RMC No. 27-2017 clarifies that real property taxes must use gross selling price or Section 6(E) fair market value, whichever is higher.

Real property transfers must be taxed only on the legally prescribed base: the gross selling price or the current fair market value determined under Section 6(E) of the National Internal Revenue Code, whichever is higher. RMC No. 27-2017 matters immediately to sellers, buyers, corporations, withholding agents, accountants, and property developers because it rejects the use of comparative sales or any other unofficial valuation method as a basis for capital gains tax, income tax, or withholding tax on the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property.

What RMC No. 27-2017 Changed

RMC No. 27-2017 clarifies the proper basis for imposing tax on the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property, whether the property is classified as a capital asset or an ordinary asset. The core rule is straightforward: the BIR must use the gross selling price or the current fair market value as determined under Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher. No other basis may be imposed by revenue officials or employees.

The clarification is important because real property taxation often involves competing valuation figures: the contract price, BIR zonal value, assessor value, broker valuations, market comparables, and internal estimates. RMC No. 27-2017 confirms that, for internal revenue tax purposes, the relevant statutory valuation rule is not an open-ended market appraisal exercise. The tax base must come from the specific bases allowed by law.

For business owners and accountants searching for the RMC No. 27-2017 real property tax base, BIR zonal value vs selling price, capital gains tax basis on sale of land, withholding tax on real property sale, or fair market value for BIR real property transfer tax, the practical point is this: determine the gross selling price, determine the applicable fair market value under Section 6(E), then apply the higher amount as the tax base where the cited rules so require.

The Statutory Valuation Rule Under Section 6(E)

RMC No. 27-2017 relies on Section 6(E) of Republic Act No. 8424, otherwise known as the Tax Reform Act of 1997 and the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997. Section 6(E) authorizes the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to divide the Philippines into different zones or areas and, after consultation with competent appraisers from both the private and public sectors, determine the fair market value of real properties located in each zone or area.

For purposes of computing any internal revenue tax, the value of real property shall be whichever is higher of two figures: the fair market value as determined by the Commissioner, or the fair market value shown in the schedule of values of the Provincial and City Assessors. In practical BIR compliance terms, this means taxpayers must check the applicable BIR zonal value and the relevant assessor’s value, then use the higher fair market value when comparing against the gross selling price.

The circular therefore reinforces a two-level comparison. First, determine the current fair market value under Section 6(E) by comparing the Commissioner’s value with the Provincial or City Assessor’s value. Second, compare that current fair market value against the gross selling price, where the applicable tax provision requires the tax to be based on the higher of the two.

Taxes and Transactions Covered

RMC No. 27-2017 applies to the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property. It expressly covers real property whether classified as a capital asset or ordinary asset. This makes the issuance relevant not only to individuals selling land, houses, condominium units, or other real property held as capital assets, but also to corporations and businesses dealing with real property as part of their trade or business.

The circular specifically refers to Section 24(D)(1) and Section 27(D)(5) of the Tax Code, as implemented by Revenue Regulations Nos. 2-98 and 7-2003. It states that, for purposes of imposing the tax under those provisions, the basis shall be the gross selling price or the current fair market value determined in accordance with Section 6(E) of the Tax Code, whichever is higher.

The taxes expressly mentioned in the clarification are capital gains tax, income tax, and withholding tax on the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property. The circular does not create a new tax rate, a new deadline, or a new documentary requirement. Its effect is to clarify and restrict the valuation basis that may be used in imposing these taxes.

Who Is Most Affected

Property sellers are directly affected because the tax due on a real property transfer may be computed on an amount higher than the contract price if the current fair market value under Section 6(E) is higher. Buyers are also affected because real estate transactions often allocate tax costs, documentary requirements, and closing conditions between the parties. A mistake in the tax base can delay the release of tax clearances, certificates authorizing registration, and transfer of title.

Corporations, real estate developers, dealers in real property, and businesses selling company-owned land or buildings should pay particular attention because the circular applies whether the real property is a capital asset or ordinary asset. Corporate accountants and CFOs must ensure that transaction computations do not rely on broker estimates, comparable sale prices, or informal valuation methods where the Tax Code and implementing regulations prescribe the gross selling price or current fair market value standard.

Withholding agents are also affected. In transactions where withholding tax applies to a sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property, the responsible party must use the proper statutory base. RMC No. 27-2017 gives taxpayers a clear basis to object when an examiner or revenue officer attempts to impose capital gains tax, income tax, or withholding tax using a comparative sale or some other non-statutory tax base.

Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

RMC No. 27-2017 does not prescribe a new filing deadline. Its compliance impact is transactional: each real property sale, exchange, or other disposition must be computed using the legally allowed tax base at the time the applicable tax return, withholding tax return, or transfer-related BIR filing is prepared.

For every covered transaction, taxpayers should identify the actual gross selling price stated in the deed or transaction document. They should then obtain or verify the applicable fair market value determined by the Commissioner for the relevant zone or area. They should also check the schedule of values of the Provincial or City Assessor. The higher fair market value under Section 6(E) must then be compared with the gross selling price, and the higher amount should be used where the applicable tax provision requires that basis.

Documentation should be retained in the transaction file. This includes the deed of sale or exchange, relevant property description, BIR zonal valuation reference, assessor’s value reference, and the computation showing how the final tax base was selected. For corporate taxpayers and businesses, this computation should be reviewed before signing the deed, booking the transaction, issuing or filing withholding tax documents, and processing the transfer with the BIR.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 27-2017 does not state a specific new penalty. However, incorrect use of the tax base can create practical and legal exposure. If a taxpayer uses a lower base than that required by Section 6(E), the BIR may assess deficiency tax under the applicable tax laws and regulations. If a revenue official uses a comparative sale or any other basis not authorized by the circular, the taxpayer may have grounds to challenge the valuation basis because the circular states that such alternative bases have no legal basis.

The most important risk is not a new penalty but a disputed assessment, delayed transaction closing, or BIR processing issue. Real property transfers are document-heavy and timing-sensitive. A valuation error may affect the issuance of tax clearances, the processing of transfer documents, and the parties’ contractual obligations under the sale or exchange agreement.

Practical Steps for Taxpayers, Accountants, and CFOs

Before signing any deed involving real property, taxpayers should run the tax computation using the gross selling price and the current fair market value under Section 6(E). The current fair market value should be supported by the higher of the Commissioner’s fair market value and the Provincial or City Assessor’s schedule of values.

Accountants should avoid using comparative sale data, broker estimates, internal appraisals, or negotiated valuations as the controlling tax base for capital gains tax, income tax, or withholding tax on real property dispositions when the applicable law requires the gross selling price or Section 6(E) fair market value basis. These figures may be useful for commercial negotiation, financing, or internal valuation, but RMC No. 27-2017 states that they cannot replace the tax base provided by law.

Corporate sellers should also review their contracts. The purchase price, tax allocation clause, closing deliverables, and responsibility for BIR filings should be aligned with the rule in RMC No. 27-2017. Where the fair market value is higher than the selling price, the parties should anticipate that the tax cost may be computed on the higher value. This should be addressed before closing, not after a dispute arises.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 27-2017 is a reminder that real property tax compliance is not only about applying the correct tax type. It is also about selecting the legally correct tax base and documenting the computation in a way that can withstand BIR review. For businesses, property owners, developers, and corporate finance teams, the difference between the contract price and the applicable fair market value can materially affect transaction cost, closing timelines, and tax risk.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients with BIR compliance, real property transfer tax structuring, tax due diligence, corporate property transactions, withholding tax issues, and responses to BIR valuation concerns. For assistance with RMC No. 27-2017, capital gains tax, income tax, withholding tax on real property transfers, or BIR zonal value concerns, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *