RMC No. 33-2019 consolidated January 2019 sugar millsite prices for applying the 1% expanded withholding tax on covered sugar transactions.
Sugar traders, millers, planters, buyers, and withholding agents dealing with raw sugar transactions for January 2019 must use the consolidated current-year millsite prices circularized under RMC No. 33-2019 when applying the one percent (1%) expanded withholding tax on sugar. The practical effect is straightforward: for covered sugar transactions during the January 2019 period, the relevant BIR reference is the consolidated weekly millsite price schedule based on Sugar Regulatory Administration issuances, rather than separate weekly operations memoranda being reviewed in isolation.
What RMC No. 33-2019 changed
RMC No. 33-2019 consolidated the weekly issuances on the price of sugar at millsite for the month of January 2019. The circular specifically consolidated Operations Memoranda Nos. 2019-01-10, 2019-01-11, 2019-02-02, and 2019-02-04. These operations memoranda covered the weekly price of sugar at millsite issued by the Sugar Regulatory Administration for January 2019.
The importance of the consolidation is not merely administrative. The price of sugar at millsite is relevant for purposes of imposing the one percent (1%) expanded withholding tax on sugar. RMC No. 33-2019 expressly links the consolidated current-year schedule to the expanded withholding tax on sugar prescribed under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 11-2014.
For accountants and tax teams, the searchable compliance issue is therefore not simply “sugar prices.” The real tax issue is the BIR consolidated price of sugar at millsite for January 2019, the 1% expanded withholding tax on sugar, and the correct reference for withholding tax computation on sugar transactions covered by the January 2019 weekly SRA millsite price issuances.
Who is affected by the consolidated January 2019 sugar millsite prices
The most directly affected taxpayers are businesses and persons involved in sugar transactions where the millsite price is used as a tax reference for expanded withholding tax purposes. This includes sugar millers, sugar traders, buyers of sugar, planters or sellers whose transactions are subject to withholding, and any withholding agent required to determine and remit the proper expanded withholding tax on sugar.
Corporate accountants, tax managers, and finance officers of agribusiness companies should pay particular attention to the circular because it identifies the relevant January 2019 weekly price references in consolidated form. Instead of treating the weekly operations memoranda as separate compliance materials, tax personnel can identify RMC No. 33-2019 as the circularized consolidated reference for January 2019 current-year prices.
Businesses that process historical tax records, respond to BIR examinations, reconcile withholding tax returns, or validate past sugar transactions may also be affected. Even if the month covered is January 2019, the circular may still matter in later audits, tax due diligence, deficiency withholding tax assessments, and accounting reconciliations involving sugar purchases or sales during that period.
Key compliance requirement: apply the 1% expanded withholding tax using the consolidated current-year schedule
The key compliance point in RMC No. 33-2019 is the use of the consolidated schedule for the current-year weekly price of sugar at millsite for January 2019. The circular clarifies that although the SRA-issued weekly price of sugar at millsite reflects comparative prices between previous and current years, the consolidated schedule contains only the current-year prices for purposes of imposing the one percent (1%) expanded withholding tax on sugar.
This distinction matters. Taxpayers should not use comparative prior-year figures as the basis for the January 2019 withholding computation if the BIR circularized schedule is intended to show the current-year price for the withholding tax purpose. The operative tax rate identified in the circular is one percent (1%), and the legal basis cited is Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 11-2014.
For internal controls, finance teams should ensure that January 2019 sugar transaction records match the applicable weekly millsite price references consolidated under RMC No. 33-2019. The covered operations memoranda are OM Nos. 2019-01-10, 2019-01-11, 2019-02-02, and 2019-02-04. These references should be retained in the tax working papers supporting any expanded withholding tax computation on January 2019 sugar transactions.
Effective date and relevant dates
RMC No. 33-2019 is dated February 27, 2019. It covers the consolidated price of sugar at millsite for the month of January 2019. The document was released in the context of circularizing weekly SRA-issued millsite prices pursuant to Revenue Regulations No. 13-2015.
For businesses reviewing tax compliance, the relevant transaction period is January 2019. The relevant tax action is the imposition and computation of the one percent (1%) expanded withholding tax on sugar based on the current-year consolidated millsite price schedule. The relevant BIR reference for search and documentation purposes is RMC No. 33-2019.
Penalties and risk areas for non-compliance
RMC No. 33-2019 does not set out a separate penalty provision. However, non-compliance risk arises under the general withholding tax framework. If a withholding agent fails to withhold, under-withholds, remits late, or uses an incorrect base for computation, the taxpayer may face the usual BIR consequences applicable to withholding tax deficiencies, including deficiency tax exposure, surcharge, interest, and compromise penalties where applicable under the Tax Code and implementing rules.
The practical risk is particularly significant for companies whose books show sugar purchases or sales for January 2019 but whose withholding tax computation does not align with the BIR-circularized current-year millsite price reference. In a BIR audit, the examiner may compare the taxpayer’s withholding tax base against the circularized sugar millsite price references and assess a deficiency if the taxpayer used a lower or unsupported amount.
Practical steps for businesses and tax teams
First, identify all sugar transactions booked for January 2019 that may be subject to expanded withholding tax. The review should cover purchase orders, invoices, millsite records, accounting entries, withholding tax returns, certificates of tax withheld, and payment vouchers.
Second, confirm whether the withholding tax computation used the relevant current-year consolidated millsite price references covered by RMC No. 33-2019. The key search phrases for tax teams are “RMC No. 33-2019 sugar millsite price,” “January 2019 consolidated price of sugar at millsite,” “1% expanded withholding tax on sugar,” “SRA price of sugar at millsite January 2019,” and “RR No. 2-98 as amended by RR No. 11-2014 sugar withholding tax.”
Third, preserve the computation trail. A defensible tax file should show the transaction, the applicable withholding tax rate of one percent (1%), the relevant millsite price reference, the withholding tax return filed, and the remittance details. For companies with high-volume sugar transactions, the finance team should prepare a reconciliation by week or transaction batch, especially where the covered period overlaps with weekly SRA price issuances.
Fourth, review potential historical exposure. Although RMC No. 33-2019 concerns January 2019, unresolved tax audits, open taxable years, internal compliance reviews, and due diligence exercises may still require confirmation that the correct BIR reference was used. Where documents are incomplete, management should reconstruct the basis of the computation using available official records and accounting support.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco can help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR issuances, validating withholding tax positions, preparing audit-ready tax documentation, and responding to BIR assessments. For companies in agribusiness, sugar trading, manufacturing, and other regulated industries, proper documentation of withholding tax computations can be the difference between a manageable audit and a costly deficiency assessment.
If your company needs assistance reviewing sugar withholding tax compliance, reconciling historical BIR filings, or preparing for a tax audit involving RMC No. 33-2019 and related revenue regulations, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.