RMC No. 89-2024 clarifies that LGU income from proprietary functions may be subject to income tax, withholding tax, VAT, CGT, DST, and invoicing rules.

Local Government Units earning income from activities performed in a proprietary, corporate, or private capacity must now treat that income as taxable business income and comply with income tax, withholding tax, VAT, percentage tax, documentary stamp tax, invoicing, and Authority to Print requirements when applicable. RMC No. 89-2024 is immediately relevant to cities, municipalities, provinces, and their counterparties because the tax exemption for income from essential governmental functions does not automatically extend to income earned from commercial or profit-oriented activities.

What RMC No. 89-2024 Clarifies

RMC No. 89-2024 clarifies the taxability of income derived by Local Government Units engaged in proprietary functions. The key rule is that income derived by an LGU acting in its corporate capacity and for the purpose of economic gain and profit is subject to tax and is treated in the same manner as income of an ordinary private corporation.

The circular distinguishes between income derived from essential governmental functions and income derived from proprietary functions. Income derived by the Government or its political subdivisions from any public utility or from the exercise of any essential governmental function is excluded from gross income under Section 32(B)(7)(b) of the Tax Code. However, where the LGU is not performing an essential governmental function and is engaged in a business, industry, or activity similar to that of ordinary taxable corporations, the income may be taxed.

For business owners, property developers, banks, contractors, lessees, buyers of LGU property, and tax managers dealing with local governments, the practical effect is clear: an LGU counterparty may not always be tax-exempt. Transactions involving lease, sale, exchange, investments, deposits, royalties, foreclosure, or other income-generating activities must be reviewed for income tax, withholding tax, VAT, percentage tax, CGT, and DST exposure.

Governmental Functions Versus Proprietary Functions

An LGU performs a governmental function when it acts as part of the machinery of government, administering the powers of the State and promoting public welfare. These functions include legislative, judicial, public, and political functions, as well as acts for public benefit involving public health, safety, morals, general welfare, security, prosperity, and contentment of inhabitants.

By contrast, a proprietary function is one undertaken for the special benefit and advantage of the community, and includes activities that are ministerial, private, or corporate in nature, not necessary to the existence of the LGU, and which inure to the advantage of its inhabitants. Under the circular, two requisites must be present for a specific act of an LGU to be considered proprietary: the LGU must not be performing an essential governmental function, and the LGU must be engaged in a similar business, industry, or activity as that performed by ordinary taxable corporations.

RMC No. 89-2024 also emphasizes that there is no hard and fast rule in determining the true nature of an LGU undertaking. The surrounding circumstances of the particular case are decisive. The basic inquiry is whether the activity is governmental in essence; otherwise, the function becomes private or proprietary in character.

Taxes That May Apply to LGU Proprietary Income

RMC No. 89-2024 states that proprietary income derived by LGUs may be subject to several internal revenue taxes. These include income tax, withholding tax, value-added tax, other percentage taxes, and documentary stamp tax, depending on the nature of the transaction and the applicable provisions of the Tax Code.

For income tax, Section 27(C) of the Tax Code provides that income derived by LGUs from the performance of proprietary activities is subject to income tax. The circular also notes that this includes taxes on passive income under Section 27(D), such as royalties, interests, dividends, sale of shares of stock, income from the expanded foreign currency deposit system, and capital gains from the sale, exchange, or other disposition of lands or buildings not actually used in the performance of the LGUโ€™s governmental functions.

For withholding tax, the circular clarifies that while withholding of creditable withholding tax generally does not apply to income payments made to the national government and its instrumentalities, including provincial, city, or municipal governments, this rule only applies to income payments received by an LGU in the performance of governmental functions. Income payments made to an LGU by reason of proprietary functions are subject to withholding tax under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98.

For VAT, when LGUs perform corporate or private functions that are proprietary in nature, they are liable to twelve percent (12%) VAT on total gross sales derived from such activity, when the transaction falls within the VAT provisions of the Tax Code. Income derived by LGUs from proprietary functions that falls under Title V of the Tax Code may instead be subject to percentage tax depending on the applicable tax base and rate.

For documentary stamp tax, LGUs entering into private contracts or agreements relating to proprietary corporate or private functions, similar to private corporations, are liable for DST under the Tax Code.

Application to LGU Property Sales, Leases, Exchanges, Investments, and Foreclosures

RMC No. 89-2024 gives specific applications that accountants and business counterparties should watch closely. For sale, exchange, or other disposition of lands or buildings not actually used in business and treated as capital assets, Section 27(D)(5) imposes a final tax of six percent (6%) based on the gross selling price or current fair market value as determined under Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher, on capital gains presumed to have been realized. The circular emphasizes that the capital gains tax is a tax burden of the seller, which in that case is the LGU.

For leasing of properties, where an LGU leases property to a private person or entity for the construction, development, and operation of a commercial activity with a view to obtaining profit, the LGU acts in a proprietary or private character because no governmental or public policy of the State is involved.

