RMC No. 60-2024 clarifies that from 2024, expenses may remain deductible despite non-withholding, but withholding tax liability still applies.
Businesses may now claim deductible business expenses even if the required withholding tax was not withheld, provided the expense is otherwise ordinary, necessary, and duly substantiated. RMC No. 60-2024 clarifies a major taxpayer concern under the Ease of Paying Taxes Act and Revenue Regulations No. 4-2024: the repeal of Section 34(K) of the National Internal Revenue Code removes the old rule that automatically blocked deductibility merely because the corresponding withholding tax had not yet been paid to the BIR.
What Changed Under RMC No. 60-2024
RMC No. 60-2024 provides clarifications and guidance on Section 6 of Revenue Regulations No. 4-2024, which implements the repeal of Section 34(K) of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended, pursuant to Republic Act No. 11976, or the Ease of Paying Taxes Act. The circular is dated April 23, 2024 and addresses how the repeal affects income tax deductions, withholding tax compliance, and ongoing BIR audits.
Before the repeal, Section 34(K) imposed an additional requirement for deductibility of certain payments. A payment that was otherwise deductible, or that was taken into account in computing gross income, could be allowed as a deduction only if the taxpayer showed that the tax required to be deducted and withheld had been paid to the BIR in accordance with the withholding tax provisions of the Tax Code.
With the repeal of Section 34(K), a payment subject to withholding tax may now be allowed as a deduction from gross income even if no tax was withheld, provided the expense is otherwise deductible and properly substantiated as an expense related to the registered business of the taxpayer. This is the central compliance change under RMC No. 60-2024.
Why This Matters to Businesses and Accountants
The practical effect is important for Philippine businesses preparing income tax returns, defending expenses in BIR audits, or reviewing withholding tax exposures. The old Section 34(K) rule created a direct link between withholding tax payment and income tax deductibility. If a company failed to withhold, the BIR could disallow the related expense for income tax purposes, even if the expense was real, business-related, and supported by documents.
RMC No. 60-2024 confirms that for taxable year covering January 1, 2024 onwards, expenses or income payments subject to withholding tax shall be allowed as deduction from gross income for purposes of computing taxable income even if no tax was withheld, provided the other requirements for deductibility have been met.
This does not mean withholding tax compliance is optional. The circular expressly states that the taxpayer shall still be liable for the payment of the corresponding withholding tax due on the income payments. In other words, the repeal helps protect the income tax deduction, but it does not erase the separate withholding tax obligation.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 60-2024
The circular affects taxpayers that make payments subject to withholding tax and claim those payments as deductions in computing taxable income. This includes corporations, partnerships, sole proprietors, professionals, withholding agents, employers, and businesses that regularly pay suppliers, contractors, lessors, professionals, employees, or service providers.
CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel should pay particular attention because the circular affects both tax return preparation and BIR audit defense. Businesses with open Letters of Authority, ongoing audits, or audit reports already submitted to the Reviewing Office should also review the special transitional rules under RMC No. 60-2024.
Common searches connected with this issuance include RMC 60-2024 withholding tax deduction, repeal of Section 34(K) NIRC, RR 4-2024 EOPT Act deductibility, BIR expense disallowance withholding tax, and income payments subject to withholding tax deductible expense.
Rules for Ongoing Audits Before January 1, 2024
RMC No. 60-2024 gives specific audit guidance for taxable periods before January 1, 2024. For ongoing audits covering taxable periods prior to January 1, 2024, expenses subject to withholding tax shall be allowed as deductions from gross income by Revenue Officers only if the corresponding tax required to be withheld has been paid, whether before the audit or before submission of the audit report to the Reviewing Office.
This means that for older taxable periods, the repeal does not automatically rescue deductions where the required withholding tax remains unpaid. If the withholding tax was paid before audit submission or before the relevant audit milestone, the expense may still be allowed as a deduction. If it was not paid, the taxpayer faces both an income tax issue and a withholding tax issue.
RMC No. 60-2024 further states that if the taxpayer failed to withhold the tax required to be withheld on expenses subject to withholding tax, and the taxpayer did not pay the same before submission of the audit report to the Reviewing Office, the Revenue Officer must recommend the issuance of an assessment notice for both income tax and withholding tax. The circular states that this is in line with Revenue Regulations No. 6-2018.
Audit Cases Already Submitted to the Reviewing Office
The circular also deals with audit cases already submitted to the Reviewing Office. For paid cases, the same application under item 1 of the circular applies. This means that where the withholding tax was paid in the manner contemplated by the circular, the related expense may be allowed as a deduction for the relevant pre-2024 taxable period.
For assessed cases, RMC No. 60-2024 states that the requirement for deductibility under the then applicable Section 34(K) of the Tax Code shall apply. Therefore, assessments for both income tax and withholding tax shall be issued. This is a key point for taxpayers already in the audit pipeline: the timing and procedural stage of the case matter.
Rules for Taxable Year January 1, 2024 Onwards
For taxable year covering January 1, 2024 onwards, the circular adopts the new EOPT approach. Expenses or income payments subject to withholding tax shall be allowed as deductions from gross income for purposes of computing taxable income even if no tax was withheld, as long as the other requirements for deductibility are met.
Those other requirements remain important. The expense must still be an ordinary and necessary expense of the taxpayer’s registered business, must be duly substantiated, and must satisfy the general deductibility rules under the Tax Code and applicable BIR regulations. RMC No. 60-2024 does not create a deduction for unsupported, personal, fictitious, or non-business expenses.
At the same time, businesses should not interpret this as a waiver of withholding tax. The BIR expressly clarifies that the taxpayer remains liable for the corresponding withholding tax due on the income payments. Thus, the correct compliance position is not to ignore withholding tax, but to recognize that failure to withhold no longer automatically destroys the income tax deduction for taxable year 2024 onwards.
Penalties and Tax Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 60-2024 does not provide a new penalty rate, surcharge rate, interest rate, or compromise penalty schedule. It instead clarifies the tax consequences of non-compliance depending on the taxable period involved.
For ongoing audits covering taxable periods prior to January 1, 2024, failure to withhold and failure to pay the required withholding tax before submission of the audit report to the Reviewing Office can result in the recommendation for issuance of assessment notices for both income tax and withholding tax. For audit cases already assessed, the old Section 34(K) deductibility requirement applies, and assessments for both income tax and withholding tax shall be issued.
For taxable year January 1, 2024 onwards, the taxpayer may still claim the deduction if the expense otherwise qualifies, but the taxpayer remains liable for the corresponding withholding tax due. Businesses should therefore expect the BIR to continue enforcing withholding tax obligations separately from the income tax deductibility issue.
Practical Steps for Businesses Now
First, businesses should separate their analysis by taxable period. For taxable periods before January 1, 2024, especially those under ongoing BIR audit, companies should verify whether withholding taxes on deductible expenses were paid before audit submission or before the applicable audit stage. For taxable year January 1, 2024 onwards, companies should update their tax computation review to reflect that non-withholding does not automatically bar the expense deduction.
Second, accounting teams should preserve substantiation. The repeal of Section 34(K) does not excuse weak documentation. Official receipts or invoices, contracts, proof of payment, accounting entries, withholding tax records, and business-purpose documentation remain critical in proving that the expense is ordinary, necessary, and related to the taxpayer’s registered business.
Third, withholding tax processes should still be maintained. Companies should continue reviewing payments to suppliers, professionals, contractors, lessors, employees, and other payees to determine whether expanded withholding tax, withholding tax on compensation, final withholding tax, or other withholding obligations apply. RMC No. 60-2024 protects deductibility in the specified circumstances, but it does not remove the liability for withholding tax due.
Fourth, taxpayers with pending audits should assess whether the case is an ongoing audit, a paid case, or an assessed case already submitted to the Reviewing Office. The circular treats these situations differently, and the correct position may affect whether the taxpayer can defend the income tax deduction or whether exposure exists for both income tax and withholding tax.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 60-2024 is favorable to taxpayers, but it requires careful application. The timing of the taxable period, the audit status, the payment of withholding tax, and the quality of expense documentation all affect the legal and practical outcome. A business may have a stronger deduction defense for 2024 onward, while still facing a separate withholding tax liability.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in BIR audit defense, withholding tax compliance, EOPT Act implementation, assessment review, protest strategy, and tax documentation controls. For guidance on RMC No. 60-2024, Revenue Regulations No. 4-2024, the repeal of Section 34(K), or BIR assessments involving expense disallowance and withholding tax, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.