RMC No. 39-2014 clarifies when employee pension, provident fund, and profit-sharing plan payouts are taxable or excluded as contribution returns.

Employee pension plan payouts, provident fund dividends, and similar distributions may be taxable to employees in the year they are actually distributed, unless the payout is merely a return of the employee’s own contributions or qualifies as tax-exempt retirement benefits under Section 32(B)(6)(a) of the Tax Code. Employers, HR teams, payroll officers, CFOs, and trustees of pension, stock bonus, profit-sharing, and provident fund plans should review their payout classifications immediately because RMC No. 39-2014 took effect immediately and directly affects how employee benefit distributions are treated for income tax purposes.

What RMC No. 39-2014 Changed

RMC No. 39-2014 clarified the tax treatment of payouts made by employee pension plans, stock bonus plans, profit-sharing plans, and provident funds. The key rule is that the entire amount of benefits paid by an employer’s pension, stock bonus, or profit-sharing plan for the benefit of employees is taxable to the employee in the year of distribution, except for two specific exclusions: payouts representing a return of the employee’s personal contributions to the fund, and retirement benefits exempt under Section 32(B)(6)(a) of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended.

This clarification matters because some employee benefit plans are allowed by their charters to disburse benefits, including dividends, to beneficiary-employees. Businesses may have previously treated certain plan payouts as non-taxable because the trust itself may qualify for income tax exemption under Section 60(B). RMC No. 39-2014 makes clear that the exemption applicable to the employee trust is not the same as a blanket exemption for amounts distributed to employees.

The Circular starts from the general rule under Section 60(A) of the Tax Code: income of any kind of property held in trust is subject to income tax. It then recognizes the exception under Section 60(B), which exempts from income tax an employee’s trust forming part of a pension, stock bonus, or profit-sharing plan of an employer, provided the statutory conditions are met. However, the Circular emphasizes the further rule that amounts actually distributed to an employee or distributee are taxable in the year distributed to the extent they exceed the amount contributed by that employee or distributee.

Who Is Most Affected

The most affected taxpayers are employers maintaining employee pension plans, provident funds, stock bonus plans, profit-sharing plans, and similar retirement or employee benefit arrangements. This includes companies with collective bargaining agreements that establish provident funds for covered employees, companies with non-contributory benefit plans funded solely by the employer, and companies with contributory plans where employees may voluntarily contribute amounts to the fund.

Employees who receive dividends, resignation benefits, separation-related plan distributions, or other payouts from these plans are also directly affected. The tax consequence falls on the employee-recipient because the Circular states that the benefits are taxable on the part of the employees in the year distributed, subject only to the stated exceptions.

CFOs, corporate accountants, payroll officers, HR compensation teams, and trustees should pay close attention to this ruling when processing employee pension plan payouts, provident fund dividends, employee trust fund distributions, taxable retirement plan benefits, and tax treatment of employee contributions. These are the phrases tax managers and accountants are likely to search when determining whether a payout should be treated as taxable compensation or excluded from income.

Key Rule for Non-Contributory Pension or Provident Plans

In a non-contributory plan, where employees are not allowed to contribute to the provident plan and the employer makes the required contributions, the entire distribution to covered employees may be taxable if it does not otherwise qualify for an exemption. RMC No. 39-2014 gives the example of a provident fund established under a collective bargaining agreement between a labor union and a corporation, where the corporation is obligated to establish a trust fund and make contributions at specified rates, while the daily paid employees are not allowed to contribute.

Where that provident fund distributes dividends to covered employees, the entire amount of the dividends is subject to income tax on the part of the covered employees in the year distributed. Since there are no employee personal contributions in that example, there is no employee contribution amount to return or exclude.

The same treatment applies where an employee covered by the non-contributory provident plan resigns and receives benefits that do not qualify as tax-exempt separation or retirement benefits. In that situation, the benefits are subject to income tax on the part of the employee to the extent of the entire amount received in the year distributed.

Key Rule for Contributory Pension or Provident Plans

RMC No. 39-2014 also addresses contributory plans. In the example provided, the daily paid employees are allowed to contribute up to Twenty Thousand Pesos (Php20,000) each year to the provident plan. The presence of employee contributions changes the analysis, but only to the extent the payout actually represents a return of the employee’s own contributions.

If the provident fund distributes dividends to covered employees, those dividends do not constitute a return of the employees’ voluntary contributions. As a result, the entire amount of the dividends is subject to income tax on the part of the covered employees in the year distributed. This is an important compliance point: dividend distributions from an employee pension or provident fund should not automatically be treated as a non-taxable return of capital merely because employees have contributed to the plan.

The Circular provides a numerical example involving an employee who contributed a total of Sixty Thousand Pesos (Php60,000) to the provident fund. Upon resignation, she received benefits from the provident plan amounting to Three Hundred Thousand Pesos (Php300,000), and the benefits did not qualify as tax-exempt separation or retirement benefits. Of the Php300,000 received, Php60,000 constituted a return of her contribution to the provident fund. The taxable portion was therefore Two Hundred Forty Thousand Pesos (Php240,000), computed as Php300,000 less Php60,000.

Effective Date and Immediate Compliance Impact

RMC No. 39-2014 states that it shall take effect immediately. The document is dated May 12, 2014, and employers and plan administrators should treat the clarification as immediately applicable from its effectivity. Any company processing employee benefit payouts, provident fund dividends, pension plan benefits, stock bonus plan distributions, or profit-sharing plan distributions must classify the payment correctly at the time of distribution.

The critical timing rule is that the taxable amount is recognized in the year in which it is actually distributed. This means payroll, accounting, and tax teams should not treat the issue as merely theoretical or deferred. Once the amount is paid or distributed to the employee, the income tax consequences arise for that taxable year.

Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 39-2014 does not prescribe a special penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or separate administrative fine for non-compliance. However, the practical tax risk is significant because an incorrect non-taxable classification may result in underreported employee income and potential deficiency tax exposure under the ordinary rules of the Tax Code.

For businesses, the risk is not limited to the employee’s own tax reporting. Employers and plan administrators should evaluate whether their payroll, withholding, reporting, and documentation practices properly reflect the taxable character of the distribution. Where payouts are incorrectly excluded from taxable income, the company may face audit questions on the basis for the exclusion, the plan documents, employee contribution records, and whether the payout qualifies as tax-exempt retirement benefits under Section 32(B)(6)(a).

Practical Steps for Employers, CFOs, and Accountants

First, identify whether the plan is non-contributory or contributory. If the plan is non-contributory and employees did not make personal contributions, there is generally no employee contribution component to exclude when dividends or non-exempt benefits are distributed.

Second, separate each payout into its proper components. Dividends distributed by the fund are taxable in full according to the Circular. Benefits paid upon resignation or other distribution events are taxable in full unless they qualify as tax-exempt separation or retirement benefits, or unless a portion clearly represents a return of the employee’s own contributions.

Third, maintain exact employee contribution records. In the contributory plan example, the tax result depends on proving that Php60,000 of the Php300,000 payout represented a return of the employee’s own contribution. Without reliable contribution records, a taxpayer may have difficulty supporting the non-taxable portion of the payout.

Fourth, confirm whether the retirement or separation benefit qualifies for exemption under Section 32(B)(6)(a). RMC No. 39-2014 expressly states that its taxable treatment does not apply to retirement benefits exempt under that provision. This requires a separate legal and factual review of the applicable retirement plan, the employee’s eligibility, the reason for separation, and the statutory requirements for exemption.

Fifth, update payroll and tax reporting procedures. Companies should ensure that employee pension plan payouts, provident fund dividends, employee trust distributions, and resignation benefits from provident plans are reviewed before release. The tax treatment should be documented contemporaneously, not reconstructed only when a BIR audit begins.

Why This Matters for Philippine Businesses

RMC No. 39-2014 is especially important for businesses with long-standing provident funds, union-negotiated benefit funds, management retirement plans, or employee savings arrangements. The existence of an employee trust does not automatically make all payouts tax-free. The decisive question is what the employee actually received, whether the employee personally contributed to the fund, whether the distribution exceeds those personal contributions, and whether a specific statutory exemption applies.

For CFOs and corporate accountants, the most practical takeaway is that employee pension plan payouts must be reviewed transaction by transaction. A dividend distribution, a resignation benefit, and a tax-exempt retirement benefit may look similar as cash paid from a fund, but they may have different tax consequences.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists Philippine businesses, employers, CFOs, HR departments, and tax teams in reviewing employee benefit plans, provident fund payouts, retirement benefit structures, BIR compliance issues, and tax audit risks. Our Makati-based tax and business law practice can help determine whether a specific pension plan payout is taxable, whether an exemption under Section 32(B)(6)(a) may apply, and what documentation should be prepared before distributions are made.

For legal guidance on RMC No. 39-2014, employee pension plan payouts, provident fund dividends, retirement benefit taxation, and BIR compliance for employer-sponsored benefit plans, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *