RMC No. 52-2020 temporarily allowed taxpayers to e-mail withdrawals of assessment protests or FDDA appeals for tax amnesty during ECQ/GCQ.

Taxpayers pursuing tax amnesty while their assessment protest or FDDA appeal remained pending were temporarily allowed, beginning May 27, 2020, to file the required withdrawal by e-mail instead of being forced to physically appear before the BIR during the ECQ or GCQ. For businesses with disputed Final Assessment Notices, Formal Letters of Demand, or Final Decisions on Disputed Assessment, the immediate compliance point was clear: prepare a signed PDF withdrawal, attach the required scanned received page, and send it to the correct BIR office using the prescribed e-mail format.

What RMC No. 52-2020 Changed

RMC No. 52-2020 amended and supplemented RMC No. 11-2020, dated February 6, 2020, by temporarily allowing the filing by electronic mail of the withdrawal of a protest on a Final Assessment Notice or Formal Letter of Demand, or the withdrawal of an appeal on a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, for purposes of tax amnesty. The circular was issued in view of the continuing implementation of Enhanced Community Quarantine and General Community Quarantine, which restricted ordinary physical filing before BIR offices.

Before this temporary relief, taxpayers generally had to file the withdrawal physically before the concerned Regional Office or National Office. Under RMC No. 52-2020, physical filing remained available, but online or electronic filing was temporarily recognized as a valid option for the specific purpose of withdrawing a protest or appeal in connection with tax amnesty under the rules discussed in Q22 and Q23 of RMC No. 57-2019, as amended by RMC No. 11-2020.

The most important rule is that the withdrawal is deemed filed on the date and time the BIR receives the e-mail. This matters because tax amnesty applications often depend on whether the taxpayer has properly withdrawn the pending dispute. A taxpayer that sends the withdrawal to the wrong office, omits the required PDF, or fails to include the scanned received page of the original protest or appeal risks having the withdrawal treated as incomplete or not properly filed for amnesty processing.

Who Is Affected

RMC No. 52-2020 affects taxpayers with existing disputed assessments who intend to avail of tax amnesty and who must withdraw a pending protest or appeal as part of the amnesty process. This includes corporations, SMEs, individual taxpayers engaged in business, withholding agents, and other taxpayers with pending protests against a FAN or FLD, or pending appeals from an FDDA.

The issuance is especially relevant to CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel handling BIR assessment cases during the quarantine period. Common search issues include BIR tax amnesty withdrawal of protest by email, withdrawal of protest on FAN or FLD, appeal on FDDA tax amnesty, RMC 52-2020 email filing, and BIR disputed assessment amnesty requirements.

Required PDF Attachment and Supporting Page

The soft copy of the letter of withdrawal of protest or appeal must be in PDF format. It must be individually attached to the e-mail and signed by the taxpayer or by the taxpayer’s duly authorized representative. The rule is specific: the withdrawal letter itself must be attached as a PDF, not merely typed in the body of the e-mail.

The withdrawal letter must also contain the scanned copy of the first page of the protest or appeal being withdrawn. That first page must show the appropriate BIR office’s received stamp and must be marked as Annex A of the withdrawal letter. This requirement allows the BIR to connect the withdrawal to the actual protest or appeal previously filed and to verify that the withdrawal relates to an existing docketed assessment dispute.

Prescribed E-Mail Format

The e-mail must be addressed to the appropriate BIR office and must follow the format required by RMC No. 52-2020. The recipient field must contain the e-mail address of the appropriate BIR office, and the sender field must be the filer’s e-mail address. The subject must state that it is the withdrawal of the protest of FAN or FLD, or the appeal on FDDA, of the named taxpayer, filed before the named BIR office.

The body of the e-mail must identify the name of the taxpayer, the name of the filing party, the position of the filer, the date the protest or appeal was filed, the taxable year, and the summary of the FAN, FLD, or FDDA. The summary must include the assessment number or reference number, the tax type, the basic tax, the penalties, and the total. These details are important because they establish the assessment being withdrawn and help the BIR processor attach the e-mail and withdrawal letter to the proper docket.

Where to Send the Withdrawal

For withdrawals of protests against FAN or FLD, the e-mail must be sent to the appropriate Revenue Region or, for large taxpayers, to the Large Taxpayers Service. RMC No. 52-2020 lists the regional e-mail addresses, including rr_1csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 1 Calasiao, rr_2csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 2 Cordillera Administrative Region, rr_3csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 3 Tuguegarao City, rr_4csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 4 City of San Fernando, Pampanga, rr_5csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 5 Caloocan City, rr_6csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 6 City of Manila, rr_7acsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 7A Quezon City, rr_7bcsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 7B East NCR, rr_8acsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 8A Makati City, and rr_8bcsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 8B South NCR.

The circular also lists rr_9acsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 9A CaBaMiRo, rr_9bcsu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 9B LaQueMar, rr_10csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 10 Legazpi City, rr_11csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 11 Iloilo City, rr_12csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 12 Bacolod, rr_13csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 13 Cebu City, rr_14csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 14 Eastern Visayas, rr_15csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 15 Zamboanga City, rr_16csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 16 Cagayan de Oro City, rr_17csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 17 Butuan City, rr_18csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 18 Koronadal City, and rr_19csu@bir.gov.ph
for Revenue Region No. 19 Davao City. For the Large Taxpayers Service, the listed e-mail address is manuel.mapoy@bir.gov.ph
.

For withdrawal of appeals against the FDDA, the proper office is the Appellate Division, and the listed e-mail address is hayle.bonilla@bir.gov.ph
. This distinction is critical: a protest against a FAN or FLD is not the same as an appeal from an FDDA, and taxpayers must route the withdrawal to the office identified for the type of disputed assessment involved.

Deadline and Temporary Effect

RMC No. 52-2020 took effect as a relief measure during the ECQ and GCQ period. It expressly states that regular filing of papers or pleadings in connection with the protest or appeal, pursuant to existing rules and revenue issuances, shall resume as soon as the ECQ or GCQ is lifted. Once that happens, the option for online filing of withdrawal of any protest or appeal before the concerned BIR offices will no longer be allowed.

Because the filing date is the date and time of receipt of the e-mail, taxpayers should retain proof of transmission and receipt, including the sent e-mail, attachments, timestamp, and any BIR acknowledgment. The BIR personnel or processor is required to print the e-mail and the withdrawal letter and attach them to the docket accordingly.

Penalties and Risks of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 52-2020 does not impose a separate monetary penalty for failure to follow the e-mail filing procedure. However, the practical risk is significant. If the withdrawal is not properly filed, is sent to the wrong BIR office, lacks the signed PDF withdrawal letter, omits Annex A, or does not identify the assessment details, the taxpayer may be unable to establish a valid withdrawal for tax amnesty purposes.

For companies attempting to close disputed assessments through tax amnesty, non-compliance can delay processing, create docketing issues, and expose the taxpayer to continued controversy over whether the protest or FDDA appeal remains pending. In tax practice, a defective filing can be costly even when no separate fine is stated, because it can affect the availability, timing, and documentation of the intended tax amnesty relief.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers

Taxpayers should first confirm whether the pending matter is a protest against a FAN or FLD, or an appeal from an FDDA. They should then prepare a signed letter of withdrawal in PDF format, attach the scanned first page of the original protest or appeal showing the BIR received stamp as Annex A, complete the prescribed e-mail body, and send the filing only to the correct BIR office. The assessment summary should be checked carefully, particularly the assessment number or reference number, taxable year, tax type, basic tax, penalties, and total amount.

Corporate taxpayers should also ensure that the person signing or sending the withdrawal is properly authorized. If the filer is a representative, the authority should be internally documented and readily available in case the BIR later asks for proof. The taxpayer should keep a complete digital filing record, including the final signed PDF, annex, sent e-mail, timestamp, and any reply from the BIR.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 52-2020 is a procedural relief issuance, but it affects a substantive tax strategy: the taxpayer’s ability to withdraw an assessment dispute for purposes of tax amnesty. Businesses should not treat the e-mail as a mere administrative formality. The withdrawal must match the correct assessment, be sent to the proper office, and be supported by the required scanned received copy of the original protest or appeal.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, business owners, CFOs, accounting teams, and in-house counsel in handling BIR assessment disputes, tax amnesty compliance, protest withdrawals, FDDA appeals, and related tax controversy documentation. For assistance in reviewing your assessment status, preparing a withdrawal of protest or appeal, or coordinating a compliant BIR tax amnesty filing, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *