RMC No. 19-2010 orders BIR offices to continue cooperative tax audits and apply RA 6938 or RA 9520 rules based on the March 22, 2009 cut-off.
Cooperatives with pending BIR tax investigations should not assume that registration as a cooperative, or the passage of the Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008, automatically stops an audit. RMC No. 19-2010 directs all concerned BIR offices to continue pending tax investigations of cooperatives and to issue tax assessments when warranted, subject to specific audit rules depending on whether the taxable period falls before or after March 22, 2009.
What RMC No. 19-2010 Changed for Cooperative Tax Audits
RMC No. 19-2010 clarified the BIR’s audit position after the issuance of the Joint Rules and Regulations implementing Republic Act No. 9520, otherwise known as the Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008. The Department of Finance, Cooperative Development Authority, and the Bureau of Internal Revenue jointly signed those implementing rules on February 5, 2010.
The key directive is straightforward: all concerned BIR offices must continue all pending tax investigations involving cooperatives and may issue tax assessments if the facts and law warrant an assessment. The circular therefore rejects any interpretation that the implementation of Republic Act No. 9520 suspends, cancels, or automatically terminates existing BIR tax audit cases against cooperatives.
For business owners, cooperative officers, accountants, and tax practitioners, the practical effect is that cooperative tax exemption issues remain subject to BIR examination. A cooperative under audit must still respond to notices, substantiate its tax treatment, preserve its accounting records, and determine which cooperative tax law applies to the taxable period under investigation.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 19-2010
RMC No. 19-2010 directly affects cooperatives that have pending or potential BIR tax investigations. This includes cooperatives with tax cases existing before March 22, 2009, cooperatives whose 2008 internal revenue tax returns are under audit, and fiscal-period cooperatives whose taxable year ended before March 22, 2009.
The circular is also important for BIR examiners, revenue officers, cooperative accountants, external auditors, cooperative board members, tax counsel, and officers responsible for compliance with the Cooperative Development Authority. Because the circular involves the coordination between the BIR and the CDA, it is especially relevant to cooperatives whose transactions, tax exemptions, or tax liabilities straddle the transition from Republic Act No. 6938, the old Cooperative Code, to Republic Act No. 9520, the Philippine Cooperative Code of 2008.
Taxpayers searching for RMC No. 19-2010, BIR tax audit of cooperatives, cooperative tax exemption Philippines, RA 9520 tax investigation, and CDA authorization for BIR audit should understand that the circular is not a general tax exemption issuance. It is an audit-guidance issuance that tells BIR offices when they may proceed and what authority must be obtained for certain post-March 22, 2009 cooperative tax cases.
Key Audit Rules and Cut-Off Dates
The most important date in RMC No. 19-2010 is March 22, 2009, the effectivity date of Republic Act No. 9520. The circular divides cooperative tax investigations based on this date.
For tax cases existing before March 22, 2009, the governing law is the old Cooperative Code under Republic Act No. 6938. The BIR expressly stated that Republic Act No. 9520 did not provide for retroactive effect. This means a cooperative cannot automatically invoke the new law to defeat or revise the tax consequences of a case that existed before the effectivity of Republic Act No. 9520.
For the audit or investigation of 2008 internal revenue tax returns of cooperatives, including returns of fiscal-period taxpayers whose taxable year ended before March 22, 2009, all BIR offices are authorized to issue notices of investigation following the procedures under the applicable Audit Program. This confirms that the BIR may still initiate or continue audit procedures for the 2008 returns of cooperatives, as well as relevant fiscal-year returns ending before the RA 9520 cut-off date.
For all other tax cases covering periods beyond March 22, 2009, BIR offices must obtain prior authorization from the CDA. The authorization must be released by the CDA or its Extension Office having jurisdiction over the cooperative, with a copy furnished to the concerned cooperative, within twenty days from receipt of the BIR’s request.
Compliance Requirements for Cooperatives Under Investigation
Cooperatives under BIR investigation should first identify the taxable period covered by the audit. If the case existed before March 22, 2009, the old Cooperative Code under Republic Act No. 6938 governs. If the case concerns the 2008 internal revenue tax return, or a fiscal year ending before March 22, 2009, the BIR may issue notices of investigation under the applicable Audit Program. If the case covers periods beyond March 22, 2009, the cooperative should verify whether the required prior CDA authorization was obtained.
Cooperatives should also preserve documentation supporting their tax treatment, including CDA registration records, tax returns, financial statements, books of accounts, member and non-member transaction records, exemption claims, and correspondence with the BIR and CDA. The circular authorizes continued investigation and assessment if warranted, which means the cooperative must be ready to prove both its factual and legal basis for any claimed tax exemption or preferential treatment.
For CFOs and accountants, the immediate compliance step is to map each BIR audit notice against the relevant period. A notice involving periods before March 22, 2009 should be reviewed under Republic Act No. 6938. A notice involving periods after March 22, 2009 should be checked for the CDA authorization requirement. This timeline analysis can materially affect the validity, scope, and handling of the audit.
Penalties and Assessment Risk for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 19-2010 does not set out a new penalty rate, surcharge, interest rate, compromise penalty, or separate administrative fine. Its significance lies in authorizing BIR offices to continue pending investigations and issue tax assessments if warranted.
The practical risk for cooperatives is therefore assessment exposure. If a cooperative fails to respond properly to the BIR, fails to substantiate its exemption, or relies on Republic Act No. 9520 for a period to which it does not retroactively apply, the BIR may proceed with the investigation and issue an assessment. For periods beyond March 22, 2009, the cooperative should also carefully check whether the BIR complied with the prior CDA authorization requirement before proceeding with the tax case.
Practical Steps for Cooperative Officers, Accountants, and Tax Counsel
First, determine the exact taxable period covered by the investigation. The March 22, 2009 cut-off date is central. A cooperative should not respond to a BIR audit without first identifying whether the old Cooperative Code or Republic Act No. 9520 is the applicable legal framework.
Second, confirm the procedural authority for the investigation. For 2008 internal revenue tax returns and fiscal years ending before March 22, 2009, BIR offices are authorized to issue notices of investigation under the applicable Audit Program. For periods beyond March 22, 2009, the BIR office must obtain prior authorization from the CDA, which should be released within twenty days from receipt of the BIR request, with a copy furnished to the cooperative.
Third, prepare a documentary matrix. The cooperative should organize its CDA documents, BIR filings, accounting records, exemption bases, and tax payments by year and by transaction type. This is especially important where the cooperative has both member and non-member transactions or where the BIR may question whether certain income is taxable.
Fourth, avoid relying on a blanket exemption argument. RMC No. 19-2010 confirms that investigations continue and assessments may issue if warranted. A cooperative’s defense should be period-specific, law-specific, and evidence-based.
Fifth, seek legal and tax review before submitting explanations or documents. In cooperative tax audits, the framing of the response can affect not only the current assessment but also future audits, CDA coordination, and the cooperative’s broader tax compliance posture.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises cooperatives, corporations, SMEs, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel on BIR audits, tax assessments, cooperative tax exemption issues, and compliance with Philippine tax regulations. RMC No. 19-2010 is a reminder that cooperative tax status does not eliminate the need for careful audit defense, correct period analysis, and proper coordination with regulatory requirements.
If your cooperative has received a BIR notice of investigation, is facing a tax assessment, or needs guidance on the tax treatment of cooperative transactions under Republic Act No. 6938 or Republic Act No. 9520, our Makati-based tax and business law team can help assess the applicable rules, prepare responses, and protect your position. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance and tax audit defense.