RMC No. 47-2011 confirms that interest on cooperative members’ savings and time deposits is not subject to 20% final withholding tax.

Cooperatives should not withhold the 20% final tax on interest earned by their members from savings and time deposits with the cooperative. RMC No. 47-2011 confirms that members’ deposits with cooperatives are not treated as currency bank deposits or deposit substitutes for purposes of the final withholding tax under Section 24(B) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. For cooperatives, accountants, and compliance officers, the immediate effect is clear: interest on cooperative members’ savings and time deposits is not subject to the 20% final withholding tax imposed on bank deposit interest.

What RMC No. 47-2011 Changed for Cooperatives and Their Members

RMC No. 47-2011 clarifies the taxability of interest from savings and time deposits of cooperative members under Section 24(B) of the Tax Code. Section 24(B) generally imposes a final tax of twenty percent (20%) on interest from any currency bank deposit, and on yield or other monetary benefit from deposit substitutes, trust funds, and similar arrangements.

The important clarification is that this 20% final tax rule does not apply to interest on members’ deposits with cooperatives. The reason is specific: members’ deposits with cooperatives are not considered currency bank deposits, and they are also not treated as deposit substitutes. Because Section 24(B) applies to bank deposits, deposit substitutes, trust funds, and similar arrangements, it does not cover the cooperative members’ deposits discussed in the circular.

This is a significant compliance clarification for cooperatives because the BIR confirmed that cooperatives are not required to withhold the corresponding tax on interest from the savings and time deposits of their members. For a cooperative paying interest to its members, this affects withholding tax treatment, accounting entries, tax remittance procedures, and possible exposure to deficiency withholding tax assessments.

The Supreme Court Ruling Behind the Clarification

RMC No. 47-2011 is anchored on the Supreme Court ruling in Dumaguete Cathedral Credit Cooperative vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, G.R. No. 182722, dated January 22, 2010. In that case, the Supreme Court held that cooperatives are not required to withhold taxes on interest from savings and time deposits of their members.

The Supreme Court recognized the prior BIR position that the final withholding tax on interest under Section 24(B)(1) applies to interest paid by banks, and that members’ deposits with cooperatives are not currency bank deposits or deposit substitutes. The circular also cites BIR Ruling DA-591-2006, dated October 5, 2006, which confirmed the exemption of interest income on members’ deposits, over and above share capital holdings, from the 20% final withholding tax.

The Court also emphasized the constitutional protection given to cooperatives. Section 15, Article XII of the Constitution considers cooperatives as instruments for social justice and economic development. The ruling stated that exempting cooperative members from the imposition of the final tax under Section 24(B)(1) of the Tax Code is more consistent with the letter and spirit of the Constitution.

Who Is Affected by RMC No. 47-2011

The taxpayers most directly affected are cooperatives that accept savings and time deposits from their members. This includes credit cooperatives and other cooperatives that maintain members’ deposits and pay interest or similar returns on those deposits.

Cooperative members are also directly affected because the clarification means that the interest they earn from their savings and time deposits with the cooperative should not be reduced by the 20% final withholding tax applicable to ordinary bank deposit interest. For individual members, the practical issue is whether the cooperative should deduct final tax from the interest credited or paid to them. Under RMC No. 47-2011, the answer is no, provided the interest is from the member’s savings or time deposit with the cooperative covered by the ruling.

Corporate accountants, tax managers, and cooperative treasurers should pay close attention to this issuance because it directly affects withholding tax compliance. A cooperative that incorrectly treats member deposit interest as bank deposit interest may over-withhold taxes from members. On the other hand, a revenue examiner who treats such interest as subject to final withholding tax would be acting contrary to the clarification in RMC No. 47-2011 and the Supreme Court ruling it applies.

Key Tax Rule: No 20% Final Withholding Tax on Covered Cooperative Member Deposit Interest

The key rule is specific: interest income on members’ deposits with cooperatives, including savings and time deposits, is not subject to the 20% final withholding tax under Section 24(B)(1) of the Tax Code. The same reasoning was applied to deposits of primaries with federations under Section 27(D)(1), because the deposits are not currency bank deposits and are not deposit substitutes.

This clarification should not be read as a blanket exemption for all kinds of income earned by cooperatives or their members. The ruling addresses the taxability of interest from savings and time deposits of cooperative members. It does not create new rates, new filing deadlines, or a general exemption for unrelated income streams. The compliance focus is the withholding tax treatment of interest on cooperative members’ deposits.

The most relevant search phrases for accountants and cooperative officers are: 20% final withholding tax cooperative deposits, tax on interest income of cooperative members, RMC 47-2011 cooperative savings deposits, BIR taxability of cooperative time deposits, and Dumaguete Cathedral Credit Cooperative withholding tax.

Compliance Requirements and Effective Date

RMC No. 47-2011 is dated October 5, 2011. It instructs all internal revenue officers and others concerned to be guided accordingly and to give the circular wide publicity. The issuance does not provide a separate future effectivity date, a transition period, or a special deadline for filing or adjustment.

For practical compliance, cooperatives should ensure that their accounting and withholding tax procedures distinguish between ordinary bank deposit interest and interest paid by the cooperative on members’ savings and time deposits. Interest from covered cooperative member deposits should not be subjected to the 20% final withholding tax under Section 24(B)(1).

Cooperatives should also review prior withholding practices. If the cooperative has been withholding 20% final tax on covered member deposit interest, management should consult tax counsel or a tax adviser on the proper treatment, documentation, and possible remedial steps. If a cooperative is under audit and the assessment includes alleged deficiency withholding tax on members’ savings or time deposit interest, RMC No. 47-2011 and the Dumaguete Cathedral ruling should be raised as direct authority.

Penalties and Deficiency Tax Exposure

RMC No. 47-2011 does not impose a new penalty. Instead, it clarifies that the cooperative in the cited Supreme Court case was not liable to pay assessed deficiency withholding taxes on interest from the savings and time deposits of its members. The ruling also stated that the cooperative was not liable for delinquency interest of 20% per annum in relation to that assessed deficiency withholding tax.

This point matters in tax audits. If the BIR assesses a cooperative for failure to withhold 20% final tax on interest paid to members from savings and time deposits, the cooperative has strong authority to contest the assessment. The circular confirms that the 20% final withholding tax does not apply because the deposits are not currency bank deposits or deposit substitutes.

However, cooperatives should still maintain proper records. The non-applicability of the 20% final tax depends on the nature of the deposit and the relationship between the cooperative and its members. Records should show that the interest relates to members’ savings or time deposits with the cooperative, not to another taxable arrangement outside the scope of the clarification.

Practical Steps for Cooperatives, Accountants, and Tax Managers

First, cooperatives should review their chart of accounts and withholding tax setup to confirm that interest on members’ savings and time deposits is not automatically tagged as subject to 20% final withholding tax. Accounting software, payroll-style payment modules, and manual withholding templates should be checked.

Second, cooperatives should preserve documentation identifying the deposits as members’ savings or time deposits. This includes membership records, deposit agreements, board-approved policies, interest computation schedules, and ledgers showing that the payees are cooperative members.

Third, cooperatives facing a BIR audit should reconcile any assessment for deficiency final withholding tax against RMC No. 47-2011. The cooperative should be prepared to explain that the assessed interest payments are not interest from currency bank deposits, deposit substitutes, trust funds, or similar arrangements within the meaning of Section 24(B)(1).

Fourth, cooperative officers should align internal policies with the Supreme Court doctrine cited in the circular. The strongest compliance position is not merely to say that cooperatives are exempt, but to show that the specific income involved is interest on members’ savings or time deposits with the cooperative.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 47-2011 is especially useful for cooperatives, cooperative federations, accountants, and tax managers dealing with BIR audits, withholding tax reconciliations, and member deposit interest. The key is proper classification, documentation, and presentation of the cooperative’s tax position before any dispute escalates into a formal assessment.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists cooperatives, corporations, SMEs, and business owners with BIR compliance, tax assessments, withholding tax issues, and tax dispute strategy. If your cooperative or business is dealing with the 20% final withholding tax, interest income classification, or a BIR audit involving member deposits, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Philippine tax and business law firm based in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *