RMC No. 10-2018 clarifies that withholding tax arises upon payment, payability, accrual, or book recording, whichever comes first.
Withholding agents cannot wait for actual cash payment before recognizing withholding tax when the income payment has already become payable or has already been accrued or recorded as an expense or asset in the payor’s books. RMC No. 10-2018 clarifies that, for withholding tax purposes, the controlling rule is whichever comes first: payment, payability, accrual, or book recording. This matters immediately for government agencies, local government units, government-owned or controlled corporations, and private withholding agents whose accounting entries may trigger withholding before disbursement.
What RMC No. 10-2018 Changed or Clarified
RMC No. 10-2018 clarifies the time of withholding and remittance of taxes withheld by withholding agents, including National Government Agencies and Instrumentalities, Local Government Units, and Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations. The clarification was issued because of a practical conflict between the withholding tax rule under Section 2.57.4 of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Section 4 of Revenue Regulations No. 12-2001, and accounting procedures under the Government Accounting Manual.
The key rule is that the obligation of the payor to deduct and withhold tax arises at the time an income payment is paid or payable, or when the income payment is accrued or recorded as an expense or asset in the payor’s books, whichever comes first. The term payable refers to the date the obligation becomes due, demandable, or legally enforceable.
The practical effect is important: if the payor has already recorded the amount as an expense or asset, the obligation to withhold may already exist even if the supplier, contractor, consultant, or other income payee has not yet been paid. For businesses and government entities searching for guidance on time of withholding tax Philippines, withholding upon accrual, due to BIR account recognition, and withholding tax on construction in progress, RMC No. 10-2018 confirms that book recognition can trigger withholding obligations.
Who Is Most Affected
The ruling directly affects withholding agents, especially government offices and entities that follow government accounting procedures. These include National Government Agencies and Instrumentalities, Local Government Units, and Government-Owned and Controlled Corporations. It is also relevant to private corporations and other payors because the underlying rule being clarified comes from RR No. 2-98, as amended by RR No. 12-2001, which governs withholding obligations generally.
The most affected taxpayers are entities that record expenses or assets before actual payment. This includes payors handling construction contracts, infrastructure projects, property, plant and equipment acquisitions, professional service contracts, contractor billings, and other transactions where obligations may be accrued or capitalized before cash release. Corporate accountants and CFOs should pay particular attention when preparing accrual entries, accounts payable schedules, construction in progress accounts, and tax remittance calendars.
Key Compliance Rule: Withholding Is Triggered by the Earliest Event
RMC No. 10-2018 reiterates that the time of withholding is determined by the earliest applicable event. The obligation to withhold arises when the income payment is paid, when it becomes payable, when it is accrued, or when it is recorded as an expense or asset in the payor’s books. The rule does not allow a withholding agent to defer withholding solely because cash has not yet been released.
The clarification is especially significant where an item is booked as an asset rather than immediately expensed. The circular specifically addresses government projects and states that the obligation to withhold arises at the time the government agency books construction of property, plant and equipment as Construction in Progress with the appropriate asset classification. This is because RR No. 12-2001 requires withholding based on whichever comes first.
For construction-related government transactions, the Government Accounting Manual provides that during the construction period, all expenses incurred in relation to the construction of property, plant and equipment are taken up in the books as Construction in Progress with the appropriate asset classification. Once construction is completed, the Construction in Progress account is reclassified to the proper asset account. The circular clarifies that the earlier booking of Construction in Progress may already be enough to trigger the withholding obligation.
Why the Government Accounting Manual Created Confusion
The issue arose because illustrative accounting entries under the Government Accounting Manual recognized Due to BIR accounts only upon payment of the accounts payable to the income payee. This appeared to conflict with the BIR rule that withholding may arise earlier, upon accrual or recording as an expense or asset.
RMC No. 10-2018 resolves this by confirming that the BIR withholding tax rule prevails for determining the time of withholding. The circular states that the obligation to withhold taxes already arises when an expense or asset is already recorded, whether or not the same has been paid, pursuant to RR No. 12-2001.
Deadlines and Effective Compliance Point
RMC No. 10-2018 is dated January 31, 2018. The circular does not create a new tax rate, threshold, or separate numerical deadline. Its compliance point is transactional: withholding must be recognized at the earliest of payment, payability, accrual, or recording in the books as expense or asset.
For accounting teams, the deadline problem is therefore not a single calendar date but the timing of each transaction. Once the income payment becomes payable, or once it is accrued or recorded in the books, the withholding obligation may already arise. This requires coordination between accounting, treasury, procurement, project management, and tax compliance teams so that the withholding tax return and remittance process follows the correct triggering event.
Penalties and Enforcement Risk
RMC No. 10-2018 does not state a new special penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or compromise penalty. However, it strictly enjoins all internal revenue officers and others concerned to implement the circular. The compliance risk is that withholding agents that wait until actual payment, despite earlier accrual or asset recognition, may be treated as having failed to withhold or remit at the proper time under the applicable withholding tax rules.
For businesses and government entities, the safer compliance position is to review accounting entries and determine whether any recorded expense, asset, payable, or Construction in Progress account has already triggered withholding. A mismatch between accounting recognition and tax remittance can expose the withholding agent to BIR examination issues even if the supplier has not yet received cash.
Practical Steps for CFOs, Accountants, and Government Finance Officers
First, review accounts payable, accrued expenses, asset accounts, and Construction in Progress accounts to determine whether income payments have already been recorded. If the item has been booked as an expense or asset, the withholding tax treatment should be evaluated immediately.
Second, align the tax calendar with accounting recognition, not merely with cash disbursement. RMC No. 10-2018 makes clear that withholding may be triggered before payment. Accounting teams should therefore flag entries that create payable, accrued, expense, asset, or Construction in Progress balances involving income payments subject to withholding.
Third, update internal controls for government contracts, construction projects, contractor billings, and capitalized project costs. For government projects, finance officers should pay special attention to the point when property, plant and equipment construction costs are booked as Construction in Progress, because that is specifically identified as a withholding trigger under the circular.
Fourth, coordinate with suppliers and contractors so that withholding tax certificates and billing records are consistent with the timing required by BIR rules. A supplier may think tax should be withheld only upon cash payment, but the withholding agent must follow the rule that applies to payment, payability, accrual, or recording, whichever comes first.
Finally, document the basis for the withholding decision. When a transaction is accrued, recorded as an asset, or booked as Construction in Progress, the accounting entry, invoice, contract, billing statement, and withholding tax computation should be retained together. This will help explain why withholding was recognized at a particular point in time if reviewed by the BIR, COA, or internal auditors.
ASG Law Can Help With Withholding Tax Compliance
RMC No. 10-2018 is a reminder that withholding tax compliance is not only a tax filing issue; it is also an accounting systems, procurement, and internal controls issue. Businesses and government contractors that rely only on payment dates may miss earlier withholding triggers created by accruals, payables, asset recognition, or Construction in Progress accounting.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, government contractors, accountants, and business owners in reviewing withholding tax exposure, BIR compliance procedures, accounting-triggered tax obligations, and documentation practices. For assistance with RMC No. 10-2018, withholding tax timing, BIR assessments, or tax compliance reviews, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.