RMC No. 104-2020 circularizes April 2020 sugar millsite prices for computing the 1% Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar transactions.
Sugar mills, traders, buyers, and withholding agents dealing with sugar transactions for April 2020 must use the consolidated millsite price schedule circularized under RMC No. 104-2020 when determining the basis for the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar. The key compliance point is direct: the relevant April 2020 sugar millsite price data has been consolidated for withholding tax purposes, and taxpayers handling sugar purchases or related payments should align their tax computation and documentation with that schedule.
What RMC No. 104-2020 Changed
RMC No. 104-2020 circularized the Consolidated Price of Sugar at Millsite for the month of April 2020. The consolidated price information was taken from Operations Memorandum Nos. 45-2020, 46-2020, 47-2020, and 48-2020.
The issuance matters because the price of sugar at millsite is used for purposes of imposing the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar. The governing withholding tax rule cited in the issuance is Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 11-2014.
In practical terms, RMC No. 104-2020 does not announce a new withholding tax rate. The rate remains one percent (1%) for the covered sugar transactions under the applicable regulations. What it provides is the consolidated April 2020 millsite price reference relevant to the computation and implementation of that tax.
Why the Consolidated Sugar Millsite Price Matters
The Sugar Regulatory Administration issues weekly Price of Sugar at Millsite data reflecting comparative prices between the previous year and the current year. RMC No. 104-2020 explains that the consolidated schedule in the weekly Operations Memoranda contains only the current year price for purposes of imposing the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar.
For accountants and tax teams, that distinction is important. Comparative price information may help industry participants understand price movement, but the consolidated schedule circularized for withholding tax purposes is focused on the current year figure relevant to the tax computation. When reviewing April 2020 transactions, the tax team should avoid relying on irrelevant comparative figures if the purpose is the withholding tax base.
This is the type of issuance that may appear administrative, but it affects the defensibility of withholding tax computations. In a BIR examination, a taxpayer should be able to show that the price basis used for the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar is consistent with the official consolidated millsite price schedule circularized for the relevant month.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 104-2020
RMC No. 104-2020 is most relevant to businesses and withholding agents participating in or accounting for sugar transactions for April 2020. This includes sugar mills, sugar planters and traders, buyers of sugar, processors, distributors, and other parties whose payments or transactions may trigger the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar.
The issuance is also important for corporate accountants, CFOs, tax managers, bookkeepers, and external tax practitioners supporting clients in the sugar industry. For these professionals, the common search issues are likely to include RMC No. 104-2020 sugar millsite price, April 2020 sugar price BIR withholding tax, 1% expanded withholding tax on sugar, Sugar Regulatory Administration millsite price, and RR No. 2-98 sugar withholding tax.
Companies outside the sugar industry may still be affected if they purchased sugar or made payments covered by the applicable withholding tax rules during the relevant period. The relevant question is not merely whether the company is a sugar producer, but whether it made transactions where the official sugar millsite price is needed to determine the proper withholding tax base.
Key Compliance Requirement and Relevant Date
The document was issued on October 1, 2020. It circularized the Consolidated Price of Sugar at Millsite for April 2020, as contained in Operations Memorandum Nos. 45-2020, 46-2020, 47-2020, and 48-2020.
The key compliance requirement is to apply the consolidated current-year millsite price schedule for April 2020 when computing the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 11-2014.
Taxpayers reviewing April 2020 sugar transactions should match the relevant purchase documents, payment records, withholding tax returns, accounting entries, and certificates of tax withheld against the applicable millsite price basis. Where the taxpayer used a different figure, the reason should be reviewed and documented. Where the taxpayer failed to withhold, underwithheld, or recorded a different tax base, the issue should be assessed for possible correction, reconciliation, or disclosure depending on the status of the taxpayer’s filings and any pending BIR audit.
Penalties and Audit Risk for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 104-2020 itself does not state a separate penalty. However, because the circular relates to the imposition of the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar, non-compliance may create ordinary withholding tax exposure under the National Internal Revenue Code and applicable BIR regulations.
The practical risk is that the BIR may question whether the withholding agent used the correct tax base for April 2020 sugar transactions. If the withholding tax was computed using an unsupported price, the taxpayer may face deficiency withholding tax exposure, plus applicable additions depending on the facts of the case and the applicable assessment rules.
For businesses, the compliance risk is not limited to the amount of the one percent (1%) tax. A withholding tax issue can also affect deductibility positions, vendor documentation, audit findings, and the taxpayer’s ability to prove that the correct amount was withheld and remitted at the proper time.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Tax Teams
Businesses that handled sugar transactions for April 2020 should first identify all transactions where the price of sugar at millsite was used, or should have been used, in computing withholding tax. The accounting team should then compare the working papers and tax computation against the consolidated April 2020 millsite price schedule circularized through RMC No. 104-2020.
Second, withholding tax returns, certificates of tax withheld, purchase documents, and supplier records should be reconciled. The purpose of the reconciliation is to determine whether the one percent (1%) Expanded Withholding Tax on sugar was computed using the proper price basis under RR No. 2-98, as amended by RR No. 11-2014.
Third, companies should preserve copies of the internal computation, the relevant invoices or purchase documents, withholding tax certificates, and proof of remittance. In a tax audit, the issue will often be evidentiary: the taxpayer must show not only that tax was withheld, but that the withholding was computed using the correct official basis.
Fourth, if an inconsistency is discovered, the company should consult tax counsel before making any corrective filing or written submission. The proper approach may depend on whether the period is under audit, whether a deficiency assessment has been issued, and whether the discrepancy involves a computation issue, a documentation issue, or an actual failure to withhold.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 104-2020 is a reminder that BIR compliance in regulated industries often depends on specific monthly schedules, agency data, and industry-specific withholding tax rules. For sugar businesses and companies dealing with commodities subject to special withholding tax treatment, small errors in the tax base can become significant audit issues when multiplied across transactions.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house legal teams in reviewing BIR issuances, reconciling withholding tax compliance, preparing audit defenses, and responding to BIR findings. For assistance with sugar withholding tax, BIR compliance, expanded withholding tax exposure, or tax audit strategy, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.