RMC No. 143-2019 clarifies who may be treated as Top Withholding Agents required to remit 1% and 2% creditable withholding taxes.
Businesses should not automatically withhold 1% creditable withholding tax on purchases of goods and 2% creditable withholding tax on purchases of services merely because their names appear in a published list of Top Withholding Agents. RMC No. 143-2019 clarifies that only taxpayers that actually satisfy the criteria under Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019, and are not among the excluded categories identified by the BIR, may be treated as Top Withholding Agents required to withhold and remit these 1% and 2% CWTs.
What RMC No. 143-2019 Changed for Top Withholding Agents
RMC No. 143-2019 clarifies the inclusion of taxpayers as Top Withholding Agents, or TWAs, who are obliged to withhold and remit the 1% creditable withholding tax on purchases of goods and the 2% creditable withholding tax on purchases of services. The clarification is important because being classified as a TWA creates recurring withholding obligations on ordinary supplier payments. For businesses, this directly affects procurement, accounts payable processing, supplier documentation, tax remittances, and BIR audit exposure.
The circular traces the development of the TWA rules. The 1% creditable withholding tax on purchases of goods was originally imposed under Revenue Regulations No. 12-94 on taxpayers belonging to the top 5,000 corporations, as determined by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. This group was later expanded to the top 10,000 private corporations under Revenue Regulations No. 17-2003, where minimum threshold amounts under different selective criteria were prescribed. Under the same rules, the 2% CWT on purchases of services was imposed in addition to the 1% CWT on purchases of goods. The coverage was later expanded to the top 20,000 private corporations under Revenue Regulations No. 14-2008, and to the top 5,000 individual taxpayers under Revenue Regulations No. 6-2009.
RMC No. 143-2019 emphasizes the underlying policy: the obligation to withhold these CWTs is intended for taxpayers whose business operations have a significant level of economic impact and whose transactions can help the BIR detect and collect potential revenues through their stakeholders and business partners. Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019 was issued to simplify the criteria for selecting Top Withholding Agents introduced by Revenue Regulations No. 11-2018.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 143-2019
The ruling affects corporations, individual taxpayers, businesses, procurement departments, accounting departments, and tax compliance officers that may have been included in a published list of Top Withholding Agents. It is especially relevant to taxpayers whose inclusion may have resulted from isolated or unusual transactions rather than regular business volume, and to taxpayers that are not supposed to be treated as TWAs even if they appear to meet a numerical threshold.
The clarification is also important for suppliers dealing with large customers. If a customer is a valid Top Withholding Agent, supplier invoices and collections may be subject to the 1% or 2% creditable withholding tax system. If the customer is not validly covered, the supplier should not assume that withholding is automatically required merely because of a publication error or a failure to delete a taxpayer from an existing list.
Taxpayers Excluded from the Top Withholding Agent List
RMC No. 143-2019 confirms that, in implementing Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019, Operations Memorandum Order No. 20-2019 directed revenue officials to exclude certain taxpayers from the identification of TWAs, even if they satisfied the prescribed criteria under the regulation.
The excluded taxpayers include national government agencies, government-owned or controlled corporations, state universities and colleges, and local government units. The circular also identifies taxpayers that were included because of one-time transactions, such as estate tax and donor’s tax transactions, as excluded from TWA identification.
The circular further addresses individual taxpayers deriving income on a commission basis, such as insurance agents and real estate brokers. These taxpayers are subject to verification of their duly filed 2018 Quarterly Income Tax Returns, specifically BIR Form No. 1701Q, to determine the regularity of their transactions. The BIR expressly clarified that if the P12 million criterion was satisfied only in one taxable quarter, the taxpayer shall not be qualified as a Top Withholding Agent.
Taxpayers that are tax-exempt from payment of income taxes and have no proprietary activities are also excluded. The circular gives examples such as foundations, non-stock non-profit institutions, tax-exempt educational institutions, religious institutions, and charitable institutions.
Key Compliance Rule: Publication Alone Is Not Enough
The most important compliance rule in RMC No. 143-2019 is that taxpayers cannot be compelled to withhold the 1% and 2% CWTs if they do not satisfy the criteria of Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019 or if they fall within the excluded categories under Operations Memorandum Order No. 20-2019.
This rule applies even where the taxpayer was included in a newspaper publication of Top Withholding Agents or was not deleted from an existing list. In practical terms, a taxpayer’s appearance in a published TWA list is not conclusive if the taxpayer does not actually qualify under the applicable criteria or is among those that the BIR itself directed to be excluded.
For corporate accountants and tax managers searching for RMC 143-2019 Top Withholding Agents, 1% CWT purchases of goods, 2% CWT purchases of services, RR 7-2019 withholding tax criteria, or BIR TWA list inclusion, the operative takeaway is straightforward: confirm whether the taxpayer is validly covered before applying the withholding obligation to supplier payments.
Deadlines and Effective Compliance Points
RMC No. 143-2019 was issued on December 16, 2019. It does not create a new filing deadline, tax rate, or separate due date. Instead, it clarifies who may be compelled to perform the existing withholding and remittance obligation for the 1% and 2% CWTs.
For taxpayers potentially included in the TWA list, the immediate compliance point is documentary verification. Businesses should review whether they satisfy the criteria under Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019 and whether they fall under any exclusion in Operations Memorandum Order No. 20-2019. Individual taxpayers earning commissions should specifically review whether the P12 million criterion was satisfied only in one taxable quarter based on their duly filed 2018 Quarterly Income Tax Returns, BIR Form No. 1701Q. If the threshold was met only once in one taxable quarter, the circular states that the taxpayer shall not be qualified as a TWA.
Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance
RMC No. 143-2019 does not state a new penalty specific to this clarification. However, businesses validly classified as Top Withholding Agents remain exposed to the ordinary consequences of failing to withhold and remit required creditable withholding taxes under applicable tax rules. Conversely, taxpayers that are not validly TWAs should be careful not to unnecessarily impose withholding on suppliers without confirming their actual status.
The practical risk is two-sided. A valid TWA that fails to withhold may face BIR compliance issues. A taxpayer that is not a valid TWA but withholds solely because of an erroneous or outdated listing may create commercial disputes with suppliers and unnecessary accounting complications. RMC No. 143-2019 is therefore useful both as a compliance guide and as a basis to contest improper inclusion in the TWA list.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
Businesses should first confirm whether they are included in the list of Top Withholding Agents and then determine whether the inclusion is supported by the criteria under Revenue Regulations No. 7-2019. The analysis should not stop at the publication itself. RMC No. 143-2019 makes clear that publication or continued inclusion in an existing list does not automatically create the obligation if the taxpayer does not qualify or should have been excluded.
Second, accounting teams should classify their taxpayer profile. Government entities, GOCCs, state universities and colleges, local government units, taxpayers included because of one-time estate or donor’s tax transactions, commission-based individual taxpayers whose P12 million threshold was met only in one quarter, and tax-exempt entities without proprietary activities should assess whether they fall within the exclusions described in the circular.
Third, procurement and accounts payable systems should be aligned with the taxpayer’s verified TWA status. If the business is a valid TWA, payment processing should capture whether the transaction involves goods subject to 1% CWT or services subject to 2% CWT. If the business is not validly a TWA, the company should document the basis for not applying the TWA withholding obligation.
Fourth, businesses should keep records supporting their position. For individual commission earners, the 2018 Quarterly Income Tax Returns, BIR Form No. 1701Q, are specifically relevant because the circular refers to verification of duly filed quarterly returns and the regularity of transactions. For tax-exempt entities, records showing the nature of tax exemption and absence of proprietary activities may be important in supporting exclusion.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 143-2019 is a reminder that BIR withholding tax compliance is not simply a mechanical exercise. A taxpayer’s inclusion in a list may need to be tested against the underlying regulation, the taxpayer’s actual transactions, and the BIR’s own exclusions. For companies and high-volume taxpayers, the difference between being a valid Top Withholding Agent and being improperly included can affect thousands of supplier payments and recurring monthly tax compliance procedures.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and tax teams in reviewing Top Withholding Agent classification, withholding tax obligations, BIR correspondence, supplier tax treatment, and compliance documentation. For legal guidance on RMC No. 143-2019, RR No. 7-2019, 1% and 2% creditable withholding tax obligations, and BIR tax compliance in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.