RR No. 1-2004 exempts marginal income earners from 1% creditable withholding tax on agricultural supplier payments effective January 1, 2004.
Businesses that buy agricultural, forest, marine, livestock, poultry, fish, and similar products from small self-employed individuals must recognize an important withholding tax exemption effective retroactively from January 1, 2004. RR No. 1-2004 keeps the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax on payments to agricultural suppliers, but expressly excludes payments to marginal income earners whose gross sales or receipts do not exceed P100,000.00 during any 12-month period. Hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, supermarkets, canneries, food processors, livestock dealers, poultry dealers, fish dealers, marine product dealers, hardwares, factories, furniture shops, and similar establishments should immediately review supplier classifications and withholding practices to avoid imposing tax on exempt marginal income earners or failing to withhold on covered suppliers.
What RR No. 1-2004 Changed
RR No. 1-2004 further amends Section 2.57.2(S) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as last amended by Revenue Regulations No. 30-2003. The amended provision covers income payments made to suppliers of agricultural products and prescribes the applicable creditable withholding tax rate. The key change is the express exemption of marginal income earners from the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax otherwise imposed on payments made to agricultural suppliers.
The regulation confirms that income payments made by establishments to agricultural suppliers remain subject to creditable withholding tax at the rate of one percent (1%). However, this withholding obligation does not apply where the payee is a marginal income earner as defined under Revenue Regulations No. 11-2000 dated December 12, 2000. Under the regulation, marginal income earners are individuals who do not otherwise derive compensation as employees under an employer-employee relationship, who are self-employed, and who derive gross sales or receipts not exceeding P100,000.00 during any 12-month period.
For Philippine tax compliance teams, the practical issue is not merely the one percent (1%) withholding tax rate. The larger issue is proper payee classification. A business that regularly buys goods from small-scale self-employed sellers must determine whether the seller is an ordinary agricultural supplier subject to creditable withholding tax or a marginal income earner exempt from such withholding.
Who Is Most Affected
RR No. 1-2004 is particularly relevant to establishments that regularly purchase agricultural, forest, marine food and non-food products, livestock, poultry, fish, marine products, and similar goods from suppliers. The regulation specifically refers to payments made by hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, food processors, canneries, supermarkets, livestock dealers, poultry dealers, fish and marine product dealers, hardwares, factories, furniture shops, and all other establishments.
This means the rule is not limited to traditional food businesses. A supermarket purchasing produce, a cannery purchasing marine products, a restaurant buying vegetables or fish, a resort sourcing local food supplies, a poultry dealer purchasing livestock-related products, or a furniture shop purchasing forest products may fall within the scope of the rule, depending on the nature of the payment and the supplier.
Small sellers are also affected. Self-employed individuals who are not employees and whose gross sales or receipts do not exceed P100,000.00 during any 12-month period are treated as marginal income earners for purposes of this exemption. For them, RR No. 1-2004 is significant because payments they receive from covered establishments should not be reduced by the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax if they qualify under the regulation.
Income Payments Still Subject to 1% Creditable Withholding Tax
The general rule under the amended Section 2.57.2(S) is that income payments made to agricultural suppliers are subject to one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax. The term agricultural suppliers includes suppliers or sellers of agricultural, forest and marine food and non-food products, livestock and poultry of a kind generally used as, or yielding or producing foods for human consumption, and breeding stock and genetic materials therefor.
The regulation also clarifies the meaning of livestock, poultry, and marine products. Livestock includes cows, bulls and calves, pigs, sheep, goats, and other similar animals. Poultry includes fowls, ducks, geese, turkey, and other similar animals. Marine products include fish and crustaceans, including eels, trout, lobsters, shrimps, prawns, oysters, mussels, clams, shells, and other aquatic products.
Accordingly, unless the payee falls within the marginal income earner exemption, covered establishments must apply the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax on qualifying income payments to agricultural suppliers. This is the key compliance point for accountants and withholding agents searching for BIR rules on agricultural suppliers withholding tax, one percent creditable withholding tax, marginal income earners exemption, and withholding tax on payments to farmers and fish suppliers.
Marginal Income Earners Exempt from Withholding
The most important relief provided by RR No. 1-2004 is the exclusion of marginal income earners from the withholding tax requirement. A marginal income earner, for purposes of the amended rule, must be an individual, must not otherwise derive compensation as an employee under an employer-employee relationship, must be self-employed, and must derive gross sales or receipts not exceeding P100,000.00 during any 12-month period.
This threshold is important. The exemption turns on gross sales or receipts not exceeding P100,000.00 during any 12-month period, not on net income or taxable income. Businesses dealing with very small sellers should therefore avoid applying a generic withholding approach without first considering whether the supplier falls within the marginal income earner classification under the regulation.
For CFOs and accounting departments, the practical risk is two-sided. If the seller is not a marginal income earner, the establishment should withhold the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax. If the seller is a qualified marginal income earner, the payment is exempt from that withholding under RR No. 1-2004. Proper documentation and supplier classification are therefore essential.
Effective Date and Retroactive Application
RR No. 1-2004 was issued on January 14, 2004, but its effectivity clause provides that the regulations shall retroact to January 1, 2004. This retroactive effect matters because covered establishments must apply the exemption and the amended rule beginning January 1, 2004.
Businesses reviewing withholding tax compliance for payments made at the start of 2004 should therefore use January 1, 2004 as the operative date. Payments made on or after that date to qualifying marginal income earners should be treated under the exemption, while payments to non-exempt agricultural suppliers remain subject to the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax.
Compliance Requirements for Businesses and Withholding Agents
RR No. 1-2004 does not impose a new filing form or a separate deadline in the text of the regulation. Its compliance impact is operational: covered establishments must identify which payees are agricultural suppliers, determine whether the marginal income earner exemption applies, and apply the correct withholding tax treatment to payments beginning January 1, 2004.
Businesses should first map all payments to suppliers of agricultural, forest, marine, livestock, poultry, fish, and similar products. Second, they should determine whether the payee is an individual, self-employed, not an employee, and within the P100,000.00 gross sales or receipts threshold during any 12-month period. Third, they should segregate exempt marginal income earners from ordinary agricultural suppliers subject to the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax. Fourth, accounting teams should align vouchers, supplier records, withholding tax computations, and internal controls with the amended Section 2.57.2(S).
This is especially important for businesses with many small local suppliers. A restaurant, resort, supermarket, fish dealer, poultry dealer, or food processor may deal with both larger agricultural suppliers and small self-employed sellers. Applying a single withholding treatment to all suppliers may lead to errors. RR No. 1-2004 requires a more precise classification.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RR No. 1-2004 does not state a special penalty provision for violations of the amended rule. However, because the regulation amends the rules on income payments subject to creditable withholding tax, non-compliance may still create exposure under the general withholding tax rules of the National Internal Revenue Code and applicable BIR regulations. The specific risk is that the BIR may question a withholding agent that fails to withhold the one percent (1%) tax on covered payments to non-exempt agricultural suppliers.
At the same time, improper withholding from marginal income earners may create commercial and documentation issues with small suppliers who should have received payments without the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax deduction. The safer approach is to document the basis for the withholding or exemption at the time of payment, instead of reconstructing supplier status during a tax audit.
Practical Steps Businesses Should Take Now
Covered businesses should update their supplier onboarding and accounts payable procedures to reflect RR No. 1-2004. Any establishment purchasing agricultural, forest, marine, livestock, poultry, fish, or similar products should ensure that its accounting team can identify whether the payee is an ordinary agricultural supplier or a marginal income earner.
Accounting departments should also review recurring supplier master lists and payment templates. If a supplier is an individual, self-employed, not an employee, and within the P100,000.00 gross sales or receipts threshold during any 12-month period, the business should consider the marginal income earner exemption from creditable withholding tax. If the supplier does not qualify, the one percent (1%) creditable withholding tax under Section 2.57.2(S), as amended, should generally be applied to the covered income payment.
Businesses should also train procurement and finance personnel not to treat all agricultural suppliers alike. The regulation covers a wide range of products, including agricultural, forest and marine food and non-food products, livestock, poultry, breeding stock, genetic materials, fish, crustaceans, shells, and other aquatic products. A proper tax review should therefore be built into purchasing workflows, especially for establishments that source from small-scale local sellers.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 1-2004 is a good example of how a seemingly small withholding tax amendment can affect daily purchasing, supplier onboarding, accounts payable, and BIR audit risk. The key is not only knowing that the rate is one percent (1%), but knowing when the rate does not apply because the payee is a marginal income earner with gross sales or receipts not exceeding P100,000.00 during any 12-month period.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, in-house counsel, and tax teams in reviewing withholding tax compliance, supplier documentation, BIR audit exposure, and practical tax controls for Philippine operations. For assistance with creditable withholding tax, marginal income earner classifications, BIR compliance reviews, and supplier tax documentation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.