RMC No. 19-2018 clarifies that prior mortgage value cannot be used as the CGT or DST base for sales of previously mortgaged Philippine real property. Use statutory values.
Real property sellers, buyers, accountants, and conveyancing teams should not compute Capital Gains Tax and Documentary Stamp Tax using an old mortgage appraisal merely because the property was previously mortgaged at a higher value. RMC No. 19-2018 clarifies that the tax base must still come from the values expressly allowed by the Tax Code: the gross selling price or consideration, and the fair market value determined under Section 6(E), whichever is higher. This matters immediately in property closings because using a prior mortgage value can overstate the tax due, delay the issuance of tax clearances, and create unnecessary disputes at the Revenue District Office.
What RMC No. 19-2018 Changed for Sales of Previously Mortgaged Real Property
RMC No. 19-2018 addresses a specific problem encountered in real estate tax processing: some Revenue District Offices were computing Capital Gains Tax and Documentary Stamp Tax on real property sales based on the mortgage value previously appraised for the property, instead of the bases fixed by law. This became an issue where a property had earlier been mortgaged at a value higher than its zonal value or fair market value, and the mortgage appraisal was later treated as if it controlled the tax computation on a sale.
The clarification is direct: the previous mortgage value is not a lawful basis for computing Capital Gains Tax or Documentary Stamp Tax on the later sale of real property. Revenue officers cannot depart from the Tax Code by considering the mortgage value previously set for the property. For taxpayers, this means the computation should be anchored on the statutory tax base, not on a bank appraisal, loan value, collateral value, or other mortgage-related valuation.
Capital Gains Tax Basis Under RMC No. 19-2018
For Capital Gains Tax on the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property located in the Philippines and classified as a capital asset, the applicable final tax cited in RMC No. 19-2018 is six percent (6%). The tax is based on the gross selling price or the current fair market value as determined in accordance with Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher.
The practical rule is therefore simple but important: compare the gross selling price with the fair market value determined under Section 6(E). The higher amount is the basis for the 6% Capital Gains Tax. If a previous mortgage appraisal is higher than both values, it does not replace the statutory comparison. If the mortgage value is lower, it likewise does not control. The mortgage value is outside the legal formula clarified by RMC No. 19-2018.
For sales or other dispositions of real property to the Government, any of its political subdivisions or agencies, or government-owned or controlled corporations, RMC No. 19-2018 quotes the Tax Code rule that the tax liability may be determined either under Section 24(A) or under Section 24(D), at the option of the taxpayer. Businesses and individual sellers dealing with government buyers should therefore review the applicable income tax treatment before finalizing the tax computation.
Documentary Stamp Tax Basis on Deeds of Sale and Real Property Conveyances
For Documentary Stamp Tax on deeds of sale and conveyances of real property, RMC No. 19-2018 reiterates that the DST is based on the consideration contracted to be paid for the realty or on its fair market value determined in accordance with Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher. This applies to conveyances, deeds, instruments, or writings whereby land, tenements, or other realty are granted, assigned, transferred, or otherwise conveyed to the purchaser or to another person designated by the purchaser.
The same core point applies: the prior mortgage value is not the DST base. In a sale of previously mortgaged property, the DST computation should be tied to the consideration agreed upon in the sale documents and the Section 6(E) fair market value, not to a historic mortgage valuation. Where one of the contracting parties is the Government, the provision quoted in RMC No. 19-2018 states that the DST is based on the actual consideration.
What Counts as Fair Market Value for CGT and DST Purposes
RMC No. 19-2018 emphasizes that the phrase fair market value is not open-ended. The relevant value is the fair market value determined in accordance with Section 6(E) of the Tax Code. Section 6(E) authorizes the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to divide the Philippines into zones or areas and determine the fair market value of real properties located in each zone or area, after consultation with competent appraisers from both the private and public sectors.
For purposes of computing any internal revenue tax, the value of the property under Section 6(E) is whichever is higher between the fair market value determined by the Commissioner and the fair market value shown in the schedule of values of the Provincial or City Assessors. In practice, RMC No. 19-2018 notes that the fair market value determined by the Commissioner is commonly known as the zonal value.
This means that, for real property tax documentation and closing computations, taxpayers should secure and compare the relevant BIR zonal value and the local assessor’s schedule of values. The higher of those two values is the Section 6(E) fair market value. That Section 6(E) fair market value is then compared with the selling price or consideration, depending on whether the computation is for CGT or DST.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 19-2018
RMC No. 19-2018 is most relevant to sellers and buyers of real property that had previously been mortgaged, particularly where the mortgage value, loan appraisal, or collateral valuation is higher than the BIR zonal value or the assessor’s fair market value. It affects individual taxpayers selling capital assets, estates and trusts disposing of real property, corporations and businesses handling property transfers, developers and property investors, banks and lending institutions involved in prior mortgages, and accountants processing tax payments for real estate transactions.
In-house counsel, CFOs, corporate accountants, brokers, and notaries should also take note because the ruling affects transaction closing checklists. The correct tax computation is essential for payment forms, electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration, deed registration, and transfer of title. Search terms likely to matter to taxpayers include RMC No. 19-2018 capital gains tax real property, BIR mortgage value CGT DST, sale of previously mortgaged property tax basis, zonal value versus mortgage value, and documentary stamp tax real property fair market value.
Effective Date and Compliance Requirement
RMC No. 19-2018 takes effect immediately. For transactions processed from its effectivity, taxpayers and Revenue District Offices should apply the clarified basis for computing Capital Gains Tax and Documentary Stamp Tax in sales of previously mortgaged real property.
The compliance requirement is to prepare the computation using only the lawful bases identified in the circular. For CGT, use the higher of the gross selling price and the current fair market value determined under Section 6(E). For DST, use the higher of the consideration contracted to be paid and the Section 6(E) fair market value, subject to the special rule on actual consideration where one contracting party is the Government. Do not use the previous mortgage value as the tax base merely because it appears in earlier mortgage documents, appraisal records, or bank collateral files.
Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance
RMC No. 19-2018 does not create a new penalty schedule. However, incorrect computation can still create practical tax risk. Underpayment may expose the taxpayer to deficiency tax issues under the Tax Code, while overpayment can unnecessarily increase transaction costs and may require a refund or tax credit process. A computation based on an unauthorized mortgage value may also delay processing at the Revenue District Office if the taxpayer, buyer, seller, or examiner disputes the tax base.
The business risk is especially significant in time-sensitive closings. If the wrong base is used, parties may disagree over who shoulders the additional tax, whether the deed can be registered, and whether title transfer deadlines can be met. For corporate sellers and buyers, an erroneous computation can affect accounting entries, tax accruals, deal pricing, and closing deliverables.
Practical Steps for Taxpayers, Accountants, and Property Teams
Before paying CGT and DST on a sale of previously mortgaged real property, taxpayers should obtain the deed or sale agreement showing the gross selling price or consideration, the applicable BIR zonal value, and the assessor’s fair market value under the relevant schedule of values. They should then disregard the previous mortgage value for purposes of the CGT and DST base, unless it independently appears as the actual consideration in the sale documents, which is a different matter from being a prior mortgage appraisal.
For Capital Gains Tax, compute the 6% final tax using the higher of the gross selling price and the Section 6(E) fair market value. For Documentary Stamp Tax, compute the tax using the higher of the consideration contracted to be paid and the Section 6(E) fair market value. Where the Government is one of the contracting parties, review the special rule quoted in RMC No. 19-2018 on actual consideration for DST, and the taxpayer’s option for the income tax treatment of gains from sales to the Government.
Parties should also document the comparison in the closing file. A simple computation sheet showing the selling price, zonal value, assessor’s value, Section 6(E) fair market value, and resulting tax base can prevent avoidable disputes. For corporate transactions, the same computation should be reviewed by accounting, tax, and legal teams before payment and before submission to the Revenue District Office.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Real property transfers often involve more than a deed of sale. They require proper tax computation, documentary review, payment timing, title transfer coordination, and risk allocation between seller and buyer. RMC No. 19-2018 is a useful taxpayer clarification because it prevents mortgage appraisals from being used as a substitute tax base, but parties still need to apply the rule carefully in actual closing documents.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists individuals, corporations, property owners, developers, investors, and in-house legal teams with BIR compliance, Capital Gains Tax and Documentary Stamp Tax computations, real property conveyancing, tax documentation, and transaction structuring. For assistance with a sale of previously mortgaged real property, CGT and DST computations, or BIR processing concerns, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.