RMO No. 11-2023 updates BIR’s BEST Annual Search rules, setting eligibility, criteria, deadlines, rewards, and disqualification grounds for revenue personnel.

BIR offices, service units, regional offices, and revenue officials involved in employee recognition must apply revised nomination, screening, documentary, deadline, and disqualification rules for the BIR’s BEST Annual Search. RMO No. 11-2023 matters to taxpayers indirectly because it is an internal governance and human resource issuance: it strengthens how the tax authority identifies awardees for outstanding performance and exemplary ethical behavior, which affects institutional accountability, public service standards, and the Bureau’s internal performance culture.

What RMO No. 11-2023 changed

RMO No. 11-2023 amended RMO No. 1-2019, dated November 9, 2018, on the criteria, procedures, and additional provisions for the BIR’s Best Employee for Service Excellence and Public Trust, referred to as the BIR’s BEST Annual Search. The order prescribes uniform policies and procedures for selecting the BIR’s BEST and defines the roles and responsibilities of the committees, offices, and personnel involved in selection and recognition.

The most important change is the formalized and more detailed selection architecture for two award categories: BIR’s BEST for Outstanding Performance and BIR’s BEST for Exemplary Ethical Behavior. Instead of leaving recognition to general appreciation or ad hoc internal recommendation, the order provides coverage rules, weighted criteria, documentary requirements, deadlines, disqualification grounds, and endorsement responsibilities.

The issuance is also aligned with the Civil Service Commission’s Program on Awards and Incentives for Service Excellence, or PRAISE, and the Program to Institutionalize Meritocracy and Excellence in Human Resource Management. This makes the BIR’s internal award process part of a broader civil service framework for merit, incentives, ethical behavior, and public accountability.

Who is affected by RMO No. 11-2023

The direct parties affected are all BIR officials and employees holding permanent positions, especially those who may be nominated for the BIR’s BEST Annual Search. Heads of Offices, Service and Regional Enhanced PRAISE Committees, the Executive Enhanced PRAISE Committee, the Human Resource Development Service, the Personnel Division, the Administrative and Human Resource Management Division, the Administrative Service, the Procurement Division, the Finance Service, and the Budget Division also receive specific duties under the order.

Taxpayers, private corporations, SMEs, withholding agents, and tax practitioners do not receive a new tax filing requirement, new tax rate, new return, new withholding obligation, or new taxpayer deadline under RMO No. 11-2023. For businesses searching for “RMO No. 11-2023 BIR compliance,” “BIR’s BEST Annual Search,” “BIR employee awards criteria,” “BIR PRAISE Committee deadline,” or “BIR exemplary ethical behavior award,” the key point is that this is an internal BIR personnel governance issuance rather than a taxpayer compliance regulation.

Coverage and eligibility requirements

To be covered by the annual search, the nominee must be a BIR official or employee holding a permanent position. The nominee must have rendered at least three years of continuous service in the Bureau as of the nomination or submission deadline. The nominee must also have a performance rating of Very Satisfactory, or its equivalent, for the last six semester performance rating periods or the last three annual consecutive performance rating periods prior to nomination.

The nominee must not have been found guilty of any administrative or criminal offense involving moral turpitude. The nominee must also have no pending administrative or criminal case at the time of nomination, as certified by the Internal Investigation Division or Regional Investigation Division. The period covered by the annual search is the last three years prior to nomination, and the accomplishments for which the nominee is being recognized must have been consistently and continuously carried out during that period.

Criteria for outstanding performance

For BIR’s BEST for Outstanding Performance, the criteria are weighted as follows: superior accomplishment, 30%; consistency of work performance, 30%; impact and sustainability of contribution, 30%; and work performed outside the scope of regular assignments, 10%.

Superior accomplishment refers to the nominee’s performance or delivery of service in assigned tasks, including positive outcomes, amount of money saved, uniqueness, originality, and impact on public interest. Consistency of work performance measures the quality and level of consistency of service based on historical data or work record. Impact and sustainability focus on innovation or idea-type contributions that have been adopted, the number of individuals, communities, or offices benefited, and evidence of sustained use or continuous implementation for at least three years or longer. Work outside regular assignments covers accomplishments beyond the nominee’s usual duties but still integral to service delivery.

Criteria for exemplary ethical behavior

For BIR’s BEST for Exemplary Ethical Behavior, the criteria are: impact of behavioral performance, 30%; quality and consistency of behavioral performance, 20%; risk or temptation inherent in the work, 20%; obscurity of the position, 20%; and years of service, 10%.

This category focuses on conduct, not merely output. It assesses whether the nominee’s extraordinary act created a powerful effect or impact on the Bureau or the public, whether the nominee consistently manifested exemplary conduct, whether the work exposed the nominee to substantial risk or temptation, whether the position was lowly or obscure in relation to the extraordinary conduct shown, and the nominee’s cumulative years of government service in relation to the accomplishment.

Key deadlines and documentary compliance

Heads of Offices in the National and Regional Offices must evaluate personnel and select their office nominees. Each office may submit only one nominee per category. The nomination must include a duly accomplished nomination form and the required recommendation letter or endorsement. The submission to the respective Service or Regional Enhanced PRAISE Committee must be made on or before May 15 of the current year.

The Service or Regional Enhanced PRAISE Committees must select one representative per category and submit the name of the representative to the Human Resource Development Service, Attention: Personnel Division, on or before June 15 of the current year. The submission must include the duly accomplished nomination form signed by the nominator; recommendation from the Head of Office or endorsement of the Superior Official, if applicable; certification, excerpts of deliberation, or minutes of deliberation signed by the Service or Regional Enhanced PRAISE Chairperson; latest CS Form 212 or Personal Data Sheet with passport size 1 ½ inch by 1 ½ inch photo; certified photocopies of IPCR forms for the last six consecutive performance rating periods or CESPES ratings for the last three years for third-level officials; clearance from the Internal Investigation Division or Regional Investigation Division; and copies of supporting documents, awards, or commendations.

Each nomination must also include a soft or scanned copy of the documentary requirements and must be submitted electronically to the Personnel Division. For certain Heads of Offices, endorsement by a specified superior official is required: the Commissioner of Internal Revenue is endorsed by the Secretary of Finance; Deputy Commissioners by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue; Assistant Commissioners by Deputy Commissioners; and Regional Directors by the Deputy Commissioner for the Operations Group.

Final selection, rewards, and CSC nomination

The Human Resource Development Service, through the Personnel Division, consolidates the documents of Service and Regional nominees and schedules the Executive Enhanced PRAISE Committee meeting. The Executive Enhanced PRAISE Committee selects the top five awardees for both categories and then selects the over-all winner for each category. The over-all winners must be endorsed to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue on or before August 1 of the current year for approval.

The four finalists for Outstanding Performance and Exemplary Ethical Behavior each receive a monetary reward of P5,000 and a Certificate of Recognition containing a citation and the signature of the Commissioner. The over-all winners receive monetary reward and plaque amounting to P10,000 each, with Plaques of Recognition containing a citation and the Commissioner’s signature. The awarding ceremony is to take place every September, subject to changes upon prior notice.

The over-all winners may also be nominated to the Civil Service Commission Annual Search for Outstanding Public Officials and Employees. The over-all winner for Outstanding Performance is nominated to the Presidential Lingkod Bayan or CSC Pag-asa Award, while the over-all winner for Exemplary Ethical Behavior is nominated to the Dangal ng Bayan Award. Only over-all winners selected by the Executive Enhanced PRAISE Committee are the BIR’s official nominees to the annual CSC Honor Awards Program.

Disqualification and limits on nomination

An employee or official may not be nominated for more than one award category in the same annual search. Over-all winners, finalists, and Service or Regional nominees who were previously conferred with either BIR’s BEST award may still be nominated to the same or another category only after five years from the conferment of the award, and only if the nomination is based on a new set of accomplishments or exemplary norms and behavior.

The order also identifies specific grounds for disqualification. Non-compliance with procedures, incomplete documentary requirements, and failure to observe the prescribed deadline render the nominee ineligible for the BIR’s BEST. Any misrepresentation in submitted documents is a ground for disqualification. A nominee requesting any member of the Executive Enhanced PRAISE Committee or member of the Secretariat, whether directly or through intermediaries, for special favor or consideration is also subject to disqualification.

Practical compliance steps for BIR offices and officials

BIR offices should calendar the May 15, June 15, August 1, September, and January 15 dates associated with nomination, endorsement, approval, awarding, and reporting. They should also maintain performance records, IPCR forms, CESPES ratings where applicable, supporting awards or commendations, and investigation clearances well ahead of the annual search cycle.

Heads of Offices should ensure that nominations reflect individual accomplishments, not the collective accomplishments of the entire office. This is especially important because the order expressly states that nominations of Heads of Offices should reflect their individual accomplishments or individual behavioral norms.

Human resource and PRAISE committees should also maintain local databases that generate demographic data on awardees, including gender, position, disabilities, and ethnic group. The order requires the program to adhere to incentives and awards based on performance, innovative ideas, and exemplary behavior, without discrimination based on gender identity, sexual orientation, disabilities, religion, or indigenous group membership.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco can help

RMO No. 11-2023 does not impose a new taxpayer return, payment, or withholding obligation, but it is still relevant to businesses that monitor BIR governance, administrative issuances, and the standards by which revenue personnel are evaluated. For companies dealing with tax audits, BIR investigations, administrative correspondence, and regulatory compliance, understanding the Bureau’s internal accountability framework helps contextualize how public service, ethics, and performance are institutionalized within the tax authority.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, accountants, in-house counsel, and tax practitioners in understanding BIR issuances, responding to tax assessments, managing compliance deadlines, and navigating disputes with Philippine tax authorities. For guidance on BIR compliance, tax controversy, corporate regulatory requirements, and business law matters, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *