RMC No. 31-2012 requires strict computation of BIR compromise penalties on dishonored checks and warns of criminal referral if unpaid.

Taxpayers who pay internal revenue taxes by check must ensure that the check is fully funded and honored, because a dishonored check can expose the taxpayer not only to collection issues but also to the compromise penalties prescribed under the BIR’s Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties. RMC No. 31-2012 reiterates that BIR offices must strictly compute and collect the correct penalties on dishonored checks, without reducing or changing the amount unless the proper BIR approving authority allows it.

What RMC No. 31-2012 Changed for Dishonored Check Penalties

RMC No. 31-2012 did not create a new tax rate or a new tax return. Its immediate compliance impact is that it tightened enforcement of existing BIR rules on the computation of compromise penalties for dishonored checks. The BIR noted that penalties on dishonored checks had been under-collected because concerned offices failed to strictly follow the policies and guidelines under Revenue Memorandum Order No. 19-2007 dated August 8, 2007.

The practical consequence is straightforward: when a taxpayer’s check payment is dishonored, the BIR officer handling the matter should not arbitrarily reduce, change, or negotiate a different compromise penalty. The amount must follow the Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties under RMO No. 19-2007, unless a lower or different compromise amount is approved by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or another authorized BIR official, depending on the case.

For Philippine businesses, this matters because tax payments by check remain common in corporate compliance, especially for businesses coordinating payments through accounting departments, treasury teams, messengers, or authorized representatives. A dishonored check may arise from insufficient funds, account closure, technical bank issues, signatory problems, or mismatched account instructions. RMC No. 31-2012 confirms that the BIR’s internal response should be stricter and more uniform.

Who Is Affected by RMC No. 31-2012

RMC No. 31-2012 affects taxpayers and BIR personnel dealing with dishonored checks issued for tax obligations. The most affected taxpayers are corporations, SMEs, withholding agents, employers, VAT-registered businesses, percentage tax taxpayers, excise taxpayers, and other entities that pay taxes through checks or authorize representatives to settle BIR liabilities.

The issuance is also important for CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, bookkeepers, and in-house counsel because it directly concerns payment controls. A tax return may be filed, and a check may be delivered, but if the check is dishonored, the taxpayer may still face penalties and possible escalation. Businesses searching for “BIR dishonored check penalty,” “RMC 31-2012 dishonored checks,” “BIR compromise penalty dishonored check,” “RMO 19-2007 compromise penalties,” and “tax payment check bounced Philippines” should understand that the BIR is directed to impose the prescribed penalty strictly.

Key Compliance Rule: Penalties Must Follow the Prescribed Schedule

The central rule reiterated by RMC No. 31-2012 is that compromise penalties for criminal violations of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended, not involving fraud, must strictly follow the amounts in the Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties attached to RMO No. 19-2007.

The Circular specifically reiterates that, in no case, shall the compromise penalty differ from the amount specified in the Schedule unless duly approved by the Commissioner, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, or, in proper cases, the Regional Director. This is the main operational restriction: field-level discretion is limited. A BIR officer cannot simply accept a lower compromise penalty on a dishonored check without the required approval.

RMC No. 31-2012 also reiterates that compromise penalties are suggested amounts for settlement of criminal liability. Because of that legal character, they may not be imposed or exacted in the same way as a tax assessment. However, if the taxpayer refuses to pay the suggested compromise penalty, the violation must be referred to the appropriate office for criminal action.

Can the BIR Accept a Higher or Lower Compromise Amount?

Yes, but the authority and approval rules matter. RMC No. 31-2012 reiterates that the schedule of compromise penalties under RMO No. 19-2007 does not prevent the Commissioner or the Commissioner’s duly authorized representative from accepting a compromise amount higher than the prescribed amount.

A lower compromise offer, however, may be accepted only after approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or the concerned Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner, or Regional Director. This distinction is critical for businesses negotiating with the BIR after a dishonored check incident. A taxpayer cannot assume that a lower settlement proposal will be valid merely because it was discussed with or received by a BIR officer. Proper approval must exist.

Penalties and Criminal Exposure for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 31-2012 reminds taxpayers and BIR personnel of Section 275 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. Under Section 275, any person who violates any provision of the Tax Code or any rule or regulation issued by the Department of Finance, for which no specific penalty is provided by law, may, upon conviction for each act or omission, be punished by a fine of not more than P1,000 or imprisonment of not more than six months, or both.

This reminder is significant because a dishonored check issue should not be treated as a purely clerical or banking inconvenience. Depending on the circumstances, refusal to settle the suggested compromise penalty may result in referral for criminal action. For corporate taxpayers, the risk is not limited to the amount of the check. There may also be internal accountability issues involving the officers, employees, or representatives who caused or allowed the dishonored payment.

Effective Date and Immediate Compliance Impact

RMC No. 31-2012 is dated July 9, 2012. The compliance message is immediate and continuing: BIR officers and all concerned persons are directed to strictly comply with the rules on computing penalties on dishonored checks. Although the issuance is administrative in tone, its impact is practical for any taxpayer whose check payment to the BIR is dishonored.

For businesses, the continuing relevance is that old dishonored check practices, informal negotiations, or expectations of reduced penalties may not protect the taxpayer. The BIR’s own offices were reminded that under-collection of penalties is not acceptable and that the prescribed compromise penalty schedule must be followed unless proper approval is obtained.

Practical Steps for Businesses Paying BIR Taxes by Check

First, businesses should verify funding before releasing any check for tax payment. Treasury and accounting teams should confirm cleared balances, signatory authority, account status, and bank cut-off limitations before a check is delivered to the BIR or an authorized collecting bank.

Second, companies should treat BIR checks differently from ordinary supplier checks. A dishonored supplier check may create commercial consequences, but a dishonored tax payment check can create BIR penalties and potential criminal referral. The approval workflow should therefore require final confirmation from both accounting and treasury before the check is issued.

Third, if a check is dishonored, the company should immediately determine the reason for dishonor, replace the payment if still allowed, coordinate with the proper BIR office, and document all corrective steps. The company should also ask what specific compromise penalty is being applied under the relevant schedule and whether any deviation from that amount has been properly approved.

Fourth, businesses should avoid relying on verbal assurances that a lower penalty will be accepted. RMC No. 31-2012 makes clear that a compromise penalty lower than the prescribed amount requires approval by the proper BIR authority. Without that approval, the taxpayer may remain exposed to further enforcement action.

Finally, companies should update internal tax payment policies. The persons responsible for preparing checks, approving disbursements, filing tax returns, and coordinating with the BIR should know that dishonored checks are not merely accounting errors. They can trigger compromise penalties and possible referral for criminal action if not resolved properly.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 31-2012 is a reminder that BIR compliance is not only about filing the correct return; it is also about ensuring that tax payments are valid, honored, and properly documented. A dishonored check can quickly become a penalty and enforcement issue, especially where the taxpayer delays, disputes the compromise amount, or relies on informal arrangements.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, accountants, CFOs, and in-house counsel in handling BIR compliance issues, tax payment disputes, compromise penalty concerns, and communications with revenue officers. For guidance on dishonored check penalties, BIR assessments, compromise penalties, or tax compliance controls, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult our tax and business law team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *