RMC No. 112-2023 clarifies that FDA beverage classification helps determine sweetened beverage excise tax treatment, but BIR retains final tax authority.

Sweetened beverage manufacturers, distributors, and importers cannot rely on an FDA product classification as an absolute shield from sweetened beverage excise tax. RMC No. 112-2023 makes clear that, while the Food and Drug Administration has a role in classifying beverages under the Codex food category system, the Bureau of Internal Revenue retains the final authority to determine whether a product is taxable or excluded from excise tax under Section 150-B of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.

What Changed Under RMC No. 112-2023

RMC No. 112-2023 clarifies the relationship between FDA beverage classification and BIR excise tax enforcement for sweetened beverages. The clarification matters because Section 150-B of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended by Republic Act No. 10963 or the TRAIN Law, imposes excise tax on sweetened beverages. At the same time, the law excludes certain products from the coverage of sweetened beverage excise tax, including milk products.

The key point is that FDA classification is relevant, but not controlling for tax purposes. The FDA’s function is tied to the adoption and application of the Codex Alimentarius Food Category Descriptors, particularly Codex Stan 192-1995, Rev. 2017 or the latest version adopted by the FDA. However, the BIR emphasized that the FDA’s determination is not absolute, final, and conclusive when the issue is whether a beverage is subject to excise tax or falls within an exclusion.

For tax administration, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue retains the authority to review classifications and classify products for taxation purposes, especially where the FDA does not strictly adhere to the applicable Codex descriptors. This clarification is important for products marketed as milk drinks, flavored milk drinks, milk-based beverages, or similar products seeking exclusion from sweetened beverage excise tax.

Who Is Affected by the Clarification

RMC No. 112-2023 affects manufacturers, distributors, importers, traders, and tax teams handling beverage products that may be classified as sweetened beverages under Section 150-B. It is particularly relevant to businesses selling non-alcoholic beverages in liquid, powder, or concentrate form that contain caloric or non-caloric sweeteners added by manufacturers.

The clarification is especially important for companies dealing with milk products, flavored milk drinks, fermented milk, soymilk, flavored soymilk, powdered milk, infant formula milk, follow-on milk, growing-up milk, and ready-to-drink milk. These products are specifically discussed because Section 150-B(C) of the NIRC and Section 6 of Revenue Regulations No. 20-2018 exclude all milk products from sweetened beverage excise tax, but only where the product properly falls within the applicable milk product classification.

For CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax managers, the practical issue is not only whether a product has an FDA-issued classification, but whether that classification can withstand BIR review using the Codex descriptors and the actual product composition and production process.

FDA Classification Still Matters, But It Has Limits

The circular recognizes that the NIRC and Revenue Regulations No. 20-2018 refer to beverage descriptions adopted by the FDA. Section 150-B(B)(1) defines sweetened beverages by reference to the Food Category System from the Codex Alimentarius Food Category Descriptors adopted by the FDA. Section 150-B(C) likewise refers to excluded products as described in the same Codex-based food category system adopted by the FDA.

Revenue Regulations No. 20-2018 also states that the proper classification of beverages shall be subject to determination by the FDA. In addition, Department Circular No. 2019-0319 dated August 1, 2019 adopted the Food Category System and Descriptors of the General Standard for Food Additives, Codex Stan 192-1995, Rev. 2018, as the basis for identifying and classifying food products in applications for authorization.

However, RMC No. 112-2023 distinguishes regulatory classification from tax determination. The FDA may issue authorizations and classifications for purposes of registration and regulatory compliance. But for excise tax purposes, the BIR may review whether the FDA classification follows the proper Codex descriptors and whether the product is truly covered by an exclusion under Section 150-B(C).

Special Focus on Milk Products and Flavored Milk Drinks

The circular gives particular attention to milk products because they are expressly excluded from sweetened beverage excise tax. Under the cited provisions, all milk products are excluded, including plain milk, infant formula milk, follow-on milk, growing-up milk, powdered milk, ready-to-drink milk, flavored milk, fermented milk, soymilk, and flavored soymilk.

RMC No. 112-2023 explains that classification as a milk product is not automatic merely because a product contains milk or is marketed as a milk drink. The Codex category for dairy products and analogues includes Fluid Milk and Milk Products under category 01.1, with subcategories such as Fluid Milk (plain), Other Fluid Milk (plain), Fluid Buttermilk (plain), and Flavoured Fluid Milk Drinks.

For flavored fluid milk drinks, the Codex description includes all mixes and ready-to-drink fermented or non-fermented milk-based drinks with flavorings or food ingredients that intentionally impart flavor. However, the circular emphasizes that milk products are products obtained by the processing of milk, and may contain food additives and other ingredients functionally necessary for processing.

This means that determining whether a beverage is a milk product requires an analysis of its composition and the production process involved in its manufacture. A product will not automatically be treated as an excluded milk product simply because it contains milk or carries milk-related branding.

Compliance Requirements and Documents Businesses Should Review

RMC No. 112-2023 discusses FDA Circular No. 2021-005 dated February 9, 2021, which provides a uniform procedure for requesting FDA confirmation of product classification and type of sweetener used in aid of TRAIN Law implementation for sweetened beverage products. The circular notes that manufacturers, distributors, and traders requesting confirmation must submit a request letter indicating the list of products being requested for confirmation.

The requirements also include a Certificate of Analysis issued within twelve (12) months by an FDA-recognized laboratory for each product, indicating the presence of the declared sweetener. A scanned copy or photograph of the actual label approved by the FDA showing the list of ingredients must also be submitted.

For businesses, this means that tax and regulatory teams should align FDA submissions, labels, ingredients lists, product formulations, Certificates of Analysis, and excise tax positions. The BIR’s clarification makes it risky to treat FDA confirmation as a standalone tax exemption document without checking whether the product fits the statutory exclusion and the applicable Codex descriptors.

Effective Date and Immediate Business Impact

RMC No. 112-2023 states that it takes effect immediately. The circular is dated September 28, 2023, and businesses covered by the sweetened beverage excise tax rules should apply the clarification immediately in product classification, tax filing, pricing, and audit defense.

The immediate consequence is that businesses claiming exclusion from sweetened beverage excise tax should review their product classification basis. This is particularly urgent for products positioned as milk drinks, flavored milk drinks, milk-based beverages, soymilk, or other products whose tax treatment depends on whether they fall within the exclusions under Section 150-B(C).

Penalties and Risks of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 112-2023 does not create a new penalty provision. However, it expressly states that proper beverage classification is crucial to the correct imposition and collection of excise tax on sweetened beverages, and that the clarification is intended to protect revenues and safeguard against improper classification giving rise to exclusions from excise tax to the detriment of the government.

The practical risk is therefore a BIR challenge to a company’s claimed exclusion, followed by the determination and collection of excise tax if the product is found taxable. Companies that rely on an unsupported or overbroad FDA classification may face assessment exposure if the BIR determines that the product does not properly fall within the milk product exclusion or another exclusion under Section 150-B(C).

Practical Steps for Beverage Companies, CFOs, and Tax Managers

Businesses should begin by identifying all products classified internally as exempt or excluded from sweetened beverage excise tax. For each product, management should confirm the exact legal basis for exclusion under Section 150-B(C) and Section 6 of Revenue Regulations No. 20-2018.

For products claiming treatment as milk products, the review should go beyond marketing descriptions. The company should examine whether the product is obtained by the processing of milk, whether added ingredients are functionally necessary for processing, and whether the product falls under the relevant Codex category adopted by the FDA.

Companies should also keep complete supporting records, including FDA classification documents, Certificates of Analysis issued within the required twelve-month period, FDA-approved labels, ingredients lists, product formulation records, and internal tax memoranda explaining the basis for any claimed exclusion. These records should be consistent across regulatory, labeling, accounting, and tax positions.

Finally, businesses should prepare for the possibility that the BIR may review and disagree with an FDA classification for tax purposes. The safest approach is to treat FDA classification as important supporting evidence, but not as the final word on excise tax liability.

Why This Matters for BIR Audits and Product Launches

RMC No. 112-2023 is highly relevant in BIR audits, new product launches, reformulations, import planning, and pricing decisions. A wrong sweetened beverage excise tax classification can affect product costing, tax returns, supply agreements, and audit exposure.

For beverage manufacturers and importers, the circular underscores the need for coordinated legal, tax, regulatory, and product development review before claiming that a product is outside the scope of sweetened beverage excise tax. The more a product depends on a technical food classification, the more important it is to document the Codex basis and the statutory exclusion.

ASG Law Can Assist with Sweetened Beverage Excise Tax Compliance

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses on BIR compliance, excise tax exposure, product classification issues, FDA-related tax documentation, and audit defense. For beverage companies, importers, distributors, and CFOs dealing with sweetened beverage excise tax questions under RMC No. 112-2023, early legal review can prevent costly classification disputes.

For assistance in reviewing beverage product classifications, preparing tax position papers, responding to BIR audits, or aligning FDA documentation with excise tax compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *