RMC No. 31-2009 confirms interest expense deductions must be reduced when taxpayers earn final-taxed interest income, even without tax arbitrage.

Taxpayers with both interest expense and final-taxed interest income cannot avoid the statutory reduction of deductible interest expense merely by arguing that there was no tax arbitrage. RMC No. 31-2009 confirms that, for taxable year 2005, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas’ claimed interest expense was subject to disallowance to the extent required under Section 34(B)(1) of the Tax Code and Revenue Regulations No. 13-2000, resulting in a deficiency income tax assessment of P1,224,675,111.92.

What RMC No. 31-2009 Changed or Clarified

RMC No. 31-2009 circularizes the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s memorandum dated June 6, 2009 on the disallowance of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas’ claimed interest expense for taxable year 2005. The ruling resolves a conflict between the BIR and BSP on whether the statutory limitation on interest expense deductions applies only when a taxpayer enters into a tax arbitrage scheme.

The Commissioner’s position is direct: the Tax Code does not require proof of tax arbitrage before the limitation applies. If, during the taxable year, a taxpayer incurs interest expense on indebtedness connected with trade or business and also earns interest income subjected to final withholding tax, the deductible interest expense must be reduced by the percentage prescribed by law.

For taxable year 2005, the BSP claimed that it should be allowed to deduct the full amount of its interest expense because its borrowings and investments were undertaken as part of its legally mandated monetary functions, particularly to maintain price stability and manage liquidity through open market operations. The BIR rejected this position. The purpose of the borrowing or investment did not remove the transaction from the statutory limitation where the legal conditions for reduction were present.

The Key Tax Rule on Deductibility of Interest Expense

Section 34(B)(1) of the Tax Code allows as a deduction the amount of interest paid or incurred within a taxable year on indebtedness connected with the taxpayer’s profession, trade, or business. However, the same provision reduces the otherwise allowable deduction by a percentage of the taxpayer’s interest income that was subjected to final tax.

The circular recites the applicable statutory percentages under the Tax Code of 1997: 41% beginning January 1, 1998; 39% beginning January 1, 1999; and 38% beginning January 1, 2000. It also notes that Republic Act No. 9337 amended the proviso to refer to 42% of interest income subjected to final tax, and that effective January 1, 2009, the percentage became 33%. R.A. No. 9337 took effect on November 1, 2005.

In practical terms, the rule prevents a taxpayer from claiming a full deduction for borrowing costs while earning interest income that is already subjected to preferential final tax treatment. The BIR emphasized that the limitation applies as a statutory formula, not as a penalty that depends on proving a taxpayer’s intent to arbitrage.

Who Is Affected by RMC No. 31-2009

Although the ruling specifically involves the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, the principle matters to corporations, banks, financial institutions, holding companies, investment-heavy businesses, and any taxpayer that both incurs business-related interest expense and earns interest income subjected to final withholding tax.

Corporate taxpayers with treasury placements, bank deposits, government securities, treasury bonds, notes, or other interest-bearing investments should pay particular attention. The same is true for businesses with loan financing on one side of the balance sheet and passive interest income on the other side. The BIR’s view is that the limitation applies regardless of whether the loan and investment were deliberately paired as an arbitrage arrangement.

For CFOs, corporate accountants, and tax managers, the most important search phrases are: BIR interest expense deduction limitation, RMC 31-2009 interest expense, BSP deficiency income tax interest expense, 38% interest income final tax deduction, and tax arbitrage interest expense Philippines. These phrases capture the core issue: when interest expense must be reduced because the taxpayer also earned final-taxed interest income.

Requisites for Deductibility of Interest Expense

RMC No. 31-2009 quotes Revenue Regulations No. 13-2000, which sets out the requisites for deducting interest expense from gross income. There must be indebtedness; there must be interest expense paid or incurred on that indebtedness; the indebtedness must be that of the taxpayer; the indebtedness must be connected with the taxpayer’s trade, business, or exercise of profession; and the interest expense must have been paid or incurred during the taxable year.

The regulation also requires that the interest must have been stipulated in writing, must be legally due, and must not arise from a prohibited related-party interest payment arrangement under Section 34(B)(2)(b), in relation to Section 36(B) of the Tax Code of 1997. The interest must not be incurred to finance petroleum operations. In addition, where interest is incurred to acquire property used in trade, business, or the exercise of profession, the taxpayer must not have treated the interest as a capital expenditure.

These requirements remain important because the BIR’s position in RMC No. 31-2009 does not say that all interest expense is automatically deductible. Rather, even if interest expense satisfies the general requisites for deductibility, the allowable deduction is still subject to the statutory reduction when the taxpayer also earns interest income subjected to final withholding tax.

The BSP Assessment and the Amount at Stake

The circular states that the deficiency income tax assessment involved P1,224,675,111.92 for taxable year 2005. The assessment arose from the disallowance of BSP’s claimed interest expense equivalent to 38% or 42% of its interest income subjected to final withholding tax.

BSP argued that it was not engaged in an interest arbitrage scheme. It maintained that its investments in government securities, treasury bonds and notes, and other securities were undertaken pursuant to its mandate to maintain price stability. It also argued that it did not borrow money from financial institutions for reinvestment purposes, but used borrowings as a monetary tool in open market operations to mop up or siphon off excess liquidity in the banking system.

The BIR did not accept these arguments as a basis for full deductibility. The Commissioner emphasized that the law is clear: once there is interest expense incurred on one side and final-taxed interest income earned on the other side during the same taxable year, the limitation applies. The rule applies regardless of whether a tax arbitrage scheme was entered into, regardless of the date of the interest-bearing loan, regardless of the date of the investment, and regardless of the currency of the loan, investment, or deposit.

Effective Dates and Percentages to Watch

RMC No. 31-2009 itself is dated June 15, 2009, while the Commissioner’s memorandum circularized by it is dated June 6, 2009. The taxable year involved in the BSP assessment was 2005. For businesses reviewing historical assessments, protests, or amended tax positions, the relevant dates and percentages matter because the limitation percentage depends on the law applicable to the taxable period.

The circular identifies 41% beginning January 1, 1998; 39% beginning January 1, 1999; and 38% beginning January 1, 2000 under the Tax Code of 1997. It further notes that R.A. No. 9337 amended the proviso to 42% of the interest income subjected to final tax, with a later change to 33% effective January 1, 2009.

Businesses should avoid applying a current-year percentage to an old taxable year without checking the applicable statute, effectivity date, and transitional period. In tax audits, the wrong percentage can materially affect the deficiency income tax exposure, especially for taxpayers with substantial borrowings and significant interest income.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 31-2009 does not create a new penalty schedule. However, it shows the practical consequence of non-compliance: the BIR may disallow a portion of the claimed interest expense deduction and issue a deficiency income tax assessment. In the BSP matter, the stated deficiency income tax assessment for taxable year 2005 was P1,224,675,111.92.

For private taxpayers, the risk is not limited to the reduction of the deduction. A deficiency assessment may also give rise to statutory additions under the Tax Code, depending on the facts, the taxable period, the nature of the assessment, and the taxpayer’s compliance posture. Companies should therefore treat the interest expense limitation as a computation issue that must be addressed before filing, not merely as an audit issue to be defended later.

Practical Steps for CFOs, Accountants, and Corporate Taxpayers

First, identify all interest expense claimed as a deduction for the taxable year. Confirm that each item satisfies the requisites under Revenue Regulations No. 13-2000, including written stipulation, legal due date, connection with trade or business, and proper treatment as expense rather than capital expenditure where applicable.

Second, identify all interest income earned during the same taxable year that was subjected to final withholding tax. This includes interest income from bank deposits, placements, government securities, treasury bonds, notes, and other interest-bearing instruments where final tax was imposed.

Third, compute the statutory reduction using the percentage applicable to the relevant taxable year. For historical years, check the applicable law for that year instead of assuming the current percentage. RMC No. 31-2009 is especially relevant where the taxpayer argues that the borrowing and the investment were not connected or were not part of a tax arbitrage scheme.

Fourth, document the computation in the tax working papers. The company should be able to show the gross interest expense, the interest income subjected to final withholding tax, the applicable percentage, the amount of reduction, and the final deductible interest expense claimed in the return.

Fifth, review prior-year positions where the company claimed full deductibility of interest expense despite earning final-taxed interest income. The BIR position in RMC No. 31-2009 is broad and may be invoked in audits involving banks, financing companies, holding companies, and ordinary corporations with material passive interest income.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 31-2009 is a reminder that interest expense deductions require more than proof that the borrowing was business-related. Where a taxpayer also earns interest income subjected to final withholding tax, the BIR may require a statutory reduction even without proving tax arbitrage. For businesses with loans, deposits, treasury placements, securities investments, or historical deficiency assessments, this issue can materially affect income tax exposure.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR assessments, preparing protest strategies, validating tax computations, and strengthening documentation for deductible expenses. For assistance with interest expense deductibility, deficiency income tax assessments, BIR audits, and Philippine tax compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *