RMC No. 54-2021 clarifies who must file BIR Form 1709, disclose related party transactions, and prepare transfer pricing documentation.

Businesses with related party transactions must immediately re-check whether they are required to file BIR Form No. 1709, also known as the Related Party Transaction or RPT Form, because RMC No. 54-2021 narrows and clarifies the taxpayers covered by RR No. 34-2020 while confirming that covered taxpayers must disclose all related party transactions, regardless of amount. The most urgent compliance point is this: materiality thresholds do not determine whether a reportable related party transaction must be disclosed in the RPT Form. Once a taxpayer is required to file the RPT Form, all related party transactions must be reported, and no reasonable estimates are allowed.

What RMC No. 54-2021 Changed for BIR Form 1709 Compliance

RMC No. 54-2021 clarifies the rules under RR No. 34-2020 on the submission of BIR Form No. 1709 and the preparation of Transfer Pricing Documentation, or TPD. The circular explains that not all taxpayers with related party transactions are automatically required to file the RPT Form. A taxpayer must file the RPT Form only if three conditions are present: the taxpayer is required to file an Annual Income Tax Return, the taxpayer has transactions with a domestic or foreign related party during the taxable period, and the taxpayer falls under one of the specified covered categories.

The covered categories are large taxpayers, taxpayers enjoying tax incentives, taxpayers reporting net operating losses for the current taxable year and the immediately preceding two consecutive taxable years, and related parties that have transactions with any of those taxpayers. This is important for corporate accountants and CFOs because the duty to file BIR Form 1709 depends not only on the existence of related party transactions, but also on the taxpayer’s classification or the classification of its related party.

Who Is Affected by RMC No. 54-2021

Large taxpayers remain covered, but RMC No. 54-2021 clarifies that a taxpayer is a large taxpayer only if it has been classified and duly notified by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue under RR No. 1-1998 or amendatory rules. A business that merely meets the criteria but has not been duly notified by the Commissioner is not considered a large taxpayer for purposes of this RPT Form requirement.

Taxpayers enjoying income tax incentives are also affected. RMC No. 54-2021 states that covered taxpayers include, among others, BOI-registered and economic zone enterprises enjoying Income Tax Holiday or subject to preferential income tax rate. For ecozone taxpayers, the circular makes an important distinction: an economic zone enterprise subject to regular corporate income tax is not required to file the RPT Form merely because it operates inside an economic zone. Only those enjoying income tax incentives, such as Income Tax Holiday or the 5% Special Tax on Gross Income, are required to file, unless they are covered under another category such as large taxpayer status, net operating losses, or related party dealings with covered taxpayers.

Tax-exempt corporations are generally not required to file the RPT Form. Taxpayers exempt from income tax under Section 30 of the Tax Code or similar provisions of the Tax Code or special laws are not required to file. This includes regional or area headquarters and representative offices of foreign corporations that are not allowed by law to derive income from the Philippines. Post-employment benefit plans are likewise not required to file an RPT Form if their related party transactions consist only of contributions from their sponsor employers.

Preferential Income Tax Rate and International Carrier Clarifications

RMC No. 54-2021 clarifies that whether a taxpayer is subject to preferential income tax rate should be determined based on how the taxpayer is taxed as a whole, not on a per-transaction basis. Therefore, a corporate taxpayer subject to regular corporate income tax does not become required to file the RPT Form merely because some transactions are subject to preferential tax treatment under tax treaties or the Tax Code, provided it does not fall under the other covered categories.

Examples of taxpayers subject to preferential income tax rates include proprietary educational institutions and hospitals, and regional operating headquarters. International carriers, although subject to preferential rates under Section 28(A)(3) of the Tax Code or a relevant tax treaty, are not required to file an RPT Form if they are subject to tax based on Gross Philippine Billings or gross revenues. The same applies to international carriers exempt from tax under a treaty or on the basis of reciprocity. However, international carriers taxed on profits from sources within the Philippines are required to file an RPT Form.

Net Operating Losses and the Three-Year Rule

For purposes of the RPT Form requirement, net operating losses must be determined based on income tax rules, not merely the loss reflected in the Audited Financial Statements. RMC No. 54-2021 refers to Section 34(D)(3) of the Tax Code, under which net operating loss means the excess of allowable deductions over gross income in a taxable year.

The circular also clarifies that registration fees, business permits and licenses, and taxes, except those excluded under Section 34(C)(1) of the Tax Code, are allowable deductions and should be considered in computing net operating losses. For companies searching for BIR Form 1709 net operating loss rules, the key test is whether the taxpayer reported net operating losses for the current taxable year and the immediately preceding two consecutive taxable years.

What Must Be Reported in the RPT Form

Once a taxpayer is required to file BIR Form 1709, it must disclose all related party transactions, irrespective of amount. RMC No. 54-2021 expressly states that the materiality threshold is relevant only in determining who must prepare Transfer Pricing Documentation. It is not a threshold for deciding whether a related party transaction should be reported in the RPT Form.

The RPT Form must use actual amounts, not estimates. A reasonable estimate is not sufficient because the RPT Form contains a perjury clause requiring the taxpayer or its authorized representative to attest to the truthfulness of the facts stated. Similar transactions with the same related party may be aggregated if possible. For example, if a company sold raw materials to a subsidiary on several occasions amounting to P20,000,000 in aggregate and also provided monthly support services for P500,000 per month, the transactions may be reported as sale of goods of P20,000,000 and sale of services of P6,000,000.

The TPD and other supporting documents are no longer required to be attached to the RPT Form. Instead, they must be made available during audit. This is a practical change for taxpayers preparing annual income tax return filing packages because the form is filed, but the supporting transfer pricing file must still be ready for BIR examination.

When Transfer Pricing Documentation Is Required

RMC No. 54-2021 makes clear that the obligation to prepare a TPD applies only to taxpayers that are first required to file the RPT Form and then meet any of the materiality conditions under RR No. 34-2020. If a taxpayer is not required to file the RPT Form, it is not mandated to prepare TPD under RR No. 34-2020, even if it meets materiality figures. However, the taxpayer may still prepare TPD voluntarily to prove that related party transactions are at arm’s length during audit.

TPD is mandatory if the taxpayer has annual gross sales or revenue for the subject taxable period exceeding P150,000,000 and total related party transactions with foreign and domestic related parties exceeding P90,000,000. TPD is also mandatory if the sale of tangible goods involving the same related party exceeds P60,000,000 within the taxable year. For service transactions, payment of interest, utilization of intangible goods, or other related party transactions involving the same related party, the threshold is more than P15,000,000 within the taxable year. TPD is also required if TPD was required to be prepared during the immediately preceding taxable period because the taxpayer exceeded the relevant thresholds.

Annual gross sales or revenue means the gross sales, receipts, revenues, or fees reported in the Annual Income Tax Return, regardless of whether the transactions were with related parties or third parties. In computing total related party transactions, the taxpayer must total amounts received or receivable from related parties, amounts paid or payable to related parties, and outstanding balances of loans and non-trade amounts due from or to all related parties. Compensation paid to key management personnel, dividends, and branch profit remittances are not included in that computation.

Currency, Advance Pricing Agreements, and 2020 Transition Rules

The RPT Form requires disclosure of amounts in foreign currency and their equivalent in local currency. If several currencies were used and it is impractical to indicate all currencies in the RPT Form, the equivalent in local currency should be disclosed instead. In all cases, the exchange rate to be used is the rate at the transaction date. The same rule applies in preparing the TPD.

RMC No. 54-2021 also clarifies that related party transactions covered by an Advance Pricing Agreement are exempt from disclosure in the RPT Form only if the APA is approved and accepted by the BIR. The APA may be unilateral, bilateral, or multilateral. The BIR is not obliged to accept a unilateral APA entered into by a foreign taxpayer and the tax authority of the foreign taxpayer’s country of residence, even if it applies to an international transaction involving a Philippine related party.

For short-period returns, the filing of the RPT Form is mandatory only for short-period returns originally required by law or existing revenue issuances to be filed in 2021 and subsequent years. RR No. 34-2020 took effect immediately after publication in a newspaper of general circulation on December 23, 2020, and its provisions apply only to RPT Forms required to be submitted after its effectivity. Taxpayers not required to file the RPT Form and that had already finalized their 2020 AFS before the effectivity of RR No. 34-2020 are not expected to comply with the Section 4 disclosure requirement and cannot be penalized for non-disclosure.

Penalties and Audit Risk for Non-Compliance

The most direct penalty risk under RMC No. 54-2021 arises when a taxpayer submits an incomplete RPT Form. If the taxpayer fails to supply material information, such as details of related parties and related party transactions, the BIR will treat the RPT Form as not duly filed. The penalty for failure to file such information return will then be imposed.

Compliance with RR No. 34-2020 does not exempt a taxpayer from audit. The BIR will use submitted RPT Forms to conduct an initial transfer pricing risk assessment, identify high-risk taxpayers, and determine whether to conduct a transfer pricing audit. The BIR also retains the right to conduct a transfer pricing audit against taxpayers with related party transactions, regardless of whether they are required to file the RPT Form or prepare TPD. Even taxpayers not mandated to file the RPT Form or prepare TPD must still present sufficient evidence during audit to prove that their related party transactions were conducted at arm’s length.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants

Businesses should first map all domestic and foreign related parties and identify whether the taxpayer or any related party is a large taxpayer, enjoys income tax incentives, or has reported net operating losses for the current taxable year and the immediately preceding two consecutive taxable years. They should also verify whether large taxpayer status was actually classified and duly notified by the Commissioner, because mere satisfaction of criteria is not enough.

Second, companies should determine whether they must file BIR Form 1709 together with the Annual Income Tax Return and ensure that all related party transactions are disclosed using actual amounts. Companies should not use materiality thresholds as a reason to omit transactions from the RPT Form.

Third, taxpayers required to file the RPT Form should separately test whether they must prepare TPD using the P150,000,000 gross sales or revenue threshold, the P90,000,000 total related party transaction threshold, the P60,000,000 tangible goods threshold per same related party, and the P15,000,000 threshold for services, interest, intangibles, or other related party transactions per same related party.

Fourth, taxpayers should prepare audit-ready records even when TPD is not mandatory. The arm’s length principle remains important, and the burden of proof rests on the taxpayer when challenged by the BIR. For CFOs and tax managers, the safest approach is to keep contemporaneous support for pricing, intercompany agreements, invoices, receivable and payable balances, and exchange rate computations at transaction date.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 54-2021 makes related party transaction compliance more technical, especially for large taxpayers, BOI and PEZA enterprises, companies enjoying Income Tax Holiday or the 5% Special Tax on Gross Income, and corporate groups with cross-border or domestic related party dealings. A mistake in determining coverage, omitting material information, or failing to maintain transfer pricing support can expose the company to penalties and audit risk.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR Form 1709 obligations, testing transfer pricing documentation thresholds, preparing audit-ready related party transaction files, and responding to BIR transfer pricing inquiries. For help with BIR Form 1709, RR No. 34-2020, RMC No. 54-2021, and Philippine transfer pricing compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *