RMC No. 35-2006 clarifies 12% VAT and 2% EWT treatment of freight, accessorial charges, commissions, and reimbursable expenses of freight forwarders.
Freight forwarders, importers, exporters, and shippers must separate freight, accessorial charges, offshore charges, local service charges, commissions, and reimbursable expenses correctly because RMC No. 35-2006 determines which amounts are subject to 12% VAT and 2% expanded withholding tax. The most important rule is that cross-border freight and certain third-party charges are not automatically part of the forwarder’s VATable gross receipts, but local movement charges may be fully VATable depending on how the transaction is invoiced and receipted.
What RMC No. 35-2006 Changed for Freight Forwarders
RMC No. 35-2006 clarifies the proper value-added tax and expanded withholding tax treatment of freight and other incidental charges billed by freight forwarders. It recognizes that freight forwarding transactions are not all the same. A freight forwarder may act merely as an intermediary or integrator for cross-border shipments, but may also assume full responsibility for moving cargo from one point in the Philippines to another.
For cross-border movement of goods, meaning outbound movement from the Philippines to a foreign port or inbound movement from a foreign port to the Philippines, the freight forwarder is treated as an intermediary between the shipper and third-party service providers such as international air carriers, sea carriers, foreign forwarders, or foreign agents. The circular states that amounts collected by the forwarder for these third-party service providers are treated as amounts held in trust and do not form part of the forwarder’s gross receipts for VAT purposes.
For local movement of goods, meaning the movement of cargo from one place in the Philippines to another, the treatment is stricter. If the forwarder issues a VAT official receipt for the entire amount paid by the shipper, the entire amount is considered compensation for the forwarder’s service and becomes part of its VATable gross receipts. Amounts paid by the forwarder to subcontractors or third-party service providers are treated as its cost of doing business, unless the forwarder follows the required reimbursable expense procedures.
VAT Treatment of Outbound Freight Forwarding Charges
For outbound movement, the freight, excluding the commission of the forwarder, together with accessorial charges and offshore destination charges, is not treated as part of the forwarder’s gross receipts. These amounts are considered payments intended for third-party service providers, not income of the freight forwarder.
The amounts that form part of the forwarder’s VATable gross receipts for outbound shipments are the local origin charges and the actual commission income of the forwarder on the freight. Local origin charges may include trucking, processing, documentation charges, disbursement fees, and other related charges for services rendered in the Philippines in connection with the outbound movement.
For administrative convenience, the forwarder’s commission may be computed at 5% of total freight charges, based on the IATA rate. The circular’s illustration uses a freight rate of P167,750.00, resulting in a 5% commission of P8,387.50. Together with local origin charges of P1,700.00, the total VATable charges amount to P10,087.50, with 12% VAT of P1,210.50.
VAT Treatment of Inbound Freight Forwarding Charges
For inbound movement, the freight, excluding the commission of the forwarder, accessorial charges, and offshore origin charges are also excluded from the forwarder’s gross receipts because they are amounts held in trust for third-party service providers.
The items treated as part of VATable gross receipts for inbound movement are local destination charges, currency adjustment factor or CAF, and the actual commission income of the forwarder on the freight. Local destination charges may include collect fees, turn-over or breakbulk fees, trucking, processing, documentation charges, and related charges for services rendered in the Philippines.
The inclusion of CAF is important for accountants and CFOs reviewing freight forwarding invoices because RMC No. 35-2006 defines CAF as a fee charged by forwarders to clients to cover losses due to exchange-rate fluctuations between the Philippine peso and foreign currencies. For VAT purposes, CAF in inbound movement is treated as part of the forwarder’s gross receipts.
VAT Treatment of Local Movement of Goods
For local movement, the entire amount received by the forwarder is subject to 12% VAT if the forwarder issues a VAT official receipt for the full amount. The circular gives a direct example: if a forwarder collects P100,000.00 from a shipper for carriage of goods from Manila to Cebu, the forwarder must issue an official receipt reflecting P100,000.00 as gross receipts and VAT of P12,000.00. The forwarder must pay output VAT of P12,000.00, and the VAT-registered shipper may claim input VAT of P12,000.00.
The result changes if the forwarder treats third-party charges as reimbursable expenses or advance payments. In that case, the forwarder may issue a VAT official receipt only for its own services and a Non-VAT Acknowledgment Receipt for the reimbursable amounts. The amount covered by the Non-VAT Acknowledgment Receipt does not form part of the forwarder’s gross receipts, provided the strict substantiation and recording requirements are followed.
Requirements for Reimbursable Expenses and Advance Payments
RMC No. 35-2006 allows reimbursable expenses and advance payments to be excluded from the forwarder’s VATable gross receipts only if the forwarder follows specific procedures. The forwarder must issue Non-VAT Official Acknowledgment Receipts for reimbursable expenses or advance payments, except those incurred for the benefit of the forwarder. These amounts must have been previously recorded as receivables for cash advances on behalf of shippers.
The third-party service providers must issue official receipts in the name of the shippers, not in the name of the freight forwarders. The forwarder must record the reimbursable expenses or advances under the account “RECEIVABLE FOR CASH ADVANCES ON BEHALF OF SHIPPERS.” For liquidation, the forwarder must attach the original copies of the official receipts issued by the third-party service providers in the name of the shippers to the Non-VAT Official Acknowledgment Receipts issued to the shippers.
This distinction is critical in BIR audits of freight forwarders, importers, exporters, and logistics companies. If the third-party charges are not properly documented, receipted, and recorded, the BIR may treat them as part of the forwarder’s gross receipts subject to VAT.
Invoicing Rules and Input VAT Claims by Shippers
Every VAT-registered forwarder must issue a VAT official receipt for every sale of service containing the information required under Section 4.113-1(B) of Revenue Regulations No. 16-2005. For inbound and outbound movements, the forwarder may show separately in one billing statement the amounts held in trust for third-party service providers and the charges subject to VAT.
The VAT component shown in the VAT official receipt issued by the forwarder is the amount of input VAT that may be claimed by the client. However, RMC No. 35-2006 also provides that the VAT shown in the official receipt may not always be the same as the output VAT ultimately declared by the forwarder in its VAT return. For cross-border movement, the forwarder’s actual gross receipts are determined by deducting from total receipts the amounts due to third-party service providers, exclusive of VAT and amounts held in trust.
If the forwarder’s actual commission is higher than 5% of freight, the output VAT must be based on actual taxable gross receipts. In the circular’s illustration, although the VAT official receipt showed output VAT of only P1,210.50, the actual taxable gross receipts amounted to P19,450.00, resulting in output VAT of P2,334.00. The forwarder must declare P2,334.00 in its VAT return and attach a reconciling schedule.
If the forwarder’s actual commission is lower than 5% of freight, the forwarder must still report the output VAT already passed on to the client if that amount is higher. In the illustration, the computed output VAT based on actual taxable gross receipts was P1,134.00, but the VAT passed on to the client was P1,210.50. The forwarder must report P1,210.50 for VAT purposes.
Expanded Withholding Tax Treatment: 2%, Not 10%
For expanded withholding tax purposes, RMC No. 35-2006 states that freight forwarders are not treated as commercial brokers or agents subject to 10% withholding tax. Instead, they are treated as other contractors, specifically operators of forwarding establishments, under Section 2.57.2(E)(4)(d) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 6-2001. The applicable EWT rate is 2%.
For cross-border transactions, the 2% EWT to be withheld and remitted by the client or shipper is based only on the gross commissions received, plus local origin or destination charges and CAF. For services subject to regular VAT, the circular provides the formula: EWT equals VAT amount multiplied by 2%, divided by the VAT rate. For zero-rated services, EWT equals total compensation for zero-rated services multiplied by 2%.
The circular also treats payments to third-party service providers as subject to expanded withholding tax. The forwarder must withhold and remit the 2% EWT on behalf of various shippers because the forwarder controls the disbursement of the funds. The forwarder must also prepare a listing or summary of shippers or clients showing the freight and accessorial charges, net of commission, and attach the summary to the EWT return filed with the BIR.
For local transactions, the withholding of 2% EWT generally falls on the shipper who claims the expense for income tax purposes. If the forwarder issues a VAT official receipt for the entire amount, the shipper withholds 2% EWT on the entire amount exclusive of VAT. If part of the amount is booked as advances or reimbursable expenses, the shipper remains primarily responsible for remitting withholding taxes on the reimbursable amounts because the shipper is the party ultimately claiming the expense.
Penalties and Audit Risks for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 35-2006 does not impose a new special penalty rate, but it identifies serious tax consequences and audit risks. For cross-border movement, BIR examiners are directed to require the covering contract or rate agreement between the forwarder and the shipping or airline company, together with other relevant documents, to determine the actual commission earned by the forwarder.
The circular also adopts an audit priority rule. Freight forwarders that report commissions, whether in VAT official receipts or VAT returns, below 5% of total freight charged are first priority for audit. For local movement, forwarders that do not report the entire amount as gross receipts even though the transaction is covered by a VAT official receipt issued by the forwarder are also subject to first priority audit.
The substantiation rule is equally important. Payments to third-party service providers for actual freight, accessorial charges, and offshore origin or destination charges must be supported by official receipts issued by the international carrier, foreign freight forwarder, or foreign agent in the name of the freight forwarder, plus acceptable proofs of payment and relevant documents such as billing statements, deposit slips, confirmation receipts, acknowledgment receipts, contracts, summaries, or schedules. If these documents are missing, the payments may be treated as part of the forwarder’s gross receipts subject to VAT and may be disallowed as deductions for income tax purposes.
Practical Steps for Freight Forwarders, Shippers, Importers, and Exporters
Freight forwarders should immediately review whether their billing statements separate VATable charges from amounts payable to third-party service providers. For cross-border movement, the billing statement should clearly identify local origin charges, local destination charges, CAF, commissions, freight net of commission, accessorial charges, and offshore origin or destination charges. The VAT official receipt should cover only the VATable charges, while non-VAT amounts held in trust should be properly documented.
For local movement, forwarders should decide whether the full amount will be treated as their gross receipts or whether part of the charges will be treated as reimbursable expenses or advances. If the latter approach is used, the forwarder must ensure that third-party official receipts are issued directly in the name of the shipper, Non-VAT Acknowledgment Receipts are issued for reimbursements, and the accounting entry “RECEIVABLE FOR CASH ADVANCES ON BEHALF OF SHIPPERS” is used consistently.
Shippers, importers, exporters, and corporate accountants should review freight forwarding invoices before booking input VAT, deductions, and withholding taxes. Search terms such as VAT on freight forwarding charges Philippines, 2% EWT freight forwarder, RMC 35-2006 VAT treatment, freight forwarder reimbursable expenses VAT, and withholding tax on freight and accessorial charges are directly relevant to this compliance review.
Businesses should also confirm whether BIR Form No. 2307 is being issued correctly. For third-party service provider payments made through the forwarder, the certificate should reflect the proper payor, agent, and payee relationship required by RMC No. 35-2006. Incorrect withholding documentation may create issues for the shipper claiming deductions and for the service provider claiming creditable taxes withheld.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 35-2006 is especially important for logistics companies, importers, exporters, manufacturers, distributors, e-commerce sellers, and businesses that regularly pay freight forwarding charges. The tax exposure usually comes from documentation gaps: VAT official receipts issued for the wrong amount, Non-VAT Acknowledgment Receipts not supported by third-party receipts, commissions below the 5% audit benchmark, or EWT remittances and BIR Form No. 2307 certificates that do not match the actual transaction flow.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses in reviewing freight forwarding contracts, billing statements, VAT official receipts, withholding tax procedures, BIR Form No. 2307 documentation, and audit defense strategies. For help with BIR compliance, VAT exposure, EWT treatment, or tax audit documentation involving freight forwarders and logistics transactions, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.