RMC No. 85-2018 requires two eCARs for estate settlement plus sale, donation, or waiver of real property rights, with proper Registry of Deeds sequencing.
Real property transfers involving an estate settlement plus a sale, donation, or waiver of rights require careful eCAR handling because one title may involve two separate taxable transactions. RMC No. 85-2018 clarifies that where a taxpayer submits documents showing both settlement of an estate and a subsequent transfer of the same property, the Bureau of Internal Revenue must issue two Electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration, and the taxpayer must follow the proper presentation sequence with the Registry of Deeds to avoid an invalid eCAR notice.
What RMC No. 85-2018 Changed for Real Property Transfers
RMC No. 85-2018 addresses a practical problem encountered by taxpayers who have multiple transactions involving only one title in transferring real properties with the Land Registration Authority. The clarification is especially important in transactions where inherited property is first settled among heirs and then transferred through sale, donation, or waiver of rights.
The central rule is straightforward: when the documentation shows two transactions, the BIR must issue two eCARs. One eCAR relates to the settlement of the estate. The other eCAR relates to the transfer through sale or donation. The fact that only one certificate of title is involved does not mean that only one eCAR is required.
This matters because the eCAR is the tax clearance document used in registering the transfer of real property with the Registry of Deeds. If a taxpayer, broker, accountant, family representative, or lawyer treats the transaction as requiring only one eCAR, the land registration process may be disrupted and the second transaction may be invalidated in the system.
Extra-Judicial Settlement with Sale or Waiver of Rights
RMC No. 85-2018 specifically answers the question of how many eCARs must be issued when the taxpayer submits an Extra-Judicial Settlement with Sale or an Extra-Judicial Settlement with Waiver of Rights. The BIR clarification is that there are two transactions involved: first, the settlement of the estate; and second, the transfer through sale or donation. Because there are two transactions, two eCARs will be issued.
The ruling is important for families settling estates where heirs simultaneously agree to sell the inherited property or waive rights in favor of another person. Even if the estate settlement and transfer are embodied in one instrument, the BIR treats the arrangement as involving two separate registration consequences. Taxpayers should therefore prepare for two eCAR issuances rather than assuming that a single eCAR will cover the entire transfer chain.
The Revenue Officer assigned to the One-Time Transaction, or ONETT, Team must advise the taxpayer to present the two eCARs simultaneously to the Registry of Deeds. This simultaneous presentation is not a mere administrative preference. RMC No. 85-2018 states that presenting only one eCAR to the Registry of Deeds will invalidate the second eCAR transaction in the system, resulting in the issuance of a Notice of Invalid eCAR by the Registry of Deeds.
Separate Documents: Extra-Judicial Settlement and Deed of Sale or Donation
RMC No. 85-2018 also covers a second situation: where the taxpayer submits two separate documents, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement and a Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation. In this case, the BIR again confirms that two eCARs must be issued.
However, the processing sequence is different. The ONETT Revenue Officer must first issue an eCAR for the estate settlement. That estate settlement eCAR must then be presented by the taxpayer to the Registry of Deeds for the issuance of a new title.
After the new title is issued for the first transaction, the new title number becomes the basis for the issuance of the eCAR for the second transaction, whether the second transaction is a sale or a donation. This means that where the parties use separate documents, the second eCAR cannot properly proceed without the title number resulting from the first registration step.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 85-2018
The taxpayers most affected are heirs, estate representatives, buyers of inherited property, donees, sellers of estate property, real estate brokers, accountants handling capital gains tax or donorβs tax filings, and lawyers preparing deeds involving inherited real property. Businesses acquiring real property from estates should also pay close attention, because an improperly handled eCAR process can delay registration and title transfer.
The issuance is also relevant to corporate buyers and developers purchasing land from heirs. In many real estate acquisitions, the title remains in the name of a deceased registered owner, and the heirs execute an Extra-Judicial Settlement together with a Deed of Absolute Sale. RMC No. 85-2018 confirms that this is not a one-step eCAR transaction for BIR and land registration purposes.
Common search terms connected with this issue include RMC 85-2018 eCAR, two eCARs estate settlement sale, Extra-Judicial Settlement with Sale eCAR, Notice of Invalid eCAR Registry of Deeds, and eCAR for inherited real property transfer Philippines.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
The key compliance requirement under RMC No. 85-2018 is procedural but critical. If the transaction is an Extra-Judicial Settlement with Sale or Extra-Judicial Settlement with Waiver of Rights, the taxpayer must expect two eCARs and must present both eCARs simultaneously to the Registry of Deeds.
If the taxpayer uses two separate instruments, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement and a separate Deed of Absolute Sale or Deed of Donation, the estate settlement eCAR must be issued and used first for the issuance of a new title. The new title number issued after the estate settlement then becomes the basis for the second eCAR covering the sale or donation.
RMC No. 85-2018 does not provide a new tax rate, new threshold, or new filing deadline. It does, however, remind taxpayers that applicable taxes for both transactions may be paid at the same time to avoid incurring penalties and interest. This is a practical option for taxpayers who want to reduce delay and avoid additional tax exposure while the documents move through BIR ONETT processing and Registry of Deeds registration.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
The immediate risk identified in RMC No. 85-2018 is the issuance of a Notice of Invalid eCAR by the Registry of Deeds. This may occur where only one eCAR is presented when two eCARs are required, resulting in the invalidation of the second eCAR transaction in the system.
The tax risk is also practical. If taxpayers do not pay the applicable taxes for both transactions within the relevant periods under the governing tax rules, penalties and interest may accrue. RMC No. 85-2018 does not state specific penalty rates or deadlines, so taxpayers should verify the underlying tax obligations applicable to the transaction, including taxes connected with estate settlement, sale, or donation, before submitting documents for eCAR issuance.
For business buyers, the risk is not limited to penalties. A defective or incomplete eCAR process may delay the issuance of a clean title, postpone closing, disrupt financing, affect due diligence timelines, or expose the buyer to disputes among heirs if the estate settlement is not properly completed before the onward transfer.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers, Accountants, and Corporate Buyers
First, identify whether the transaction involves only one transfer or two separate transactions. If the property is still under the name of a deceased owner and the heirs are also selling, donating, or waiving rights, treat the matter as involving at least an estate settlement plus a second transfer.
Second, determine whether the parties are using a combined instrument, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement with Sale, or separate instruments, such as an Extra-Judicial Settlement and a Deed of Absolute Sale. This affects how the eCARs should be presented or sequenced.
Third, coordinate with the ONETT Team and the Registry of Deeds before presentation. For a combined estate settlement with sale or waiver, the two eCARs must be presented simultaneously. For separate documents, the estate settlement eCAR must support the issuance of the new title first, and the resulting new title number must then be used for the second eCAR.
Fourth, consider paying the applicable taxes for both transactions at the same time where appropriate. RMC No. 85-2018 expressly recognizes this option as a way to avoid penalties and interest. This can be particularly useful where the parties want to close a sale promptly or where delays may affect financing, possession, or turnover obligations.
Fifth, document the transaction carefully. The deed, tax declarations, title, estate documents, tax payments, and eCAR processing should be aligned so that the BIR and Registry of Deeds can clearly trace the first transaction and the second transaction.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 85-2018 is short, but its practical impact is significant for real estate transactions involving inherited property. A mistake in eCAR sequencing can delay registration, trigger a Notice of Invalid eCAR, and create avoidable tax exposure for heirs, buyers, donors, donees, and corporate acquirers.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients with BIR ONETT compliance, eCAR processing strategy, estate settlement documentation, deeds of sale or donation, tax risk review, and coordination of real property transfers with the Registry of Deeds. For assistance with eCAR issuance, inherited property transfers, or BIR compliance for real estate transactions, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.