RMC No. 44-2005 classifies software payments as royalties, business income, services, or know-how, with specific withholding tax and VAT rules.
Businesses paying for computer software must classify the transaction correctly before payment because RMC No. 44-2005 treats some software payments as royalties subject to final withholding tax, some as ordinary business income subject to creditable withholding tax, and some as service income or rental income depending on the rights transferred. The most important practical consequence is that a Philippine buyer, reseller, distributor, retailer, subsidiary, or end-user may become the withholding agent for income tax and VAT, especially when the software owner or licensor is a nonresident foreign payee.
What RMC No. 44-2005 changed for software payments
RMC No. 44-2005 provides the BIR’s guidelines for the taxation of payments for computer software. It recognizes that software transactions are not taxed in only one way. The tax treatment depends on whether the transaction involves a transfer of copyright rights, a transfer of a copyrighted article, software development or modification services, or the provision of know-how relating to software programming techniques.
The circular defines software as a program or series of programs containing instructions for a computer, whether operational software or application software. It may be transferred in writing, electronically, by magnetic tape or disk, laser disk, CD-ROM, Internet download, network transfer, as part of computer hardware, or in an independent form usable on different hardware.
The key rule is that payments for the use of, or the right to use, copyright over software are generally royalties. However, payments for a mere copy of software, without the acquisition of copyright rights, are generally business income. This distinction matters because royalties may be subject to final withholding tax, while ordinary business income may be subject to regular income tax and creditable withholding tax depending on the payee and payor.
When software payments are treated as royalties
Payments are treated as royalties when they are made for the use of, or the right to use, copyright relating to software. RMC No. 44-2005 treats software as generally assimilated to literary, artistic, or scientific work protected by copyright laws. Therefore, where a taxpayer pays for rights that belong to the copyright owner, the payment may be royalty income.
A transaction is classified as a transfer of copyright rights if the transferee acquires any of the following rights: the right to make copies of the software for distribution to the public by sale, transfer of ownership, rental, lease, or lending; the right to prepare derivative computer programs based on the copyrighted software; the right to make a public performance of the software; the right to publicly display the computer program; or any other right of the copyright owner, the unauthorized exercise of which would constitute copyright infringement.
Where only copyright rights are transferred and not full copyright ownership, the payments are royalties. A transaction that does not transfer all substantial rights in the copyright is treated as a license generating royalty income.
When software payments are treated as business income
Payments are generally treated as business income when the transaction involves the transfer of a copyrighted article rather than copyright rights. A copyrighted article includes a copy of software fixed in a floppy disk, CD-ROM, computer memory, hard drive, or any other medium from which the work can be perceived, reproduced, or communicated.
If the buyer acquires a copy of software but does not acquire copyright rights, or acquires only a de minimis grant of such rights, and the transaction does not involve services or know-how, the transfer is classified solely as a transfer of a copyrighted article. The payments for that copyrighted article constitute business income.
RMC No. 44-2005 also states that site license, enterprise license, and network license arrangements will generally be dealt with as business income where the rights to make multiple copies are limited to copies necessary to operate the software within the licensee’s own business. This is important for companies buying software for internal operations because the ability to install the software on several computers or within a network does not automatically make the payment a royalty if the copying right is only for internal operational use.
Tax treatment of software ownership and copyright transfers
For a full or partial transfer of copyright by a resident individual owner, the payment forms part of the owner’s gross income and is subject to the graduated income tax rates of 5% to 32% under Section 24 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997. For a domestic corporation owner, the amount paid forms part of gross income and is subject to 32% income tax under Section 27 of the NIRC.
For a transfer by a foreign corporation engaged in trade or business in the Philippines, the payment forms part of gross income and taxable income subject to 32% income tax under Section 28 of the NIRC. For a nonresident foreign corporation, the amount paid for the copyright or portions transferred is subject to a final tax of 32% based on gross income.
If the foreign owner of the copyright is a resident of a country with an existing tax treaty with the Philippines, royalties paid to that owner may be subject to the reduced treaty rate on royalties, provided the treaty conditions are complied with. RMC No. 44-2005 does not supply a single treaty rate because the applicable rate depends on the relevant tax treaty.
Tax treatment for resellers, distributors, retailers, and local subsidiaries
Payments made by a local subsidiary, reseller, distributor, or retailer to a domestic corporation owner of a copyright, or to a reseller or distributor licensee of a copyright, are subject to a final income tax of 20% based on the gross amount of royalties under Section 27(D) of the NIRC. The local subsidiary, reseller, distributor, or retailer making the payment must withhold the tax.
Payments made by local subsidiaries, resellers, distributors, or retailers to a nonresident foreign licensor or owner of software are royalties subject to 32% final income tax based on the gross amount under Section 28(B)(1) of the NIRC. The full amount must be withheld and collected by the subsidiary, reseller, distributor, or retailer making the payment under RR No. 2-98. Again, if the foreign licensor or owner is entitled to tax treaty relief, the reduced treaty rate may apply if the conditions are complied with.
Tax treatment for end-users buying or licensing software
When an end-user purchases copyrighted articles from local subsidiaries, resellers, distributors, or distributors of resellers, the payments are business income to the seller. The seller is subject to 32% income tax based on net taxable income if it is a domestic corporation under Section 27(A) of the NIRC.
The end-user must withhold 2% income tax on the gross amount of payments to the local subsidiary, reseller, or distributor if the end-user is required to withhold under RR No. 2-98, as amended by RR No. 14-02. The required withholding agents include a juridical person whether or not engaged in trade or business, an individual with respect to payments made in connection with trade or business, and a government office including a government-owned or controlled corporation and provincial, city, or municipal government.
Where a local end-user directly acquires a license to use software from a foreign owner or licensor, payments made by the end-user to the foreign licensor or owner are royalties subject to 32% income tax based on gross amount, imposed on royalties derived by a nonresident foreign corporation. The end-user must withhold and collect the tax. A reduced tax treaty royalty rate may apply if the foreign licensor or owner is a resident of a treaty country and the applicable treaty conditions are satisfied.
VAT on software transactions
RMC No. 44-2005 states that the following software payments are subject to 10% value-added tax under Sections 106 and 108 of the NIRC: royalty payments for the use of copyright over software; payments made to resellers, distributors, or retailers engaged in the trade or business of distributing or selling software; and payments for services rendered in the Philippines in connection with software purchased.
For nonresident payees, the payor in control of the VAT payment must withhold VAT on the relevant fees on behalf of the nonresident payee. The payor must file a separate VAT return for and on behalf of the nonresident payee using BIR Form No. 1600, the Monthly Remittance Return of Value-Added Tax and Other Percentage Taxes Withheld. The duly filed BIR Form No. 1600 and proof of payment serve as sufficient basis for the payor’s claim of input tax against output tax that may be due.
The payor is also required to issue BIR Form No. 2307, Certificate of Creditable Tax Withheld at Source, in quadruplicate upon the request of the nonresident payee. The first three copies are given to the payee, while the fourth copy is retained by the payor.
Mixed software contracts, after-sales service, and know-how
Software contracts may include installation, maintenance, customization, or other after-sales services by the foreign licensor or owner, or by a local subsidiary, reseller, or distributor. RMC No. 44-2005 requires the contract price to be broken down, either based on the contract or by reasonable apportionment, so each component receives the correct tax treatment. The portion for the use of software is treated as royalties, while the portion for services is treated as income from services.
If one part of the contract is by far the principal purpose and the other parts are merely ancillary and largely unimportant, the tax treatment of the principal part generally applies to the whole consideration. This de minimis rule is important for bundled software and service arrangements because businesses should document the commercial purpose and allocation of fees before payment.
Where a software house or programmer supplies information about the ideas and principles underlying the program, such as logic, algorithms, programming languages, or techniques, the payment may be characterized as royalties to the extent it is consideration for secret formulas or information concerning industrial, commercial, or scientific experience.
Effective date and revoked issuance
RMC No. 44-2005 took effect immediately and covers software payments paid or payable starting its effectivity date. It also revoked or amended inconsistent revenue issuances, including RMC No. 77-2003, to the extent inconsistent with the new guidelines.
The circular is dated September 1, 2005. Businesses reviewing software payments, foreign software licenses, SaaS-style contracts, enterprise licenses, reseller arrangements, software maintenance fees, and payments to nonresident software licensors should therefore treat the classification of the software transaction as a front-end tax compliance issue, not merely an accounting issue after payment.
Practical steps for businesses, CFOs, and accountants
Companies should first identify what the contract actually transfers: copyright ownership, copyright rights, a copyrighted article, services, rental rights, or know-how. The contract label is not controlling if the rights granted show a different tax character. A payment called a license fee may be a royalty, business income, service income, or rental income depending on the rights and obligations in the transaction.
Second, determine whether the payee is a domestic corporation, resident individual, resident foreign corporation, nonresident foreign corporation, local reseller, or foreign licensor. This directly affects whether the applicable income tax treatment is 20% final withholding tax on domestic corporate royalty payments, 32% final withholding tax on royalties to nonresident foreign corporations, 2% creditable withholding tax on certain payments to local resellers or distributors, or regular income tax treatment.
Third, determine whether VAT applies and whether VAT must be withheld on behalf of a nonresident payee through BIR Form No. 1600. For software payments to nonresidents, the VAT withholding obligation is a major compliance point because the payor may need the filed BIR Form No. 1600 and proof of payment to support its input tax claim.
Fourth, for foreign licensors or owners, review tax treaty availability before payment. RMC No. 44-2005 recognizes reduced treaty royalty rates when the foreign owner or licensor is a resident of a country with an existing tax treaty with the Philippines and the prescribed conditions are met. Businesses should not assume treaty relief applies automatically.
Finally, businesses should keep the software contract, invoice, payment records, withholding tax returns, VAT withholding documents, BIR Form No. 1600, proof of payment, and BIR Form No. 2307 where applicable. These documents are essential in a BIR audit involving software license fees, enterprise software payments, reseller purchases, direct foreign software subscriptions, and withholding tax on royalties.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco can help
RMC No. 44-2005 remains important for Philippine businesses that pay for software, license foreign platforms, buy enterprise software, resell software, or structure IT service contracts with local and foreign providers. The wrong classification can result in under-withholding, VAT exposure, disallowed input tax claims, and audit disputes over whether a payment is a royalty, business income, service income, rental income, or capital gain.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, CFOs, accountants, and in-house legal teams on BIR compliance, withholding tax, VAT, tax treaty analysis, software licensing, reseller contracts, and cross-border technology payments. For assistance in reviewing software agreements, royalty withholding, VAT withholding for nonresident payees, and BIR audit exposure, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.