PHIC payments to doctors and hospitals are subject to EWT: 10% or 15% on professional fees and 2% on facility fees, with separate receipts and BIR Form 2307.
PHIC payments made directly to hospitals, clinics, and medical practitioners for members’ benefits must be treated as income payments subject to expanded withholding tax. For healthcare providers and PHIC-accredited facilities, the practical consequence is immediate: professional fees paid to doctors are subject to 10% or 15% expanded withholding tax, while facility fees paid to hospitals or clinics are subject to 2% expanded withholding tax. The payment may arise from a member’s health benefit, but when PHIC pays the service provider directly, withholding tax compliance must still be observed.
What RMC No. 38-2011 Clarifies
RMC No. 38-2011 clarifies the application of expanded withholding tax, or EWT, on payments made by the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation to medical practitioners, hospitals, and clinics in connection with PHIC members’ benefits. The clarification addresses the question of whether PHIC payments of members’ medical benefits, when paid directly to the service provider, are subject to withholding tax.
The answer is yes. PHIC may be exempt from income tax as a government-owned and controlled corporation, but that exemption does not remove its obligations as a withholding agent of the Bureau of Internal Revenue. Its withholding responsibilities include withholding the correct tax on income payments, whether for compensation, operating expenses, acquisition of goods and equipment, services rendered to the corporation, or medical services rendered to PHIC members.
The ruling is important because some PHIC field or regional offices had taken the position that payments to hospitals and medical practitioners were merely reimbursements of members’ benefits, not payments for services. RMC No. 38-2011 rejects that practical distinction for withholding tax purposes where PHIC has control over the payment and the payment is made to the healthcare service provider.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 38-2011
The most directly affected taxpayers are PHIC-accredited hospitals, clinics, and medical practitioners who receive payment from PHIC for services rendered to PHIC members. The ruling also affects PHIC regional and field offices, BIR examiners and auditors, healthcare administrators, hospital billing departments, accountants handling BIR Form 2307, and doctors receiving professional fees through hospital-facilitated PHIC claims.
For hospitals and clinics, the key issue is the proper separation of facility fees from professional fees. For medical practitioners, the key issue is the correct withholding rate on professional fees. For PHIC as withholding agent, the compliance issue is whether the payment is properly classified, withheld, receipted, and reported through the correct Certificate of Income and Tax Withheld.
Applicable Expanded Withholding Tax Rates
Professional fees paid to medical practitioners are subject to the EWT rates under Section 2.57.2(A) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended. The applicable rate is 10% if the professional’s gross income does not exceed P720,000 in a year, and 15% if the professional’s gross income exceeds P720,000 in a year.
RMC No. 38-2011 also states that, in the illustration provided, the 15% rate applies where the medical practitioner did not submit a sworn declaration of gross income. This makes the sworn declaration practically important for medical practitioners who may otherwise be subjected to the higher withholding rate.
Facility fees paid to hospitals or clinics are subject to 2% EWT under Section 2.57.2(N) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended. The facility fee covers the hospital or clinic component of the PHIC benefit, including medical procedures, room and board, and pharmacy charges, as described in the ruling.
How PHIC Should Apply the Withholding Tax
PHIC determines members’ medical benefits based on a pre-approved amount on a per-case basis. Because PHIC can determine the portion attributable to professional fees and the portion attributable to facility fees, it must apply the corresponding EWT rate to each separately identified component.
The ruling’s example involves a PHIC member confined in a PHIC-accredited hospital, where the member’s PHIC benefits consist of P4,000 in professional fees and P10,000 in facility fees, for a total PHIC benefit of P14,000. On the professional fee of P4,000, PHIC withholds 15%, or P600, assuming the medical practitioner did not submit a sworn declaration of gross income. On the facility fee of P10,000, PHIC withholds 2%, or P200. Total tax withheld is therefore P800.
Based on that computation, PHIC pays the hospital P13,200, representing the total PHIC benefit of P14,000 less total withholding tax of P800. For accountants and hospital billing teams, this example is critical because it shows that the withholding is not computed using one uniform rate on the entire PHIC benefit. The professional fee and facility fee must be identified and taxed using their respective withholding rates.
Official Receipts and BIR Form 2307 Requirements
RMC No. 38-2011 also clarifies the documentation consequences of separating professional fees from facility fees. In the example, Hospital X should not issue an Official Receipt for the full P14,000 PHIC benefit. The hospital should issue the Official Receipt only for the amount pertaining to the facility fee, or P10,000. The medical practitioner should issue the Official Receipt for the professional fee of P4,000.
The same separation applies to BIR Form 2307. PHIC must issue a BIR Form 2307 in the name of the hospital reflecting income paid of P10,000 and tax withheld of P200. PHIC must also issue another BIR Form 2307 in the name of the medical practitioner reflecting income paid of P4,000 and tax withheld of P600.
This is a practical compliance point for PHIC-accredited hospitals and medical practitioners because mismatched receipts and withholding certificates can create reconciliation issues during tax filing, audit, or BIR examination. The facility fee belongs to the hospital or clinic; the professional fee belongs to the doctor. The receipts and certificates should follow that economic and tax treatment.
Effective Date and Compliance Significance
RMC No. 38-2011 is dated September 1, 2011. It was issued as a clarification for all revenue officers and employees, withholding agents, medical practitioners, hospitals, clinics, and others concerned. While the document does not state a separate future effectivity date, it provides guidance on how the existing EWT rules under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended, should be applied to PHIC payments.
For current compliance review, the ruling remains useful as a reference point for tax treatment of PHIC benefit payments made directly to healthcare providers. Businesses and healthcare institutions searching for PHIC withholding tax, EWT on doctors’ professional fees, BIR Form 2307 for hospitals, withholding tax on PHIC payments, and 2% EWT facility fees should treat this issuance as a core BIR clarification on the proper separation of professional fees and facility fees.
Penalties and Audit Risk for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 38-2011 does not prescribe a new standalone penalty. However, because it confirms that the payments are subject to expanded withholding tax, non-withholding, under-withholding, improper classification, or incorrect issuance of BIR Form 2307 may expose the withholding agent and the payees to the usual tax compliance risks arising from failure to apply the correct withholding tax treatment.
The main audit risk is classification. Treating the entire PHIC payment as a mere reimbursement, treating the entire amount as a hospital facility fee, failing to recognize the doctor’s professional fee, or issuing only one withholding certificate when two payees are involved may all create problems during BIR examination. The ruling makes clear that PHIC, as the person having control over the payment, is required to withhold the tax that should be withheld on income payments made to professionals and hospitals or clinics.
Practical Steps for Hospitals, Doctors, and PHIC-Related Accounting Teams
Hospitals and clinics should ensure that PHIC claims and billing records clearly identify the professional fee component and the facility fee component. Medical practitioners should check whether their gross income declaration has been properly submitted when relevant, because the applicable EWT rate on professional fees may be 10% or 15% depending on gross income and supporting declaration. Accounting teams should reconcile Official Receipts and BIR Forms 2307 so that the hospital’s documents cover only the facility fee, while the doctor’s documents cover the professional fee.
For PHIC-related withholding tax compliance, the safest approach is to treat each payment component according to its tax character. Professional fees paid to medical practitioners should be withheld at 10% or 15%, as applicable. Facility fees paid to hospitals or clinics should be withheld at 2%. BIR Form 2307 should then be issued separately to the hospital or clinic and to the medical practitioner, reflecting the correct income paid and tax withheld for each.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Healthcare providers, clinics, hospitals, and medical practitioners dealing with PHIC payments should not treat withholding tax as a back-office formality. The classification of professional fees, facility fees, receipts, and BIR Form 2307 entries can affect tax filings, audit exposure, and income reporting. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises Philippine businesses and regulated entities on BIR compliance, withholding tax issues, tax documentation, and audit risk management.
For assistance with PHIC withholding tax, expanded withholding tax compliance, BIR Form 2307 reconciliation, or tax audit preparation, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.