RMC No. 3-2022 requires BIR compromise penalties to be separated from deficiency tax, surcharge, and interest in assessment notices and BIR Form 0605.
Taxpayers facing BIR audits must now check whether any compromise penalty is being presented separately from deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest. RMC No. 3-2022 clarifies that compromise penalties should not be mixed into the portion of the assessment notice that covers deficiency taxes and civil penalties. Instead, BIR assessment notices must distinguish between Part I, covering deficiency basic tax and civil penalties, and Part II, covering compromise penalties for violations uncovered during audit.
What RMC No. 3-2022 Changed
RMC No. 3-2022 clarified the proper preparation of assessment notices for compromise penalties. The key rule is separation: compromise penalties must be presented in a separate part of the assessment notice and must not form part of the assessment notice reflecting deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest.
The clarification is based on Revenue Memorandum Order No. 7-2015, which provides that compromise penalties incident to violations shall be itemized in the assessment notice or demand letter, but should not form part of the assessment notice for deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest. Instead, the compromise penalty should appear as a separate assessment notice or demand letter as the amount suggested to the taxpayer to pay in lieu of criminal prosecution.
For uniformity, the prescribed formats under Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended by RR No. 18-2013, such as the Preliminary Assessment Notice and Formal Letter of Demand, must now be composed of Part I and Part II. Part I pertains to deficiency basic taxes and civil penalties. Part II pertains to assessed compromise penalties relating to violations uncovered during the conduct of audit.
Why the Separation of Compromise Penalties Matters
The practical impact is significant for taxpayers receiving a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Assessment Notice. A compromise penalty is not the same as deficiency tax, surcharge, or interest. It is an amount collected in lieu of criminal prosecution for a violation committed by the taxpayer, and payment is based on a compromise agreement validly entered into between the taxpayer and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue.
Because a compromise penalty is tied to settlement in lieu of criminal prosecution, it should not be treated as an automatic component of the deficiency tax assessment. Taxpayers, accountants, and counsel reviewing a BIR assessment should therefore identify whether the BIR is demanding payment of deficiency taxes and civil penalties under Part I, while merely stating the suggested compromise penalty under Part II.
This distinction matters in BIR audit defense, protest preparation, settlement evaluation, and internal accounting review. Businesses should avoid treating a compromise penalty as if it were automatically the same kind of collectible deficiency tax item as basic tax, surcharge, or interest. The document makes clear that the compromise penalty is separately presented because it has a different legal character and purpose.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 3-2022
RMC No. 3-2022 affects all taxpayers under BIR audit where violations are uncovered and compromise penalties may be suggested. This includes corporations, SMEs, sole proprietors, professionals, withholding agents, VAT taxpayers, percentage tax taxpayers, and other registered taxpayers who may receive a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, or BIR payment form in connection with an audit.
The issuance is also important for corporate accountants, CFOs, finance heads, tax compliance officers, in-house counsel, and external tax practitioners. Any business reviewing a BIR deficiency tax assessment should check the structure of the assessment notice. The taxpayer should confirm whether deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest are separated from compromise penalties, and whether the BIR Form No. 0605 payment forms are prepared separately.
Internal Revenue officials and employees are expressly directed to follow this clarification. However, taxpayers should still verify compliance when they receive BIR notices, because the circular itself recognizes that there were instances when assessment notices for deficiency basic taxes and civil penalties also included compromise penalties.
Key Compliance Requirements Under RMC No. 3-2022
The central compliance requirement is documentary separation in the assessment process. The Preliminary Assessment Notice and Formal Letter of Demand must be composed of Part I and Part II. Part I must pertain to deficiency basic tax and civil penalties. Part II must pertain to assessed compromise penalties relative to violations uncovered during audit.
The applicable notices are supported by prescribed annexes. Annex A refers to the Preliminary Assessment Notice Part II. Annex B.1 refers to the Formal Letter of Demand Part II. Annex B.2 refers to the Final Assessment Notice. These formats are intended to promote uniformity in the preparation of BIR assessment notices involving compromise penalties.
The payment form requirement is also specific. BIR Form No. 0605 for the settlement or payment of deficiency basic tax and civil penalties in Part I of the assessment notices must be prepared separately from BIR Form No. 0605 for compromise penalties in Part II. In practical terms, a taxpayer should not expect one combined payment form to cover both categories when the assessment includes both deficiency taxes and compromise penalties.
For businesses searching for BIR compromise penalty assessment notice rules, BIR Form 0605 compromise penalty, Preliminary Assessment Notice Part II, Formal Letter of Demand compromise penalty, or RMC No. 3-2022 tax audit procedure, the key point is that compromise penalties must be segregated in both the notice and payment documentation.
Effective Date and Deadline
RMC No. 3-2022 states that it shall take effect immediately. No separate transition period, grace period, or future implementation date is stated. This means BIR personnel preparing assessment notices and taxpayers reviewing assessment notices should apply the clarification at once.
The issuance date appearing in the circular is December 1, 2021. The document title reflects RMC No. 3-2022 and its publication or release context in January 2022. For taxpayers, the practical instruction is straightforward: for any assessment notice involving compromise penalties after effectiveness, the taxpayer should expect a Part I and Part II structure and separate BIR Form No. 0605 payment forms.
Penalties and Risk for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 3-2022 does not create a new tax rate, surcharge rate, interest rate, or penalty amount. It also does not prescribe a new compromise penalty schedule. Instead, it clarifies how compromise penalties should be reflected in BIR assessment notices and payment forms.
The risk for taxpayers is not a new penalty under this circular, but confusion in assessment handling. If a compromise penalty is mixed with deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest, a taxpayer may mistakenly treat it as an ordinary assessed tax item rather than a suggested amount payable in lieu of criminal prosecution. This may affect how the taxpayer evaluates protest strategy, settlement options, accounting treatment, and payment documentation.
Businesses should also remember that compromise penalties are connected to violations committed by the taxpayer. The circular describes compromise penalties as amounts collected in lieu of criminal prosecution, where payment is based on a compromise agreement validly entered into between the taxpayer and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. That language should alert taxpayers to review the alleged violation carefully before payment or settlement.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers and Accountants
First, when a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Assessment Notice is received, identify whether the assessment contains both deficiency taxes and compromise penalties. The deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest should be under Part I. The compromise penalty should be under Part II.
Second, check the BIR Form No. 0605 payment forms. There should be separate preparation of BIR Form No. 0605 for the deficiency basic tax and civil penalties in Part I, and another BIR Form No. 0605 for the compromise penalties in Part II.
Third, review the alleged violations underlying the compromise penalty. Since compromise penalties are tied to payment in lieu of criminal prosecution, management should not simply approve payment without understanding the alleged violation, the audit findings, and the legal consequences of compromise.
Fourth, coordinate the response among the accounting team, tax counsel, and management. The accounting team should verify the figures and payment forms. Tax counsel should review whether the BIR assessment format complies with RMC No. 3-2022, RMO No. 7-2015, and RR No. 12-99 as amended by RR No. 18-2013. Management should evaluate whether payment, protest, or settlement is appropriate.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house legal teams on BIR assessments, tax audit responses, compromise penalties, payment documentation, and protest strategy. RMC No. 3-2022 is a reminder that even the format of a BIR assessment notice can affect how a taxpayer understands and responds to an audit finding.
For companies that received a Preliminary Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, Final Assessment Notice, or BIR Form No. 0605 involving compromise penalties, ASG Law can review the notice, identify procedural and substantive issues, and assist in preparing a legally grounded response. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance, tax assessments, and compromise penalty issues in the Philippines.