RMC No. 9-2012 adopts COA guidance requiring forfeited real properties with one lump valuation to be recorded separately by prorating tax liability by fair market value.

Government accountants and BIR personnel handling forfeited real properties must separately record each property even when several parcels were originally lumped together and assigned only one aggregate valuation equivalent to a taxpayer’s liability. RMC No. 9-2012 clarifies that, for accounting purposes, the total tax liability must be prorated among the forfeited real properties based on their fair market values. This matters because a single lump-sum entry can distort the National Government books, impair accountability over each property, and create difficulty in tracking, disposing, reconciling, or auditing forfeited assets.

What RMC No. 9-2012 Changed

RMC No. 9-2012 circularized the full text of the Commission on Audit’s reply to the Bureau of Internal Revenue on the recording of forfeited real properties that were lumped and assigned a single valuation in the National Government books of the BIR. The issue was practical and accounting-driven: several real properties had been forfeited in favor of the BIR, but instead of being individually valued in the BIR books, they were grouped together and assigned one valuation equivalent to the related tax liability.

The key rule is that the tax liability should not remain as one undifferentiated amount for multiple properties. Instead, the tax liability must be allocated or prorated among the real properties based on their fair market values. This allows each forfeited property to be separately recorded in the BIR books at an allocated amount, using a pro rata computation tied to the relative value of each property.

For businesses and tax practitioners, the significance of RMC No. 9-2012 is not that it imposes a new tax rate or new tax return filing obligation. Rather, it clarifies how forfeited real properties are accounted for once they enter government books. This is important in tax enforcement, distraint, levy, forfeiture, settlement, and audit situations where tax liabilities may be satisfied or represented by real property assets rather than cash payments.

Who Is Affected by the COA Guidance

The direct audience of RMC No. 9-2012 consists of internal revenue officers, BIR employees, government accountants, and other personnel involved in recording, monitoring, and reporting forfeited properties. The circular is addressed to all internal revenue officers, employees, and others concerned, which makes it relevant to BIR accounting, collection, legal, operations, and audit functions.

Businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel should also understand the ruling because it shows how the government may account for real properties forfeited in favor of the BIR. Taxpayers with delinquent tax liabilities, businesses involved in tax collection disputes, owners of levied or forfeited properties, and advisers handling compromise, collection, or enforcement matters may encounter this issue when multiple properties are applied against a single tax liability.

The most affected private-sector parties are not ordinary taxpayers filing routine returns, but taxpayers facing BIR collection proceedings involving real property. These may include corporations with assessed tax liabilities, real estate owners whose properties are subject to levy or forfeiture, and businesses negotiating or reviewing the accounting consequences of property-based satisfaction of tax obligations.

The Required Method: Prorate the Tax Liability Based on Fair Market Value

The Commission on Audit advised that the tax liability must be prorated based on the fair market values of the forfeited real properties. In the example circularized under RMC No. 9-2012, three properties had fair market values and zonal values of P13,500.00, P82,500.00, and P1,250.00, for a total fair market value and zonal value of P97,250.00. The total tax liability to be allocated was P83,164.53.

Using the pro rata approach, the property valued at P13,500.00 represented 14% of the total and was assigned P11,643.03 of the tax liability. The property valued at P82,500.00 represented 85% of the total and was assigned P70,689.85 of the tax liability. The property valued at P1,250.00 represented 1% of the total and was assigned P831.65 of the tax liability. The total allocation remained P83,164.53, or 100% of the tax liability.

This computation is the operational core of RMC No. 9-2012. Where multiple forfeited properties are covered by one lumped valuation, the BIR should determine each property’s share in the total value and then apply that share to the total tax liability. The result is a separate recorded amount for each property, even though the tax liability originally appeared as one aggregate amount.

Key Figures and Accounting Treatment in RMC No. 9-2012

The figures in the COA example are specific and important. The combined fair market value of the properties was P97,250.00. The combined zonal value was also P97,250.00. The tax liability to be allocated was P83,164.53. The allocation was made at pro rata rates of 14%, 85%, and 1%, corresponding to allocated amounts of P11,643.03, P70,689.85, and P831.65.

The principle is that each property must be matched with a proportionate amount of the tax liability. This prevents the BIR books from showing a single tax-liability-based amount without a meaningful breakdown per property. For internal controls, audit trail, and asset monitoring, this allocation is essential because each real property is a distinct government asset once forfeited in favor of the BIR.

For search purposes, accountants and taxpayers may encounter this topic using terms such as RMC 9-2012 forfeited real properties, BIR recording of forfeited properties, COA guidance on BIR books, tax liability prorated based on fair market value, and National Government books BIR forfeited assets.

Effective Date and Compliance Deadline

RMC No. 9-2012 is dated February 24, 2012. The COA reply circularized in the issuance is dated February 10, 2012. The circular does not provide a separate future effectivity date, transition period, filing deadline, or taxpayer submission deadline. Instead, all concerned were enjoined to be guided accordingly.

Because the circular concerns accounting guidance for BIR books, the practical compliance point is immediate application by concerned BIR offices when recording forfeited real properties that were previously lumped and assigned a single valuation. For private taxpayers, the circular does not create a new filing deadline or payment date. Its relevance arises when reviewing how forfeited properties are reflected in government records, particularly where one tax liability covers multiple properties.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 9-2012 does not state a specific penalty, surcharge, interest, compromise penalty, or criminal consequence for failure to follow the accounting treatment described in the circular. It is an internal guidance circularizing the COA’s accounting advice on how to record forfeited real properties in the National Government books of the BIR.

However, the absence of a specific penalty does not make the guidance unimportant. Incorrect or lumped recording of forfeited properties may create audit, reconciliation, asset control, and accountability issues within government records. For taxpayers and counsel reviewing forfeiture-related matters, inaccurate recording may also complicate the verification of which property was applied against which portion of the tax liability.

Practical Steps for Businesses, Accountants, and Tax Counsel

Businesses dealing with BIR collection actions involving real property should keep a clear schedule of each property, its fair market value, zonal value, assessed value if relevant, title details, and the tax liability to which it relates. Where several properties are involved in satisfying one tax liability, the taxpayer’s records should be capable of showing how the total liability is allocated among the properties.

Corporate accountants and CFOs should not assume that a forfeiture involving multiple properties will be treated as one indivisible asset transaction for all purposes. RMC No. 9-2012 shows that, at least for BIR recording in National Government books, separate property-level allocation is required using a pro rata method based on fair market value.

In-house counsel should also preserve documentation showing the basis of valuation. Because the COA guidance uses fair market values to compute the pro rata rate, disputes may arise if there is disagreement over the values used for each property. Relevant documents may include tax declarations, zonal value certifications, appraisal documents, BIR collection records, notices of levy or forfeiture, and internal accounting schedules.

Where a taxpayer is negotiating with the BIR or reviewing the consequences of forfeiture, counsel should request or prepare a property-by-property allocation table. That table should identify the total tax liability, the fair market value of each property, the percentage share of each property, and the allocated tax liability per property. This mirrors the method recognized in RMC No. 9-2012 and provides a clearer audit trail for both the taxpayer and the government.

Why This Matters in BIR Collection and Real Property Forfeiture

RMC No. 9-2012 is a short issuance, but it addresses a real problem in tax enforcement accounting. When real properties are forfeited for tax liabilities, one aggregate amount may be administratively convenient, but it is not enough for proper government accounting. Each property must be separately identifiable in the books, and the corresponding value assigned to each property must be rationally derived.

The ruling is also a reminder that tax liabilities and property values are not always identical. In the circularized example, the total value of the properties was P97,250.00, while the tax liability was P83,164.53. The solution was not to record each property at its full fair market value as the tax liability amount, but to allocate the tax liability proportionately according to each property’s share in the total fair market value.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, property owners, corporate officers, and accounting teams on BIR assessments, collection remedies, tax enforcement, compromise, levy, forfeiture, and documentation issues. RMC No. 9-2012 is highly relevant when a taxpayer needs to understand how forfeited real properties should be reflected, allocated, and reconciled against a tax liability.

For companies facing BIR collection action or reviewing the tax and accounting consequences of property forfeiture, ASG Law can assist in preparing allocation schedules, reviewing BIR records, coordinating with accountants, and developing a legal strategy for assessment, collection, or settlement concerns. For assistance with BIR compliance and tax enforcement matters, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *