RMC No. 61-2016 bars tax reporting by netting receivables and payables; taxpayers must record gross income, VAT, percentage tax, and withholding.

Businesses that settle receivables and payables by offsetting can no longer treat only the net amount as the taxable transaction. RMC No. 61-2016 requires taxpayers to record sales, service fees, interest income, interconnection fees, receivables, and payables at their gross amounts for income tax, VAT, percentage tax, and withholding tax purposes, even when the parties commercially agree to net settlement of cash flows.

What RMC No. 61-2016 Changed

RMC No. 61-2016 prescribed the policies and guidelines for accounting and recording transactions involving netting or offsetting. Its central rule is straightforward but significant: for taxation purposes, taxpayers are strictly prohibited from offsetting due to and due from, or payable and receivable, transactions in a manner that understates the gross amount of income, purchases, expenses, VAT, percentage tax, or withholding tax obligations.

The circular standardizes the treatment of arrangements where one party owes another, but the parties agree that only the net amount will be paid. While net settlement may be convenient commercially, the BIR requires the underlying transactions to be recognized separately and at gross. The rule applies even where contracts contain standard commercial provisions allowing the parties to net settle.

The BIR based the circular on Section 6(H), in relation to Sections 57(B), 113, and 237 of the National Internal Revenue Code, and on the definitions of gross income and gross receipts under Sections 32(A) and 108. This means the rule is not merely bookkeeping guidance. It directly affects income recognition, VAT or percentage tax computation, withholding tax compliance, invoicing, and deductibility of expenses.

Who Is Most Affected

RMC No. 61-2016 affects taxpayers that regularly have reciprocal receivable and payable arrangements. This includes supermarkets and suppliers with display fees, marketing support, service fees, trade discounts, or deductions from invoice settlements; telecommunications companies with access charges or interconnection fees; banks and financial institutions with borrowers who are also depositors; service providers with revenue-sharing arrangements; and businesses that net off trade receivables against trade payables.

VAT-registered businesses are particularly affected because the circular requires the accrued receivables or payables arising from the sale or lease of goods or properties, or the performance of services, to be recognized at gross for income and VAT purposes. Taxpayers subject to percentage tax are also covered, as shown by the banking illustration where gross receipts tax was computed on the full interest income, not on the net interest spread after offsetting deposit interest expense.

Withholding agents must also pay close attention. Income payments subject to creditable or final withholding taxes under RR No. 2-98, as amended, must be recorded at gross regardless of whether the transaction is actually offset or provides for net settlement of cash flows.

Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

The practical compliance requirement is that every component of the transaction must be documented, invoiced, recorded, and taxed based on its true gross amount. A taxpayer cannot rely on a reduced cash payment to justify reduced income, reduced VAT, reduced percentage tax, or reduced withholding tax.

In the supermarket and supplier example, Company F sold food products to Company S worth P11,200.00, inclusive of VAT. Company S paid only P8,000.00 after deducting P3,200.00 as service fees for the display of Company Fโ€™s products. The BIR required Company S to record purchases at the gross amount of P10,000.00, not P8,000.00. Company S also had to declare the P3,200.00 service fee as revenue and issue an official receipt for the service fee.

The circular further illustrates the VAT and withholding tax consequences. In that example, the service fee was broken down into service fee income of P2,857.14 and deferred VAT payable of P342.86. Creditable withholding tax on the service fee was computed at 2% of P2,857.14, or P57.15. For the sale of goods, creditable withholding tax was computed at 1% of P10,000.00, or P100.00, while output VAT on the sale was P1,200.00.

In the telecommunications example, Company G billed a postpaid subscriber P1,000.00 for an outgoing call to a subscriber of Company S. The arrangement provided for a 50% interconnect share as access charge or interconnection fee. The BIR required the interconnection share of Company S to form part of the reported gross revenue of Company G, while Company G simultaneously recognized the corresponding interconnection fee expense and liability due to Company S. Outright or automatic netting-out of payments due to other telecommunications companies against the gross revenue of the collecting telco is not allowed.

The same example shows that the telco paying the access charge must compute withholding tax on the gross amount of the interconnect share of the other telco, net of VAT. For a P1,000.00 charge with a 50% interconnect share, the access charge expense was shown as P446.43, deferred input VAT as P53.57, access charge payable as P491.07, and CWT payable as P8.93.

In the banking example, Bank X earned P1,000,000.00 in interest income from a loan to Company A, while Company A earned P200,000.00 in deposit interest from Bank X. Bank X could not report only P800,000.00 of interest income in its percentage tax return. It was required to declare P1,000,000.00 as income subject to percentage tax. The circularโ€™s illustration computed gross receipts tax at 5%, resulting in P50,000.00 percentage tax on the P1,000,000.00 interest income.

Penalties and Tax Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 61-2016 does not create a new specific penalty table, but the tax risks are substantial. If a taxpayer records only the net amount, the BIR may assess deficiency income tax, VAT, percentage tax, expanded withholding tax, final withholding tax, surcharge, interest, and compromise penalties under the applicable provisions of the Tax Code and implementing regulations.

The circular specifically warns that any amount offset against income payments by the payor that is not subjected to creditable or final withholding tax shall not be allowed as a deductible expense of the payor. This follows RR No. 12-2013, which disallows deductions for expenses where the corresponding withholding tax was not remitted.

Businesses should also be careful when labeling service fees as discounts. RMC No. 61-2016 applies the principle of substance over form. If a supposed discount is in substance a service fee, the BIR may disregard the label and treat the amount as income of the recipient, subject to creditable withholding tax and VAT. The circular expressly states that a service fee disguised as a discount may be considered income subject to tax, and that the purported discount may not be allowed as a deduction from gross selling price for VAT purposes if it is not a true discount under RR No. 16-2005, as amended.

Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants

Businesses should immediately review contracts, billing practices, collection arrangements, and accounting entries that involve netting, offsetting, deductions from invoices, contra accounts, intercompany charges, revenue-sharing, service fees, display allowances, rebates, and so-called discounts. The legal and tax teams should confirm whether the contract label matches the actual substance of the transaction.

Accounting teams should ensure that receivables and payables are booked at gross, not merely at the net cash settlement amount. Sales invoices and official receipts should be issued for the proper gross transactions. VAT and percentage tax should be computed on the gross taxable base required by the circular. Withholding tax should be computed and remitted on the proper gross income payment, net of VAT where applicable.

For supplier-retailer arrangements, CFOs should scrutinize trade deductions, shelf-space fees, display fees, marketing support, and rebates. For telcos and revenue-sharing businesses, gross revenue and corresponding access charges or interconnection fees must be recorded separately. For banks and financial institutions, interest income and interest expense must not be netted for percentage tax reporting where the gross amount is the proper taxable base.

Relevant search terms for taxpayers dealing with this issue include RMC No. 61-2016 netting offsetting, BIR gross reporting receivables payables, VAT treatment of service fee disguised as discount, withholding tax on offset transactions Philippines, and tax accounting for net settlement Philippines.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 61-2016 is a practical reminder that commercial convenience does not control tax treatment. A net settlement clause may simplify payment, but it does not authorize net reporting for income tax, VAT, percentage tax, or withholding tax purposes. The BIR will look at the substance of the transaction, the gross taxable base, the invoices and receipts issued, and whether withholding taxes were properly remitted.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing contracts, correcting invoicing flows, assessing withholding tax exposure, preparing BIR compliance positions, and defending taxpayers in audits involving VAT, percentage tax, gross receipts, deductions, and withholding tax. For assistance with RMC No. 61-2016 compliance and BIR audit risk management, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *