RMO No. 23-2024 introduces risk-based VAT refund verification, with low-risk, medium-risk, and high-risk classifications affecting BIR review scope.
VAT refund claimants filing from July 1, 2024 onward must prepare for a new risk-based verification system: low-risk claims may no longer undergo sales and purchase verification, medium-risk claims will generally be checked at a 50% verification rate, and high-risk claims will still be subject to 100% verification. For businesses with recurring VAT refund claims, especially exporters, zero-rated sellers, importers, and companies claiming unutilized input VAT, RMO No. 23-2024 changes how refund dossiers should be prepared, reviewed, and defended before the BIR.
What RMO No. 23-2024 Changes
RMO No. 23-2024 prescribes the guidelines, policies, and procedures for implementing the risk-based approach in the verification and processing of Value-Added Tax refund claims under Section 112(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 11976, otherwise known as the Ease of Paying Taxes Act, and as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 5-2024.
The key change is that VAT refund claims will no longer be verified in exactly the same manner regardless of risk profile. Instead, the BIR will classify each VAT refund claim as low-risk, medium-risk, or high-risk using a point system. The classification will then determine the extent of verification of sales and purchases. This is significant because a low-risk classification can substantially reduce audit friction, while a high-risk classification can still result in full verification of both sales and purchases.
The order also reinforces the statutory 90-day period for processing VAT refund claims. BIR offices and officials who possess data needed for risk classification must respond to the processing office within five days from receipt of the request. Because the law mandates a 90-day processing period, the order states that failure by a BIR office or official to provide data within the prescribed five-day period may result in administrative action if that inaction causes delay in the processing of the VAT refund claim.
Who Is Affected
RMO No. 23-2024 is most relevant to VAT-registered businesses that regularly file VAT refund claims, particularly exporters, taxpayers with zero-rated sales, companies with excess or unutilized input VAT, importers claiming input VAT on importations, and enterprises with recurring quarterly, semestral, or annual refund applications.
Large corporations and sophisticated taxpayers with frequent refund claims should pay close attention because prior refund history, frequency of filing, amount of claim, tax compliance history, and prior disallowances are now express risk factors. SMEs that are first-time VAT refund claimants should also take note because first-time claimants are automatically treated as high-risk for the succeeding three VAT refund claims. For purposes of the order, a first-time claimant refers to one with no history of VAT refund application since registration with the BIR, or no previous administrative claim for VAT refund for the last five years prior to the application, as certified by the BIR Assessment Programs Division.
Automatic High-Risk VAT Refund Claims
Several claims are automatically treated as high-risk and therefore require full verification. These include VAT refund claims filed from April 27, 2024 to June 30, 2024; claims filed by first-time claimants, which remain high-risk for the succeeding three VAT refund claims; the fourth claim following three consecutive low-risk classifications of processed VAT refund claims; claims filed under Section 112(B) of the Tax Code; claims filed by taxpayers tagged as Cannot Be Located; claims filed by taxpayers with complaints duly filed at the Department of Justice or those facing criminal cases before the courts under the Run After Tax Evaders and Run After Fake Transactions programs; claims filed by taxpayers whose immediately preceding VAT refund claim was fully denied; and VAT refund applications covering more than one taxable quarter where at least one taxable quarter is already prescribed.
The enumeration is not exclusive. Other cases may be considered high-risk as determined by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue based on reasonable criteria, including relevant risk factors not otherwise captured in the risk matrix.
Risk Classification Thresholds
The risk classification is determined using a point system based on main risk factors. These include the amount of the VAT refund claim, frequency of filing VAT refund claims, tax compliance history, and other risk factors such as the level of disallowance from previous claims.
The resulting weighted average is interpreted as follows: low-risk means 35.00% and below; medium-risk means above 35.00% but not exceeding 60.00%; and high-risk means above 60.00%. The risk matrix attached to the order is used as a guide by the processing offices in determining the risk level of a particular VAT refund claim.
The order also addresses missing data. If the processing office cannot secure data from the concerned office, or if data relating to a specific risk factor is unavailable, that risk factor is excluded from the matrix. The weight assigned to the excluded factor is then reallocated to the corresponding risk factor with available data or information within the same category. However, the processing office must properly document its efforts to secure the data, such as email or letter requests, follow-ups, and other similar communications.
Verification Rules for Low-Risk, Medium-Risk, and High-Risk Claims
All risk levels still require submission of complete documentary requirements prescribed by the BIR. Before officially receiving the application, the assigned Revenue Officer must conduct checklisting and pre-verification procedures to ensure completeness of the documents submitted by the taxpayer-claimant. Only applications with complete documentary requirements are to be received and processed by the authorized processing office.
For low-risk VAT refund claims, processing is limited to checking the authenticity and completeness of the documentary requirements under the Checklist of Mandatory Requirements in RMO No. 71-2023. Verification of sales of goods and services, purchases, and input tax is no longer performed. This is the most important practical benefit of being classified as low-risk.
For medium-risk claims, the default verification rate is 50%. For sales transactions, the documents subject to verification must cover at least 50% of the amount of sales and 50% of the total invoices or receipts, including inward remittances and proof of VAT zero-rating. The documents are randomly assigned numbers and sorted from lowest to highest, with the first 50% forming the documents for verification. If the selected documents are insufficient to cover the minimum 50% of total zero-rated and exempt sales, additional documents are examined until the 50% threshold is reached. Sales adjustments supported by credit or debit memos, journal vouchers, and other relevant documents must also be fully verified in addition to the minimum 50% sales verification.
For local purchases with input VAT claimed in medium-risk cases, verification must consider 50% of total suppliers, with suppliers for big-ticket purchases prioritized. The remaining non-big-ticket suppliers are randomly numbered and sorted. If the selected documents do not cover at least 50% of total local purchases with input VAT claimed, additional documents are examined until the minimum 50% threshold is reached. Big-ticket purchases are subject to 100% verification of supporting purchase invoices or receipts, including the related proof of payment.
For importations with input VAT claimed in medium-risk cases, verification must consider 50% of total suppliers of imported purchases of goods for which input VAT is claimed. If the selected documents do not cover at least 50% of total importations with input VAT claimed, additional documents must be examined until the minimum 50% threshold is covered. Verification of refund claims for unutilized input VAT on importations must include the VAT Payment Certification issued by the Revenue Accounting Division of the Bureau of Customs and copies of Import Entry and Internal Revenue Declarations or Informal Import Declaration or Single Administrative Document submitted by the taxpayer-claimant as part of the mandatory requirements.
For high-risk claims, 100% verification of sales and purchases must be performed, including general verification procedures applicable to the year of application of the VAT refund. In addition, if a medium-risk claim results in at least 30% disallowance of the total amount of VAT refund claim upon examination using the default 50% verification rate, the risk classification is modified to high-risk, requiring 100% verification on both sales and purchases.
Deadlines and Effective Date
The order covers VAT refund claims filed starting July 1, 2024 onward. Businesses filing VAT refund claims from that date should assume that their claims will be screened under the risk-based system and that their compliance history, prior disallowance record, filing frequency, and refund amount may affect how extensively the BIR verifies the claim.
Businesses should also note the treatment of claims filed from April 27, 2024 to June 30, 2024. These claims are automatically considered high-risk or require full verification. This transitional treatment matters for taxpayers expecting faster processing under the Ease of Paying Taxes Act but whose claims fall within the covered period.
Penalties and Consequences of Non-Compliance
RMO No. 23-2024 does not impose a new taxpayer monetary penalty for being classified as medium-risk or high-risk. The practical consequence is procedural: a higher risk classification means broader verification, more supporting documents to defend, and a greater risk that unsupported amounts may be disallowed.
The order does, however, recognize accountability within the BIR process. BIR offices or officials who fail to provide requested data within the five-day period may be administratively dealt with under Section 269(J) of the Tax Code if the failure or inaction causes delay in processing the VAT refund claim.
Practical Steps for VAT Refund Claimants
Taxpayers should treat RMO No. 23-2024 as a reason to strengthen refund documentation before filing, not after receiving BIR queries. A company preparing a VAT refund claim should first determine whether it may be automatically classified as high-risk. First-time claimants, taxpayers with prior full denials, taxpayers with unresolved enforcement issues, and taxpayers filing claims covering multiple taxable quarters should expect closer scrutiny.
Second, taxpayers should review their prior VAT refund history for disallowances. Because the BIR will consider previous claims for the immediately preceding six years, including the amount of claim, period of claim, date of application, amount granted or denied, and percentage of disallowance, prior refund outcomes can directly affect future risk classification.
Third, businesses should organize sales and purchase records so they can withstand either 50% verification or 100% verification. Medium-risk taxpayers should not assume that only half of the documents matter, because a 30% disallowance under the 50% verification may convert the claim into high-risk status and trigger full verification. For importers, VAT Payment Certifications and import declarations should be complete, consistent, and readily traceable to the input VAT claimed.
Fourth, companies should ensure that the application is complete at filing. The order is clear that only applications with complete documentary requirements are to be officially received and processed. For CFOs, accountants, and tax managers searching for VAT refund risk-based approach Philippines, BIR VAT refund 90 days, RMO 23-2024 VAT refund, low-risk VAT refund claim, or EOPT VAT refund rules, the operational lesson is straightforward: refund speed now depends not only on entitlement, but also on risk profile and documentary readiness.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMO No. 23-2024 makes VAT refund strategy more technical. A claimant must now think not only about whether input VAT is refundable, but also how its filing history, documentation, compliance record, prior disallowances, and transaction sampling exposure may affect the BIRโs verification scope.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel in preparing VAT refund claims, reviewing documentary requirements, assessing refund risk classification, addressing BIR verification issues, and defending claims against disallowance. For assistance with VAT refund filings, BIR compliance, tax controversy strategy, or Ease of Paying Taxes Act implementation, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.