RMC No. 39-2004 allowed Local Water Districts to settle 1996-2002 income and franchise tax liabilities by paying 40% within strict BIR deadlines.
Local Water Districts with unresolved income tax and franchise tax liabilities for taxable years 1996 to 2002 were given a limited settlement window: pay 40% of the income and franchise tax liabilities due, execute the required Settlement Agreement, and submit the required documents to the proper Revenue District Office within the stated deadlines. For taxable years 2000 to 2002, the deadline was July 30, 2004. For taxable years 1996 to 1999, the deadline was December 15, 2004. Failure to avail within those dates meant exposure to collection of the full tax due, including increments.
What RMC No. 39-2004 Changed for Local Water District Tax Liabilities
RMC No. 39-2004 prescribed a settlement mechanism for the income tax and franchise tax liabilities of Local Water Districts organized under then Presidential Decree No. 198 for taxable years 1996 to 2002. The measure was anchored on the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s authority to abate or cancel internal revenue taxes, penalties, and interest under Section 204(B), in relation to Section 7(c), of the Tax Reform Code.
The core relief was specific: a Local Water District that duly executed the Settlement Agreement and fully complied with its terms could settle in full its income and franchise tax liabilities for taxable years 1996 to 2002 by paying the equivalent of 40% of the income and franchise tax liabilities due for those years.
This was not a blanket exemption from tax. It was a compromise-style settlement mechanism with strict documentary and payment requirements. The benefit applied only to Local Water Districts that availed of the Settlement Agreement within the prescribed periods and complied with the terms and conditions required by the Bureau of Internal Revenue.
Who Was Affected by RMC No. 39-2004
The issuance specifically affected Local Water Districts organized under then Presidential Decree No. 198 with income tax and franchise tax liabilities for taxable years 1996 to 2002. These were public utility entities operating water services and facing historical income and franchise tax exposure for the covered years.
The issuance also directly affected Revenue District Offices having jurisdiction over Local Water Districts. The RDO was the office where the Local Water District availing of the settlement mechanism had to submit the duly executed Settlement Agreement and make the payment due. The RDO was also required to forward the Settlement Agreement, supporting requirements, and proof of payment to the Office of the Commissioner.
For accountants, finance officers, and counsel of Local Water Districts, the most important search phrases connected with this issuance are: RMC No. 39-2004 local water district tax settlement, Local Water District income tax liabilities 1996 to 2002, franchise tax liabilities Local Water Districts Philippines, BIR 40% tax settlement Local Water District, and PD 198 water district tax liabilities.
Key Settlement Rate and Covered Taxable Years
The settlement rate under RMC No. 39-2004 was 40% of the income and franchise tax liabilities due for taxable years 1996 to 2002. The phrase “income and franchise tax liabilities” is important because the mechanism was not limited to one tax type. It covered both income tax liabilities and franchise tax liabilities for the specified taxable years.
The covered period was divided into two deadline groups. For taxable years 2000, 2001, and 2002, the payment and requirements were due on or before July 30, 2004. For taxable years 1996, 1997, 1998, and 1999, the payment and requirements were due on or before December 15, 2004.
RMC No. 39-2004 also recognized that some Local Water Districts may be financially unable to pay even the 40% settlement amount. In such cases, the Commissioner could, on a case-to-case basis, allow the abatement or cancellation of tax liabilities, penalties, and interest lower than 40%, but only upon application by the Local Water District showing financial incapacity to pay the taxes, penalties, and interest.
Deadlines Under RMC No. 39-2004
The first key deadline was July 30, 2004. This applied to the payment and requirements for taxable years 2000 to 2002, inclusive. A Local Water District seeking settlement for those years had to execute the Settlement Agreement, comply with the required terms and conditions, and pay the amount due through the RDO having jurisdiction over it on or before that date.
The second key deadline was December 15, 2004. This applied to the payment and requirements for taxable years 1996 to 1999, inclusive. A Local Water District seeking settlement for those earlier years had to comply within that separate deadline.
These deadlines mattered because the circular expressly stated that after the dates referred to, Local Water Districts would no longer be allowed to settle their tax liabilities for the covered years under the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement. In other words, the 40% settlement mechanism was time-bound and conditional.
Verification by the Revenue District Office
RMC No. 39-2004 did not allow Local Water Districts to make unverified or final self-assessments without review. The RDO concerned was ordered to verify the truth and correctness of the self-assessment made by the Local Water District.
For taxable years 2000 to 2002, the RDO had one year from July 30, 2004 to verify the truth and correctness of the self-assessment. For taxable years 1996 to 1999, the RDO had one year from December 15, 2004 to verify the truth and correctness of the self-assessment.
If the RDO determined that the self-assessment made by the Local Water District was not true or correct, the RDO was required to inform the Commissioner in writing. This means the settlement mechanism depended not only on payment and submission, but also on accurate reporting and proper self-assessment by the Local Water District.
Penalties and Consequences for Non-Compliance
The principal consequence for non-availment or late availment was loss of the settlement benefit. After the applicable deadlines, Local Water Districts could no longer settle the covered liabilities under the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement.
RMC No. 39-2004 instructed revenue officers to apply the full force of the law against Local Water Districts that did not avail of the settlement mechanism. This included collection of the full amount of the tax due and the increments thereto. The word “increments” is significant because it indicates that the exposure was not merely the basic tax, but also the applicable additions connected with unpaid tax liabilities.
The issuance also directed revenue officers to ensure that all income and franchise tax liabilities due from Local Water Districts beginning January 1, 2003, including increments if any, were assessed and collected from Local Water Districts under their jurisdiction. This made clear that the settlement mechanism was limited to taxable years 1996 to 2002 and did not excuse liabilities beginning 2003.
Practical Steps for Local Water Districts and Their Accountants
For Local Water Districts covered by RMC No. 39-2004, the immediate task at the time was to determine the income and franchise tax liabilities due for taxable years 1996 to 2002, segregate the liabilities by deadline group, and compute the 40% settlement amount.
The next step was to execute the required Settlement Agreement and submit it to the Revenue District Office having jurisdiction over the Local Water District. The Local Water District also had to submit the requirements under the Settlement Agreement and proof of payment of the income and franchise taxes due.
Where a Local Water District could not pay the 40% settlement amount, the appropriate course was to apply for abatement or cancellation below 40% by showing financial incapacity. The issuance made this relief discretionary and case-specific, meaning the Local Water District had to substantiate its inability to pay.
For post-2002 compliance, Local Water Districts needed to ensure that income and franchise tax liabilities beginning January 1, 2003 were properly assessed, reported, and paid. RMC No. 39-2004 expressly instructed revenue officers to collect liabilities from 2003 onward, including increments where applicable.
Why RMC No. 39-2004 Still Matters for Tax Risk Reviews
Although RMC No. 39-2004 dealt with historical liabilities, it remains relevant in tax due diligence, local government utility reviews, water district compliance audits, and legacy tax exposure assessments. A Local Water District’s records should show whether it availed of the settlement mechanism, whether the Settlement Agreement was executed, whether payment was made, and whether the RDO later questioned the truth or correctness of the self-assessment.
For a buyer, lender, regulator, or auditor reviewing a Local Water District or related water utility arrangement, the key question is not merely whether old liabilities existed. The question is whether the covered income and franchise tax liabilities for 1996 to 2002 were settled under the 40% mechanism, whether supporting documents were filed with the correct RDO, and whether later tax liabilities from January 1, 2003 onward were assessed and collected.
ASG Law Can Assist with BIR Compliance and Historical Tax Exposure Reviews
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, regulated entities, public utility stakeholders, accountants, and business owners on BIR compliance, tax assessments, settlement options, and historical tax exposure reviews. For Local Water Districts and entities dealing with old tax liabilities, the practical issue is often documentary: proving what was filed, what was paid, what was settled, and what remains collectible.
If your organization is reviewing Local Water District tax exposure, BIR assessments, franchise tax liabilities, income tax liabilities, or settlement documentation under RMC No. 39-2004, ASG Law can help assess the legal and tax compliance position, prepare submissions, and coordinate a practical response strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on BIR compliance and tax risk management.