RMC No. 59-2019 publishes CDA-BIR Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 on TRAIN Law cooperative tax rules and compliance guidance.
Cooperatives, their accountants, and tax compliance teams must align their BIR and CDA compliance positions with Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019, the CDA-BIR rules published through RMC No. 59-2019. The issuance matters because it formally circulates the rules and regulations implementing Section 3 of Republic Act No. 10963, otherwise known as the Tax Reform for Acceleration and Inclusion Law, in relation to Section 5(b) of Republic Act No. 8424, or the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.
What RMC No. 59-2019 Changed
RMC No. 59-2019 published, for the information and guidance of all concerned, the full text of Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 between the Cooperative Development Authority and the Bureau of Internal Revenue. The subject of the joint order is the implementation of Section 3 of Republic Act No. 10963, the TRAIN Law, in relation to Section 5(b) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.
The practical change is that taxpayers and tax officers are directed to use the CDA-BIR Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 as the governing administrative guide for the covered TRAIN Law implementation matter involving cooperatives and the BIR’s authority under Section 5(b) of the Tax Code. For businesses dealing with cooperatives, cooperative federations, suppliers, customers, or member-related transactions, the key point is that the BIR has not merely referred to a CDA rule informally; it has circulated the joint CDA-BIR rules through an official Revenue Memorandum Circular.
For search and compliance purposes, the relevant terms are RMC No. 59-2019, Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019, CDA BIR rules, TRAIN Law cooperatives, Section 3 RA 10963, and Section 5(b) NIRC. These are the phrases accountants, cooperative officers, CFOs, and tax practitioners should use when tracing the applicable administrative authority.
Who Is Most Affected
The most directly affected taxpayers are cooperatives registered or dealing with the Cooperative Development Authority, including cooperative officers responsible for tax compliance, accounting teams preparing BIR filings, and external accountants advising cooperatives on their obligations under the TRAIN Law and the National Internal Revenue Code.
Businesses that transact with cooperatives are also affected in a practical sense. Suppliers, customers, withholding agents, and corporate finance teams should verify whether their treatment of cooperative-related transactions is consistent with the CDA-BIR rules published under RMC No. 59-2019. Where a business relies on a cooperative’s tax status, registration, documentation, or representations, the business should ensure that its files support the position taken in its BIR returns and accounting records.
Revenue officials and BIR employees are expressly covered by the circular’s directive. The circular is addressed to all revenue officials, employees, and others concerned. This means that the issuance is intended not only for taxpayers, but also for BIR personnel who will administer, review, audit, or apply the rules covered by the CDA-BIR Joint Administrative Order.
Key Dates and Compliance Reference Points
RMC No. 59-2019 is dated May 27, 2019. It refers to Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 dated May 20, 2019. These two dates are important for tax teams reviewing historical compliance, defending tax positions in audit, or determining which administrative rule was in circulation at the relevant time.
The circular does not state a separate payment deadline, filing deadline, tax rate, penalty amount, or threshold. Its function is publication and guidance. Because no separate deadline is stated in RMC No. 59-2019 itself, taxpayers should avoid assuming that it created a new filing period or grace period. Instead, the correct approach is to treat the circular as the BIR publication of the CDA-BIR implementing rules and then review the substantive requirements under Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 and the underlying statutes.
For accountants and CFOs, the immediate compliance question is not whether a new tax rate was created by the circular, but whether the company’s cooperative-related documentation and tax treatment are consistent with the CDA-BIR rules that the BIR officially circulated.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 59-2019 does not specify a new penalty table, surcharge, interest rate, or compromise penalty. It also does not independently impose a specific fine for failure to comply with the circular. However, non-compliance with the substantive rules implemented under the TRAIN Law and the National Internal Revenue Code may still create ordinary tax audit exposure under existing law.
The principal risk for cooperatives and businesses dealing with cooperatives is a mismatch between claimed tax treatment and the administrative rules recognized by the BIR and CDA. If a cooperative claims a tax position without proper support, or if a business dealing with a cooperative relies on unsupported documentation, the transaction may become vulnerable during BIR examination. The risk may include disallowance of tax treatment, assessment exposure, documentary deficiencies, and disputes over whether the taxpayer followed the applicable rules.
Taxpayers should therefore treat RMC No. 59-2019 as a compliance signpost. It tells taxpayers where the BIR expects them to look: Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019, issued jointly by the CDA and BIR, implementing Section 3 of RA No. 10963 in relation to Section 5(b) of the NIRC.
Practical Steps for Cooperatives, CFOs, and Accountants
First, cooperatives should confirm that their tax compliance files include the applicable CDA and BIR documents supporting their current tax position. Registration papers, certifications, board approvals, financial records, and BIR filings should be organized in a way that allows the cooperative to explain its treatment of transactions if reviewed.
Second, businesses transacting with cooperatives should review whether their accounting and withholding practices are based on current and properly documented cooperative status. It is not enough to rely on assumptions or past practice. Where the tax treatment of a transaction depends on cooperative status or a specific statutory rule, the business should retain documentary support.
Third, tax teams should cite the correct authority in internal memoranda, audit responses, and board-level tax risk discussions. The correct reference is RMC No. 59-2019, dated May 27, 2019, which published CDA-BIR Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019 dated May 20, 2019. The joint order concerns the rules and regulations implementing Section 3 of RA No. 10963, the TRAIN Law, in relation to Section 5(b) of RA No. 8424, the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended.
Fourth, companies should avoid overstating what the circular says. RMC No. 59-2019 does not itself provide a new tax rate, a new threshold, or a new filing deadline. Its legal significance is that it formally makes the joint CDA-BIR implementing rules available for guidance and directs all concerned to be guided accordingly.
Why This Matters in BIR Audits and Cooperative Tax Planning
For tax planning, RMC No. 59-2019 is important because cooperative tax issues often sit at the intersection of CDA regulation and BIR enforcement. A cooperative may satisfy corporate or sectoral requirements but still need to show that its tax reporting is consistent with BIR-recognized rules. Conversely, a business dealing with cooperatives must be able to show why it treated payments, receipts, or documents in a particular way for tax purposes.
For BIR audits, the circular gives taxpayers a clear official reference point. When preparing audit submissions, accountants may cite RMC No. 59-2019 to show that the relevant implementing rules are the CDA-BIR Joint Administrative Order No. 1-2019. This can help organize legal arguments and prevent confusion over whether the issue is governed only by CDA rules, only by BIR issuances, or by a joint administrative framework.
ASG Law Can Help with Cooperative and BIR Compliance
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises cooperatives, corporations, SMEs, and in-house legal and finance teams on BIR compliance, tax documentation, audit defense, and regulatory coordination with government agencies. For businesses affected by RMC No. 59-2019, the key task is to confirm that cooperative-related tax positions are properly documented, legally grounded, and defensible before the BIR.
If your cooperative, corporation, or accounting team needs assistance reviewing CDA-BIR compliance, preparing audit responses, or aligning tax practices with TRAIN Law and National Internal Revenue Code requirements, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.