RMC No. 10-2004 clarifies VAT, refund, invoice replacement, and Gross Receipts Tax rules for banks and non-bank financial intermediaries under RA 9238.

Banks and non-bank financial intermediaries that handled government transactions and interbank transactions in January and February 2004 had to act quickly: VAT withheld by government agencies could not simply be deducted from VAT or gross receipts tax, and refund or invoice-correction steps had fixed cut-off dates of April 30, 2004 and May 31, 2004. RMC No. 10-2004 clarified how banks and non-bank financial intermediaries should treat VAT, non-VAT invoices, interbank transactions, and the reimposed Gross Receipts Tax under Republic Act No. 9238.

What RMC No. 10-2004 Changed

RMC No. 10-2004 supplemented RMC No. 9-2004 in relation to the implementation of Republic Act No. 9238, particularly for banks and non-bank financial intermediaries affected by the reimposition of Gross Receipts Tax. The circular addressed two major transition issues: first, the treatment of VAT withheld by government agencies and instrumentalities on services rendered by banks and non-bank financial intermediaries; and second, the treatment of interbank financial transactions entered into in 2004 before the publication of Republic Act No. 9238 on February 16, 2004.

Before the reimposition of Gross Receipts Tax, government agencies and instrumentalities such as the Bureau of Treasury and the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas were required under Section 114(c) of the Tax Code of 1997 to deduct and withhold VAT at the rate of six percent (6%) on gross receipts for services rendered. That withholding was creditable against the VAT liability of the person from whom the VAT was withheld. RMC No. 10-2004 clarified that, for the affected banks and financial intermediaries, those amounts could not be used as deductions from either VAT liability or Gross Receipts Tax.

Who Is Affected

The circular applies to all banks, non-bank financial intermediaries performing quasi-banking functions, non-bank financial intermediaries, internal revenue officers, and other concerned parties. In practical terms, this affected banks and financial institutions that received payments from government agencies or instrumentalities where six percent (6%) VAT had been withheld under Section 114(c) of the Tax Code.

It also affected banks and non-bank financial intermediaries that entered into interbank financial transactions in January 2004 and in February 2004 before the February 16, 2004 publication of Republic Act No. 9238. Tax departments, finance officers, bank compliance teams, and accountants had to review whether VAT invoices had been issued, whether VAT had been withheld, whether non-VAT invoices had to be issued in replacement, and whether refund or adjustment deadlines applied.

VAT Withheld by Government Agencies Cannot Be Deducted by Banks

The most important rule under RMC No. 10-2004 is that banks and non-bank financial intermediaries may not deduct from their VAT liability or from their Gross Receipts Tax the VAT collected from government agencies and instrumentalities where the latter withheld six percent (6%) VAT on gross receipts for services rendered and remitted the same to the BIR under Section 114(c) of the Tax Code.

Instead, the BIR stated that it would refund the VAT charged by the banks and non-bank financial intermediaries to the government agencies or instrumentalities, but only upon application by those government agencies or instrumentalities. The refund required proof that the amount required to be withheld and remitted under Section 114(c) had actually been remitted to and collected by the BIR.

The circular also required that the banks or non-bank financial intermediaries must have reported and listed the government agencies or instrumentalities as withholding agents that withheld VAT from them in their January and February 2004 VAT returns, and the amounts withheld must have been reported in those returns.

Refund Deadlines for January and February 2004 Government Transactions

RMC No. 10-2004 imposed specific refund application deadlines. For transactions entered into in January 2004, the request for refund had to be received by the BIR on or before April 30, 2004. For transactions entered into in February 2004, the request for refund had to be received by the BIR on or before May 31, 2004.

These dates were critical because the circular did not give banks and non-bank financial intermediaries a general right to offset the withheld VAT against their own tax liabilities. The mechanism was a refund to the government agency or instrumentality, subject to proof of actual remittance and proper reporting in the January and February 2004 VAT returns of the bank or financial intermediary.

Rules for Interbank Transactions Before February 16, 2004

For interbank transactions entered into by banks and non-bank financial intermediaries in taxable year 2004 before the publication of Republic Act No. 9238, RMC No. 10-2004 set out transition rules covering VAT filing, Gross Receipts Tax filing, input tax treatment, invoice surrender, refunds between counterparties, and GRT adjustments.

Banks and non-bank financial intermediaries were required to file a VAT return and remit VAT on or before February 25, 2004 for transactions entered into in January 2004. For transactions entered into in February 2004 before the publication of Republic Act No. 9238, the VAT return and payment were due on March 20 or March 25, 2004, as applicable. The circular expressly provided that no deduction or adjustment would be allowed against the VAT liability arising from interbank transactions entered into during that period.

The circular separately required banks and non-bank financial intermediaries to report and pay Gross Receipts Tax on transactions entered into for January 2004 on or before February 25, 2004. For subsequent months, the Gross Receipts Tax was to be reported and paid on the 25th day following the month when the transactions occurred.

No Input Tax Allowed on VAT Invoices Issued by Banks and Financial Intermediaries

RMC No. 10-2004 made clear that no input tax would be allowed for any VAT invoice issued by banks and non-bank financial intermediaries. However, the recipient had two possible treatments. The amount may be included as part of the cost of the goods or services subject of the invoice, or the VAT invoice may be surrendered to the issuing bank or non-bank financial intermediary for cancellation and replacement with a new non-VAT invoice.

This rule was especially important for corporate accountants and tax managers searching for Philippine tax treatment of bank VAT invoices, non-VAT invoice replacement, and input VAT on interbank transactions. The circular effectively disallowed input VAT claims from such VAT invoices and directed taxpayers toward cost treatment or invoice correction.

Refunds Between Counterparty Banks and Invoice Surrender Deadlines

For transactions entered into during the transition period, banks and non-bank financial intermediaries could request a refund from their counterparty banks or non-bank financial intermediaries. This was allowed only if the VAT receipts or VAT invoices were surrendered within the prescribed deadlines.

For transactions entered into in January 2004, VAT receipts had to be surrendered on or before April 30, 2004. For transactions entered into in February 2004, VAT receipts had to be surrendered on or before May 31, 2004. The issuing bank or non-bank financial intermediary then had to cancel the VAT invoice and issue a non-VAT invoice in its place.

Adjustment Against Gross Receipts Tax

A bank could claim an adjustment of the VAT actually refunded against its Gross Receipts Tax liability, but only within strict limits. For January 2004 transactions, the adjustment could be claimed only up to the month of April 2004. For February 2004 transactions, the adjustment could be claimed only up to the month of May 2004.

The transaction had to be substantiated by the client-surrendered and cancelled VAT invoice and by the issuance of a non-VAT invoice in place of the cancelled VAT invoice. In other words, a GRT adjustment was not automatic. It required an actual refund, the surrender and cancellation of the VAT invoice, and the issuance of the replacement non-VAT invoice.

Penalty Relief for January 2004 VAT Filing

RMC No. 10-2004 allowed banks and non-bank financial intermediaries to file their VAT return and pay VAT due for January 2004 transactions on or before February 25, 2004 without being subjected to surcharge, penalty, and interest that may otherwise be due for late filing and payment. This was a specific transitional relief tied to the January 2004 filing and payment deadline.

The circular did not create a blanket penalty amnesty for all periods or all taxes. It specifically addressed the January 2004 VAT return and VAT payment for affected banks and non-bank financial intermediaries, provided filing and payment were made on or before February 25, 2004.

Practical Steps for Banks and Financial Intermediaries

For historical tax audits, document reconstruction, and compliance reviews involving RMC No. 10-2004, banks and non-bank financial intermediaries should confirm whether January and February 2004 VAT returns properly listed government agencies and instrumentalities that withheld six percent (6%) VAT. They should also check whether the withheld VAT was reported in the relevant VAT returns and whether the government agencies had proof that the amounts were actually remitted to and collected by the BIR.

For interbank transactions, compliance teams should verify whether VAT was remitted by February 25, 2004 for January 2004 transactions and by March 20 or March 25, 2004 for February 2004 transactions entered into before February 16, 2004. They should also confirm whether Gross Receipts Tax for January 2004 was reported and paid by February 25, 2004 and whether subsequent GRT was paid on the 25th day following the month of the transaction.

Where VAT invoices were issued, the key documents are the surrendered VAT invoice, proof of cancellation, replacement non-VAT invoice, proof of refund to the counterparty, and the GRT adjustment computation. These records matter because RMC No. 10-2004 allowed the GRT adjustment only where the refund was actually made and properly substantiated.

Key Search Terms for Tax Teams

Taxpayers and accountants researching this issuance commonly search for terms such as RMC No. 10-2004 Gross Receipts Tax banks, Republic Act No. 9238 bank GRT, VAT withheld by government agencies Section 114(c), interbank transactions VAT invoice non-VAT invoice, and BIR refund VAT banks February 2004. These phrases all point to the same compliance issue: how financial institutions should unwind or report VAT during the transition back to Gross Receipts Tax.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 10-2004 is a good example of how Philippine tax compliance can turn on transition rules, invoice treatment, refund procedures, and strict documentation deadlines. For banks, non-bank financial intermediaries, corporate taxpayers, and businesses dealing with financial institutions, the practical issue is not only knowing the rule but proving compliance through returns, invoices, withholding records, refund papers, and tax payment documents.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, financial institutions, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing BIR issuances, reconstructing tax compliance files, preparing responses to BIR findings, and advising on VAT, Gross Receipts Tax, withholding tax, and refund issues. For assistance with BIR compliance, tax audits, or Philippine tax advisory work, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *