RMC No. 58-2014 confirms withholding tax on SAJ and related judiciary allowances under the Supreme Court’s June 25, 2014 resolution.

Judiciary payroll and finance offices must withhold and remit the correct tax from the Special Allowance for the Judiciary and related allowances covered by the Supreme Court En Banc Resolution dated June 25, 2014. RMC No. 58-2014 matters immediately because it confirms that SAJ payments, equivalent monthly special allowances, and certain additional allowances from the SAJ Fund are not to be released without the corresponding tax withholding where tax is required to be deducted and withheld.

What RMC No. 58-2014 Changed

RMC No. 58-2014, dated July 22, 2014, published the full text of the Supreme Court En Banc Resolution dated June 25, 2014 concerning the withholding of tax from the Special Allowance for the Judiciary. The circular was issued for the information and guidance of all internal revenue officials, employees, and others concerned.

The key legal development is the Supreme Court’s approval of the withholding and remittance of the correct amount of tax required to be deducted and withheld from the Special Allowance for the Judiciary of officials and employees. This approval was made upon the recommendation of the Commission on Audit under Audit Observation Memorandum No. 2014-001 (SAJ), as submitted by the Fiscal Management and Budget Office.

For tax and payroll compliance purposes, the practical rule is clear: where SAJ or covered special allowance payments are made to officials or employees, the withholding agent responsible for payroll processing must determine the correct tax treatment, deduct the applicable withholding tax, and remit the same in the proper manner. The circular does not introduce a new rate table, threshold, or numerical computation formula. Instead, it confirms the coverage of the withholding requirement for the specific judiciary allowances identified in the Supreme Court resolution.

Who Is Affected

RMC No. 58-2014 primarily affects judiciary offices, court payroll units, disbursing officers, finance officers, accounting personnel, and government officials responsible for processing and releasing SAJ-related payments. It also affects incumbent justices, judges, judiciary officials, and judiciary employees who receive allowances covered by the Supreme Court resolution.

Although the circular is not directed at private corporations in the ordinary course of business, it is important for tax practitioners, government accountants, auditors, and withholding agents because it confirms a specific withholding treatment for a recurring compensation-related allowance. Philippine accountants and tax managers researching withholding tax on Special Allowance for the Judiciary, SAJ tax withholding, judiciary allowance tax, Supreme Court SAJ Resolution, and RMC 58-2014 withholding tax should treat this issuance as the BIR’s official publication of the governing Supreme Court action.

Allowances Covered by the Withholding Requirement

The Supreme Court resolution covered three categories of payments. First, it covered the monthly SAJ of incumbent justices, judges, and judiciary officials with the equivalent rank of a Court of Appeals justice or Regional Trial Court judge. Second, it covered the monthly special allowance in an amount equivalent to the SAJ being received by judiciary officials not included in the first category. Third, it covered the additional allowance from the surplus of the SAJ Fund that may be authorized to be given to judiciary officials and employees who are not direct beneficiaries under Republic Act No. 9227.

These categories are important because the withholding requirement is not limited to only one narrow group of judicial officers. The resolution expressly reaches the monthly SAJ, equivalent monthly special allowance payments, and additional allowances sourced from the surplus of the SAJ Fund when authorized for judiciary officials and employees who are not direct beneficiaries under Republic Act No. 9227.

Key Compliance Requirement and Effective Timing

The controlling compliance requirement is the withholding and remittance of the correct amount of tax required to be deducted and withheld from the covered SAJ-related payments. The Supreme Court resolution is dated June 25, 2014, while RMC No. 58-2014 is dated July 22, 2014. From a compliance standpoint, payroll and finance officers handling covered payments should have treated the issuance as immediate guidance upon publication and circulation.

The circular does not set out a separate transition period, grace period, filing deadline, or special remittance schedule. It simply enjoins all concerned to be guided accordingly and to give the circular as wide publicity as possible. Accordingly, affected offices should not wait for a separate implementing circular before applying the withholding directive to the covered SAJ-related payments.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 58-2014 does not prescribe a separate penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or administrative sanction specific to SAJ withholding. It also does not provide a special amnesty or cure period for past payroll treatment. The document’s focus is the publication of the Supreme Court’s approval of withholding and remittance of the correct tax from the covered allowances.

For compliance planning, the absence of a special penalty provision does not mean the withholding requirement may be ignored. The operative instruction is that the correct amount of tax required to be deducted and withheld must be withheld and remitted. Any office or withholding agent handling the covered allowances should therefore review whether its payroll process properly captures the covered payments, computes the correct tax, and supports the remittance with adequate payroll and accounting records.

Practical Steps for Judiciary Payroll and Finance Offices

First, identify all personnel receiving the monthly SAJ, an equivalent monthly special allowance, or an additional allowance from the surplus of the SAJ Fund. The coverage review should include incumbent justices, judges, judiciary officials with equivalent rank, judiciary officials receiving an equivalent allowance, and judiciary officials or employees receiving authorized additional allowances from the SAJ Fund surplus.

Second, map the covered allowances in the payroll system so that they are not treated as outside the withholding process. The Supreme Court resolution specifically approves withholding and remittance of the correct amount of tax required to be deducted and withheld from these payments. Payroll coding should therefore match the legal classification of the allowance and avoid manual treatment that may produce inconsistent withholding.

Third, coordinate among payroll, accounting, budget, and audit personnel. Because the approval arose from a Commission on Audit recommendation under Audit Observation Memorandum No. 2014-001 (SAJ), affected offices should expect the treatment of SAJ-related allowances to be reviewed not only as a tax issue but also as an audit and public funds accountability issue.

Fourth, preserve documentation showing how the allowance was identified, how the withholding was computed, and when the amount was remitted. The circular does not provide a special documentary checklist, but clear payroll and remittance records are essential when a payment is later reviewed by internal auditors, COA, or the BIR.

Why This Matters for Tax Compliance

RMC No. 58-2014 is narrow in subject matter but important in principle. It confirms that even allowances created for specific government compensation purposes may still require withholding when the law and the responsible authorities call for tax deduction and remittance. For withholding agents, the lesson is to review the exact legal basis of each allowance and not assume that a special statutory or institutional allowance is automatically free from withholding.

For accountants and tax practitioners, the searchable issues are straightforward: RMC 58-2014, withholding tax on SAJ, Special Allowance for the Judiciary tax, Supreme Court allowance withholding, and RA 9227 allowance tax treatment. The practical question is not merely whether the allowance is authorized, but whether the paying office has correctly withheld and remitted the tax due on the payment.

ASG Law Can Help With BIR Withholding Tax Compliance

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, employers, withholding agents, and regulated entities on Philippine tax compliance, payroll tax treatment, BIR issuances, and audit-ready documentation. While RMC No. 58-2014 concerns the Special Allowance for the Judiciary, the compliance discipline it requires is relevant to any organization that processes taxable compensation, allowances, benefits, or other payments subject to withholding.

For assistance in reviewing withholding tax exposure, payroll allowance treatment, BIR compliance procedures, or audit responses, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *