RMC No. 15-2011 revokes a prior BIR ruling and confirms that sales of company cars used in business are incidental transactions subject to 12% VAT.
Companies selling used company cars, service vehicles, and other business assets cannot rely on the argument that the sale is outside their primary line of business to avoid VAT. RMC No. 15-2011 revoked BIR Ruling No. DA-563-2006 and adopted the Court of Tax Appealsâ view that the sale of a motor vehicle used in the taxpayerâs business is an incidental transaction in the course of trade or business, and is therefore subject to 12% VAT.
What RMC No. 15-2011 Changed
RMC No. 15-2011 reversed the prior treatment given in BIR Ruling No. DA-563-2006 dated September 19, 2006. That earlier ruling had held that Interadent Zahntechnik Phils., Incorporated, whose regular business was the manufacturing and export of custom-made dental products, was exempt from VAT on the sale of its company car. The earlier reasoning was that the companyâs regular business was not the sale of motor vehicles, and that nothing indicated that its company car sale was made regularly or incidentally to its manufacturing and export activity.
The BIR changed course because of the Court of Tax Appeals ruling in CTA E.B. Case No. 287, dated January 14, 2008, in CS Garments, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue. In that case, the CTA held that the sale of a Mercedes Benz motor vehicle by CS Garments to its General Manager for P1,600,000.00 was subject to VAT. Although CS Garmentsâ primary business was manufacturing garments for sale abroad, the vehicle had been acquired and used in furtherance of that business. The sale was therefore incidental to its commercial or economic activity.
The practical change is significant: for VAT purposes, an isolated sale of a company asset may still be treated as made in the course of trade or business if the asset was purchased and used in furtherance of the taxpayerâs business. RMC No. 15-2011 therefore makes clear that taxpayers should not automatically treat the disposal of company cars as non-VAT transactions merely because the taxpayer is not a car dealer.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 15-2011
The ruling affects VAT-registered businesses that dispose of company vehicles and other assets used in their operations. This includes manufacturers, exporters, service companies, BPOs, logistics businesses, dental laboratories, garment exporters, trading companies, professional corporations, and other enterprises that keep vehicles under property, plant and equipment or similar asset accounts.
CFOs, corporate accountants, tax managers, and in-house counsel should pay attention to this issuance when handling the sale of company cars to officers, employees, managers, related parties, or third-party buyers. The key question is not whether the company is regularly engaged in selling cars. The more important question is whether the car or asset was held and used for the companyâs business, administrative, production, supply, or operational purposes.
This is particularly relevant for searches such as VAT on sale of company car Philippines, BIR VAT on disposal of fixed assets, RMC 15-2011 company vehicle VAT, sale of motor vehicle subject to VAT, and VAT on property plant and equipment sale. These are the practical issues that usually arise when a company retires an old service vehicle, sells an executive car, or transfers a company asset to an officer.
Key Compliance Rule: Incidental Business Transactions Are Still VATable
RMC No. 15-2011 applies Section 105 of the 1997 Tax Code, as amended. Under that provision, VAT applies to any person who, in the course of trade or business, sells, barters, exchanges, or leases goods or properties, renders services, or imports goods. The phrase in the ordinary course of trade or business includes the regular conduct or pursuit of a commercial or economic activity, including transactions incidental thereto.
The important phrase is including transactions incidental thereto. The CTA explained that an isolated transaction is not necessarily excluded from VAT. A transaction may still be incidental to the pursuit of a commercial or economic activity even if it is not done regularly and even if it is not the taxpayerâs main product or service.
In the CS Garments ruling adopted by the BIR, the vehicle was treated as part of property, plant and equipment. Property, plant and equipment refers to tangible assets held for use in production or supply of goods or services, for rental to others, or for administrative purposes, and expected to be used during more than one period. Because the motor vehicle was purchased and used in furtherance of the taxpayerâs business, its sale was considered incidental to that business.
The BIR therefore concluded that the sale of company cars of Interadent Zahntechnik Phils., Incorporated to its officers should be subject to VAT, being a transaction incident to the pursuit of its commercial or economic activity.
Effective Date and Revocation of Prior Rulings
RMC No. 15-2011 is dated March 16, 2011. It expressly revoked BIR Ruling No. DA-563-2006 dated September 19, 2006. It also states that all other existing rulings inconsistent with the circular are likewise considered revoked.
This means businesses should not rely on older rulings that treated sales of company cars as exempt from VAT merely because the taxpayer was not engaged in the sale of motor vehicles. For tax compliance purposes, the safer position after RMC No. 15-2011 is to evaluate whether the vehicle or asset was used in the business. If it was used in furtherance of the taxpayerâs commercial or economic activity, the sale may be treated as a VATable incidental transaction.
Penalties for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 15-2011 does not create a separate penalty provision. However, because it treats the sale of company cars used in business as subject to VAT, a taxpayer that fails to recognize output VAT on such a sale may face the ordinary consequences of underdeclared VAT under the Tax Code and applicable BIR rules.
For businesses, the risk is not merely technical. If the disposal price is material, the unrecognized 12% VAT can become a tax assessment issue. The transaction may also affect invoicing, accounting entries, VAT returns, and documentation for related-party or employee sales. A company that sold a business vehicle without VAT should review whether the transaction falls under the RMC No. 15-2011 rule and whether remedial action is needed.
Practical Steps for Businesses and Accountants
First, review all sales of company vehicles and other fixed assets. Identify whether the asset was recorded as property, plant and equipment, used for administrative purposes, used for operations, or otherwise held in furtherance of the business. If yes, the transaction should be reviewed for VAT treatment.
Second, check sales to officers, managers, employees, and related parties. RMC No. 15-2011 specifically arose from the sale of company cars to officers and from the CTA example involving a sale to a General Manager. These transactions should be supported by proper documentation, board or management approvals where appropriate, and correct tax invoices or official documents under the applicable invoicing rules.
Third, do not assume that one-time sales are automatically outside VAT. The CTA reasoning adopted in RMC No. 15-2011 states that an isolated transaction is not necessarily disqualified from being incidental to business. The decisive fact is the connection between the asset and the business activity.
Fourth, coordinate tax, accounting, and legal review before disposing of company vehicles. The disposal price, tax invoice, output VAT, accounting entry, and buyer relationship should be aligned. Where the sale involves officers or related parties, the company should also consider corporate approvals and related-party documentation.
Why This Matters for CFOs and Business Owners
RMC No. 15-2011 is a reminder that VAT is not limited to a companyâs main revenue line. A manufacturing company, export company, service company, or professional corporation may still have VAT exposure when it sells an asset used in its business. The fact that the sale is occasional, isolated, or not part of the taxpayerâs usual product line does not automatically remove the transaction from VAT.
For Philippine businesses, the compliance lesson is direct: before selling a company car or fixed asset, determine whether the asset was used in the commercial or economic activity of the business. If the answer is yes, the company should consider the 12% VAT treatment required by RMC No. 15-2011.
ASG Law Can Help with BIR Compliance and VAT Reviews
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel on VAT compliance, BIR assessments, tax documentation, and corporate transactions involving business assets. If your company is selling company vehicles, disposing of fixed assets, reviewing past VAT treatment, or responding to a BIR audit involving RMC No. 15-2011, our tax and business law team can help assess exposure and prepare a practical compliance strategy.
For assistance with BIR compliance, VAT issues, tax assessments, and corporate documentation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.