RMC No. 72-2009 confirms tollway operators are subject to VAT and must follow BIR invoicing and receipting rules for tollway services.
Tollway operators must treat their tollway services as subject to Value-Added Tax because their franchise-based services are not among the limited franchise exceptions recognized under Section 119 of the Tax Code. For businesses operating toll roads, handling toll collections, or accounting for toll-related revenues, the immediate compliance point is clear: VAT treatment, invoicing, and receipting must be aligned with the BIR’s position under RMC No. 72-2009 and the earlier RMC No. 52-2005.
What RMC No. 72-2009 Changed or Clarified
RMC No. 72-2009 reiterates the BIR’s earlier position under RMC No. 52-2005 that tollway operators are liable for VAT on the services they render. The ruling is anchored on Section 108(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 9337, which treats the sale or exchange of services in the Philippines for a fee, remuneration, or consideration as subject to VAT.
The relevant statutory language covers the performance of all kinds of services in the Philippines for others for a fee, including services rendered by franchise grantees. The key limitation is that only those franchise grantees falling within the specific exceptions under Section 119 are excluded from VAT treatment under this rule. Tollway operators do not fall within those exceptions.
The most important practical effect is that tollway operators cannot treat their franchise status alone as a basis for avoiding VAT. The BIR’s position is that the services rendered by tollway operators are taxable services under Section 108(A), because tollway operators are not the type of franchise grantees expressly covered by the Section 119 exception.
Who Is Affected by RMC No. 72-2009
The primary taxpayers affected are tollway operators and concessionaires rendering tollway services in the Philippines. These include entities that operate toll roads and collect toll fees from motorists as consideration for the use of tollway infrastructure.
The issuance is also important for corporate accountants, CFOs, controllers, tax managers, and in-house counsel of tollway companies because it directly affects VAT accounting, output tax reporting, receipting systems, and tax audit exposure. Businesses that transact with tollway operators may also need to understand the VAT treatment of toll fees, especially where input VAT documentation and official receipts are relevant to their own tax compliance.
Internal revenue officers and other BIR personnel are also expressly covered, since the circular directs that the VAT treatment of tollway operators be applied and publicized. For the years 2007 to 2009, the tax issues of tollway operators, including VAT, are placed under the jurisdiction of a specific Task Force on Tollway Operators created under Revenue Special Order No. 617-2009.
Why Tollway Operators Are Subject to VAT
The legal basis is Section 108(A) of the Tax Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 9337. That provision covers the sale or exchange of services, including services of franchise grantees, except those under Section 119 of the Tax Code.
Section 119, as quoted in RMC No. 72-2009, applies to certain franchise taxes involving radio and television broadcasting companies whose annual gross receipts of the preceding year do not exceed P10,000,000.00, and to gas and water utilities. The circular emphasizes that the exception is specific and limited. Since tollway operators are not radio or television broadcasting companies within the P10,000,000.00 gross receipts threshold, and are not gas or water utilities, they remain subject to VAT under Section 108(A).
This distinction matters because many businesses assume that a franchise grantee may automatically be outside VAT and subject only to franchise tax. RMC No. 72-2009 confirms that this assumption is incorrect. Only franchise grantees specifically falling under the Section 119 exception are excluded. All other franchise grantees, including tollway operators, are covered by VAT on their sale of services.
Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines
RMC No. 72-2009 is dated December 21, 2009. The issuance does not create a new future filing deadline, but it confirms an existing VAT position and identifies the relevant compliance framework for tollway operators.
First, tollway operators must recognize that their tollway services are subject to VAT. This affects VAT registration compliance, output VAT reporting, tax return preparation, and the treatment of toll revenues in the company’s books.
Second, all tollway operators are required to follow the invoicing and receipting format prescribed in RMC No. 40-2005. This is a specific operational compliance requirement. Tollway operators should review whether their toll receipts, official receipts, invoices, ticketing systems, electronic collection records, and accounting documentation conform to the required BIR format.
Third, all tax issues of tollway operators for the years 2007 to 2009, including VAT issues, fall under the jurisdiction of the Task Force on Tollway Operators created pursuant to Revenue Special Order No. 617-2009. This means tollway operators with open tax issues for those years should expect that the BIR may review their VAT compliance through that task force structure.
Penalties and Audit Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 72-2009 does not specify a new penalty table or a separate penalty rate. However, the practical risk is significant because failure to treat tollway services as VATable may expose a tollway operator to deficiency VAT assessments, related interest, surcharges, compromise penalties, and documentation-related issues under the general rules of the Tax Code.
The audit risk is heightened by the creation of the Task Force on Tollway Operators for tax issues covering 2007 to 2009. The express reference to the task force signals that the BIR expected focused review and enforcement involving tollway operators’ tax liabilities, including VAT.
In addition, failure to follow the prescribed invoicing and receipting format under RMC No. 40-2005 may create separate documentation issues. For VAT taxpayers, compliant invoices and receipts are not merely administrative forms; they support output tax reporting, input tax claims by customers where applicable, and the integrity of the taxpayer’s accounting records.
Practical Steps for Tollway Operators and Corporate Tax Teams
Tollway operators should immediately review whether all tollway service revenues are being treated as VATable transactions in their accounting and tax reporting systems. The review should cover toll collections, electronic toll collection records, manual receipts, official receipts, invoices, and any revenue classifications used in the company’s books.
Finance and tax teams should also verify whether the company’s invoicing and receipting format follows RMC No. 40-2005. If toll receipts or electronic collection documentation do not reflect the required VAT information, the company should coordinate with tax counsel, system providers, and accounting personnel to correct the format and preserve adequate records.
For years still relevant to an assessment, protest, refund, or litigation strategy, counsel should examine the company’s position in light of RMC No. 72-2009, RMC No. 52-2005, Section 108(A), Section 119, and Revenue Special Order No. 617-2009. The most relevant search phrases for tax teams are VAT on tollway operators Philippines, RMC 72-2009 toll fees VAT, RMC 52-2005 tollway VAT, toll fees official receipt VAT, and Section 108 franchise grantees VAT.
How ASG Law Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists tollway operators, franchise grantees, infrastructure companies, CFOs, accountants, and corporate legal teams in assessing VAT exposure, reviewing invoicing and receipting compliance, preparing BIR audit responses, and handling tax disputes arising from BIR issuances such as RMC No. 72-2009.
For businesses dealing with VAT on toll fees, franchise-based services, BIR assessments, or receipting compliance, ASG Law provides practical tax and business law advice grounded in Philippine tax rules and enforcement practice. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance, VAT exposure, and tax audit strategy.