RMC No. 100-2017 clarifies that alphalist non-submission triggers penalties but not automatic expense disallowance if withholding taxes were remitted.
Withholding agents that fail to submit the required alphabetical list of employees or payees will face a compromise penalty of P1,000 for each failure, capped at P25,000 for the calendar year, but the related expenses will not automatically become non-deductible if the withholding taxes were already properly withheld and remitted. RMC No. 100-2017 is important for employers, corporate payors, finance teams, and tax compliance officers because it clarifies the consequence of failing to file, correct, or re-submit the alphalist attached to the annual information returns for withholding taxes.
What RMC No. 100-2017 Changed
RMC No. 100-2017 clarified the sanctions for non-submission of the Alphabetical List of Employees or Payees of income payments. The core clarification is practical and taxpayer-relevant: where the withholding agent has already filed the monthly remittance returns and paid the corresponding withholding taxes, the failure to submit the alphalist does not, by itself, make the related expenses non-deductible.
This matters because withholding tax compliance in the Philippines has two connected but distinct components. First, the withholding agent must withhold the proper tax from income payments, salaries, wages, or other covered payments. Second, the withholding agent must remit the taxes by filing the required monthly remittance returns, including BIR Form 1601E, BIR Form 1601F, and BIR Form 1601C, and paying the tax due. In addition, the withholding agent must submit the annual information return, particularly BIR Form 1604E or BIR Form 1604CF, together with the alphabetical list of payees or employees.
The annual information return is described as a no-payment return. It contains, among others, the information regarding the monthly remittance of taxes withheld and the summary of payees from whom taxes were withheld and already remitted during the taxable year. In short, the alphalist supports the BIRโs ability to validate the withholding tax trail, match payees, and verify annual withholding information, even though the tax payment itself should already have been made through the monthly remittance process.
Who Is Most Affected
The issuance directly affects withholding agents. This includes employers withholding tax on compensation, businesses paying suppliers or service providers subject to expanded withholding tax, payors of income payments covered by final withholding tax, and companies that must submit annual information returns with alphalists to the BIR.
For employers, the relevant annual compliance includes BIR Form 1604CF together with the Alphabetical List of Employees. For businesses making income payments to suppliers, contractors, professionals, lessors, or other payees subject to withholding tax, the relevant annual compliance includes BIR Form 1604E together with the Alphabetical List of Payees. For CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax managers, the ruling is especially relevant because alphalist errors often arise not from failure to pay tax, but from incomplete payee information, encoding issues, validation errors, or failure to re-submit corrected files after BIR validation.
Searches such as RMC 100-2017 alphalist penalty, non-submission of alphalist BIR penalty, 1604E alphalist non-deductibility, 1604CF alphabetical list employees, and withholding agent compromise penalty are directly addressed by this clarification.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 100-2017 confirms that withholding agents must still comply with the underlying withholding tax filing and reporting requirements under the Tax Code and implementing revenue regulations. Sections 57 and 79(A) of the Tax Code of 1997, as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended, require the withholding of taxes by the payor of income or employer on certain income payments and on salaries and wages of employees.
The taxes withheld must be remitted to the BIR through the appropriate monthly remittance returns. The issuance specifically identifies BIR Form 1601E, BIR Form 1601F, and BIR Form 1601C as the monthly remittance returns through which withholding agents file and pay the corresponding tax due.
In addition to monthly remittance and payment, Sections 58(C) and 83(B) of the Tax Code require withholding agents to submit an Annual Information Return, specifically BIR Form 1604E or BIR Form 1604CF, together with the Alphabetical List of Payees or Employees. The annual information return does not replace the monthly remittance return. It is a separate information-reporting requirement that summarizes the taxes withheld and the payees or employees from whom the taxes were withheld during the taxable year.
RMC No. 100-2017 does not create a new filing deadline in the text of the issuance. Instead, it clarifies the sanction when the withholding agent fails to file the alphabetical list, fails to submit it, or fails to re-submit the complete or corrected alphabetical list after BIR validation. Businesses should therefore continue to follow the applicable deadlines for BIR Form 1604E, BIR Form 1604CF, and their required alphalist attachments under existing BIR rules and current filing systems.
Penalty for Non-Submission or Failure to Correct the Alphalist
The specific penalty clarified in RMC No. 100-2017 is a compromise penalty of P1,000 for each failure to make, file, or submit the required information return. The aggregate amount to be imposed for such failures during the calendar year shall not exceed P25,000. The circular states that this penalty is imposed pursuant to Revenue Memorandum Order No. 7-2015.
The penalty applies not only to outright non-filing of the alphabetical list of payees or employees. It also applies to failure to submit the complete or corrected alphabetical list after the validation process conducted by the BIR. This distinction is important. A company that initially submits an alphalist but fails BIR validation should not treat the initial submission as the end of compliance. If the BIR validation process requires correction, the withholding agent must re-submit the complete or corrected alphabetical list.
Payment of the compromise penalty does not relieve the withholding agent from submitting the required alphalist. The issuance is explicit that payment of the compromise penalty shall in no way relieve the withholding agent from the submission of the required Alphabetical List or the complete or corrected alphabetical list. In practical terms, paying P1,000 or even reaching the P25,000 annual cap does not cure the missing report. The business must still complete the alphalist compliance.
Does Failure to Submit the Alphalist Make Expenses Non-Deductible?
The most taxpayer-favorable clarification in RMC No. 100-2017 is that failure to file the Alphabetical List of Payees or Employees, or failure to re-submit the complete and corrected alphabetical list after BIR validation, shall not result in the non-deductibility of the expenses if the corresponding withholding taxes were already withheld and remitted.
The reasoning is that the requirement for deductibility of expenses that have been subjected to withholding tax is already complied with when the withholding agent files the monthly remittance returns and pays the taxes withheld. Thus, the alphalist failure remains a violation of the Tax Code and BIR issuances, but the sanction is the compromise penalty and continuing obligation to submit the required list, not automatic disallowance of the expense deduction where withholding and remittance were already done.
This is a significant clarification for tax assessments. Prior to this clarification, taxpayers facing BIR examinations could be exposed to arguments that missing or defective alphalists should lead to the disallowance of expenses, even where taxes had actually been withheld and paid. RMC No. 100-2017 narrows that consequence by recognizing the difference between failure to withhold and remit, on one hand, and failure to submit or correct the information return, on the other.
Superseded Rule and Practical Effect
RMC No. 100-2017 supersedes Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 5-2014 insofar as Item No. 15 is concerned, and all other issuances inconsistent with the clarification. The practical effect is that taxpayers and BIR examiners should apply the rule in RMC No. 100-2017 when evaluating the consequence of a missing, incomplete, or uncorrected alphalist in cases where withholding taxes were already withheld and remitted.
For businesses under audit, this can be important in defending expense deductions. A taxpayer should be prepared to prove that the withholding agent filed the monthly remittance returns and paid the corresponding tax due. The defense is strongest where the company can show BIR Form 1601E, BIR Form 1601F, or BIR Form 1601C filings, payment confirmations, and supporting schedules showing that the income payments were subjected to withholding tax.
What Businesses Should Do Now
Businesses should first confirm whether all monthly withholding tax returns were filed and paid. The alphalist clarification protects deductibility only where the taxes corresponding to the income payments were already withheld and remitted. If the company failed to withhold or failed to remit, RMC No. 100-2017 should not be read as curing that separate violation.
Second, finance and accounting teams should check whether BIR Form 1604E or BIR Form 1604CF was filed for the relevant taxable year, together with the correct alphalist attachment. For companies with many employees, suppliers, contractors, consultants, or professional service providers, the alphalist should be reconciled against the general ledger, withholding tax payable accounts, certificates of tax withheld, and monthly remittance returns.
Third, taxpayers should address BIR validation errors immediately. If the alphalist was rejected, incomplete, or required correction after validation, the company should re-submit the complete or corrected alphabetical list. Under RMC No. 100-2017, failure to re-submit the corrected list is itself covered by the compromise penalty rule.
Fourth, companies should document compliance in anticipation of a BIR audit. The files should include monthly remittance returns, annual information returns, alphalist files, proof of submission, proof of payment, validation results, corrected submissions, and correspondence with the BIR. This documentation can help defend against expense disallowances and limit the issue to the compromise penalty where appropriate.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 100-2017 gives withholding agents an important defense against automatic expense disallowance, but it does not remove the obligation to file and correct alphalists. Businesses should treat the ruling as a compliance and audit-management tool: prove withholding and remittance, correct the alphalist, pay the applicable compromise penalty if assessed, and preserve the deductibility position.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, employers, withholding agents, accounting teams, and in-house counsel in BIR compliance, withholding tax audits, alphalist issues, assessment defense, and tax controversy strategy. For assistance with RMC No. 100-2017, BIR Form 1604E, BIR Form 1604CF, alphalist validation errors, or withholding tax audit exposure, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.