RMC No. 24-2019 clarifies BIR Form 2316 electronic submission, USB use, and signed certified lists for employees qualified for substituted filing.
Employers preparing year-end compensation tax compliance must not assume that RR No. 11-2018 restored a physical, hard-copy filing requirement for BIR Form No. 2316. RMC No. 24-2019 clarifies that large taxpayers and non-large taxpayers that submit scanned BIR Form No. 2316 copies through the DVD method under RR No. 2-2015 may continue using that electronic storage submission route, and may even use USB memory sticks or similar storage devices when DVDs are unavailable, provided the scanned forms are in uneditable format.
What RMC No. 24-2019 Clarifies
RMC No. 24-2019 addresses confusion caused by the amendments introduced by RR No. 11-2018 to RR No. 2-98 on the Certificate of Compensation Payment and Tax Withheld, or BIR Form No. 2316, and on the Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing of Income Tax Return. RR No. 11-2018 was issued to implement the relevant provisions of Republic Act No. 10963, more commonly known as the TRAIN Law. The circular makes clear that only provisions inconsistent with the TRAIN Law were amended, while unaffected provisions of existing revenue regulations remain in force.
The practical point is important for payroll, accounting, and HR teams. Section 12 of RR No. 11-2018 amended Section 2.83.1 of RR No. 2-98 by prescribing the manner of distribution of the three accomplished copies of BIR Form No. 2316. However, it did not amend RR No. 2-2015, which governs the manner of submitting the duplicate original copy of BIR Form No. 2316 to the BIR Office. In other words, the distribution rule and the BIR submission rule are separate compliance matters.
No Return to Mandatory Hard-Copy BIR Form 2316 Filing for Covered Taxpayers
The most searched issue under RMC No. 24-2019 is whether employers must again submit physical or hard duplicate original copies of BIR Form No. 2316 to the BIR. The answer, for the taxpayers covered by the clarification, is no. RMC No. 24-2019 states that RR No. 11-2018 did not re-introduce the submission of BIR Form No. 2316 in physical or hard duplicate original copies by employers to the BIR Office, insofar as the concerned taxpayers are registered under the Large Taxpayers Service or are non-large taxpayers that opted to submit through the Digital Versatile Disk method prescribed under RR No. 2-2015.
This clarification matters because many employers prepare hundreds or thousands of BIR Form No. 2316 certificates during annualization. For large employers, a mistaken return to hard-copy submission would create unnecessary printing, signing, storage, and filing burdens. For non-large taxpayers that opted for the DVD submission route, the circular confirms that the prior electronic storage process remains available.
USB Memory Stick Submission May Be Used When DVDs Are Unavailable
RMC No. 24-2019 also recognizes a practical business reality: DVDs may not always be available. The circular allows the use of a Universal Storage Bus or USB memory stick, or other similar storage devices, in the absence or unavailability of DVDs. The condition is specific and important: the scanned copies of BIR Form No. 2316 must be made in uneditable format.
For employers searching for BIR Form 2316 DVD submission, BIR Form 2316 USB submission, uneditable scanned BIR Form 2316, or RR No. 2-2015 Form 2316 filing, this means the compliance focus should be on preserving the integrity of the scanned copies. Accounting teams should avoid submitting editable working files, spreadsheets, or modifiable document versions when the circular requires scanned copies in uneditable format.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 24-2019
RMC No. 24-2019 primarily affects employers and withholding agents that issue BIR Form No. 2316 to employees and submit the duplicate original copy to the BIR. This includes taxpayers duly registered under the Large Taxpayers Service. It also includes other non-large taxpayer employers that opted to submit through the DVD method prescribed under RR No. 2-2015.
The circular is also relevant to HR departments, payroll service providers, outsourced accounting teams, corporate accountants, CFOs, and in-house counsel responsible for year-end withholding tax compliance. Any employer with employees qualified for substituted filing must pay particular attention to the separate requirement involving the Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing of Income Tax Return.
Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing
RMC No. 24-2019 also clarifies the use of Annex F of RR No. 11-2018, which prescribed the format for the Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing of ITR. The circular observes that the table in Annex F is only applicable for employers with eighteen or fewer employees. This is a key detail for larger employers because many will naturally need additional pages or a separate attachment to list all qualified employees.
When additional pages are attached to the certification, or when a separate list is prepared as an attachment, the employer must clearly indicate in the certification a reference statement to the additional pages or attachment. The signature of the certifying employer or its duly authorized representative must also be indicated at the bottom of all pages attached to the certification.
This requirement is easy to overlook. A company may have a properly prepared employee list but still create avoidable compliance exposure if the attached pages are not clearly referenced in the certification or if the certifying employer or authorized representative fails to sign each attached page at the bottom. For employers with more than eighteen employees, the certification should be reviewed as a complete set, not merely as a cover page plus a spreadsheet.
Unnotarized Certified Lists May Be Accepted If All Pages Are Signed
In line with the administrative policy of ease of doing business, RMC No. 24-2019 states that the BIR may allow the submission of an un-notarized certified list, provided that all pages attached to the certification are duly signed by the certifying employer or its duly authorized representative. This is a practical compliance relief for employers that need to prepare and submit the substituted filing list efficiently.
The circular does not remove the need for certification. It simply allows an un-notarized certified list under the stated condition. The operational takeaway is that signature control becomes critical. Before submission, companies should verify that the authorized signatory has signed the certification and all attached pages, especially where the list exceeds the eighteen-employee format shown in Annex F of RR No. 11-2018.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 24-2019 is dated February 4, 2019. It does not create a new filing deadline in the text of the clarification. Instead, it explains how existing BIR Form No. 2316 and substituted filing list requirements should be complied with after RR No. 11-2018 and in relation to RR No. 2-2015.
For BIR Form No. 2316 submission, covered employers should determine whether they are registered under the Large Taxpayers Service or whether they are non-large taxpayers that opted for submission through the DVD method under RR No. 2-2015. If using DVD, USB, or similar storage device because DVD is unavailable, the employer must ensure that scanned copies are in uneditable format.
For the Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing of ITR, employers should check whether they have eighteen or fewer employees or whether additional pages or attachments are needed. If attachments are used, the certification must clearly refer to them, and the certifying employer or authorized representative must sign the bottom of all attached pages. If the list is un-notarized, all pages attached to the certification must still be duly signed.
Penalties and Compliance Risk
RMC No. 24-2019 does not prescribe a new penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or compromise amount. Its significance lies in clarifying the correct manner of compliance. Employers should not treat the absence of a new penalty provision as permission to relax controls over BIR Form No. 2316 and substituted filing list preparation. These documents are central to compensation withholding tax compliance and employee income tax reporting.
The practical risk is a defective submission: editable files instead of uneditable scanned copies, missing signatures on attached pages, a certified list that fails to reference additional pages, or an incorrect assumption that the BIR requires hard-copy duplicate originals despite the availability of the RR No. 2-2015 electronic storage submission process for covered taxpayers. These errors can lead to avoidable BIR queries, re-submission requests, and year-end compliance delays.
Practical Steps for Employers, CFOs, and Accountants
Employers should first map their BIR Form No. 2316 submission process against the clarification in RMC No. 24-2019. Large taxpayers and non-large taxpayers that opted for the DVD method should confirm that their scanned forms are saved in an uneditable format. If DVDs are unavailable, the company may use USB memory sticks or similar storage devices, but should document internally why that storage device was used and ensure the files remain uneditable.
Second, the payroll or accounting team should review the Certified List of Employees Qualified for Substituted Filing. If the employer has more than eighteen qualified employees, the certification should expressly refer to the additional pages or attached list. The authorized signatory should sign the bottom of every attached page, not only the first or last page.
Third, corporate accountants should coordinate with HR before submission. BIR Form No. 2316 data, employee qualification for substituted filing, and the certified list must be consistent. Any discrepancy between payroll records, tax withheld, and the list of employees qualified for substituted filing can create issues during BIR review or employee tax documentation requests.
Finally, in-house counsel and CFOs should update internal year-end tax compliance checklists to reflect the clarifications under RMC No. 24-2019, RR No. 11-2018, and RR No. 2-2015. Search terms such as RMC No. 24-2019 BIR Form 2316, substituted filing certified list, Annex F RR No. 11-2018, BIR Form 2316 DVD submission, and unnotarized certified list BIR should point to one operational conclusion: comply through the correct submission mode, preserve uneditable scanned files, and sign all required pages.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists Philippine businesses, employers, withholding agents, and finance teams in reviewing BIR compliance procedures, year-end compensation tax documentation, BIR Form No. 2316 processes, substituted filing certifications, and related tax risk controls. For companies with large employee populations, multiple payroll locations, outsourced accounting arrangements, or pending BIR compliance concerns, the safest approach is to align the process before submission rather than correct defects later.
For assistance with BIR Form No. 2316 compliance, substituted filing documentation, payroll tax procedures, or broader Philippine tax advisory work, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.