For exchange of properties, the circular states that an exchange of properties between two parties is subject to CGT and the corresponding DST based on the fair market value of their respective properties under Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, if the exchange between the LGU and the private person or entity relating to a commercial activity partakes of the nature of voluntary exchange. The private person or entity may report the gain in the manner provided under Section 24(A)(1), and for real property transactions may be subject to six percent (6%) CGT or regular income tax depending on the applicable rule. The LGU, on the other hand, is subject to six percent (6%) CGT under Section 27(D)(5) on the capital gains presumed realized from the exchange of real property considered capital asset.

For interest income and other monetary benefits, the circular treats the maintenance of deposit accounts for LGU funds and investments as proprietary where the activity is not essential to administering the powers of the State. The LGU is subject to twenty percent (20%) final tax on interest income from deposit accounts and yield or other monetary benefit from investments in government securities, commercial papers, and similar arrangements under Section 27(D)(1) of the Tax Code.

For forfeiture or purchase by an LGU in public auction of properties due to delinquency in real property taxes, the transaction is subject to CGT based on the bid price in the auction sale or the zonal value of the foreclosed property, whichever is higher. The Declaration of Forfeiture is also subject to DST under Section 196 of the Tax Code because the registration of the document with the Office of the Registry of Deeds transfers title of the forfeited property to the LGU. The circular further clarifies that if the owner fails to redeem the property and the highest bidder, which in most cases is the statutory seller or LGU, pays the CGT and DST to register the certificate of sale, there is no tax exemption in case of foreclosure sale. The Tax Code requires payment of CGT and DST even on conditional sales of real property.

Invoicing and Authority to Print Requirements

LGUs subject to the above internal revenue taxes must issue the appropriate invoice and comply with Section 237 of the Tax Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 11976, the Ease of Paying Taxes Act, and as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 7-2024. They must also apply for Authority to Print in the printing of their principal and supplementary invoices following the procedure under Revenue Regulations No. 7-2024 and other relevant revenue issuances.

This is a major compliance point. An LGU performing taxable proprietary activities is not merely dealing with the substantive tax due. It must also comply with invoicing, invoice-printing, and registration-related rules applicable to taxable transactions. Private counterparties should also ensure that the invoices and tax documentation they receive from LGUs are adequate for accounting, withholding, VAT, and audit purposes.

Effective Date and Compliance Deadline

RMC No. 89-2024 states that it takes effect immediately. It was issued on August 13, 2024. There is no deferred transition period stated in the circular. LGUs and private entities dealing with LGUs should therefore apply the clarification immediately to proprietary transactions, particularly property transactions, leases, commercial arrangements, passive income, investments, and transactions requiring invoicing and DST compliance.

Penalties and Audit Risk for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 89-2024 does not create a separate penalty schedule. However, once an LGU transaction is properly classified as proprietary and taxable, the ordinary consequences under the Tax Code and applicable regulations may follow for non-payment, non-withholding, failure to issue proper invoices, failure to secure Authority to Print when required, and failure to pay DST, VAT, percentage tax, income tax, CGT, or final tax, as applicable.

For CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel, the audit risk is not limited to LGUs. Private businesses contracting with LGUs may also face exposure where they fail to withhold, fail to secure proper invoices, improperly treat the LGU as categorically tax-exempt, or fail to account for CGT, DST, VAT, or percentage tax in commercial transactions involving public property or LGU income-generating activities.

Practical Steps for LGUs and Private Counterparties

First, classify each LGU transaction by function. Determine whether the LGU is acting in an essential governmental capacity or in a proprietary, corporate, or private capacity. The purpose of the activity, the intended beneficiaries, the manner of operation, and the disposition of revenues should be documented.

Second, identify the tax type per transaction. Sales, exchanges, and foreclosures of real property may involve six percent (6%) CGT and DST. Leases and commercial services may involve VAT at twelve percent (12%) or percentage tax, depending on the applicable rules. Deposits, royalties, investments, and similar arrangements may involve passive income taxes, including the twenty percent (20%) final tax on interest income described in the circular.

Third, review withholding tax obligations. Do not assume that payments to an LGU are automatically outside withholding tax. If the income payment is received by the LGU in relation to proprietary functions, RMC No. 89-2024 states that withholding tax under RR No. 2-98 applies.

Fourth, require proper invoices and documentation. LGUs engaged in taxable proprietary activities must issue appropriate invoices, comply with the Ease of Paying Taxes Act amendments, follow RR No. 7-2024, and apply for Authority to Print for principal and supplementary invoices when required.

Fifth, update contracts with LGUs. Commercial leases, property sale agreements, exchange agreements, development agreements, concession arrangements, investment documentation, and foreclosure-related documents should clearly allocate responsibility for CGT, DST, VAT, withholding, invoicing, and documentary requirements.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 89-2024 is important because it removes the comfort of treating all LGU income as tax-exempt. The real question is now transactional: what is the LGU doing, why is it doing it, who benefits, and is the activity comparable to business conducted by ordinary taxable corporations?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, LGUs, property owners, developers, banks, contractors, and corporate taxpayers on BIR compliance, withholding tax, VAT, documentary stamp tax, capital gains tax, property transactions, and tax risk allocation in contracts. For assistance in reviewing LGU transactions, commercial leases with local governments, sale or exchange of public property, foreclosure-related tax issues, or BIR audit exposure arising from RMC No. 89-2024, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *