taxable year had to be at least equal to the ratio for the base year. In no case could this ratio be less than 3%, or the industry benchmark as may be determined from time to time by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
How Tax Payments Were Computed for NAP Qualification
RR No. 6-2005 was specific on what counted as tax payment for the current taxable year. Only taxes actually paid in cash, as shown in the income tax return, quarterly income tax return, VAT return, and percentage tax return, were considered. Creditable withholding taxes for the taxable year concerned, if properly supported by BIR Form 2307, were treated as cash payments.
Tax credit certificates, tax debit memos, and tax credits carried over from prior years were excluded from determining tax payments for the current taxable year. This rule mattered because taxpayers could not rely on prior-year credits or non-cash applications to satisfy the required current-year payment increase.
For the base year, however, the computation was broader. The total amount of tax due for the base year was included regardless of the mode of payment, whether paid in cash, through creditable withholding tax, tax credit certificates, tax debit memos, or tax credits carried over from prior taxable years.
If the taxpayer was not in operation for the whole base year, the base-year tax payments had to be annualized. RR No. 6-2005 gave the example of a calendar-year taxpayer that started business on July 1, 2003 and paid P60,000.00 in income tax. For base-year purposes, the P60,000.00 payment would be divided by 6 months and multiplied by 12 months, resulting in annualized income tax payments of P120,000.00.
Who Could Not Qualify for the No Audit Program
RR No. 6-2005 excluded several categories of taxpayers from the program. Taxpayers reporting net loss or with a Net Operating Loss Carryover could not participate. Taxpayers paying Minimum Corporate Income Tax also could not participate. Taxpayers whose gross income, whether in whole or in part, was not subject to regular individual or corporate income tax were likewise disqualified.
These exclusions were important for CFOs and corporate accountants evaluating whether a company could rely on the NAP. A corporation paying MCIT, a taxpayer using NOLCO, or a taxpayer with income not fully subject to regular income tax could not assume eligibility simply because it was registered with the BIR or had filed returns.
Deadline for Application and Waiver of Refund Claims
The application deadline under RR No. 6-2005 was not later than 30 days from the statutory deadline for filing the first quarterly return for the succeeding year, or 30 days from the effectivity of the regulations, whichever came later. The regulation itself took effect 15 days after publication in a newspaper of general circulation.
A taxpayer had to file a duly accomplished application form together with all required attachments. The application and supporting documents would then be reviewed by a National Committee on NAP to be created by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The National Committee would recommend the issuance of a Certificate of Exemption from Audit or Investigation, to be signed by the Commissioner or another authorized office or officer.
Taxpayers also had to understand the cost of applying. RR No. 6-2005 provided that all returns and payments made by a taxpayer who applied to participate in the NAP were deemed final and conclusive. By applying, the taxpayer was deemed to have waived all rights to claim any refund pertaining to those returns and payments.
Reservation of the BIR Power to Audit
Even a taxpayer seeking or enjoying NAP benefits remained subject to audit in specific circumstances. The Commissioner retained the right to audit taxpayers to whom Letters Notice had been issued, where the notices were not disputed and remained outstanding on the date the taxpayer filed the NAP application.
The Commissioner also retained the right to audit taxpayers to whom Letters Notice may be issued in the future as a result of third-party information or information filed by the taxpayer showing an apparent discrepancy in tax payment. The audit protection also did not apply where the taxpayer failed to file all required tax and information returns, or failed to provide all information or data required in the filed returns.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Tax Teams
For businesses reviewing historical BIR compliance, RR No. 6-2005 shows how the No Audit Program operated as a tax compliance incentive rather than a general amnesty. The taxpayer had to compare current-year income tax payments against the base year, check last-quarter and first-quarter growth, compute income tax-to-sales ratios, and verify VAT or business tax ratios against the 3% minimum or applicable industry benchmark.
Corporate accountants and CFOs also had to separate cash tax payments and properly supported BIR Form 2307 creditable withholding taxes from excluded non-cash items such as TCCs, TDMs, and prior-year carryovers. This distinction was essential because the qualification computation for the current taxable year did not treat all tax credits equally.
Taxpayers also had to review whether any Letters Notice, missing returns, incomplete information returns, MCIT position, NOLCO, net loss, or non-regular income tax exposure would defeat NAP qualification or preserve the BIRโs audit authority. Search terms such as RR No. 6-2005 No Audit Program, BIR NAP requirements, 20% income tax increase BIR, 3% VAT business tax ratio, and Certificate of Exemption from Audit remain relevant for understanding the scope of this regulation.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 6-2005 is a reminder that BIR relief programs often come with strict numerical tests, filing deadlines, exclusions, and waiver consequences. Businesses should not evaluate audit-exemption programs based only on the promised benefit. They must confirm eligibility, compute the required ratios, identify disqualifying facts, and understand what rights may be waived by filing an application.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists business owners, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR compliance, tax exposure, audit risk, withholding tax issues, and documentary requirements for tax programs and assessments. For legal guidance on BIR compliance, tax audits, and Philippine tax regulations, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.