RMC No. 38-2013 clarifies that Legal Petition Notices do not suspend BIR audits and cannot replace proper protests to PANs, FLDs, and FANs.
Taxpayers cannot stop, defer, or delay a BIR audit simply by sending a Legal Petition Notice, Declaration, or similar document questioning the validity of an electronic Letter of Authority. RMC No. 38-2013 makes clear that the audit and assessment process will continue despite the receipt of these documents, and that taxpayers must use the proper protest procedures under the tax rules once assessment notices are issued.
What RMC No. 38-2013 Changed for BIR Audits and eLAs
RMC No. 38-2013 addresses a specific practice observed by the BIR: taxpayers and practitioners were sending Legal Petition Notices, also referred to as LPNs, Declarations, and similar documents, to question the validity of electronic Letters of Authority or eLAs issued for tax audits. The BIR stated that these taxpayers and practitioners appeared to believe that the filing or sending of such documents would stop or defer the investigation process.
The key clarification is direct: the normal audit or investigation process arising from a duly issued eLA will not be suspended merely because the BIR receives an LPN relating to the case. In practical terms, a taxpayer under audit should not assume that sending an LPN to the BIR will freeze the examination of books, records, tax returns, withholding tax compliance, VAT filings, income tax liabilities, or other internal revenue tax liabilities covered by the authority to audit.
The circular also states that the National Office will no longer entertain any LPN questioning the validity and enforceability of an eLA duly issued by the concerned Regional Director for the audit of a taxpayer within the region. The BIR referred to RMC No. 6-2013 as the prior clarification on the issue. This means that, for taxpayers audited under eLAs issued by the proper regional authority, the BIR position is that an LPN is not the procedural vehicle to block or overturn the audit.
Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 38-2013
This issuance is most relevant to businesses, corporate taxpayers, withholding agents, VAT-registered taxpayers, professionals, and other persons already undergoing a BIR audit under an electronic Letter of Authority. It also affects tax practitioners and consultants who prepare or advise on Legal Petition Notices, Declarations, and similar documents challenging eLAs.
For CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel, the practical consequence is important: a company should not treat an LPN as a substitute for audit cooperation, document production, or a proper protest. If the company receives an eLA, it must manage the audit as an active tax controversy, gather records, evaluate exposure, monitor deadlines, and prepare for the formal assessment process. Search phrases such as BIR eLA validity, Legal Petition Notice BIR audit, BIR audit assessment process, Preliminary Assessment Notice protest, and Final Assessment Notice protest are directly implicated by this circular.
Effect on Subpoena Duces Tecum and Continuing Investigation
RMC No. 38-2013 states that there shall be no impediment to the investigation of the taxpayer’s internal revenue tax liabilities and the eventual recommendation for the issuance of a Subpoena Duces Tecum, if warranted, in accordance with RMO Nos. 45-2010 and 88-2010.
This is a significant warning for taxpayers. If a taxpayer refuses or fails to provide records because it believes that an LPN has suspended the audit, the BIR may still proceed with enforcement steps. A Subpoena Duces Tecum may be recommended where appropriate. Businesses should therefore treat requests for records, audit notices, and related communications seriously, even if they have already submitted a letter, petition, declaration, or other objection to the audit authority.
Proper Protest Deadlines After PAN, FLD, and FAN
RMC No. 38-2013 also clarifies the taxpayer’s remedy once the assessment process reaches the notice stage. Upon receipt of a Preliminary Assessment Notice, or PAN, or upon receipt of a Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice, or FLD and FAN, the taxpayer is given fifteen (15) or thirty (30) days, as the case may be, to rebut the assessment upon compliance with the requirements for filing a protest under RR No. 12-99.
The circular does not create a new tax rate, tax base, or filing return. Instead, its most important compliance effect concerns procedure and timing. A taxpayer must distinguish between objecting to the authority to audit and filing a valid protest against an assessment. Once the BIR issues the relevant assessment notices, the taxpayer must act within the applicable fifteen (15)-day or thirty (30)-day period, depending on the stage and applicable procedure. Missing these windows can seriously prejudice the taxpayer’s ability to contest the assessment administratively.
For businesses, the practical lesson is that every PAN, FLD, and FAN must be date-stamped, logged, and immediately reviewed. The tax team should determine the exact deadline to respond, identify the factual and legal issues, gather supporting documents, and prepare a response that complies with the requirements of RR No. 12-99. A generalized LPN or declaration addressed to the wrong office is not enough.
Premature and Invalid Protests Addressed to the National Office
RMC No. 38-2013 states that any LPN, Declaration, or similar document protesting an assessment addressed to the Commissioner or any official in the National Office, without the issuance of a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment from the regional office, shall be considered premature and invalid.
This point matters because some taxpayers may believe that elevating a dispute directly to the Commissioner or National Office strengthens their position. The circular warns against that approach when the regional assessment process has not yet resulted in a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment, or FDDA. In that situation, the BIR’s position is that the filing is premature and invalid, not a valid protest that preserves rights.
For corporate taxpayers, this means the protest route must be carefully matched to the procedural stage of the case. Before an FDDA, the taxpayer should focus on responding properly to the PAN, FLD, and FAN through the prescribed administrative process. Only after the proper decision or action is issued should the taxpayer evaluate the next legal remedy.
Use Only BIR-Accredited Tax Agents and Practitioners
The circular also reminds taxpayers that, under Section 9 of RR No. 11-2006, as amended, and as clarified in RMC No. 6-2013, the BIR can refuse to transact official business with tax agents or practitioners who are not accredited before it. The responsibility is placed on taxpayers to ensure that the tax agents or practitioners they engage are accredited with the BIR.
This is not merely an administrative detail. If a company relies on a non-accredited or incompetent consultant, the taxpayer may suffer the consequences of defective filings, missed deadlines, invalid protests, or unsupported representations made to the BIR. RMC No. 38-2013 specifically warns taxpayers to scrutinize the credibility and competence of consultants, as well as the veracity of the contents of any LPN, Declaration, or similar document before signing it.
Penalties and Adverse Consequences for Improper LPNs
RMC No. 38-2013 does not prescribe a specific new monetary penalty for filing an LPN. However, it expressly warns that these documents will not gain merit and may lead to adverse consequences, including the filing of the necessary charges in court. This warning is especially relevant where the contents of a document are false, misleading, obstructive, or otherwise used in an attempt to thwart or undermine the BIR’s lawful authority.
Taxpayers should therefore avoid signing template objections, broad declarations, or aggressive notices without confirming their factual and legal basis. The safer approach is to review the authority to audit, comply with lawful audit procedures, prepare a documented defense on the merits, and file the correct protest within the applicable period when assessment notices are issued.
Practical Steps for Businesses Under BIR Audit
Businesses that receive an eLA or any BIR audit communication should first verify the scope, taxable year, issuing office, and named revenue officers. Second, the company should preserve and organize accounting records, invoices, receipts, withholding tax returns, VAT returns, income tax returns, reconciliations, and supporting schedules relevant to the audit. Third, management should assign responsibility to a qualified internal tax officer or external BIR-accredited practitioner.
Fourth, the company should not rely on an LPN or Declaration as a tool to suspend the audit. RMC No. 38-2013 makes clear that the BIR audit process will continue notwithstanding receipt of an LPN. Fifth, once a PAN, FLD, or FAN is received, the company must compute the applicable fifteen (15)-day or thirty (30)-day response period and prepare a proper protest or rebuttal under RR No. 12-99. Sixth, if a dispute reaches the FDDA stage, the company should reassess available administrative or judicial remedies based on the actual decision received.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 38-2013 is a reminder that BIR audits are won through proper procedure, credible documentation, and timely tax controversy strategy, not through informal notices that the BIR considers premature or invalid. For companies facing eLAs, PANs, FLDs, FANs, subpoena issues, or disputed assessments, early legal review can prevent missed deadlines and avoid defective filings that may weaken the taxpayer’s position.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises Philippine businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel on BIR audits, tax assessments, administrative protests, tax litigation strategy, and compliance risk management. If your business has received an eLA, PAN, FLD, FAN, or other BIR audit notice, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Philippine tax and business law team that can help protect your rights while keeping your company compliant.