RMC No. 93-2019 clarifies when two eCARs are required for estate settlement followed by sale or donation of real property.
Taxpayers transferring inherited real property through an extra-judicial settlement followed by a sale or donation must now plan for two Electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration, or eCARs, and must present or sequence them correctly with the Registry of Deeds. RMC No. 93-2019 changes the answer to Question No. 2 of RMC No. 85-2018 and clarifies how the BIR will issue eCARs when the taxpayer submits two separate documents, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement and a Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation. The practical effect is immediate for heirs, buyers, donees, real estate sellers, accountants, and corporate tax teams handling transfers of inherited property: the number and timing of eCARs will depend on whether the entire titled property or only a portion of it is being sold or donated.
What Changed Under RMC No. 93-2019
RMC No. 93-2019 amends the BIR guidance on how many eCARs must be issued when the taxpayer submits two separate documents involving the same real property transfer chain. The common situation is where heirs first settle the estate through an Extra-Judicial Settlement and then transfer the property through a Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation.
The amended rule is clear: two eCARs must be issued. One eCAR covers the settlement of the estate. The second eCAR covers the subsequent transfer through sale or donation. However, the timing of issuance differs depending on whether the sale or donation covers the total area appearing in the title, or only a portion of that area.
This clarification matters because the eCAR is required before the Registry of Deeds can complete the registration of the transfer. A wrong sequence, or the presentation of only one eCAR when two linked transactions are involved, can disrupt registration and may cause the Registry of Deeds to issue a Notice of Invalid eCAR.
Rule When the Sale or Donation Covers the Total Area
If the subject of the sale or donation is the total area appearing in the Original Certificate of Title, Transfer Certificate of Title, or Condominium Certificate of Title, two eCARs must be issued simultaneously. Both eCARs will bear the same title number.
The first eCAR is for the settlement of the estate. The second eCAR is for the transfer through sale or donation. The taxpayer must present both eCARs to the Registry of Deeds at the same time. This is not merely an administrative preference. RMC No. 93-2019 states that presentation of only one eCAR to the Registry of Deeds will invalidate the second eCAR transaction in the system, resulting in the issuance of a Notice of Invalid eCAR by the Registry of Deeds.
For taxpayers and accountants, the key search phrase is โtwo eCARs same title number estate sale donation.โ If the entire property covered by the title is being sold or donated after estate settlement, the compliance strategy is simultaneous issuance and simultaneous presentation.
Rule When the Sale or Donation Covers Only a Portion of the Total Area
If the subject of the sale or donation is only a portion of the total area appearing in the title, two eCARs are still required, but they are not issued in the same way. The eCAR for the estate settlement must be issued and presented first to the Registry of Deeds for the issuance of a new title.
Only after the estate settlement eCAR has been presented and a new title has been issued can the BIR issue the second eCAR for the sale or donation. The new title number generated from the first transaction becomes the basis for the issuance of the second eCAR covering the second transaction.
This is especially important for partitioned inheritances, partial sales of inherited land, subdivision of titled property, donations of only a portion of an estate property, and estate-to-sale transactions involving less than the full titled area. In these cases, the BIR requires the title flow to be reflected first before issuing the second eCAR.
Who Is Affected
RMC No. 93-2019 affects heirs settling estates, buyers of inherited real property, donees receiving property from heirs, real estate developers acquiring estate properties, corporate purchasers of real property, banks and lenders reviewing title transfers, accountants computing transfer taxes, and lawyers handling conveyances and estate settlements.
It is also highly relevant to CFOs and tax managers of companies acquiring property from estates. A corporate buyer may believe that payment of the purchase price and signing of the deed are the key commercial steps, but registration may still be delayed if the BIR eCAR sequence is not properly planned. Where the transfer involves an estate settlement and a sale or donation, the transaction documentation must align with the two-eCAR requirement.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
The core compliance requirement is the issuance of two eCARs when two separate documents are submitted, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement and a Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation. The timing rule depends on the scope of the property being transferred.
For total-area transfers, the taxpayer must secure two eCARs simultaneously and present both eCARs to the Registry of Deeds at the same time. For partial-area transfers, the taxpayer must first use the estate settlement eCAR to obtain a new title, then use that new title number as the basis for the second eCAR for the sale or donation.
RMC No. 93-2019 does not prescribe a new numerical filing deadline in the amended answer. However, it expressly states that the taxpayer may opt to pay the applicable taxes for both transactions at the same time to avoid incurring penalties and interest. This is a practical warning: even if the second eCAR for a partial-area transfer can be issued only after the new title number is available, taxpayers should consider whether the taxes for both transactions should be paid earlier to prevent penalty and interest exposure.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
The circular identifies a specific registration risk for total-area transfers. If only one eCAR is presented to the Registry of Deeds, the second eCAR transaction may be invalidated in the system, resulting in a Notice of Invalid eCAR by the Registry of Deeds. This can delay registration, disrupt closing, create issues between buyer and seller, and affect the release of funds where payment is tied to title transfer.
RMC No. 93-2019 also refers to the risk of penalties and interest if applicable taxes are not paid on time. It does not state new penalty rates or create a new penalty formula in the amended answer. The practical compliance point is that taxpayers should not treat the sequential issuance of the second eCAR in partial-area transfers as permission to delay tax planning or tax payment without consequence.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers, Accountants, and Corporate Buyers
First, identify whether the transaction involves one document or two separate documents. If there is an Extra-Judicial Settlement followed by a Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation, assume the RMC No. 93-2019 two-eCAR rule applies.
Second, determine whether the sale or donation covers the entire titled area or only a portion. If the entire area is transferred, coordinate with the BIR so that two eCARs are issued simultaneously and make sure both are presented to the Registry of Deeds at the same time. If only a portion is transferred, prepare for a two-step process: estate settlement first, new title issuance second, then sale or donation eCAR based on the new title number.
Third, compute the taxes for both transactions early. RMC No. 93-2019 expressly allows the taxpayer to opt to pay applicable taxes for both transactions at the same time to avoid penalties and interest. Accountants should model the tax exposure and payment timing before closing, especially in transactions where the buyer expects a clean and prompt title transfer.
Fourth, reflect the eCAR sequencing in the closing checklist, deed conditions, escrow terms, and documentary requirements. A buyer or donee should not assume that one eCAR is enough simply because the parties are dealing with the same property. The BIR rule treats the estate settlement and the sale or donation as separate transactions requiring separate eCAR treatment.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 93-2019 is a short issuance, but it has major practical consequences for estate settlements, real property sales, donations, and corporate acquisitions involving inherited property. A failure to secure and present the correct eCARs can delay registration and expose taxpayers to penalties, interest, and closing disputes.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients with BIR compliance, estate settlement documentation, real property transfers, tax payment sequencing, Registry of Deeds coordination, and transaction closing structures. For legal and tax guidance on eCAR requirements, estate-to-sale transfers, deeds of donation, and BIR registration compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.