RMC No. 158-2022 clarifies cooperative member TIN submission rules, CTE renewal risks, penalties, and justifiable reasons for delayed compliance.

Cooperatives with Certificates of Tax Exemption must act on member TIN compliance immediately: failure to submit the Taxpayer Identification Numbers of active members within the prescribed period may lead first to monetary penalties, then suspension of the Certificate of Tax Exemption, and eventually revocation with a three-year bar from renewal. For cooperatives relying on tax exemption privileges, the practical risk is direct and serious: incomplete TIN records can affect the continued validity and renewal of the cooperative’s CTE.

What RMC No. 158-2022 Changed

RMC No. 158-2022 clarifies the effect of a cooperative’s non-submission of the Taxpayer Identification Number, or TIN, of its members within six months from the issuance of its Certificate of Tax Exemption, or CTE. The clarification is tied to Item A3 of RMC No. 124-2020, which allowed the issuance of a CTE despite incomplete or non-submission of member TINs, subject to the cooperative’s obligation to submit the missing TIN information within six months from the original issuance of the CTE.

The most important rule is that cooperatives cannot treat the initial issuance of a CTE as a waiver of the TIN requirement. The BIR allowed CTE issuance despite incomplete member TIN details only as a temporary accommodation. The cooperative remains required to submit the TINs of its active members within the six-month grace period, unless the failure falls under the specific justifiable reasons recognized by the circular.

This matters because the TIN of cooperative members is among the requirements for CTE application under Section 236 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. A cooperative that fails to complete its member TIN records may expose itself to penalties, suspension of its tax exemption certificate, or loss of eligibility to renew the CTE.

Who Is Affected by the Cooperative TIN Requirement

RMC No. 158-2022 directly affects cooperatives that were issued an original Certificate of Tax Exemption despite incomplete or non-submission of the TINs of their active members. It also affects cooperatives with valid and existing CTEs, because all cooperatives are mandated to submit the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members to the Revenue District Office concerned within the period stated in the circular.

The affected entities include cooperatives applying for an original CTE, cooperatives that already received a CTE subject to completion of member TIN details, and cooperatives applying for renewal of their CTE. For accountants, cooperative officers, compliance teams, and tax practitioners, the key search issue is cooperative CTE renewal TIN requirements, BIR cooperative tax exemption compliance, and penalties for non-submission of member TINs.

The ruling is especially important for cooperatives with large membership bases, because the first-offense penalty is computed per member without a TIN, subject to an annual aggregate cap. Even where the monetary penalty is capped, the second and third offense consequences may impair the cooperative’s tax-exempt status.

Six-Month Grace Period from Original CTE Issuance

Under the clarified rule, where the BIR issued the original CTE despite incomplete or non-submission of member TINs, the cooperative must submit the TIN requirement within six months from the original issuance of the CTE. This six-month period is not optional. It is the period within which the cooperative must cure the incomplete submission.

All cooperatives issued a CTE despite non-submission of the TINs of their active members are still required to submit the TINs to the concerned Revenue District Office after the six-month grace period, unless the non-submission is covered by a justifiable reason recognized in the circular.

For renewal applications, the rule is stricter. Cooperatives applying for renewal of their CTE must complete and submit the TINs of their active members. Upon renewal, all active members must already have secured their respective TINs. Failure to submit the TINs of active members will disqualify the cooperative from CTE renewal.

Required List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members

RMC No. 158-2022 also requires submission of the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members. This list must be submitted pursuant to Cooperative Development Authority Memorandum Circular No. 2022-14, and must be filed with the RDO where the cooperative is registered.

The circular states that the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members, or updates if any, must be submitted one year after the issuance of the original CTE and yearly thereafter. This requirement is tied to the terms and conditions indicated at the back of the issued CTE and to Revenue Memorandum Order No. 76-2010.

In addition, to ensure compliance by cooperatives, including those with valid and existing CTEs, all cooperatives are mandated to submit the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members pursuant to CDA MC No. 2022-14 to the concerned RDO within thirty days from the effectivity of RMC No. 158-2022. Failure to comply exposes the cooperative to the penalties imposed under the circular.

Penalties for Non-Submission of Member TINs

The penalties under RMC No. 158-2022 escalate depending on the offense. For the first offense, the cooperative is subject to a penalty of One Thousand Pesos, or ₱1,000, per member without a TIN. However, the aggregate amount imposed for such failure during a calendar year shall not exceed Twenty-Five Thousand Pesos, or ₱25,000, as provided under Section 250 of the NIRC, as amended.

For the second offense, the penalty is suspension of the Certificate of Tax Exemption until the cooperative complies with the required submission of the TINs of its members. This is a significant operational and tax risk because the cooperative’s tax exemption position may be placed in limbo until compliance is completed.

For the third offense, the penalty is revocation of the CTE and prohibition from applying for renewal of the CTE for a period of three years from the date of revocation. This is the most serious consequence under the circular. A cooperative that loses its CTE and is barred from renewal for three years may face substantial tax and compliance consequences depending on its activities and income streams.

Justifiable Reasons That May Prevent Penalties

RMC No. 158-2022 recognizes limited justifiable reasons that may prevent the imposition of penalties for failure to submit member TINs within six months from CTE issuance. The first is where the unsubmitted TIN pertains to inactive members, provided that these inactive members have already been delisted pursuant to CDA MC No. 2022-14.

To support this justification, the cooperative must submit the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members even before the prescribed due date for submission, which is one year after CTE issuance. This means a cooperative cannot simply state that the missing TINs belong to inactive members. It must support that position through the required list and delisting under the relevant CDA issuance.

The second recognized justification is force majeure, such as a state of emergency or state of calamity declared by the National Government and the concerned Local Government Unit. However, once the force majeure ceases to exist, the cooperative must immediately complete the submission. The circular does not treat force majeure as a permanent excuse; it only delays the compliance obligation while the justifying event exists.

Practical Steps for Cooperatives and Accountants

Cooperatives should immediately audit their membership records and separate active members from inactive members. The core compliance question is whether every active member already has a TIN on record. If not, the cooperative should coordinate with those members and complete the TIN submission to the concerned RDO within the applicable period.

Cooperatives should also verify whether inactive members have been properly delisted under CDA MC No. 2022-14. If missing TINs relate to inactive members, the cooperative should prepare and submit the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members to support the position that penalties should not be imposed.

For cooperatives with existing CTEs, management should confirm whether the required list was submitted within thirty days from the effectivity of RMC No. 158-2022 and whether annual submissions have been made one year after original CTE issuance and yearly thereafter. For cooperatives approaching renewal, the most important action is to ensure that all active members have already secured their TINs before filing the renewal application.

For CFOs, accountants, and tax compliance officers, the relevant internal checklist should include the date of original CTE issuance, the six-month TIN completion deadline, the one-year deadline for submission of the List of Active Members with TIN and Inactive Members, the annual recurring submission, and any renewal deadline. These dates should be tracked because the consequences move from a monetary penalty to suspension, and then to revocation and a three-year prohibition on renewal.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 158-2022 shows that cooperative tax exemption compliance is not limited to obtaining the Certificate of Tax Exemption. The continuing obligation to maintain accurate member TIN records, submit the required lists, justify inactive member exclusions, and prepare for CTE renewal must be managed carefully to avoid penalties and loss of exemption privileges.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists cooperatives, businesses, corporate accountants, and tax teams in reviewing BIR compliance requirements, preparing submissions to Revenue District Offices, assessing exposure to penalties, and addressing CTE renewal issues. For assistance with cooperative tax exemption compliance, BIR member TIN submissions, or CTE renewal concerns, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *