RMC No. 49-2011 clarifies 2% EWT on PhilHealth case rates, hospital withholding on doctors’ fees, and 5% VAT withholding rules.
Hospitals, clinics, medical practitioners, and PhilHealth-accredited facilities must properly separate who withholds tax when PhilHealth benefits are paid under the case rate system. RMC No. 49-2011 clarifies that when the entire PhilHealth case rate is paid directly to the hospital or clinic, PhilHealth withholds 2% expanded withholding tax on the whole case rate, while the hospital or clinic must withhold 10% or 15% expanded withholding tax on the doctors’ professional fees. For government hospitals and VATable professional fees, the 5% final withholding VAT on government money payments may also apply.
What RMC No. 49-2011 Changed for PhilHealth Payments
RMC No. 49-2011 further clarifies the tax treatment of payments made by the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation, or PHIC, in connection with medical benefits availment. The clarification is important because RMC No. 38-2011 covered expanded withholding tax on payments made by PHIC where benefit payments were made separately to medical practitioners and hospitals or clinics. RMC No. 49-2011 addresses what happens when the New PhilHealth Case Rate system requires the entire case rate amount to be paid directly to the facility.
The main rule is specific: for medical cases and surgical procedures where the entire case rate amount is required to be paid directly to the facility under the New PhilHealth Case Rate pursuant to PhilHealth Circular Nos. 011-2011, 011-A-2011, and 011-B-2011, the expanded withholding tax applies to the entire case rate payment at the rate of 2%.
This means that for case rate payments, PHIC does not split the withholding between facility fees and professional fees at the time it pays the facility. Instead, PHIC withholds 2% from the entire case rate paid to the hospital, clinic, or facility. The hospital or clinic, because it controls the fund from which doctors’ professional fees will be paid, becomes the withholding agent for the doctors’ professional fees.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 49-2011
The ruling directly affects PHIC, PhilHealth-accredited hospitals and clinics, medical practitioners, government hospitals, private hospitals, finance teams of healthcare facilities, and tax officers responsible for BIR Form No. 2307 and BIR Form No. 2306 issuance. It also affects accountants and CFOs handling PhilHealth case rate payments, professional fee remittances, expanded withholding tax on doctors’ fees, and 5% withholding VAT on government money payments.
For hospitals and clinics, the practical consequence is that receiving the entire case rate from PHIC also carries a withholding responsibility. The facility must determine the proper withholding tax on payments to doctors or medical practitioners. Depending on the applicable facts, the hospital or clinic must withhold 10% or 15% expanded withholding tax on the medical practitioner’s professional fees.
For medical practitioners, the ruling affects how their professional fee payments are documented and how creditable withholding tax is reported. Depending on whether the professional fee is VATable and whether a sworn declaration of gross income was submitted, the tax base and applicable withholding treatment must be carefully computed.
Rules for Non-Case Rate PhilHealth Payments
Where the payment is not covered by the Case Rate Program and the benefit components are separately identifiable, PHIC withholds separately on professional fees and facility fees. The ruling gives an illustration involving a patient whose PhilHealth benefits consisted of P4,000.00 in professional fees and P10,000.00 in facility fees, for a total of P14,000.00.
For the professional fees, the ruling assumes that the P4,000.00 professional fee is subject to VAT and is therefore VAT-inclusive. The tax base is computed by dividing P4,000.00 by 112%, resulting in P3,571.43. Assuming the medical practitioner did not submit a sworn declaration of gross income, the 15% withholding tax applies. The expanded withholding tax on professional fees is therefore P535.71.
For the facility fees, PHIC withholds 2% expanded withholding tax on P10,000.00, resulting in withholding tax of P200.00. In that illustration, PHIC must issue two separate BIR Form No. 2307 certificates: one to the hospital or clinic for the P200.00 withholding on the facility fee, and another under the medical practitioner’s name for the P535.71 withholding on professional fees.
The same illustration also confirms the VAT withholding treatment. PHIC must withhold 5% VAT on government money payments for the professional fee component, computed as P3,571.43 multiplied by 5%, or P178.57. PHIC must issue BIR Form No. 2306 under the medical practitioner’s name for the final VAT on government money payment amounting to P178.57. However, there is no 5% withholding VAT on the facility fee because medical, dental, hospital, and veterinary services not rendered by professionals are covered by the VAT exemption under Section 109(G) of the Tax Code.
Rules for PhilHealth Case Rate Payments
For benefits covered under the Case Rate Program, the tax treatment changes because the entire case rate is paid to the facility provider. In the ruling’s illustration, the patient was confined for Dengue II, described as Dengue Fever and DHF Grades III and IV, with a case rate of P16,000.00 under PhilHealth Circular Nos. 011-2011, 011-A-2011, and 011-B-2011.
Because the entire case rate is paid to the hospital, PHIC withholds 2% expanded withholding tax on the whole P16,000.00 case rate. The withholding tax is P320.00. PHIC is required to issue only one BIR Form No. 2307 to the hospital or clinic for the P320.00 withholding.
No 5% withholding VAT applies to the entire case rate in that example because the payment is for medical, dental, hospital, and veterinary services not rendered by professionals, which are covered by Section 109(G) of the Tax Code. The ruling therefore makes clear that the entire case rate paid to the facility is not automatically subject to 5% withholding VAT merely because PHIC is a government entity. The nature of the service and the VAT exemption must still be considered.
Hospital Withholding on Doctors’ Professional Fees
Once the hospital or clinic receives the entire case rate and later pays the doctor’s professional fees, the hospital or clinic must withhold the applicable expanded withholding tax. In the case rate example, the ruling assumes that the professional fee for the patient’s case is P4,800.00. Because the professional fee is assumed to be VATable, the P4,800.00 is treated as VAT-inclusive and the tax base is computed by dividing it by 112%, resulting in P4,285.71.
Assuming the medical practitioner did not submit a sworn declaration of gross income, the applicable rate is 15%. The hospital’s withholding on the professional fee is therefore P4,285.71 multiplied by 15%, or P642.86. Hospital X must issue one BIR Form No. 2307 to the medical practitioner for the withholding on professional fees amounting to P642.86.
This is the key operational point for hospitals and clinics: when the facility receives the entire case rate from PHIC, it cannot treat the doctor’s professional fee as a mere internal allocation without withholding consequences. The facility is the party in control of the fund and must withhold the applicable 10% or 15% expanded withholding tax when it pays the medical practitioner.
5% Final Withholding VAT on Government Money Payments
RMC No. 49-2011 also confirms that PHIC must comply with the 5% withholding VAT on government money payments under Revenue Regulations No. 16-2005. For VAT exemption purposes, Section 109(G) of the Tax Code covers only medical, dental, hospital, and veterinary services, except those rendered by professionals. This distinction matters because payments to professionals may still be subject to 5% final withholding VAT if they are not VAT-exempt.
The ruling states that PHIC should withhold the 5% VAT on money payments to professionals and other facilities, if any, who are not VAT-exempt. In the non-case rate illustration, this resulted in 5% VAT withholding of P178.57 on the medical practitioner’s VAT-exclusive professional fee base of P3,571.43.
For a government hospital paying professional fees out of the case rate fund, the hospital must also consider the 5% withholding VAT on government money payments. In the case rate illustration, where the professional fee was P4,800.00 and the VAT-exclusive base was P4,285.71, the 5% VAT withholding was P214.29. In that case, the government hospital must issue BIR Form No. 2307 for the P642.86 income tax withholding and BIR Form No. 2306 for the P214.29 final VAT on government money payment.
Required BIR Forms and Documentation
For non-case rate payments, PHIC may need to issue separate BIR Form No. 2307 certificates to the hospital or clinic and to the medical practitioner. In the illustration, PHIC issued one BIR Form No. 2307 to the hospital or clinic for the P200.00 withholding on facility fees and another BIR Form No. 2307 to the medical practitioner for the P535.71 withholding on professional fees. PHIC also issued BIR Form No. 2306 to the medical practitioner for the P178.57 final VAT on government money payment.
For case rate payments, PHIC issues BIR Form No. 2307 to the hospital or clinic for the 2% withholding on the entire case rate. The hospital or clinic then issues BIR Form No. 2307 to the medical practitioner for the withholding on professional fees. If the hospital is a government hospital and the professional fee is covered by 5% withholding VAT on government money payments, the hospital must also issue BIR Form No. 2306 to the medical practitioner.
Penalties and Risk Areas for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 49-2011 does not state a special penalty schedule. However, the compliance risk is clear: failure to withhold the correct expanded withholding tax, failure to apply 5% final withholding VAT where required, or failure to issue the proper BIR Form No. 2307 or BIR Form No. 2306 may expose the withholding agent to the ordinary consequences for withholding tax non-compliance under the Tax Code and BIR rules.
The most common risk areas are misclassifying case rate payments, failing to treat the hospital or clinic as withholding agent for doctors’ professional fees, applying 2% only to a portion of the case rate instead of the entire case rate, failing to compute the VAT-exclusive base where professional fees are VAT-inclusive, and overlooking the 5% withholding VAT on government money payments involving professionals.
Practical Steps for Hospitals, Clinics, Doctors, and PHIC Payment Teams
Hospitals and clinics should first determine whether each PhilHealth benefit payment is covered by the Case Rate Program. If it is not covered by the Case Rate Program, the payment components for professional fees and facility fees must be separately reviewed for expanded withholding tax and VAT withholding. If it is covered by the Case Rate Program and the entire amount is paid to the facility, PHIC withholds 2% on the entire case rate and the hospital or clinic must withhold 10% or 15% on the doctors’ professional fees when paid.
Second, accounting teams should verify whether the professional fee amount is VAT-inclusive. Where the fee is VAT-inclusive, the tax base used in the ruling is computed by dividing the amount by 112%. This affects both the expanded withholding tax computation and the 5% withholding VAT computation.
Third, hospitals and clinics should obtain and file any sworn declarations of gross income from medical practitioners because the applicable withholding rate may be 10% or 15%, depending on the circumstances. The ruling’s illustrations apply 15% on the assumption that the medical practitioner did not submit a sworn declaration of gross income.
Fourth, government hospitals must separately check whether the 5% final withholding VAT on government money payments applies to professional fees. Section 109(G) protects medical, dental, hospital, and veterinary services from VAT, except those rendered by professionals. Payments to doctors and other professionals therefore require careful review.
Finally, PHIC-accredited facilities should reconcile BIR Form No. 2307 and BIR Form No. 2306 issuance with the actual flow of funds. The party withholding the tax must issue the correct certificate to the correct payee. This is essential for both BIR audit defense and the payee’s tax credit documentation.
ASG Law Can Assist with PhilHealth, Withholding Tax, and BIR Compliance
RMC No. 49-2011 is a technical but highly practical ruling for healthcare providers because it affects daily PhilHealth collections, doctors’ professional fee payments, BIR Form No. 2307 issuance, BIR Form No. 2306 issuance, expanded withholding tax, and 5% final withholding VAT. The amounts may appear small per transaction, but repeated errors across many claims can create significant BIR exposure.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists hospitals, clinics, healthcare businesses, professionals, and corporate taxpayers in reviewing withholding tax systems, preparing BIR compliance protocols, responding to BIR findings, and structuring payment documentation to reduce audit risk. For assistance with PhilHealth case rate tax treatment, expanded withholding tax on professional fees, or 5% withholding VAT on government money payments, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.