RMC No. 72-2018 expands BIR validation of POS, CRM, CAS, online sales, eSales, and manual receipts, with strict deadlines and penalties.

Businesses using POS machines, cash register machines, computerized accounting systems, sales receipting software, online sales channels, manual receipts, or supplemental commercial documents must be ready for BIR sales validation at the machine, branch, and record level. RMC No. 72-2018 makes sales declaration testing more aggressive by allowing the BIR to inventory registered and unregistered machines, extract Z-readings and electronic journals, compare those records against eSales and tax returns, and use the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule when machines or documents are missing or not produced.

What RMC No. 72-2018 Changed

RMC No. 72-2018, dated June 18, 2018, reiterates and supplements the BIR rules on validation and monitoring of sales generated from Point of Sale machines, Cash Register Machines, Special Purpose Machines, other sales receipting system software, receipting and invoicing under Computerized Accounting Systems, online sales transactions, and manual invoices, receipts, and supplemental commercial documents.

The most important change is operational: post-evaluation of POS, CRM, SPM, other sales receipting software, and CAS invoicing may now be conducted simultaneously with other enforcement activities such as Tax Compliance Verification Drive, surveillance, inventory stocktaking, and audit or investigation. This means a taxpayer may face a machine inventory, Z-reading extraction, e-journal review, and sales reconciliation during the same enforcement visit.

For businesses, the practical effect is that the BIR is no longer limited to looking only at filed returns or official books. It may validate sales from all available sources, including machine readings, e-journals, back-end reports, servers, middleware, consolidators, online sales, unmanned bill, coin or token-operated machines, unregistered machines, defective or damaged machines, manual invoices, expired or unregistered receipts, delivery receipts, order slips, credit memos, debit memos, cancelled receipts, collection receipts, acknowledgement receipts, and other documents affecting sales.

Who Is Most Affected

The circular is especially important for retailers, restaurants, hotels, convenience stores, pharmacies, supermarkets, service businesses, e-commerce sellers, franchise operators, and other taxpayers that issue receipts or invoices through POS, CRM, SPM, CAS, or other sales receipting software. It also affects businesses with many branches because the BIR can match the machines physically found in each branch against the BIR database.

Large taxpayers and multi-branch businesses face higher exposure because missing, unregistered, defective, or unaccounted machines can be used as a basis for sales reconstruction. SMEs are also affected because even one unregistered machine, missing Z-reading, or unsupported discrepancy may trigger sealing, subpoena, deficiency tax exposure, compromise penalties, or possible criminal referral depending on the violation.

Service providers, suppliers, contractors, and developers of sales machines, software, and systems are also directly affected. RMC No. 72-2018 requires them to assist in the extraction of sales data and Z-readings when required by the BIR or the taxpayer during post-evaluation.

Inventory of POS, CRM, SPM, and Sales Receipting Systems

The BIR must take an inventory of all POS, CRM, SPM, and other receipting machines or software, whether used to issue invoices or used only for internal control purposes. The inventory must be matched and reconciled with the list from the BIR database.

A Post Evaluation Guide Form must be accomplished for every machine. The post-evaluation kit may include pre-filled forms for registered machines using BIR data such as TIN, branch code, Machine Identification Number, Permit to Use, and serial number. Blank forms are used for unregistered machines discovered during the inventory.

The BIR will classify machines as matched or unmatched. Matched machines are those appearing in both the BIR list and the taxpayer’s premises. Unmatched machines include machines physically found at the taxpayer’s premises but not in the BIR list, and machines appearing in the BIR list but not physically found at the premises.

The list of matched and unmatched machines must be prepared on the first day of post-evaluation and signed and acknowledged by the responsible company officer. If there are unmatched machines, the taxpayer must reconcile and explain the discrepancy in writing and account for the unmatched machines within five days from receipt of the Letter Notice accompanied by the list of unmatched machines and the accomplished Post Evaluation Guide Forms.

Z-Reading, e-Journal, and Back-End Report Deadlines

The generation of Z-readings and electronic sales journals per machine must be performed simultaneously with the physical inventory of machines. The taxpayer must submit the extracted Z-reading and e-journal not later than the second day of the post-evaluation. The submission must cover the beginning and ending Z-readings or e-journal for the period stated in the Mission Order.

Sales data must be extracted from POS, CRM, other sales receipting software, and CAS records, including Z-readings, e-journals, and back-end reports from stand-alone systems, servers, middleware, or consolidators depending on the taxpayer’s system setup. Online sales transactions are expressly covered.

Back-end reports must also cover items needed for reconciliation, including void, cancelled, return, and refund items or receipts; sales to senior citizens and persons with disability; and regular or other discounts. These records matter because they may explain why gross machine readings differ from sales declarations in VAT returns, income tax returns, eSales reports, or the Summary List of Sales.

Rules on Unregistered, Defective, Retired, or Modified Machines

If the BIR finds unregistered machines, the Revenue Officer must issue an apprehension slip and immediately seal the machines after extracting sales data. The machines may be unsealed only after registration and payment of related deficiency taxes, including penalties, upon approval of the concerned LT Audit Division or Revenue District Office.

For machines subject to withdrawal from use due to retirement, sale, repair, upgrade, modification, or transfer, immediate verification and Z-reading must be conducted to ensure that all sales data up to the last day of use are recorded for internal revenue purposes. The BIR must cover beginning and ending Z-readings to determine monthly, quarterly, or annual sales for the current and prior years for which the BIR’s right to assess has not prescribed.

If a machine is being withdrawn due to repair, upgrade, or modification and BIR representatives are not available on the taxpayer’s requested inspection date, a Joint Sworn Statement must be executed by the taxpayer-user and the supplier, provider, or person who performed the repair, upgrade, or modification. The statement must include key machine information such as PTU number, Machine Identification Number if applicable, machine type, brand or model, software name and version number, release number if any, and serial number.

The Joint Sworn Statement must also attach hard and soft copies of Z-reading or periodic reading, e-journal, and back-end reports in text file format stored in properly labeled CD-R or DVD-R. These must cover beginning and ending readings sufficient to determine monthly, quarterly, or annual sales for the current and immediately three preceding years. It must also include a statement of non-suppression of sales during repair, upgrading, modification, reconfiguration, and sales data extraction, and must be signed under penalty of perjury.

Sales Reconciliation and the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule

The BIR will reconcile extracted Z-readings and e-journals against sales data from the Business Intelligence Division. Sales from Z-readings per machine will be summarized and compared with eSales and e-journal records. If the e-journal amount is higher than reported eSales, the taxpayer may be treated as having underdeclared sales. If the e-journal amount is lower than reported eSales, the violation is treated as equivalent to non-issuance of a sales invoice or receipt, or issuance of an unregistered receipt, to be dealt with under Section 264 of the Tax Code.

If documents or machines are not available after the required compliance date, a Subpoena Duces Tecum may be issued. Failure to comply may result in the use of the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule for unregistered, unaccounted, missing, or lost sales machines or manual receipts and invoices. The subpoena may also be referred to the Prosecution or Legal Division for filing of a criminal case for failure to obey subpoena.

RMC No. 72-2018 gives a concrete example. If Branch A has 100 machines in the BIR list, but only 80 machines are found during post-evaluation, and those 80 machines generated P80 million in total sales for the first quarter of 2018, the average is P1 million per machine for 90 days, or P11,111 average daily sales per machine. For 20 missing machines, the BIR may compute quarterly sales of P20 million using 20 machines multiplied by P11,111 multiplied by 90 days.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

Failure to transmit sales data to the BIR’s electronic sales reporting system carries a penalty under Section 264-A of the Tax Code, as amended by the TRAIN Law. The penalty is one-tenth of one percent of annual net income as reflected in the taxpayer’s audited financial statement for the second year preceding the current taxable year for each day of violation, or P10,000, whichever is higher. If the aggregate number of days of violation exceeds 180 days within a taxable year, the additional penalty is permanent closure of the taxpayer. The penalty does not apply if the failure to transmit is due to force majeure or causes beyond the taxpayer’s control.

Sales suppression devices are treated far more severely. Under Section 264-B, any person who purchases, uses, possesses, sells, offers to sell, installs, transfers, updates, upgrades, keeps, or maintains any software or device designed for or capable of suppressing, modifying, hiding, or deleting electronic sales records may be punished by a fine of not less than P500,000 but not more than P10,000,000, and imprisonment of not less than two years but not more than four years. Cumulative suppression of electronic sales records exceeding P50,000,000 is considered economic sabotage and is punished with the maximum penalty.

Failure to file required information returns, keep records, or supply information may also be penalized under Section 250 of the Tax Code at P1,000 for each failure, subject to an annual aggregate cap of P25,000. The circular also refers to the revised consolidated schedule of compromise penalties under RMO No. 7-2015 and to sanctions under existing issuances for revocation of the Permit to Use or Certificate of Accreditation.

Practical Steps for Businesses

Businesses should immediately reconcile their actual machines, software, serial numbers, PTUs, Machine Identification Numbers, branch locations, and BIR registration records. A taxpayer should not wait for a BIR visit before discovering that a machine in the BIR database is missing, transferred, damaged, retired, or still physically present but unregistered.

Companies should also maintain complete Z-readings, e-journals, back-end reports, void and refund reports, senior citizen and PWD discount reports, sales discount reports, online sales records, and manual receipt records. For businesses with branches, each branch should have a defensible machine inventory and a process for explaining machine discrepancies within the five-day period from receipt of the Letter Notice.

Before repairing, upgrading, modifying, reconfiguring, transferring, retiring, or cancelling any POS, CRM, SPM, CAS, or sales receipting software, businesses should secure the required BIR approvals and preserve the required sales data. They should also coordinate early with system providers because the circular requires provider assistance in data extraction.

Common search concerns under this circular include BIR POS machine inventory, CRM Z-reading submission deadline, eSales underdeclaration penalty, unregistered POS machine BIR penalty, CAS invoicing post-evaluation, and Best Evidence Obtainable Rule for missing sales machines. These are not merely technical compliance issues; they may affect deficiency tax exposure, closure risk, criminal exposure, and the taxpayer’s ability to defend its sales declarations during audit.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 72-2018 makes sales system compliance a board-level and finance-level risk issue for businesses using POS, CRM, SPM, CAS, online sales platforms, manual receipts, or supplemental commercial documents. The key is to prepare before a post-evaluation, not after a Letter Notice, subpoena, sealing of machines, or discrepancy finding has already been issued.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses in reviewing BIR machine registrations, PTUs, CAS invoicing compliance, sales reconciliation procedures, eSales reporting, branch documentation, audit defense, subpoena responses, and exposure from alleged underdeclaration of sales. For legal guidance on BIR compliance, tax audit preparation, and defense of sales declaration issues under RMC No. 72-2018, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *