RMC No. 39-2013 requires BIR tax assessment protests to be filed with the correct signing official, or risk being treated as void and unfiled.

Beginning April 29, 2013, taxpayers contesting a Final Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must file their protest only with the correct BIR official who signed the assessment document, either in person or by registered mail with return card. A protest letter filed with the wrong BIR office may be treated as void, without force and effect, and may not stop the assessment from becoming final, executory, and subject to collection.

What RMC No. 39-2013 changed

RMC No. 39-2013 clarified the BIR rules on where and how taxpayers must file protest letters, requests for reinvestigation, requests for reconsideration, and similar communications involving Final Assessment Notices, Formal Letters of Demand, and Final Decisions on Disputed Assessments. The practical rule is direct and strict: the protest must be filed with the Office of the concerned Regional Director, the Assistant Commissioner-Large Taxpayers Service, or the Assistant Commissioner-Enforcement Service, depending on which revenue official signed the Preliminary Assessment Notice, Final Assessment Notice, or Formal Letter of Demand.

The circular was issued because the BIR observed that some assessments already reported as unprotested under the Monthly Summary of Taxes Assessed-Unprotested, or BIR Form 40.00, were still being referred for reinvestigation. These cases had already become final and executory from the BIRโ€™s standpoint. Once an assessment becomes a delinquent account, it may be subject to enforcement collection through the summary remedies under Sections 205, 206, and 207 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended.

The clarification matters because taxpayers were claiming that they had filed protest letters before the deadline, but that the letters were filed with other BIR offices and did not reach the concerned Regional Assessment Divisions before the required reporting. RMC No. 39-2013 removes that uncertainty by identifying the proper receiving office and by establishing a database-based reporting mechanism for officially received protests.

Who is affected by the new filing rule

RMC No. 39-2013 affects any taxpayer who receives or contests a Final Assessment Notice, Formal Letter of Demand, or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment. This includes corporations, SMEs, large taxpayers, withholding agents, VAT-registered taxpayers, individual business taxpayers, professionals, and other persons assessed by the BIR for deficiency taxes.

The circular is especially important for CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, in-house counsel, and external tax advisers who handle BIR tax assessments and BIR protest letter filing. A taxpayer may have valid substantive defenses against a deficiency tax assessment, but those defenses may become practically useless if the protest is not filed with the correct BIR official and is later treated as not officially filed.

Large taxpayers must pay particular attention when the relevant assessment document was signed by the Assistant Commissioner-Large Taxpayers Service. Taxpayers under regional jurisdiction must verify the Regional Director who signed the assessment documents. Cases involving enforcement concerns must likewise be checked against the authority of the Assistant Commissioner-Enforcement Service.

Key compliance requirement: file with the correct BIR official

The central compliance requirement under RMC No. 39-2013 is that all letters of protest, requests for reinvestigation or reconsideration, and similar correspondences must be filed only by the taxpayer or the taxpayerโ€™s duly authorized representative, either in person or through registered mail with return card, with the office of the revenue official who signed the PAN, FAN, or Formal Letter of Demand.

For practical purposes, a taxpayer should check the signature block of the assessment document before filing any protest. If the document was signed by the Regional Director, the protest should be filed with the Office of that Regional Director. If the document was signed by the Assistant Commissioner-Large Taxpayers Service, the filing should be made with that office. If the document was signed by the Assistant Commissioner-Enforcement Service, the filing should be made with that office.

RMC No. 39-2013 expressly states that if these procedures are not followed, the protest letter, request for reinvestigation or reconsideration, or similar correspondence shall be considered void and without force and effect. This is the most important operational consequence for taxpayers: filing somewhere within the BIR is not enough. Filing must be made with the correct office identified by the circular.

Deadline and effective application

The circular states that all letters of protest, requests for reinvestigation or reconsideration, and similar correspondences accepted from taxpayers beginning April 29, 2013 shall be guided by RMC No. 39-2013. Therefore, for covered filings from April 29, 2013 onward, taxpayers and representatives must comply with the specific filing channel required by the circular.

RMC No. 39-2013 does not create a new protest period in the text of the circular. Instead, it refers to the existing deadline under Section 228 of the NIRC, as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 12-99. The circular focuses on the place and manner of receipt, official recording, and reporting of protests, not on changing the substantive period for filing a protest.

BIR reporting and database requirements

RMC No. 39-2013 also imposes internal reporting duties on the concerned revenue officials. The Regional Director, Assistant Commissioner-Large Taxpayers Service, and Assistant Commissioner-Enforcement Service are made primarily responsible for ensuring the preparation of a complete and accurate report on all protests filed in their respective offices.

These reports must be submitted to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue every Monday of each week in hard and soft copies. The soft copy is required to be emailed to the designated BIR email addresses stated in the circular. The report format is the Report on Protest Letters Received Covering Final Assessment Notices and Final Decisions on Disputed Assessments, attached as Annex A to the circular.

Based on the weekly reports, the Office of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue is required to create a database of all letters of protest, requests for reinvestigation or reconsideration, and similar correspondences received by different offices of the BIR. The database may be used to provide accurate information to concerned officials and employees, subject to the approval of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and upon written request of the concerned revenue official.

Even when no protest letter or request for reinvestigation or reconsideration has been received during a given week, the prescribed report must still be accomplished and submitted within the same period with the notation that no letter of protest or request for reinvestigation or reconsideration was received.

Consequences of non-compliance

The consequence of non-compliance is severe. A protest letter or similar communication allegedly filed by a taxpayer but not included in the BIR database shall be deemed not officially filed with the Bureau. It shall not be used as a basis for granting any request for reinvestigation or reconsideration of any Final Assessment Notice or Final Decision on Disputed Assessment issued against the taxpayer.

This can expose the taxpayer to the risk that the assessment will be treated as final, executory, and demandable. Once the assessment becomes a delinquent account, the BIR may proceed with enforcement collection through summary remedies under Sections 205, 206, and 207 of the NIRC. These summary remedies may include collection actions available to the BIR under the Tax Code for delinquent tax liabilities.

In practical terms, a taxpayer who files a protest with the wrong office may later face the argument that no valid protest was filed at all. This can lead to loss of administrative remedies, denial of reinvestigation or reconsideration, and immediate collection pressure.

Practical steps for taxpayers and tax departments

Businesses should update their BIR assessment response procedures to ensure that every protest letter is addressed and filed with the exact office of the official who signed the PAN, FAN, or Formal Letter of Demand. The signature page of the assessment document should be reviewed before the protest is finalized.

Taxpayers filing in person should secure proof of receipt from the correct receiving office. Taxpayers filing through registered mail should use registered mail with return card, as expressly recognized in RMC No. 39-2013. Internal tax teams should preserve the registry receipt, return card, receiving copy, authorization documents, and all transmittal records.

Corporate accountants and CFOs should also maintain a tax assessment docket that records the date of receipt of the PAN, FAN, Formal Letter of Demand, FDDA, the applicable protest deadline under existing rules, the office and signatory involved, the date of filing, and the proof of filing. Search terms such as BIR protest letter filing, Final Assessment Notice protest, request for reinvestigation BIR, Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, and BIR Form 40.00 should be built into internal tax compliance references so that staff can quickly identify the governing procedure.

Where a taxpayer has already filed a protest with an office other than the proper office identified in RMC No. 39-2013, the taxpayer should immediately verify whether the protest was officially recorded and whether it appears in the relevant BIR reporting system. Delay can be costly because the circular treats unrecorded protests as not officially filed.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco can help

RMC No. 39-2013 is a reminder that tax assessment defense is not only about legal arguments. It is also about exact compliance with BIR filing procedure, proof of receipt, deadline management, and proper documentation. A meritorious protest may be compromised if it is filed with the wrong office or cannot be shown to have been officially received.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporations, CFOs, accountants, and in-house legal teams in responding to BIR assessments, preparing protest letters, requests for reinvestigation or reconsideration, and managing tax controversy deadlines from administrative protest through litigation when necessary. For assistance with Final Assessment Notices, Formal Letters of Demand, FDDAs, and BIR protest compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *